logo
Air India crash raises a big question: Should every plane have a camera in the cockpit to catch what audio can't?

Air India crash raises a big question: Should every plane have a camera in the cockpit to catch what audio can't?

Time of India16-07-2025
The crash of Air India Flight 171 last month has brought back a critical question for the aviation industry — should cockpit video recorders be mandatory? The incident has reopened a two-decade-old discussion about balancing pilot privacy with public safety.
Willie Walsh, head of the International Air Transport Association (IATA) and a former pilot himself, publicly supported the idea during a conference in Singapore. 'Based on what little we know now, it's quite possible that a video recording, in addition to the voice recording, would significantly assist investigators,' Walsh said, referencing the need to better understand mental health issues involved in such incidents.
What happened on flight 171?
A preliminary report from India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) suggests that one of the pilots may have deliberately cut off fuel supply to the engines of the Boeing 787 shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad. This left the aircraft in an uncontrollable state, ultimately leading to the deaths of 241 passengers and crew, along with 19 people on the ground.
Experts say that had cockpit video footage been available, investigators could have quickly confirmed what happened and why. Instead, key questions remain unanswered.
Video recorders in other incidents
Supporters of cockpit video highlight examples where such footage proved vital. In 2023, the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) used video evidence from a Robinson R66 helicopter crash to determine the cause. The video showed that the pilot, who died in the crash, had been distracted while flying — using a mobile phone and eating during flight. The ATSB called the footage 'invaluable' and praised Robinson Helicopters for factory-installing cameras.
Following that investigation, ATSB urged more manufacturers and operators to consider camera installations for safety purposes.
Not the first time this has been proposed
The push for cockpit video recorders dates back decades. In 2000, the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) made a formal recommendation after the 1999 crash of EgyptAir Flight 990. Investigators concluded that the first officer had intentionally caused the crash, killing all 217 on board. Then-NTSB Chairman Jim Hall pressed the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to require cockpit cameras.
Despite strong arguments for safety, many pilots have expressed concern over constant surveillance. Aviation safety expert Anthony Brickhouse acknowledged this, saying, 'Video on Air India flight 171 would have answered lots of questions.' Still, he emphasized that privacy should not outweigh safety when lives are at stake.
The case for safety over privacy
Air safety expert and retired pilot John Nance echoed this sentiment. 'In the balance between privacy and safety, the scale tips toward safety, unequivocally,' he said. 'Protecting the flying public is a sacred obligation.'
The conversation around cockpit cameras may be uncomfortable for some, but with repeated tragedies and open investigations, industry leaders may soon be forced to make a final call.
As past and present crashes resurface, the industry faces pressure to act — will safety outweigh privacy in future cockpit policy?
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Failed breathalyzer test: Delta flight from Stockholm cancelled after US pilot arrested for suspected drinking; Airline denies allegations
Failed breathalyzer test: Delta flight from Stockholm cancelled after US pilot arrested for suspected drinking; Airline denies allegations

Time of India

time13 hours ago

  • Time of India

Failed breathalyzer test: Delta flight from Stockholm cancelled after US pilot arrested for suspected drinking; Airline denies allegations

Representative image A Delta Airlines transatlantic flight to New York City was cancelled after the pilot allegedly failed a breathalyzer test and was subsequently arrested, according Swedish Police's statement, report by local media The pilot was taken into custody at Stockholm's Arlanda Airport at 9.00 am local time on Tuesday under suspicion of intoxication, police spokesperson Nadya Norton told Aftonbladet, a Swedish daily newspaper. The publication identified the pilot as an American national. However, a Delta spokesperson told The Independent that "no pilot intoxication" occurred and said that she has been released from custody. "We continue to work with authorities to review what occurred," the statement added. The Delta Air Lines flight 205, scheduled for a nine-hour journey to arrive in the US at 1 PM Eastern time, was cancelled. Aftonbladet confirmed the suspect as an American pilot. Despite the spokesperson denying allegations, Delta Air Lines issued a statement pledging full cooperation with authorities saying, "nothing is more important than the safety and security of our customers and people." Swedish legislation permits fines or up to six months' imprisonment for a "normal violation". Severe cases with high blood alcohol levels can result in two-year sentences. US aviation regulations require pilots to observe an 8-hour "bottle to throttle rule", prohibiting flying while under the influence or using substances that could "adversely affect safety", as per Federal Aviation Administration guidelines. According to View From The Wing, passengers were eligible for £705 compensation due to the incident. The compensation, applicable to all passengers aboard the 226-seat Boeing 767-332, will cost Delta approximately £160,000, under European Union rule 261 covering significant delays. Additional expenses for accommodation, meals and connecting flight disruptions are separate from this compensation, VFTW states, as quoted by The Independent. European Union Aviation Safety Agency's Regulation 2018/1042 requires random alcohol testing for flight and cabin crew operating from EU member states.

Russian Boeing-737 turns back to Siberian airport after reporting depressurisation: Report
Russian Boeing-737 turns back to Siberian airport after reporting depressurisation: Report

Time of India

time16 hours ago

  • Time of India

Russian Boeing-737 turns back to Siberian airport after reporting depressurisation: Report

A Russian passenger plane operated by S7 Airlines flying to the southern Russian resort city of Sochi on Friday turned back to Novosibirsk airport in Siberia to check its cabin pressure systems, the airline and Siberian prosecutors said. The tracking website indicated that the plane, a Boeing-737 with seating capacity for 176 passengers manufactured in 2001, sent an emergency signal. The site tracked the plane turning back and then repeatedly circling and flying in large loops. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Technology Degree Leadership Digital Marketing Data Science Design Thinking Public Policy Healthcare CXO Management Others Data Science healthcare Finance Product Management PGDM Skills you'll gain: Duration: 12 Weeks MIT xPRO CERT-MIT XPRO Building AI Prod India Starts on undefined Get Details "Flight S7 5103, travelling from Novosibirsk to Sochi, is returning to its departure airport to check the cabin pressure control system," the airline told Reuters. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Enlarged Prostate Has Nothing To Do With Age. Just Stop Doing This One Common Thing! Prostate Health Journal Click Here Undo The airline said in a statement that the plane was using up fuel before landing and that a replacement aircraft had been prepared to carry passengers to their destination. The Western Siberian Transport Prosecutor's office said it was monitoring the incident. Live Events The incident comes a day after an An-24 passenger plane crashed in Russia's far east as it was preparing to land, killing all 48 people on board in an incident that spotlighted the continued use of old, Soviet-era aircraft.

Deja vu: England, Spain to clash again in Women's Euro Championship final
Deja vu: England, Spain to clash again in Women's Euro Championship final

Business Standard

timea day ago

  • Business Standard

Deja vu: England, Spain to clash again in Women's Euro Championship final

There's a sense of deja vu about the Women's European Championship final that pits defending champion England against World Cup winner Spain. The two nations faced off in the World Cup final two years ago with Spain edging an open match 1-0. I think obviously that was a massive disappointment and I feel like from a collective we probably feel like we didn't have our best performance that day, but I think if you're trying to pull on that too much then you're going to be too emotional with too many things going on, England midfielder Keira Walsh said on Thursday. Obviously you think about it a little bit but I think for us, put it to the side and focus on the game on Sunday. We've got so many new players in this team who are really confident and bring so many things to this team, so it's exciting and we can just focus on the positives. Both teams needed 120 minutes to get through their gruelling semifinals. England's super-subs had their part to play again on Tuesday with late goals first taking the match to extra time and then securing a last-gasp 2-1 victory over Italy. Spain needed a moment of magic from two-time Ballon d'Or winner Aitana Bonmati to get past a resilient German side 1-0 on Wednesday. It will be a first Euros final for Spain but even before the tournament it had been the favorite to add the European title to its collection after winning the World Cup and Nations League in the past two years. Spain's triumph at the World Cup was marred by the Luis Rubiales scandal, after the-then head of the Spanish soccer federation kissed player Jenni Hermoso during the awards ceremony. Rubiales was subsequently charged with sexual assault and convicted a few months before the start of Euro 2025, bringing an end to one of the worst chapters in the history of Spanish soccer. Walsh, who made 100 appearances for Barcelona over two-and-a-half seasons, was playing in Spain at the time and witnessed the fallout first hand. I think the most important thing for them is that they can enjoy this final, there's not the controversy surrounding it, she said. I think just for the girls this time and as a friend and another football player, for them just to go and enjoy it. They play incredible football and they deserve to be there, so as a human being I just want them to go out and enjoy the game of football. Walsh doesn't feel Spain's star-packed squad received enough credit after the World Cup triumph. Obviously after the game there was a lot of controversy and I don't think for them there was enough spotlight on how incredible they played and how incredible some of their players were, it was all about the other stuff that had gone on, she said. I think as a professional that was disappointing to see. Obviously I have a lot of friends in that team and I think they probably deserved a little bit more than what they got. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store