Unequal constituency allocations and what it means for democracy
It's a reflection of a political system still grappling with deep-seated practices of patronage and partisan control.
We must understand: this isn't simply about numbers. It's about the way resources are distributed - often not based on need or merit, but on political allegiance.
And that's a problem, because when fairness gives way to favouritism, when democracy is shadowed by partisanship, the people - the very heart of our nation - are the ones who lose.
When Pakatan Harapan, including DAP, was in government, there was a promise - a commitment - to break these old patterns.
They spoke of transparency, of equitable funding regardless of political stripes. Yet, as we see in Muar, these reforms are still works in progress.
Entrenched systems don't change overnight. They test our patience and challenge our resolve.
But make no mistake: when opposition MPs are restricted to spending their limited funds on office costs alone, unable to invest in public welfare or community development, the consequences are real and felt.
It hinders their ability to serve constituents effectively and weakens the bond between elected leaders and the people they represent.
This isn't just about politics. It's about community. About trust. About whether Malaysians feel their voices matter, regardless of the party they support.
When political funding becomes a tool for division rather than unity, cynicism grows, and engagement falters.
Syed Saddiq's creative efforts to raise funds outside of government channels show the spirit of resilience and dedication that inspires hope. But no one should have to carry that burden alone.
Our democracy calls on us to do better. To build systems that empower every representative to serve their people fully and fairly.
Only then can we build a Malaysia where fairness isn't an ideal, but a reality; where unity isn't just a slogan, but a shared experience.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
28 minutes ago
- The Star
Long-term effects of stimulus unclear
PETALING JAYA: The goodies announced by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, including the RM100 cash transfers to Malaysians above 18 years of age and the lowering of RON95 petrol price, will spur economic activity although the long-term effects remain uncertain, say economists. They opined that the measures, while likely to be offset by tax reforms, subsidy rationalisation and revenue enhancement measures, might pose certain risks to the government's fiscal position. Economist Doris Liew, who specialises in South-East Asian development, said the removal of fuel subsidies, long seen as necessary for structural reform, has faced significant political resistance. 'The lowering of RON95 prices is less about sustainable economic management and more about short-term populism. 'For Anwar, who has pledged a path of fiscal consolidation with the ambitious goal of reducing the fiscal deficit to below 3% of gross domestic product (GDP), this move appears inconsistent and politically expedient,' she opined. She cautioned that the implications of the decision were many while the tangible benefits were limited. 'First, the actual reduction in the cost of living for households will likely be marginal, particularly when weighed against the long-term fiscal cost. 'Second, it undermines Malaysia's broader ambition to transition towards electric vehicles. 'Artificially suppressing petrol prices will only deepen the public's dependence on fossil fuel vehicles and weakens incentives for cleaner alternatives,' she told StarBiz. Thirdly, the move risked a steep increase in subsidy-related expenditure over time, according to Liew observed that in 2022, fuel subsidies amounted to RM52bil, equivalent to 74% of all government subsidies. Although global oil prices have declined recently, she said projections indicated a potential rebound by 2026, which could place renewed and unsustainable pressure on public finances. Nevertheless, she said to the government's credit, several revenue-enhancing initiatives have been introduced this year, including the expansion of the sales and service tax (SST), the implementation of the global minimum tax starting January and the increase in the minimum wage, which could help increase income tax collections. However, the continued reliance on broad-based subsidies remains a cause for concern, she said, as fuel subsidies in particular, are a fiscal black hole. 'Once reinstated or increased, they become politically difficult to scale back, even when economically unsound,' she said. Commenting on the RM100 cash transfers, Liew said they might offer modest relief for low-income households, but would do little to fundamentally improve welfare or address structural inequalities. Of interest, economist Geoffrey Williams opined that the cash handout was a good initiative, viewing it as a pilot for reform of the Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah/Sumbangan Asas Rahmah programme to create a possible universal basic income (UBI), which would be a first in the world and set Malaysia as a leader in welfare reform. 'It has all of the features of a UBI because it is a cash transfer to individuals, not households, without any conditions and available universally to all Malaysians without the need to apply. 'For the moment, it is a one-off payment but it will provide useful lessons to become a regular monthly payment so that Malaysia would be the first country to have a full UBI which would be part of Anwar's legacy,' he said. Noting that the cash handout is affordable under the subsidy rationalisation savings, he said it would add consumption to the economy in the second half of the year to support economic growth especially for the low-income group as the money would be spent in local shops and communities. While noting that the cash transfer could cost the government RM2bil, Williams reckoned that the initiative would have an impact of RM6bil due to its multiplier effect. According to him, the cash transfer will not impact the government's fiscal position because it is essentially a transfer of money from one use to another. He added: 'If it supports growth, then the GDP will be higher than 4% and this helps the push towards debt and deficit ratio push targets. The funds come from subsidy rationalisation savings so development expenditure is not affected.' On the other hand, he said the small reduction from RM2.05 to below RM1.99 per litre of the RON95 fuel would be 'only marginally' helpful for boosting the economy and the subsidy rationalisation is not primarily intended to cut daily lifestyle expenses, but to reduce wasteful subsidy costs. 'The cut is very small, and so it will have a negligible impact on fuel use,' he said. Meanwhile, Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid likend the measures to a mini fiscal stimulus as the country is facing heightened economic uncertainties brought on by US tariffs and ongoing geopolitical risks. 'We have seen Bank Negara cutting the overnight policy rate by 25 basis points this month. So, it clearly shows that Keynesian economics prescriptions are at work now,' he said. Keynesian economic policies, first developed by British economist John Maynard Keynes in 1936, advocate for government intervention to stabilise or mobilise the economy when it is facing risks of a downturn. Mohd Afzanizam highlighted the fiscal consolidation exercises that had been ongoing since last year, including the SST increase by two percentage points and the diesel subsidies that had been rationalised, allowed a fiscal space to be established. 'The government is using this space to spend in order to grow the aggregate demand,' he added.
New Straits Times
5 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Chinese chambers of commerce welcomes govt's measures to ease cost of living
KUALA LUMPUR: The Associated Chinese Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Malaysia (ACCCIM) has welcomed the government's newly announced measures aimed at easing the cost of living and boosting consumer spending. "These measures would help to ease the cost of living and spur household consumption expenditure," ACCCIM said in a statement. Earlier today, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim made a highly anticipated announcement, which he described as an 'extraordinary tribute' to Malaysians. The measures include a one-off RM100 cash aid for all Malaysians aged 18 and above, the freezing of toll hikes on 10 highways, and continued Rahmah Madani sales. The government also announced that the RON95 petrol price will be reduced to RM1.99 per litre when targeted subsidies begin this September. In addition, Sept 15 has been declared a public holiday for Malaysia Day celebrations. The association said that the fuel price drop would benefit around 18 million car and motorcycle users, pending further details on the eligibility criteria. ACCCIM expressed hope that the targeted subsidy mechanism would be easy to implement to ensure a smooth rollout. Looking ahead, ACCCIM said it was looking forward to the tabling of the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) on July 31 and the 2026 Budget on Oct 10, with a focus on sustaining economic resilience and development continuity. The chamber urged the government to avoid new tax measures or policies that could further burden businesses, which are already grappling with rising costs.
New Straits Times
6 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Nga: Anwar's fuel price cut proves promises kept
KUALA LUMPUR: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's announcement of initiatives to ease the people's cost of living proves that the Madani government is fulfilling its promises, said Housing and Local Government (KPKT) Minister Nga Kor Ming. He said the reduction of the RON95 fuel price to RM1.99 per litre makes it one of the lowest in the world. "This demonstrates his concern in addressing cost-of-living issues despite financial constraints. On behalf of 22,000 KPKT families, I would like to thank the Prime Minister for the good news. Anwar said if he became Prime Minister, fuel prices would go down, and now, they will really go down. "Even with the current financial limitations, we've managed to reduce the fuel price, maintain toll rates, provide SARA (Sumbangan Asas Rahmah), and give various incentives," he said at a press conference after officiating the Asean Real Estate Conference (AREC) 2025 and the International Architecture, Interior Design and Building Exhibition (ARCHIDEX) 2025, here yesterday. Nga said the one-off RM100 aid under SARA for all Malaysians aged 18 and above also reflects the government's commitment to helping not only the B40 group but also the M40 group, which is often excluded from such aid. He said the RM2 billion allocation, benefiting 22 million Malaysians, is expected to have a multiplier effect on the economy, while the postponement of toll rate hikes serves as an anti-inflationary measure. Nga emphasised that the Madani government will continue its nation-building efforts and urged all Malaysians to unite in helping the country rise again and gain global respect. "Sometimes in the government, we are required to make some unpopular, extremely difficult decisions as leaders who care about the next generation. "I expect more good news in 2026 Budget, which is scheduled to be tabled in October, so stay tuned," he said. Yesterday, the Prime Minister announced several key initiatives as a gesture of appreciation from the Madani government to the people, including a one-off RM100 aid under the SARA programme, a freeze on toll hikes for 10 highways, and a targeted subsidy bringing the RON95 fuel price down to RM1.99 per litre. Meanwhile, Nga said the Madani government will continue with housing reforms through initiatives such as PR1MA, affordable housing, and low-cost homes. "You have to give us at least three terms to realise our vision. We're only halfway through the first term. If you give us a second and third term — 15 years — we will be able to deliver on our promises." - BERNAMA
