
Why Russia is no longer a member of the G8
BANFF — When world leaders gathered for the 70th anniversary of the D-Day landings, it was an awkward situation: Just months before, Vladimir Putin's Russia had invaded Ukraine, annexing Crimea.
Article content
That invasion precipitated a diplomatic and military crisis that, more than 10 years later, is still unfolding. And in one of the earliest signs of the international community's resistance to Russian belligerence, the leaders of the world's advanced economies ejected Russia from the G8, in March of that year.
Article content
Article content
Article content
'Personally, and I only speak for Canada here, I don't see any way of a return of Mr. Putin to the (G8) table unless Russia fundamentally changes course,' said then prime minister Stephen Harper at the time.
Article content
Article content
In fact, Putin had been slated to host world leaders in Sochi, Russia, in 2014, but the now seven-member summit regrouped and reorganized the event for Brussels, in Belgium. Since then, Russia has dramatically escalated its war on Ukraine, launching a full-scale invasion in February 2023.
Article content
John Kirton, the director of the G7 research group, said that in 2014 the sidelining of Russia was a 'very big deal.'
Article content
'Russia, which had been a democratizing country — which is why it had become basically a full member of the G8 — was clearly turning back and in a very big, bold way, and even beyond that, that was a violation of the core membership criteria for being a G7 member, you have to be a democracy,' said Kirton.
Article content
Article content
Yet, on Monday morning, U.S. President Donald Trump, who's widely perceived as friendly with the Russian strongman, lamented the ejection of Russia from what was then the G8 in remarks before reporters after meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney.
Article content
Article content
'The G7 used to be the G8. Barack Obama and a person named Trudeau didn't want to have Russia in, and I would say that that was a mistake, because I think you wouldn't have a war right now if you had Russia in, and you wouldn't have a war right now if Trump were president four years ago,' Trump said. 'It was a mistake in that you spend so much time talking about Russia, and he's no longer at the table, so it makes life more complicated, but you wouldn't have had the war.'
Article content
The story of Russia leaving the G8 is more complicated than that, however. For starters, Justin Trudeau wasn't prime minister in March 2014 — Harper was. And Harper was a bullish defender of Ukrainian sovereignty, becoming the first G7 leader to visit the embattled European nation following Russia's invasion and famously telling Putin at a Group of 20 meeting in November 2014 that he should 'get out of Ukraine.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Ottawa Citizen
16 minutes ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Donald Trump to leave G7 Summit early over Middle East tensions
U.S. President Donald Trump will leave the G7 Summit in Alberta early, with the rising tensions in the Middle East cited as the reason. Article content In a post to X late on Monday afternoon, Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, said that Trump 'had a great day at the G7,' and 'much was accomplished.' Article content Article content 'But because of what's going on in the Middle East, President Trump will be leaving tonight after dinner with Heads of State,' Leavitt wrote. Article content Article content President Trump had a great day at the G7, even signing a major trade deal with the United Kingdom and Prime Minister Keir Starmer. Much was accomplished, but because of what's going on in the Middle East, President Trump will be leaving tonight after dinner with Heads of State. — Karoline Leavitt (@PressSec) June 16, 2025 Article content In recent days, Israel and Iran have neared all-out war, with Israel assassinating a number of high-level Iranian officials and Iran responding with rocket attacks on Israel's cities. Article content Article content Trump called for the evacuation of Iran's capital Tehran on Monday, hours after he urged the country's leadership to sign a deal to limit its nuclear program and Israel signalled strikes would continue. Article content It wasn't clear if Trump knew of a fresh round of attacks Israel may have planned for the city, which has a population of more than 9 million people. Israel had earlier warned one Tehran neighbourhood to evacuate and video showed massive traffic jams as people sought to escape. Soon after Trump's post, Iran's Fars news agency reported several explosions east of the city. Article content 'Iran should have signed the 'deal' I told them to sign,' Trump wrote in a social media post from a Group of Seven leaders' summit in Alberta, Canada. 'What a shame, and waste of human life. Simply stated, IRAN CAN NOT HAVE A NUCLEAR WEAPON. I said it over and over again! Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran!' Article content Earlier in the day, Trump had said Iran wanted to make a deal, and 'as soon as I leave here, we're going to be doing something.' He didn't provide any more details.


Calgary Herald
18 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
Donald Trump to leave G7 Summit early over Middle East tensions
U.S. President Donald Trump will leave the G7 Summit in Alberta early, with the rising tensions in the Middle East cited as the reason. Article content In a post to X late on Monday afternoon, Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, said that Trump 'had a great day at the G7,' and 'much was accomplished.' Article content Article content 'But because of what's going on in the Middle East, President Trump will be leaving tonight after dinner with Heads of State,' Leavitt wrote. Article content Article content President Trump had a great day at the G7, even signing a major trade deal with the United Kingdom and Prime Minister Keir Starmer. Much was accomplished, but because of what's going on in the Middle East, President Trump will be leaving tonight after dinner with Heads of State. — Karoline Leavitt (@PressSec) June 16, 2025 Article content In recent days, Israel and Iran have neared all-out war, with Israel assassinating a number of high-level Iranian officials and Iran responding with rocket attacks on Israel's cities. Article content Article content Trump called for the evacuation of Iran's capital Tehran on Monday, hours after he urged the country's leadership to sign a deal to limit its nuclear program and Israel signalled strikes would continue. Article content It wasn't clear if Trump knew of a fresh round of attacks Israel may have planned for the city, which has a population of more than 9 million people. Israel had earlier warned one Tehran neighbourhood to evacuate and video showed massive traffic jams as people sought to escape. Soon after Trump's post, Iran's Fars news agency reported several explosions east of the city. Article content 'Iran should have signed the 'deal' I told them to sign,' Trump wrote in a social media post from a Group of Seven leaders' summit in Alberta, Canada. 'What a shame, and waste of human life. Simply stated, IRAN CAN NOT HAVE A NUCLEAR WEAPON. I said it over and over again! Everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran!' Article content Earlier in the day, Trump had said Iran wanted to make a deal, and 'as soon as I leave here, we're going to be doing something.' He didn't provide any more details.


CTV News
18 minutes ago
- CTV News
‘You're talking about a war criminal': Trump slammed for calling Russian G7 expulsion a ‘mistake'
President Donald Trump walks during the official welcome of the G7 Summit, Monday, June 16, 2025, in Kananaskis, Canada. (AP Photo/Mark Schiefelbein) U.S. President Donald Trump's criticism of Russia being expelled from the G7 is drawing sharp criticism from Canadian officials and diplomats, as Prime Minister Mark Carney navigates a summit agenda that includes both war and tariffs. 'Barack Obama and a person named Trudeau didn't want to have Russia in, and I would say that that was a mistake, because I think you wouldn't have a war right now if you had Russia in,' Trump told reporters Monday, in an apparent reference to Russia's expulsion from the group of major industrialized democracies in 2014, and to former prime minister Justin Trudeau, who was not yet elected at the time. 'There are a bunch of factual errors there,' said former Alberta premier Jason during a panel segment with CTV's Power Play Monday. 'It wasn't always the G8. It started as the G7 in the 1970s, precisely to bring together the major democratic economies of the world as a counterpoint to the coordination going on in the Soviet bloc.' Russia was only invited as part of an effort to encourage reform in the post-Soviet era, said Kenney, a move he called a 'failed experiment' as Russia later annexed Crimea and invaded Ukraine. 'Bringing Putin in … all that does is create an impossible group to discuss anything in terms of shared values or strategic interests,' Kenney said. Derek Burney, former Canadian ambassador to the U.S., was even more blunt. 'You're talking about a war criminal,' Burney said. 'There's no way anybody can pretend that Russia is a democracy today.' Burney said Trump's comments reflect a comfort with autocratic leaders, adding that Canada and other G7 members 'are going to stand firm on this.' Trump has continued to insist the war in Ukraine wouldn't have broken out had he remained in office, a statement Burney dismissed as 'nonsensical.' 'Thank God (Ukrainian President Volodymyr) Zelensky is at the G7 summit in Canada, and not Putin,' he said. Carney has invited Zelenskyy to attend alongside G7 leaders and select guests. John Manley, who served as both foreign affairs and finance minister during Jean Chretien's premiership, noted there may be 'a little piece of truth' in Trump's emphasis on keeping lines of communication open, but said that doesn't justify reinstating Russia. 'I don't think that Vladimir Putin is on the same wavelength as the other countries in the G7,' Manley said. 'His exclusion was done at a time that wasn't accompanied by enough other firm measures … but I've never believed in pulling our ambassadors out of countries.' 'We deserve what we negotiated' Despite the foreign policy fireworks, Trump said his focus at the summit was trade and Canada. 'I think our primary focus will be trade, and trade with Canada, and I'm sure we can work something out,' Trump said at a bilateral meeting with Carney. 'I'm a tariff person. I've always been a tariff (person). It's simple, it's easy, it's precise and it just goes very quickly, and I think Mark has a more complex idea, but also very good.' The two leaders met privately following weeks of calls and text exchanges in a bid to de-escalate tensions tied to tariffs and market access. Kenney said Trump's fondness for tariffs is deeply ingrained. 'He has said before that his favourite word in the English language is tariffs … and in 40 years of public commentary on issues, it is the one issue on which he has been most consistent,' he said. 'I hope that what we're going to get out of some agreement is a minimization of tariffs.' Kenney noted Trump imposed steel and aluminum tariffs on Canada during his first administration, only to later walk them back and sign the Canada-U.S.-Mexico (CUSMA) trade deal. 'The challenge for Prime Minister Carney is to bring him back to that,' Kenney said. 'The early evidence of growth in the U.S. economy… is probably not a good sign. It will probably be seen as wind in the sails of Trump tariff protectionism.' Burney said Canada must hold the line. 'We have an agreement … which reduces almost all of the tariffs between our two economies. For us to backslide on that under whatever pretext is not something we should be jumping into,' he said. 'We don't deserve modest relief. We deserve what we negotiated.' Manley echoed that concern, questioning whether Canada can rely on Trump as a trading partner. 'We did have an agreement with him before, and his first day in office, he breached it,' Manley said. 'So do we have a reliable counterparty?' Manley added that Canada needs more than promises. 'We absolutely want to have preferential access to the U.S. market,' Manley said. 'We need some stability and certainty… not something we're reviewing every year.' With files from The Canadian Press