Watchdog to create code of practice for using surveillance in mental health services
A public consultation process is currently underway by the Mental Health Commission, to seek the views of people who use mental health services about how the use of surveillance equipment impacts on them.
The views of family members, carers and friends are also being sought, as well as those of people working in the sector.
The Director of Regulation at the Mental Health Commission, Gary Kiernan, says surveillance technologies have advanced considerably in recent years, and their use has become 'a complex area' in mental health services.
He said: 'The Mental Health Commission wants to develop a code of practice that takes account of these technological advancements while encouraging and promoting good practices and high standards in relation to their use.
"This consultation is particularly concerned with how Ireland's mental health services should protect the rights of people who use mental health services, especially their rights to privacy and dignity. I would encourage all interested parties to engage and ensure their voices are heard.'
According to the commission, such technology is used to observe or monitor service users to 'inform their care and treatment'.
While CCTV is currently the most commonly used form of surveillance, other technologies being used include bodyworn cameras, infrared cameras, sensors, alarms, and GPS trackers. The use of such equipment falls under regulation 25 of the Mental Health Act 2001 (Approved Centres) Regulations 2006.
The Mental Health Commission says the purpose of the consultation is to identify key areas that the new code of practice should address.
It said: 'The Code of Practice will apply initially to inpatient mental health services. Its scope may be widened in the future to include community mental health services and community residences once the MHC's regulatory remit expands to include these services.'
The survey can be accessed online here. PDF versions of the survey may also be requested from standards@mhcirl.ie and returned via email or by post.
Focus groups and interviews with interested stakeholders will also take place, with interested parties invited to email standards@mhcirl.ie. The public consultation will close at 5pm on July 16.
Read More
Suzanne Crowe: People with severe mental illness will be failed by proposed new law
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
05-08-2025
- Irish Examiner
Prisoner died day before his scheduled transfer to psychiatric unit, report says
The death of a prisoner in Cloverhill Prison occurred a day before he was due to be transferred to a psychiatric unit, according to the Office of the Inspector of Prisons. A report into the death of the inmate has been submitted by the office to justice minister Jim O'Callaghan. The prisoner, identified only as Mr O, died on August 10, 2022, at the age of 52, while on remand for minor offences. The report said the man's cause of death is 'a matter for the coroner'. He was arrested in Dublin Airport six days earlier, 'due to his behaviour and for refusing to comply with the direction' of gardaí. The man had arrived in Ireland the previous month from Spain to visit a friend. However, his friend asked him to leave their home 'due to his erratic behaviour' prior to his arrest for a public order offence. He had been granted a nil cash bond and would have been required to sign a bail bond confirming that he would not commit an offence and be of good behaviour following release. However, the report into his death outlined: 'The investigation team were informed by Governor A that he considered that Mr O was not in a fit state of mind to take up his bail bond.' The report said that Mr O's behaviour on committal was 'erratic' and he was accommodated in a 'close supervision cell'. He was medically assessed by the prison's healthcare staff and the Prison In-reach and Court Liaison Service team, whose task is to identify people suffering mental health issues when remanded to prison. The report continued: 'Mr O was scheduled to be released from Cloverhill Prison under the Mental Health Act 2001 to St Vincent's Psychiatric Unit on 11 August 2022. However, Mr O was discovered unresponsive in his cell on August 10, 2022.' The report also outlined that on August 8, a psychiatrist, A, recorded on the Prisoner Healthcare Management System that a call had been received from gardaí saying that the judge 'would be striking out charges' against Mr O 'if treatment could be arranged, given his current mental state'. The investigation team were told that Mr O had spent time in a psychiatric hospital outside the jurisdiction, "and it was believed he had not taken his prescribed medication over the previous 10 months'. A second psychiatrist, B, told the investigation team that 'accessing treatment in a community-based psychiatric facility is extremely challenging'. Referencing the 2006 Vision for Change document on mental health services, the psychiatrist 'pointed out that, 17 years later, mentally ill persons in prison custody still cannot easily gain access to psychiatric community-based facilities', said the report, adding that 'this lack of access results in prisoner-patients not receiving the mental health treatment they require.' The report continued: 'This is consistent with the Inspectorate's findings during its recent thematic evaluation of the provision of psychiatric care in the Irish prison system.' The report also said: 'Mr O died in prison before his legitimate mental health treatment needs could be met. This only serves to underscore the urgent need to forge new system-wide clinical care pathways, including rapid transfer to local civil psychiatric hospitals, for prisoner-patients such as Mr O.' The report is calling for 'urgent consideration' to be given to 'the systemic changes that are required to facilitate the swift transfer of persons suspected or convicted' of minor offences, 'who have mental disorders, to local psychiatric hospitals'. It added: 'As this is likely to require the development and opening of appropriately secure, intensive care facilities/designated beds in civil psychiatric hospitals, this calls for a multi-agency approach.' Falsification of records Meanwhile, the report also said that it 'is imperative that the falsification of records is treated with the utmost seriousness', after the investigation team found that three entries confirming special observation checks were conducted at Mr O's cell were carried out after the time of Mr O's death. The report outlined the three checks were recorded as being conducted at 7am, 7.15am, and 7.30am on the morning of Mr O's death – after he was found unresponsive at 6.50am. 'The investigation team noted that an (unsuccessful) effort had been made to erase the three entries,' stated the report, adding that it 'clearly suggests' that the entries 'were being pre-filled by staff, entirely negating the value of this recording safeguard'.
Irish Examiner
01-08-2025
- Irish Examiner
Health workers see inclusion as central to caring for patients
Training to raise awareness of diversity and inclusion among medical workers is boosting the quality of services being delivered to patients, says Dr Suzanne Crowe, president of the Medical Council. Dr Crowe, who works in paediatric intensive care, says that an inclusive medical workforce leads to greater understanding of patients' needs, culturally competent care, and ultimately, better health outcomes for patients. Speaking during Cork Pride 2025, which runs from July 26 to August 3, Dr Crowe says that she welcomes Pride events, which allow us to pause and reflect on the importance of accepting people for who they are. In this Q&A interview, Dr Crowe outlines some of the areas in which Irish health service providers have been very positive in ensuring diversity and inclusion in how patients are cared for, while also highlighting a number of areas where further improvements would be beneficial, notably further supports to help doctors with a disability to carry out their work effectively. Does the Irish medical profession see itself as actively diverse and inclusive? I think the medical profession does see itself as diverse, and increasingly inclusive. Medicine as a profession welcomes people from all walks of life, and there is increasing diversity in terms of gender and sexuality, so I would see it as being inclusive in this sense. In my opinion, we've made a lot of progress over the last couple of decades in certain areas, particularly in diversity of ethnic backgrounds, as well as from a gender balance point of view. The profession is increasingly seeing equal numbers of men and women working in medicine, in fact, we're seeing a shift towards it being more female-dominated in some specialisms. Our most recent (2024) Medical Workforce Intelligence data shows that the gender split among GPs in Ireland had slightly more females (52.4%) than males (47.6%). The majority of female GPs are between the ages 30 and 59, and older age brackets from there and above are dominated by males. This suggests that as older male GPs retire, the proportion of females in general practice will continue to grow. As well as this, in 2024 our clinically active medical workforce consisted of 13.8% of doctors who qualified in the EU/UK, and 27.8% who qualified outside of Ireland, the EU and the UK — meaning that 41.6% of our medical workforce qualified outside of Ireland. Without these doctors, our health system would collapse immediately. An area that could be improved upon is for doctors with a disability. Further supports should be put in place for doctors with a disability to carry out their work effectively. Overall, the profession does regard itself as diverse and inclusive. In what ways does the sector's openness help with attracting and retaining talent? The healthcare sector is very active in attracting talent, both in Ireland and abroad. Doctors are united as protectors of health — of the individual, and the community; and Ireland is now seen as an open, democratic, and progressive society to live in. That's why a career in medicine in Ireland can be rewarding for those who have experienced trauma or marginalisation for their beliefs, and are seeking to contribute to an inclusive, modern society. While openness brings many benefits to medicine, it's worth noting areas that still need attention, such as long working hours, working environment, and conditions. We may be attracting talent, but need to ensure we're retaining our workforce in Ireland by providing a sustainable environment to work in. Do you believe there is a link between having a diverse workforce and safer patient outcomes? I believe there is. As doctors, we should ensure that we advocate for trust, partnership and informed consent in our relationships with patients. The Medical Council carried out research in 2023, which showed that 80% of people feel it is important to be treated as a partner in their healthcare by their doctor. What this essentially means is that patients want their doctor to be approachable — someone they can bring personal concerns to. This same survey showed that people in Ireland believe that the elderly (57%), members of the travelling community (34%), refugees (33%) and immigrants (32%) are among the minority groups most at risk of receiving substandard care. Members of minority groups have unique healthcare needs and may find it easier to speak to a doctor who comes from a similar background. If the patient can relate to their doctor, they'll feel understood, in a safe space, and like their care will be approached in a non-judgemental way. This helps patients feel safe in communicating with their doctor, which helps the doctor to personalise their treatment plan and direct it to specific issues. It can help the patient to follow their plan when there's a good relationship. All these elements combined help to enhance patient care and improve patient safety. Does training help promote a more actively diverse and inclusive approach to recruitment? Training our future workforce at an early stage to have an open, empathetic approach to people of different backgrounds helps ensure that Diversity, Equity & Inclusion (DE&I) awareness is already part of their understanding when they start work. Discrimination and lack of understanding can impede the path to compassionate healthcare. Bringing DE&I awareness to students throughout the lifecycle of the doctor from school into undergraduate and postgraduate education; will help doctors to address potential biases. Not only do they then have the awareness, correct language, and training about DE&I, but they'll eventually look to recruit that diversity into their own teams, because they know it'll increase inclusion, produce better working environments, and ultimately enhance patient care when treating patients of different backgrounds. Celebrating Pride also provides chances to educate and to learn, promote awareness and increase understanding of issues faced by the LGBTQI+ community. We saw a great turnout of doctors and healthcare workers from the HSE and LGBT Ireland for the Dublin Pride Parade a couple of weeks ago, and I have no doubt the representation will be strong for Cork Pride as well. LGBT Ireland's LGBT+ Champions programme is available to doctors and healthcare professionals to help understand the identities and advocate for their LGBTQI+ patients. These are provided by LGBT Ireland, the HSE, post graduate training bodies, universities, advocacy groups and charities.
Irish Independent
31-07-2025
- Irish Independent
‘Profound decline' in number of people being restrained in Irish mental health services, report finds
Restrictive practices include physically restraining someone or secluding them in a room and not allowing them to leave. The report was published by the Mental Health Commission (MHC), the independent regulator of mental health services in Ireland. It shows the total of 'restrictive practice episodes' in approved mental health centres fell significantly between 2018 and 2024. Over that seven-year period, the use of physical restraint and seclusion fell by 91pc in Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS). The use of mechanical restraint on children – using devices or bodily garments to restrain someone – was banned by the MHC in 2023. Professor Jim Lucey, the author of the report and inspector of Mental Health Services, said: 'Children are specifically protected from restrictive practices in Irish mental health care through a human rights-based approach, acknowledging their particular vulnerability to trauma and harm from restrictive interventions. 'Seclusion and physical restraint can have adverse implications for their emotional development. This approach, underpinned by the principles of trauma-informed care, has been further enhanced by the revised regulations.' There was a 'profound decline' in the number of restrictive practice episodes in CAMHS over the seven-year period, from 2,608 in 2018 to 238 in 2024. 'Our regulatory changes and initiatives, coupled with the commitment of leadership and staff to person-centred, therapeutic care has been instrumental in accelerating the downward trend in restrictive practice use in Ireland since 2022, and building on a significant decline observed since 2018,' MHC chief executive John Farrelly said. The findings of the report have been welcomed by the MHC as a 'positive result' for mental health services, with evidence showing restrictive practices are 'counterproductive' and do not help to reduce levels of violence and aggression in approved treatment centres. ADVERTISEMENT Learn more 'We have found significant reductions in both the frequency and duration of these practices, particularly since our new regulations and our improved, near real-time reporting system came into effect,' MHC director of regulation Gary Kiernan said. 'Furthermore, the steps we have taken in conjunction with approved centres to achieve these reductions includes mandatory training, new policies, and detailed post-incident reviews, emphasising a shift towards trauma-informed and person-centred care. 'We have also introduced enhanced oversight and reporting, requiring services to report each episode of seclusion or restraint within three working days of its commencement.' Rules around the use of seclusion and mechanical restraint were revised by the MHC in 2023, in an effort to prioritise the dignity and wellbeing of service users. The review was prompted by development in international human rights, advancements in person-centred care and evidence showing the 'harmful physical and psychological consequences of restrictive practices'. 'Our vision extends beyond the current scope of restrictive practices. It is our hope that this human rights approach will be applied more broadly to include all areas of care,' Prof Lucey added. 'It is our long-term goal of fostering a culture that prioritises dignity, autonomy and wellbeing across all aspects of mental healthcare, not just in the context of restrictive interventions.'
