Nigel Owens' verdict on controversial schoolboy try
A controversial try scored just before halftime in a South Island schoolboy rugby match has drawn global attention and a firm ruling from former international referee Nigel Owens.
Marlborough Boys' College scored a 28-26 win over Nelson College, but it was a moment just before the break that has become the biggest talking point of the match.
Lining up a penalty from right in front of the posts after informing the referee they were taking the kick, Marlborough centre Anru Erasmus instead nudged the ball towards the touchline to his teammate Finn Neal, who scored.
The Nelson side were huddled under the posts expecting a straightforward penalty to be kicked.
After a brief period of discussion with one of his assistants, the referee awarded the try.
ADVERTISEMENT
"He doesn't contravene any law that I can think of, so it's a try," he said.
Commentator Jeff McTainsh called the incident "the most bizarre try you'll ever see".
In a post to X, the Welsh ex-international referee Owens looked into the legality of the try.
"No try. You must make a genuine attempt to kick at goal before the try can be allowed to stand. This clearly wasn't," the 53-year-old said, adding that the play should have been brought back.
"PK void scrum."
World Rugby Law 8.20 said: "If the team indicates to the referee the intention to kick at goal, they must kick at goal. The intention to kick can be communicated to the referee or signalled by the arrival of the kicking tee or sand, or when the player makes a mark on the ground."
ADVERTISEMENT
The moment has caused plenty of discussion, with the UK's Daily Telegraph and Planet Rugby covering the try.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
2 days ago
- 1News
Nigel Owens' verdict on controversial schoolboy try
A controversial try scored just before halftime in a South Island schoolboy rugby match has drawn global attention and a firm ruling from former international referee Nigel Owens. Marlborough Boys' College scored a 28-26 win over Nelson College, but it was a moment just before the break that has become the biggest talking point of the match. Lining up a penalty from right in front of the posts after informing the referee they were taking the kick, Marlborough centre Anru Erasmus instead nudged the ball towards the touchline to his teammate Finn Neal, who scored. The Nelson side were huddled under the posts expecting a straightforward penalty to be kicked. After a brief period of discussion with one of his assistants, the referee awarded the try. ADVERTISEMENT "He doesn't contravene any law that I can think of, so it's a try," he said. Commentator Jeff McTainsh called the incident "the most bizarre try you'll ever see". In a post to X, the Welsh ex-international referee Owens looked into the legality of the try. "No try. You must make a genuine attempt to kick at goal before the try can be allowed to stand. This clearly wasn't," the 53-year-old said, adding that the play should have been brought back. "PK void scrum." World Rugby Law 8.20 said: "If the team indicates to the referee the intention to kick at goal, they must kick at goal. The intention to kick can be communicated to the referee or signalled by the arrival of the kicking tee or sand, or when the player makes a mark on the ground." ADVERTISEMENT The moment has caused plenty of discussion, with the UK's Daily Telegraph and Planet Rugby covering the try.
Otago Daily Times
08-05-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Wrexham lock in date for Phoenix
Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney, co-owners of Wrexham, with the trophy after winning League One In England. Hollywood-backed Welsh football club Wrexham will play the Wellington Phoenix in Wellington on July 19. RNZ reported last month the Red Dragons would play the Phoenix in July, but the match date at Wellington's Sky Stadium has now been confirmed. The Welsh side, owned by Hollywood duo Rob McElhenney and Ryan Reynolds, recently sealed their third promotion in as many years and will next season compete in the EFL Championship, one rung below the Premier League. Wrexham is also likely to play Melbourne Victory and Sydney FC as part of their pre-season build up. The date confirmation is some positive news for the Phoenix club, which endured a tough season in both the men's and women's A-League competition, neither side making the play-offs. The men finished 11th and the women ninth. Wrexham have developed a global profile on the back of being bought by Reynolds and McElhenney and their popular Disney+ series Welcome to Wrexham. The Phoenix have previously hosted games against international clubs West Ham, Newcastle United, Boca Juniors and David Beckham's LA Galaxy.
NZ Herald
06-05-2025
- NZ Herald
Bill McCaw, oldest living All Black, dies aged 97
His son John McCaw, also a loose forward, represented Canterbury from 1986-87. McCaw played in the famous 1953 test when Wales beat the All Blacks 13-8 in 1953 in Cardiff – the last time the Welsh tasted victory over New Zealand. He spoke about the match in an interview with the Herald in 2021. 'It's not such a good thing carrying that 'honour' of being in that team to lose to Wales – you can't get that one off your back. But it's still a big item of rugby history, isn't it? 'We always like to think we struck the Welsh at a time when they were at their peak with players like Bleddyn Williams and Ken Jones, and they had some pretty notable forwards too. 'Yes, it always gets thrown up at you – 'you were in that team which lost to Wales'. I just ignore it.' McCaw said he's often asked if he is related to a certain Richie McCaw. 'I tell people look, I'm not related to Richie, but I was the first McCaw All Black,' he said. Happy 90th Birthday to All Black #527 Bill McCaw. It was a thrill to take Bill and his family for a helicopter ride and picnic in the mountains yesterday. Posted by Richie McCaw on Friday 25 August 2017 'On my 90th birthday, my family took me out for a helicopter ride and of course who was the pilot but Richie. 'We all enjoyed it and he is such an easy guy to talk to, very down to earth. We didn't get into match specifics at all – his record is too overwhelming.'
