Barne Estate case: Oral contract generates mountain of paperwork in court
An oral contract is not worth the paper it is written on, the film mogul Samuel Goldwyn once observed.
The oral contract that ended in the alleged sale of the Barne Estate in Co Tipperary to the billionaire businessman John Magnier has generated a veritable mountain of paperwork.
Magnier and family are suing Barne Estate owner Richard Thomson-Moore and others over the purported sale on the evening of August 22nd, 2023 of the 751-acre estate in Co Tipperary.
There were boxes piled up on the seats of a crowded Court 11 and stacks of blue-grey boxes bearing the name of Magnier's solicitors Arthur Cox for which there was no room in the court.
READ MORE
After lunch Mr Justice Max Barrett acknowledged that he is going to need a bigger courtroom and ordered that the boxes be removed to let people sit down.
Magnier's counsel Paul Gallagher led the court patiently through page after page of written evidence – more than 500 pages in total.
Among the WhatsApp messages he read was one from Alex Thomson-Moore, the sister of Richard Thomson-Moore, who wrote: 'One of us needs to be writing a diary and turning this into a Sunday night TV thriller.' Tolstoy's War and Peace, more like.
Counsel for the Barne Estate Martin Heyden interjected to say there had been an 'extraordinarily disproportionate' level of demand for documents in the case from Magnier's side and the process was costing a 'staggering amount of money'.
[
'Gargantuan' data search ongoing in case over alleged €15 million sale of Barne estate to businessman John Magnier
Opens in new window
]
The star witness, John Magnier, gave evidence just after 3pm. 'This is my first day here ever,' he added with a pause when asked how often he had ended up in court over a deal like this.
He has amassed a huge fortune through his Coolmore bloodstock operation and much of Co Tipperary. He crossed swords with Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson and won.
Yet, aside from the odd horse racing interview about his Coolmore prodigies, he rarely, if ever, speaks in public about his dealings. He has made his fortune while remaining a mystery.
He spoke quietly and deliberately, aside from once when he got irritated and handed Heyden a copy of his statement only to demand it back again later.
The Barne Estate was adjoining two farms that he owned and he was keen to purchase it. He went to visit it on July 7th, 2023 and noticed something odd.
The Thomson-Moores were growing potatoes, which is 'hard on land'. When he inquired he was told that the Thomson-Moores were always 'strapped for cash' and had found a cash customer for the potatoes.
'That struck a chord with me,' he said. On the evening of August 22nd, Thomson-Moore, his wife, and auctioneer John Stokes arrived to the Coolmore House.
Stokes demanded €18 million for the Barne Estate. 'That led me to believe that they were not serious about doing a deal. I was taken aback by it,' said Magnier.
'Between the jigs and reels and going back and forth,' he added, they finally settled on a figure of €15 million.
Stokes and the Thomson-Moores adjourned to another room and then came back. 'John [Stokes] put out his hand, and said, 'John, we have a deal.''
It wasn't subject to anything, they all shook hands, everybody was happy and he thought he had a deal, Magnier remembered.
He later gave the Thomson-Moores €50,000 in cash for three reasons: firstly, for allowing him to till the farm; secondly, because they were under financial pressure; and thirdly, because they were resisting a counter-offer from US-based businessman Maurice Regan.
[
John Magnier confirms he gave 'strapped for cash' estate owners €50,000 in cash in two envelopes
Opens in new window
]
Magnier knew when the money was returned on September 11th, 2023 that the deal was in trouble.
He wanted to resolve the issue by peaceful means and upped his offer to more than €16 million and €500,000 in a trust for the Thomson-Moores' disabled son. It was rejected. 'We were left with no choice but to launch proceedings,' he said.
He spoke with Stokes on October 6th. 'I asked him what was going on. 'John, there is one word for it – greed.''
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
36 minutes ago
- Irish Times
The moving target that is RTÉ's woes
If there were one thing to be gleaned from Wednesday's Oireachtas media committee session with RTÉ 's leadership team, it is that the political focus has well and truly moved on since last summer. One of the big talking points to come out of last June's session with director general Kevin Bakhurst and co was the issue of outsourcing. The former BBC News editor was forced at the time to deny that the national broadcaster's transformation plan – a central plank of which is a contentious move to increase spending on outsourced, 'independent' productions – was tantamount to privatisation of in-house programming. All this after he was peppered with questions on the matter by members of the committee. Very little oxygen was expended on that issue on Wednesday. Instead, attention had largely shifted to RTÉ's latest financial foul-up: the €3.7 million or so written off on a troubled capital spending project to replace a legacy IT system in the organisation. But outsourcing has not gone away. Just last week, RTÉ announced plans to switch production of some religious programming – specifically, 'Christian worship content', as the broadcaster put it in a statement – to outside producers. It means Masses will no longer be broadcast from Donnybrook and will, instead, be produced by churches nationwide. READ MORE Asked briefly about it on Wednesday, Bakhurst said RTÉ hopes to get a 'different and a better product' out of the move and denied the broadcaster is phasing out religious programming. [ Ryan Tubridy has not repaid RTÉ €150,000 he received for Renault deal, Bakhurst tells media committee Opens in new window ] That will be cold comfort for staff, who are already concerned about the outsourcing of flagship programming such as Fair City and the Late Late Show, as announced last year. RTÉ's group of unions has reportedly written to the organisation's head of HR to request a meeting about last week's announcement. Asked on Wednesday about morale within RTÉ, Bakhurst diplomatically noted that it was 'very mixed'. Change is 'very difficult', he said, and there remains 'a very high level of anger and disappointment' about the 2023 secret payments scandal. In some areas of the organisation, however, morale is 'very good', the director general claimed. Against a backdrop of redundancies and outsourcing, it is difficult to imagine where these pockets of good feeling might be.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Digital transformation and personalised medicine are reshaping PharmaChem
Ireland's PharmaChem industry comprises more than 90 biopharmaceutical, pharmaceutical and chemical companies, including eight of the world's top 10 Biopharma companies. The sector contributes about 20 per cent to Ireland's GDP, and generates more than €116 billion annually in exports. Ireland ranks as the world's third-largest pharmaceutical exporter and is Europe's second-largest exporter of complex pharmaceutical goods and medicines. The sector supports more than 80,000 jobs and has attracted more than €10 billion in foreign direct investment over the past decade. Today Ireland's biopharmaceutical and chemical industries stand at a critical juncture, with opportunities for growth alongside several pressing challenges. Since 2014 the Pharma Industry Awards , organised by Business River, have celebrated outstanding achievements by individuals and organisations that set new standards in the pharmaceutical industry. The annual awards event attracts hundreds of industry professionals, some of whom reflect here on trends over the past decade and what the future holds. READ MORE Emmeline Yuen-O'Sullivan, senior enterprise account executive at Aizon , identifies digital transformation as the most notable shift in pharmaceutical manufacturing optimisation over the past decade. 'As pharma manufacturing grows more complex, this transformation has laid the groundwork for the next phase of intelligent, real-time decision-making,' she says. Susan Costello, network director at BioPharmaChem Skillnet , points to the shift towards advanced and personalised therapies as the most transformative trend. 'The emergence of mRNA vaccines and cell and gene therapies has redefined our sector,' Costello observes. 'This evolution has not only reshaped manufacturing but also created a pressing need for upskilling and workforce development.' For Clodagh Phelan, marketing specialist at Camida , the rise of strategic partnerships across the supply chain is one of the most impactful trends. 'At Camida, we've seen how collaboration between manufacturers, suppliers and logistic partners has driven resilience, innovation and accelerated time-to-market,' says Ms Phelan. Victor Vargas, commercial director and strategic lead at QuickStat, A Kuehne+Nagel Company , notes that personalised medicine is experiencing a boom, with projected annual growth exceeding 10 per cent until 2032. 'QuickStat together with Kuehne Nagel has heavily invested in the necessary infrastructure to enable trade and continuous supply,' he adds. Jimmy Blaney, group vice-president, and director business development and marketing, at Asgard Cleanroom Solutions , comments that the BioPharma sector has been revolutionised by the shift from traditional construction methods to off-site modular approaches. 'These advantages are especially clear when navigating potential tariffs and supply-chain constraints, where consolidated off-site production lessens cross-border complexities,' Blaney explains. Over the past decade, gas detection technologies have undergone substantial advancements, particularly regarding the integration of connected technologies, according to Rebecca Keogh, business development manager at OBW Technologies . 'Traditional gas detectors have been replaced by more sophisticated systems that can communicate with other devices and software monitoring systems, enabling real-time data collection and sharing,' Ms Keogh adds. The view from trade organisation BioPharmaChem Ireland is that there is untapped potential for Ireland's life sciences sector to move up the value chain, leveraging research capabilities in biotechnologies, microbiome science, advanced materials, drug delivery and data analytics. Pharma Industry Awards by the numbers To maintain competitiveness, the sector's strategy is shifting towards several key themes. Advanced Therapeutics represents a big focus area, alongside expanded Global Business Services capabilities. The lobby group has identified development of the indigenous Biotech sector as crucial for creating a more resilient ecosystem. In addition, growing Contract Development and Manufacturing Organisations (CDMOs) and accelerating digitalisation across the sector are strategic priorities for BioPharmaChem Ireland members. Vargas believes that a trend shaping the pharmaceutical industry in the coming years will be the heightened focus on developing robust and specialised logistics infrastructure. 'By investing in state-of-the-art logistics solutions, companies like QuickStat are enabling the efficient and safe handling of sensitive pharmaceutical products, ensuring that Ireland remains at the forefront of pharmaceutical innovation and patient care for years to come,' he says. Blaney expects that sustainable building practices, digital integration and agile production techniques will dominate the industry's future. 'Growing demand for personalised therapies and stringent regulations will require adaptable, high-spec facilities, ensuring off-site construction remains a truly disruptive force in BioPharma's future,' says Blaney. Phelan is of the view that sustainability and supply chain transparency will define the next era in the industry. 'Pharmaceutical companies are increasingly seeking partners who align with ESG goals, ensuring ethical sourcing, reduced environmental impact and data-driven visibility throughout the supply chain.' Yuen-O'Sullivan expects digital transformation to accelerate, with artificial intelligence adoption progressing from isolated experiments to widespread, in-process implementation under GxP conditions. 'Lightweight AI-powered tools will enable faster deployment of digital solutions, making advanced, real-time analytics more accessible,' she says. Keogh predicts that integration of gas detectors with cloud-based systems will enhance centralised data analysis, reporting and management. 'Progress in sensor technology will focus on improving the portability, versatility, and accuracy of gas detection devices. Innovations such as AI and machine learning integration in sensors will increase accuracy and pattern detection,' says Keogh. Costello also believes that digitalisation and sustainability will be important trends going forward and she stresses the crucial importance of ensuring companies have robust talent strategies in place. In its 2023-2027 strategy document, BioPharmaChem Ireland called for a national strategy to identify future talent requirements and position Ireland as the global location of choice for Global Business Services. The document suggested that the government should establish an 'Office for Life Sciences' to co-ordinate these efforts. The strategy emphasises the development of project management and customer relationship management skills, as well as digital skills. In the report, Matt Moran, director of BioPharmaChem Ireland, commented: 'Ireland has benefited greatly from the growth of biologics, pharmaceuticals and chemicals industries and I believe that the best is yet to come.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Arrive and thrive: A helping hand for moving to Ireland
The desire to move to a new country for fresh opportunities or a better quality of life helps drive corporate relocations all across Ireland. It also provides employers here with access to highly skilled personnel. But if such relocations don't work out, it can be a costly mistake, says David Dowling of Ireland Relocations, part of the Cronin Group. As well as logistics and machinery, the business specialises in relocation of international personnel. In all cases, careful handling is required. 'We provide stress-free and tailored relocation solutions for corporate clients, individuals and families who are relocating to Ireland and what we say is that preparation is what allows their employees to arrive, ready to thrive,' says Dowling. The company provides a range of services including visa and employment permit management, home search, temporary accommodation solutions, and school search for families. As well as bringing people over for a 'look see' in advance, once the candidate has arrived, it provides settle-in and orientation services. READ MORE 'The idea behind it is that when they arrive in Ireland, they've already seen their accommodation, and have talked to the school, having come over maybe a month or two before their kids are due to start,' Dowling explains. 'For the employer, it means much less chance of a failed assignment because they settle in much more quickly and do a better job, with less of a chance that one of the family simply cannot settle in and wants to go back.' Ireland Relocations can provide a comprehensive hand-holding service to new arrivals, helping them through all the practical details that might otherwise soak up their time, from opening bank accounts to signing up with utilities providers and figuring out transport links, all of which can feel overwhelming. 'It's not just about visas and employment permits but about how to help someone get their PPS number and all the documentation required for that too, for example. It's all about making it a much smoother and stress-free assignment for them,' says Dowling. Such assignments are made right across the country, with some of Ireland Relocations' biggest clients coming from sectors such as pharmaceuticals, med tech, IT and nursing homes. For most people moving to Ireland, a priority is to secure accommodation close to their new workplace. In a housing crisis, doing that independently has become a serious challenge. 'Many are coming for great jobs and are really happy with the pay and conditions but it may not occur to them that they are landing in the middle of an accommodation crisis and that it is going to be really hard,' says Dowling. One of the advantages of working with Ireland Relocations is that it gets access to 'off-market' rentals. 'It means we can offer them a better choice than if they were searching for themselves. We can also recommend certain areas near their workplace, based on their particular criteria. For example, it might be that they want proximity to a school, or a train link, or to be beside the sea. We can give them advice on all of that rather than them having to try to figure it out for themselves. 'We've specialists in every location across the country who know the local markets really well and have built up relationships with auctioneers and even landlords who will phone us to say they've a property coming available in a month or two's time. They know these people all come reference checked and, because they are being brought in by employers, have good jobs and are likely to be secure tenants.' The biggest mistake those relocating independently tend to make is choosing the wrong location. 'Often they just don't realise how far away they are from their work and how difficulties can occur as a result. On a map it might look good but it may not be connected up in terms of transport routes, for example,' says Dowling. 'Sometimes when they do it independently the property viewed online is not the same as the one they arrive to – it's simply not in the same condition. Alternatively, they may not have seen the neighbouring properties or the whole setting. The other thing is that sometimes people arrive with pets, only for the landlord to say, sorry, no pets allowed.' Proper relocation services enables people to avoid all such nasty surprises, while comprehensive orientation supports when they arrive ensure the move is a positive one all round. For employers, such relocation services packages come at a cost but it is far cheaper than having an unhappy candidate leave and having to start all over again, as Dowlng points out: 'It's all about having a successful assignment.'
