Judge overstepped power when ordering government to appoint judges faster, appeal court rules
Article content
CALGARY — The Federal Court overstepped its authority when it ordered the government to fill an 'unacceptably high' number of judicial vacancies within a 'reasonable time,' the Federal Court of Appeal ruled Wednesday.
Article content
In a forceful rebuttal of the trial court ruling published Wednesday, the appeal court issued a sharp reminder to both judges and government: stay in your lane.
Article content
Article content
Article content
'No one disputes the utmost importance of filling judicial vacancies to ensure a healthy judiciary, and relatedly, a healthy democracy,' wrote Justice Richard Boivin on behalf of the panel of three appeal judges.
Article content
Article content
'But it remains that the judicial branch of government, like the other two branches of government — the executive and the legislative — fortify themselves by acting properly within their legitimate spheres of competence,' he continued.
Article content
Boivin said the Federal Court 'overstepped its jurisdictional bounds' when it ruled that the court could order the government to fill a high number of empty judge positions within a certain amount of time.
Article content
In his 2024 ruling lambasting the Liberal government, Federal Court Justice Henry S. Brown issued an unprecedented declaration that the prime minister and minister of justice must fill current and future vacancies within a 'reasonable time.'
Article content
Article content
The lawsuit was filed by Ottawa-based human rights lawyers Yavar Hameed and Nicholas Pope who argued that the lingering judicial vacancies were impacting Canadians' access to justice.
Article content
Article content
At the time, there were 75 judge positions waiting to be filled, an unusually high number. Brown said that the long delay was 'failing' Canadians.
Article content
His ruling noted that nine months after the chief justice of Canada wrote the Liberal government denouncing the situation, nothing had changed.
Article content
'The situation as outlined by the Chief Justice of Canada and Canadian Judicial Council is clearly critical and untenable and thus most serious, and therefore in the Court's view may not simply be ignored,' the judge wrote.
Article content
'Very unfortunately, the Court has no reason to expect the situation will change without judicial intervention,' he added, while declaring the government needed to reduce the vacancy rate to 'mid-40s.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
31 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
Justice minister says he doesn't like 'soft on crime' slogans, but won't 'diminish' those concerns
OTTAWA — Justice Minister Sean Fraser says that while he does not believe in using labels like 'soft on crime,' which critics employ to describe the justice system, he says it is important not to dismiss the concerns of those who use them. Article content 'I don't necessarily agree with the sloganeering approach, but that doesn't mean someone who may agree with it doesn't have a point that deserves the government's attention,' he told National Post in a recent wide-ranging interview on Wednesday. Article content Article content Article content Fraser enters the justice and attorney general portfolio at a time when premiers and police chiefs are pressing the federal government to further restrict access to bail, particularly in Ontario, as a strategy to stem the rising tide of auto thefts and home invasions, which police across the Greater Toronto Area and other regions of the country have reported. Article content Article content Making bail more difficult for those accused of these crimes, particularly when violence is used and when they are connected to organized crime, was a promise made by Prime Minister Mark Carney in late April's federal election, which saw the Liberals elected to a fourth term. Article content The Liberals also campaigned on a pledge to make bail harder for those charged with certain human trafficking and drug smuggling offences, as well as bringing in tougher sentencing guidelines for courts to follow for repeat offenders convicted of a home invasion or auto theft. Article content Article content Crime was a major focus of Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre's campaign, with candidates handing out leaflets emblazoned with the percentages of how much car theft has increased in and around Toronto, where they flipped several seats from the Liberals. Article content Conservatives have continued to draw attention to crime rates by laying them squarely at the feet of what they describe as 'soft on crime' and 'catch-and-release' Liberal justice policies. Article content Fraser says the discussion around tightening bail is rooted in legal analysis and not 'exclusively on the increased scrutiny that you may see from the public or from another political party.' It is also a multi-jurisdictional matter, he points out, and touches on issues like training for judges and justices of the peace, as well as the shortage of Crown prosecutors, which the Liberals have pledged to tackle.
Vancouver Sun
42 minutes ago
- Vancouver Sun
Justice minister says he doesn't like 'soft on crime' slogans, but won't 'diminish' those concerns
OTTAWA — Justice Minister Sean Fraser says that while he does not believe in using labels like 'soft on crime,' which critics employ to describe the justice system, he says it is important not to dismiss the concerns of those who use them. 'I don't necessarily agree with the sloganeering approach, but that doesn't mean someone who may agree with it doesn't have a point that deserves the government's attention,' he told National Post in a recent wide-ranging interview on Wednesday. Fraser enters the justice and attorney general portfolio at a time when premiers and police chiefs are pressing the federal government to further restrict access to bail, particularly in Ontario, as a strategy to stem the rising tide of auto thefts and home invasions, which police across the Greater Toronto Area and other regions of the country have reported. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Making bail more difficult for those accused of these crimes, particularly when violence is used and when they are connected to organized crime, was a promise made by Prime Minister Mark Carney in late April's federal election, which saw the Liberals elected to a fourth term. The Liberals also campaigned on a pledge to make bail harder for those charged with certain human trafficking and drug smuggling offences, as well as bringing in tougher sentencing guidelines for courts to follow for repeat offenders convicted of a home invasion or auto theft. Crime was a major focus of Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre's campaign, with candidates handing out leaflets emblazoned with the percentages of how much car theft has increased in and around Toronto, where they flipped several seats from the Liberals. Conservatives have continued to draw attention to crime rates by laying them squarely at the feet of what they describe as 'soft on crime' and 'catch-and-release' Liberal justice policies. Fraser says the discussion around tightening bail is rooted in legal analysis and not 'exclusively on the increased scrutiny that you may see from the public or from another political party.' It is also a multi-jurisdictional matter, he points out, and touches on issues like training for judges and justices of the peace, as well as the shortage of Crown prosecutors, which the Liberals have pledged to tackle. 'When we hear the scrutiny that may come from the public on an issue that's an early warning system that you should be looking into, has there been a change? What is underlying that change?' The involvement of organized crime has increased the number of car thefts in areas like Ontario, said Fraser, who on Wednesday met with the chief of Peel Regional Police to discuss the matter. Asked whether Canadians have a point when they say the country is 'soft on crime,' Fraser says he sees the issue differently. 'I think it's important that we don't operate in the space of slogans and sound bites, but that we don't diminish concerns that are raised when it comes to the very real issues that underlie those distinct issues that come forward.' 'So when I hear that kind of language, sometimes it reflects a desire to get something in the news because it's easy to communicate. But just because someone uses a slogan doesn't mean you should ignore a social fact that may underlie it.' With the House of Commons preparing to break for summer, Fraser says the government will be taking the next few months to hear from police and other stakeholders about other measures that may help address public safety, but said a bill ushering in some of the Liberals' platform commitments is expected to be tabled this fall. He is also still settling into his new role. Fraser has yet to have his first sit-down with Supreme Court Justice Richard Wagner, outside of an introductory call. Framed photos, which have yet to be hung, also sit around parts of Fraser's office, which is the same one the country's justice ministers have traditionally used. The weight of the role is not lost on Fraser, who graduated with a law degree from Dalhousie University and had a legal career before entering politics in 2015. 'You almost treat the attorney general role as an institution,' he said. The Liberals' upcoming bail reform measures represent the second time in the same number of years that the Liberals have enacted tougher measures. The last time was in 2023, when former justice minister Arif Virani shepherded through legislation aimed at repeat violent offenders and those accused of intimate partner violence, a move that followed calls from premiers and police chiefs, as well as the high-profile shooting death of a 28-year-old Ontario Provincial Police officer, where the accused had been released on bail. At the time, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and other advocacy groups warned that toughening bail access would lead to an increase in the number of individuals who were legally innocent finding themselves in pre-trial detention and exacerbate the country's already high population of Indigenous and Black people in provincial jails. Fraser told National Post that while public scrutiny is part of what has put the issue around car theft and home invasions on the government's 'radar,' he said it is not the driving force. 'Public attention on an issue is one of many factors, but the public attention is not in and of itself what drives it. It's the public attention that reflects a problem that people see in their communities,' he said. He added the government would be 'remiss' to ignore what it has heard from parts of Ontario, even if he says 'that may not be the same level of noise' emanating from Pictou County, N.S., where he hails from. Fraser says the proposed Criminal Code changes do not reflect how 'the country is more dangerous today than it was yesterday,' given there has been a mix of certain types of crimes increasing, while other parts of the country have shown a more 'encouraging trend.' 'Law is very much responsive to social changes that take place in communities, he said. 'And that's a strength of a democracy, is that you have the opportunity to take feedback, not from just the people who administer the system, but the people for whom it is administered.' National Post staylor@ Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our newsletters here .
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
This is the design for the new National Monument to Canada's Mission in Afghanistan
The National Capital Commission unveiled final designs for the new National Monument to Canada's Mission in Afghanistan. It will be built on Booth Street across from the Canadian War Museum. (National Capital Commission/release) Construction is set to begin next spring on the new National Monument to Canada's Mission in Afghanistan. The National Capital Commission approved the design for the monument that will be located on Booth Street at LeBreton Flats across from the Canadian War Museum. It will be located near the National Holocaust Monument. 'The National Monument to Canada's Mission in Afghanistan will serve as a testament to the commitment and sacrifice of Canadian Armed Forces members, police officers, public servants and civilians who served in Canada's mission in Afghanistan,' the federal government said on its website. 'The Monument will also recognize the strong support offered by Canadians at home to those who served during the mission.' Ottawa monument The National Capital Commission unveiled final designs for the new National Monument to Canada's Mission in Afghanistan. The monument on Booth Street across from the Canadian War Museum is expected to be finished in 2028. (National Capital Commission/release) The design of the monument, developed by Team Stinson, draws on elements of healing from a Medicine Wheel, with four portals and an interior area described as a 'sanctuary where the fallen are remembered.' The names of the fallen Canadian soldiers and maple leaves will be inscribed on the walls of three quadrants, while the fourth wall facing the direction of Afghanistan is dedicated to fallen Afghan allies, according to Veterans Affairs Canada. 'In the centre, four bronze flak jackets stand draped on crosses—utilitarian yet poignant reminders of protection. This Monument creates a powerful opportunity to honour and reflect, and to seek balance and healing, for all Canadians." Ottawa monument The National Capital Commission unveiled final designs for the new National Monument to Canada's Mission in Afghanistan to be built in Ottawa. (National Capital Commission/release) The federal government says 158 Canadian Armed Forces members, a diplomat, four aid workers, a government contractor and a journalist died while in Afghanistan. NCC officials expect the monument to be completed in the spring/summer of 2028.
