Palms West attack: Hospital, PBSO to discuss security staffing after patient beats nurse
ROYAL PALM BEACH — HCA Florida Palms West Hospital is taking steps to increase security on its Southern Boulevard campus following the Feb. 18 beating of a nurse by a patient that fractured "essentially every bone' in her face and put her at risk of going blind.
The nurse, 67-year-old Leelamma Lal of Royal Palm Beach, remains at St. Mary's Medical Center in West Palm Beach nearly a month after the attack.
Palms West on March 10 opened a work station for the Palm Beach County Sheriff Office inside its emergency room, HCA spokesperson Louis Lochte said. The hospital is "in talks" with PBSO to hire an off-duty deputy to provide added security, Lochte later confirmed.
'This is unimaginable': Palms West nurse's children react to mother's beating by patient
A sheriff's spokesperson said the agency has not stationed a deputy at the private hospital and that the work station only serve as a "courtesy space" that private businesses can offer law-enforcement officers where they can fill out reports and make calls if they choose to do so.
"Our job is to be patrolling the area in which we're expected to patrol, not to be sitting in a hospital,' the sheriff's office spokesperson said.
The hiring of an off-duty deputy would be on the terms that any business would receive, the sheriff's office said.
Deputies arrested Stephen Scantlebury, the patient who beat Lal, on a charge of attempted second-degree murder on Feb. 18. The sheriff's office placed a hate-crime enhancement on the case after deputies said Scantlebury "made utterances" about the Lal' race after the attack. Lal, a nurse at Palms West for 21 years, is from India.
A spokesperson for the State Attorney's Office said Thursday it intends to charge Scantlebury, 33, of Wellington with attempted first-degree murder because of the hate-crime enhancement.
Lal was caring for Scantlebury, who had come to Palms West complaining of chest pains. The 33-year-old's family said he had been experiencing moments of paranoia, and the staff was evaluating him to see if Palms West needed to send him to a hospital certified to handle mental-health cases under the state's Baker Act.
When Lal entered the room, Scantlebury allegedly jumped on top of her and hit her face repeatedly with his fists. Scantlebury then ran out of the hospital and was detained as he ran along Southern Boulevard.
Circuit Judge Howard Coates on Feb. 27 ordered that Scantlebury kept in custody prior to his trial, citing security concerns.
Palms West attack: CEO decries 'unprovoked, senseless violence' in patient's beating of nurse
The Florida Agency for Health Care Administration released a report this week stating a Feb. 24 evaluation at HCA Palms West found "no deficiencies at the time of the survey.' Palms West CEO Jason Kimbrell disclosed the finding in an email to his staff on Feb. 25.
Karen Terry, the attorney representing Lal, questioned the depth of the evaluation and said Palms West's lack of security allowed Scantlebury to attack Lal and then flee from the hospital.
She added the hospital shouldn't even have been treating the patient because it is not a facility that receives patients under the Baker Act, which allows for a 72-hour involuntary hospitalization for those who might harm others or themselves.
Terry filed last week a request to the court to access Scantlebury's medical history, the hospital's security camera footage and a list of its policies regarding Baker Act patients.
"I don't know how to explain that finding, with everything I've seen," said Terry, a partner at the Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley law firm in West Palm Beach.
Valentina Palm covers Royal Palm Beach, Wellington, Greenacres, Palm Springs and other western communities in Palm Beach County for The Palm Beach Post. Email her at vpalm@pbpost.com and follow her on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, at @ValenPalmB. Support local journalism: Subscribe today.
This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: Palms West, PBSO to discuss security staffing after beating of nurse
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
Ormond Beach biker, 60, killed when car pulls in front of him on S.R. 415
An Ormond Beach motorcyclist was killed this morning when he slammed into a sedan that pulled in front of him on State Road 415, according to the Florida Highway Patrol. The 60-year-old Ormond Beach man was heading south on State Road 415 on a Harley-Davidson motorcycle when a Ford Fusion pulled out in front of him at Fort Smith Boulevard, according to the Florida Highway Patrol. The motorcycle hit the left side of the Ford, which was driven by a 48-year-old Deltona man. First responders took the 60-year-old to HCA Florida Lake Monroe Hospital, but authorities pronounced him dead at the hospital. The driver of the Fusion had serious injuries, and first responders took him to the same hospital. The crash happened about 7:16 a.m., and the Florida Highway Patrol is investigating. Authorities have cleared the roadblock at the intersection. The motorcyclist was not wearing a helmet. This article originally appeared on The Daytona Beach News-Journal: One dead after Volusia County motorcycle crash on S.R. 415
Yahoo
02-06-2025
- Yahoo
2 motorcyclists injured after colliding with alligator on Florida interstate
VOLUSIA COUNTY, Fla. (WFLA) — Two motorcyclists were taken to a hospital Saturday after officials said they crashed into an alligator on Interstate 4 in Volusia County. The motorcyclists, a 67-year-old DeLeon Springs man and a 25-year-old Orange City woman, were both heading westbound in the inside lane when they collided with the gator, the Florida Highway Patrol told NBC affiliate WESH. Hillsborough officials identify 24-year-old killed by gunman who opened fire on car The impact caused both motorcyclists to veer off the interstate. Troopers said the 67-year-old crashed his 2022 Suzuki GSX-R1000R motorcycle into a tree. He and the Orange City woman were taken to HCA Lake Monroe Hospital with non-life-threatening injuries, according to authorities. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission was dispatched to the scene to assist with the injured alligator. As of Sunday, the crash remained under investigation, and no further information was immediately available. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
29-05-2025
- Yahoo
Residents critique care at Rochester's Frisbie Hospital under HCA
If you wanted to know how things have gone at Frisbie Memorial Hospital since for-profit HCA Healthcare, the world's largest hospital conglomerate, took over in 2020, Wednesday's public meeting in Rochester told two stories. Corporate leaders and hospital staff marched in lockstep to the podium and offered their own positive self-assessments. Residents came not to praise HCA, but to plead with the state's Health Care Consumer Protection Advisory Commission and Attorney General John Formella to help make their community hospital better. The meeting was 2½ hours long so everyone who signed up could speak. The first 88 minutes of input, however, was almost entirely HCA and Frisbie officials talking about the strides they've made. State Sen. Tom McGough and state Rep. Julie Miles, both Merrimack Republicans who are on the commission, prodded doctors, nurses and officials to speak in unscripted terms, answer questions and be accountable to patients. 'That's a great testimonial from the CMO. I'm thrilled to hear that things have come back — ortho, neuro, partial hospital psych services. That's fantastic. We've got a room full of folks. What are we about to hear? What are you still missing?' McGough asked Dr. Trevor Eide, the chief medical officer. Eide said Frisbie's goal is to take care of as many patients as possible in Rochester and send only the sickest patients to Portsmouth Regional Hospital, which is also owned by HCA. 'If I had to say there's one thing that I'd like to have back, one service line, I think nephrology to provide dialysis for our dialysis patients.' Eide said when pressed. Hospital officials listed several areas of improvement, including faster turnaround to transfer critically ill patients to other hospitals and better access to outpatient services, primary care and specialists. Frisbie has also decreased the time it takes a patient coming into the emergency room to be evaluated by a provider, which is now less than six minutes, according to Dr. Carly Shiembob, the medical director for Frisbie's emergency department. Yvonne Goldsberry, a member of the commission, suggested HCA provide a community benefit report like nonprofit hospitals are required to share with the public. Goldsberry, Formella, McGough and Miles all suggested better communication and community outreach. Merger fallout Residents focused mostly on services they lost after HCA saved Frisbie from closing just before COVID-19 hit. Commission members also made note of services Frisbie no longer provides, such as discontinuing labor and baby delivery services. In 2022, Formella's office investigated why HCA, which had agreed as part of the merger in 2020 to continue several services for at least five years, reneged on its promise and began sending expectant mothers 21 miles down the Spaulding Turnpike to Portsmouth. Ultimately, HCA and the AG's Office worked out a deal in 2023 for HCA to provide $2.75 million to the Greater Rochester Community Health Foundation to improve health and well-being for Rochester-area residents. 'How would you have us spend the $2.75 million, which is not much to a big company like HCA. But that money came from HCA and, let's face it, it's got to be part of the cost of business. How would you have this commission spend it?' McGough asked Rochester Mayor Paul Callaghan, one of the speakers who praised Frisbie. Callaghan suggested using the money to improve mental health and drug addiction services. Sharp criticism Dr. Mike Metzger, who worked at Frisbie as a cardiologist from 2005 to 2023 and now works at Wentworth-Douglass Hospital in Dover, said the most seasoned doctors and nurses have left Frisbie. 'I feel like HCA does have a playbook, and it knows how to harvest its profit,' Metzger said. 'I say this with great sadness. I was one of the biggest cheerleaders of Frisbie, but I feel like this has to be said. While there may be some services there, they're nominally there. Most patients are being transported to Portsmouth Hospital.' Sharon Croft, who was born at Frisbie and was a school nurse for almost 30 years, said she and others lost their doctors and received little or no notification. Others said the bad communication about doctor departures put some of them in a bind when it came time to renew the medications they relied on or couldn't find where their doctors moved to. Incidents like those eroded trust in the hospital and HCA, they said. 'Even though we hear all of these good things, people that I deal with, people in my neighborhood, they don't want to go to Frisbie,' Croft said. 'They want to go someplace else. It's not the people, it's what's available to them, and whether they are actually going to get the things they need. Or are they going to end up going someplace else anyway?' Roberta Goodrich, who lived in Rochester for 22 years before moving to Wakefield and previously worked at Frisbee, was disappointed when HCA closed the White Mountain Medical Center, the Barrington Walk-In Care and Seacoast Readicare in Somersworth. HCA officials said they had to close their clinics because they were losing money and didn't have enough patients to justify staying open. Goodrich said the reduction in services makes it clear that HCA values profits over patients. 'Since the HCA acquisition, Frisbie Hospital no longer has labor and delivery maternity care. How many women want to have prenatal care and then find out they have to go somewhere else to deliver,' Goodrich said. 'Delivery doesn't really generate much money for the company unless it's a complicated delivery or involves a C section.' Marsha Miller, who lives across the street from Frisbie, said she goes to Wentworth-Douglass because her husband can't get the care he needs in their home city. 'No matter what stories we hear today, and they are awesome, the reality is that people in Rochester that have touched the hospital before these changes, have that negative image,' Miller said. She said Frisbie can overcome the negative perception with better care and better communication. Putting patients first Formella was asked why so many people from HCA took up the majority of time during public comments and why residents didn't get to speak until the meeting was more than half-way over. 'We're going to think hard about that going forward as to how to make sure that these forums are true community forums, and we hear mostly from community members,' Formella said. 'Obviously, we don't' want to tell people they can't speak, but we also need to make sure that we're setting this up in a way that we hear from the community. I think we heard a lot from the community tonight, but I think in forums going forward, we're going to work to make sure we're hearing even more from community members and less from representatives from corporations.' Goldsberry agreed, saying HCA knows how to stay on message. 'The hospital has a lot of resources, and when they come to public events, they come with all their resources,' she said. 'Community members don't have those kinds of resources.' She said the commission will balance the testimony during the public meeting with a large amount of feedback its received from residents who email in their concerns. To submit a question for the Health Care Consumer Protection Advisory Commission, email Christine Rioux at dpierce@
