Fury at minister's winter fuel insult: Campaigners hit out at claims the cut did NOT affect pensioners' health
In an incendiary intervention as the Government U-turned on the payments, Torsten Bell dismissed warnings from campaigners that removing it from ten million older people had risked a spike in cold-related illnesses and deaths.
Mr Bell told MPs that among those who had been hit by the cuts imposed by Chancellor Rachel Reeves last winter, 'we see no differential effects on their health'.
But his comments triggered an angry response from campaigners and threatened to overshadow efforts by ministers to undo the political damage caused last year by the decision to means-test the winter fuel payment – one of Ms Reeves's first acts in Government.
Dennis Reed, of over-60s campaign group Silver Voices, said: 'It is a ridiculous thing to say.
'We know from our own members that a lot of people have been shivering in their homes with their overcoats on last winter because they were too afraid to put the heating on.
'Many conditions, such as arthritis and respiratory conditions, are made worse by the cold – how can he possibly claim it's had no effect?'
Ms Reeves yesterday confirmed a Government U-turn on the issue, and that 'more people will get winter fuel allowance this winter' – but she was unable to say who will qualify.
Dennis Reed, of over-60s campaign group Silver Voices, (pictured) said:'We know from our own members that a lot of people have been shivering in their homes with their overcoats on last winter because they were too afraid to put the heating on'
She also said the Government will not set out until the autumn how the reinstated payments will be funded.
Last night the End Fuel Poverty Coalition wrote to the Department for Work and Pensions and the Office for National Statistics demanding evidence for Mr Bell's claim.
Group co-ordinator Simon Francis said: 'One of the things we often talk about in relation to fuel poverty is just how hidden it can be, especially among pensioners, who are often reluctant to come forward and admit they're struggling, even to their own relatives.
'You can easily imagine a situation where a pensioner puts the heating on when family visits, just to make it appear as though everything is fine, when in fact it's not. We're particularly concerned about the health impacts of this.'
Mr Francis added that official figures pointed to a 3.3 per cent increase in the usual number of deaths among over-75s last winter.
Sir Iain Duncan Smith, a former Conservative Work and Pensions Secretary, accused Mr Bell of 'desperate spin' and that there was no basis for his claim.
He added: 'What we do know is that being cold makes many health conditions worse. We also know that millions of older people had less money to pay their gas bill. If Labour really think it had no effect, why are they bringing it back?'
In opposition, Labour claimed that means-testing the winter fuel allowance would cause almost 4,000 extra deaths each winter.
The finding was based on research by the Left-wing think-tank the Resolution Foundation, which at the time was run by Mr Bell.
But yesterday he told MPs the evidence suggested that last winter there had been 'fewer deaths than normal'.
The Government's handling of the issue dominated Prime Minister's Questions, with Kemi Badenoch accusing Sir Keir Starmer of presiding over 'chaos'. She added: 'All we see is U-turn after U-turn – his head must be spinning.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
23 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Our list of the summer's best culture picks
Politics Weekly is taking a break for the summer. But, as is tradition, John Harris has a roundup of some of his favourite cultural picks
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Scotland's night-time economy must be safeguarded for future
A detailed plan for action, dubbed the Northern Lights Manifesto, has been tabled by The Night Time Industries Association (NTIA) Scotland, setting out no fewer than 31 'ambitious, urgent and actionable recommendations to safeguard and transform the country's night-time economy'. The many and varied proposals include the appointment of a dedicated minister for the night-time economy in the Scottish Government – mirroring appointments made by governments in other countries – and statutory duties for local authorities to create and implement their own night-time economy strategies. Proposals for financial relief and regulatory reform are at the heart of the blueprint, with the NTIA calling for immediate reductions in value-added tax (a power that rests in the hands of the UK Government) and business rates for night-time venues. The document also calls for a rethink of the 'licensing burdens' on both hospitality and accommodation providers. 'Scotland's night-time economy is not just about bars and clubs,' declared Mike Grieve, owner of the renowned Sub Club in Glasgow and Scotland chair of the NTIA. 'It is about the creative soul of our towns and cities. Without immediate and strategic government support, we risk losing the venues, voices and businesses that define Scotland's global identity. Northern Lights is a blueprint for meaningful action – and the time to act is now.' Read more: The language chosen by Mr Grieve, a respected figure on the Glasgow business scene, is emotive, and it is no surprise. The sector which Mr Grieve and his colleagues have campaigned for throughout their careers has had an arduous time since the coronavirus pandemic emerged in early 2020. Ultimately, businesses such as nightclubs and live music venues were among the last to fully reopen following long spells of Covid restrictions, but the sector's problems did not end there. A surge in energy costs that accelerated in the wake of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, an inflation crisis which has put pressure on discretionary income, and a change in consumer behaviour post-pandemic - with many people changing their socialising habits because of inadequate transport provision late at night - have left many businesses in crisis mode. Indeed, it is probably no exaggeration to say that the night-time economy in Scotland is at a real fork in the road. It seems there is a genuine risk that the sector we knew before the pandemic might never return. Of course, the businesses that make up the night-time economy are not alone in struggling at this moment in time. The broader economy is stuck in the doldrums and growth has so far been elusive for a UK Government which has made that its number one mission. We are probably beyond the point where any sector can expect to receive direct financial support from either the UK or Scottish governments, which was given to help keep businesses afloat during the pandemic. But there is plenty in the NTIA blueprint, which was authored by respected Scottish licensing lawyer Stephen McGowan, that ministers should at least give serious thought to implementing. There will be people who ask what is the fuss all about. Those of a certain vintage who no longer have close ties to the late-night economy, which can occur as people get older, might simply shrug their shoulders at its predicament. As such, it is important that organisations such as the NTIA exist to highlight its significance, both culturally and economically to Scotland, as it has emphatically done with this document. The organisation notes that the night-time economy, which spans hospitality, live music, clubs, cultural venues, bars and late-night transport, supports more than 137,000 jobs in Scotland, and generates £43.5 billion in economic value to the UK. Aside from this significant, tangible contribution, the night-time economy brings many intangible benefits to Scottish society too. Gone may be the days when people of my generation attended nightclubs on a regular basis, but that does not mean we are unaware of the importance of the late-night economy. The ability of Scotland's major towns and cities to provide a vibrant night-time scene is surely key to convincing young people to live and work in these locations, and is undoubtedly an asset when major employers in places such as Glasgow and Edinburgh are looking to attract talent which might otherwise head for Manchester or London. A thriving night-time economy is massively important to the cultural life of Scotland too, enriching the lives of people who reside here and helping with the wider effort to promote the country as a tourist destination. Just look at the fervour which has met the Oasis reunion concerts this summer as people have gathered in their hundreds of thousands to celebrate a band which, lest we forget, partly built its legend with a short gig in Glasgow live music venue King Tut's Wah Wah Hut. My time as a frequenter of late-night bars and nightclubs are probably gone for good, but I remember fondly the many nights in my student days and in my twenties when friendships were forged and achievements were celebrated. These are memories that last a lifetime, and they were all created amid the excitement that the late-night economy has to offer. It would be a crying shame if current and future generations are denied this opportunity, even though it should be acknowledged that times change and young people today perhaps do not embrace nightlife to the extent which my generation did. Ministers in the Scottish and UK governments should, at the very least, commit to meeting the NTIA, and allow the organisation to present its blueprint. Even if ministers will find it impossible to adopt every recommendation, there is plenty in the document that, if enacted, would make a significant difference to an industry of major importance to the Scottish economy.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Pressure is building on Sir Keir Starmer to sack his trade envoy to Turkey over trip to northern Cyprus
Pressure was last night coming from within Labour for Keir Starmer to sack his trade envoy to Turkey over an unauthorised trip. Afzal Khan is back in the UK after a trip to the self-declared Turkish republic of northern Cyprus - a territory the UK, and most of the rest of the world, does not recognise. During his trip, the MP for Manchester Rusholme met Ersin Tatar, the leader of Turkish Cypriots, in his official residence. He posed for a photo with the leader, giving a suggestion of a bilateral meeting as opposed to a personal visit. After days of questions being asked by others, the Daily Mail understands the matter is being raised internally within Labour, with a sense of unhappiness as to how it has been allowed to escalate into a diplomatic spat and demands that No 10 act. Labour MPs are also believed to have raised the matter with ministers to channel the fury of Greek Cypriots over the trip. The official government of Cyprus said the visit last week was 'absolutely condemnable and unacceptable' and that UK officials should 'respect' their state. It also provoked an outcry from Greek Cypriots who have called for his dismissal over a breach of UN resolutions that forbid recognition of the territory's government. Mr Khan was due to receive a degree from a local university, but no announcement has been made, suggesting he may have been recalled by the UK Government or a news blackout was imposed, given the controversy. The trip is said to have been a 'personal' visit and ministers were not aware of the plans, raising further questions about whether he can remain in his job. Tory MP Sir Roger Gale, the honorary president of the all-party parliamentary group for Cyprus, said Sir Keir should sack Mr Khan. 'The UK has a responsibility as a guarantor power to Cyprus,' he added. 'His position as trade envoy is untenable.' Shadow foreign affairs minister Wendy Morton has written to ministers calling for the envoy to be removed from his role. 'This visit risks undermining the UK's credibility as a guarantor power and as an impartial interlocutor in settlement negotiations,' she said. Mr Tatar waded into the row this week by criticising the 'intolerant statements and excessive attacks made by the Greek Cypriot side'. A hardline nationalist who is close to Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan, he added that the visit was undertaken 'at my invitation'. Mr Tatar told Mr Khan he wanted to pursue a 'two-state solution' despite no international recognition of the seized territory, it was reported. Mr Khan replied that his friends of Cypriot origin living in Manchester had encouraged him to visit the island, adding: 'That is why I am happy to be here.' A government spokesman said last night the visit was 'undertaken in a personal capacity' and there was no change to the UK's long-standing position on the seized territory.
