
People Die, Dogs And Pigeons Live Is New Mantra Of Life: Sena Editorial
Shiv Sena(UBT) on Wednesday supported the Supreme Court's orders upholding the Bombay High Court's stay on feeding pigeons and asking the municipal authorities to pick up and house all stray dogs in Delhi and parts of the National Capital Region in dedicated shelters within eight weeks.
In the party mouthpiece 'Saamana' editorial, the Shiv Sena(UBT) said that pigeons and stray dogs pose a threat to human health, and it is wrong to incite religious sentiments on this.
"Thousands of people are crushed to death like dogs and cats every year in road and railway accidents, neither the government nor the people who believe in ghost mercy feel sorry for it. 'People die, dogs and pigeons live' is the new mantra of life, a distortion that has emerged in the last ten years. A community speaks of taking up arms to feed pigeons. In the thoughts of Lord Mahavira, there is no place for violence and such recklessness, and Hinduism does not say that even biting dogs should be given five kilos of government foodgrains. Still, in our country, the invention of ghost mercy is being created unnecessarily in the name of religion," claimed the Thackeray camp.
'People are dying or committing suicide in India due to hunger, numerous diseases, and debt, but some people are not concerned about these dying brothers and sisters. They feel a pang of pity and are disturbed by the concern for the survival and food for pigeons, stray dogs, and cats. Some people in Mumbai and Delhi have raised a riot over pigeons and stray dogs. Even though the High Court and now the Supreme Court have warned against putting seeds in pigeon houses in Mumbai, the pity-mongers are not ready to listen," said the Thackeray camp.
The editorial further stated, 'No one should show mercy to stray dogs in Delhi. The Supreme Court has ordered that these dogs be taken to shelter homes far from human settlements. Stray dogs have increased in all cities in India. These dogs run around, biting people...They attack children. Even those who go for morning walks are terrified of such dogs. The number of deaths due to rabies after dog bites has increased. In the last five years, over two crore people have been bitten by dogs. Out of which over a thousand people have died. Some have become permanently disabled. This picture is not good.'
Referring to the protest over feeding pigeons in Mumbai, Saamana said 'brave' Maharashtra has to fight to save the lives of people from the side effects of feeding pigeons, but a particular community is not only stuck to its stand on feeding pigeons, but the religious leaders of that community are using language like "We will fight with weapons in hand to feed pigeons on occasion". 'Riots broke out in Mira-Bhayander, Mumbai, over feeding pigeons. Pigeons are harmful to human health. The Supreme Court has ordered that pigeons are harmful and should not be fed, and that pigeon houses (Kabutar Khanas) should be closed. Does not the apex court give its ruling after weighing all sides?' asked the editorial.
Reiterating its support for a ban on pigeon feeding in public places, the editorial argued that many diseases are caused by the saliva, droppings, and feathers of pigeons.
"Being in contact with pigeon droppings is harmful to lung health. Pigeons are causing serious diseases in young children, and Dr Sujeet K. Rajan, a leading specialist in Chest Medicine, specialising in Respiratory Medicine and Interstitial Lung Disease (ILD), gave this information to the High Court through an affidavit. 'Lung diseases are increasing in the elderly, children, and women above the age of 60'. This is due to the infection caused by pigeons. Therefore, the doctors' group said that pigeon houses in densely populated cities like Mumbai should be moved, and the court accepted it. The municipal administration followed the court's order. However, the Jain community has taken a stand that by feeding pigeons, they attain goodness... How much of this is really a sense of religion and faith?" the editorial raised questions.
"In the past, pigeons used to work as postmen. Now it is not like that. Therefore, the fights over pigeons and dogs are pointless. There are organisations like 'PETA' that work to prevent cruelty to animals. Maneka Gandhi is worried about stray dogs and monkeys that cause hysteria across the country, but in Delhi, monkeys attack people. Even the bites of monkeys are fatal. This is because people who show mercy to pigeons, monkeys and stray dogs consider their lives miserable. People are not able to live a good life. People have become hungry, poor, and are living like beggars on PM Modi's five to ten kilos of free ration," said the editorial.
The Uddhav Thackeray camp, in a FAQ format, explained the importance of the court's decisions.
The Saamana editorial has reiterated that pigeon saliva, droppings and feathers cause serious lung diseases, especially among children, the elderly and women. Attacks by stray dogs, especially on children and those taking their morning walks, have increased. In the last five years, more than two crore people have been bitten by dogs, thousands have died from rabies, and some have been permanently disabled.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
25 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Best of Both Sides: SC order on stray dogs overlooks that compassion is what makes a city a home
A month ago, I carried five tiny kittens home from the street. They were stranded in a house about to be demolished, shivering, hungry, and still too young to eat on their own. Today, they are healthy, curious, and very sure they own my home. It is astonishing how quickly an animal can change when it is given care. This week's Supreme Court order that every street dog in Delhi be relocated to a shelter within eight weeks is, at its heart, about care — or rather, the lack of it. Yes, the threat of rabies is real. Yes, we need solutions to incidents of aggression and population growth. But there is a difference between solving a problem and sweeping it out of sight. Even if the order were legally sound, the reality on the ground makes it impossible to execute. To begin with, we don't know exactly how many dogs there are in Delhi. There hasn't been a count in 10 years. The 'estimate' offered by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi is around 8 lakh. Against those numbers, Delhi has just 20 temporary shelters, none of them government-run. Building and running enough facilities to house every dog would cost crores. We struggle to build bridges for decades, yet we are expected to build and staff thousands of shelters in two months. Ironically, the same MCD that has already failed to meet sterilisation targets and hasn't supplied anti-rabies vaccines in the numbers needed is now being tasked with the creation of humane shelters. Not once has the Court asked the civic body for accountability. But the most important reason to doubt the effectiveness of this order is neither legal nor logistical, it's logical. Mass removal simply doesn't work. We know this from Turkey, where a similar programme descended into mass culling, only for the stray population to rebound. The sterilise-vaccinate-return approach, enshrined in Indian law, exists because it works. Remove the dogs who already have a place, and you create space for new ones who don't. If the intent is to curb rabies cases in Delhi, then this order does more harm than good. To start with, panic fanned by WhatsApp messages declares that 2,000 people die of rabies every day in the national capital. Yet, the government's own figures — given in a reply to a question in the Lok Sabha just months ago — tell a very different story. According to official data, in 2024, there were 54 'suspected human rabies deaths' in the entire country — none from Delhi. The root cause of death by rabies is the shortage of rabies vaccines at government hospitals. Sending every single stray to a shelter cannot be a one-stop solution to India's rabies crisis. Look at Romania, where, after shelters were filled and streets emptied, unsterilised and unvaccinated dogs moved into the emptied territories. Beyond the failures of policy and denial of science, though, there is something more troubling: The absence of care. Article 51A(g) of our Constitution, which asks us to show compassion to all living creatures, is meant to shape how we live and the principles we live by. The persistent caricature of those who oppose this verdict is the elite South Delhi aunty, feeding pedigreed dogs in her gated colony. In truth, most community dogs live in less privileged neighbourhoods, sustained by families who cannot keep them inside their small homes but still take responsibility for them. I think of a friend who found a dog abandoned outside his home. He took the dog in, not into his house but into his life. Neighbours feed him. Someone else covers the cost of vaccinations. In winter, children in the lane make sure he has a blanket. This is what a community of care looks like: Fragile, improvised, but deeply human. The real cause of Delhi's stray population is abandonment. What happens when the dog bought for a child's birthday is dumped a year later? When he mates with another discarded pet, producing a litter born into homelessness? The owners face no penalty. But the puppies will be rounded up, sent to overcrowded shelters, where they will disappear. Even if Delhi somehow found the space and money overnight, removing sterilised, vaccinated dogs from their territories will undo years of rabies control and leave the streets more unsafe. The alternative is not a mystery. It is in our laws already: Large-scale sterilisation and vaccination, strict enforcement against illegal breeding and abandonment, public education on responsible pet ownership, and support for communities that care for animals where they are. The Supreme Court may have, in all its wisdom, passed the order that it has. Yet, the Chief Minister still has the chance to step in and stop an unworkable, unlawful order from taking effect — and to choose care over cruelty disguised as efficiency. Inhumanity is easy. It is also a sign of our times. But care — for each other, for the animals who live alongside us — is what makes a city worth calling home. The writer is national spokesperson, NCP (SP)


The Hindu
25 minutes ago
- The Hindu
The Hindu Morning Digest: August 15, 2025
Got caught up in sharp contests among political parties: ECI to Supreme Court The Election Commission of India (ECI) told the Supreme Court on Thursday (August 14, 2025) that it got 'caught up' in the 'sharp contests' among political parties. Appearing before a Bench of Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi, senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, for the ECI, pointed to the allegations raised against it about EVMs, and now the portrayal of the special intensive revision (SIR) exercise in Bihar as 'citizenship screening'. India endorses Trump-Putin summit in Alaska The Ministry of External Affairs on Thursday (August 14, 2025) 'endorsed' the summit between U.S. President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska, which could also decide the course of the tariffs the U.S. has imposed on India. Randhir Jaiswal, official spokesperson of the Ministry of External Affairs, said India stood ready to support peace efforts to end the conflict in Ukraine, and stated India-U.S. relations will move ahead based on 'mutual respect and shared interests'. Donald Trump thinks Vladimir Putin is ready to make a deal on Ukraine U.S. President Donald Trump said on Thursday (August 14, 2025) he believes Russian President Vladimir Putin will make a deal about his war on Ukraine, and that the threat of sanctions against Russia likely played a role in Moscow's decision to seek a meeting. Mr. Trump is scheduled to meet with Mr. Putin in Alaska on Friday (August 15, 2025). The U.S. President said he is unsure whether an immediate ceasefire can be achieved, but expressed interest in brokering a peace agreement. Rajnath hails Operation Sindoor as model of precision, self-reliance on eve of Independence Day On the eve of India's 79th Independence Day, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh praised Operation Sindoor as a 'precise and balanced' military response that highlighted India's 'new vision'. In his message to the armed forces on Thursday (August 14, 2025), he said the operation showcased India's new vision, technological advances, self-reliance, use of drones, layered air defence, electronic warfare, and network-centric operations. He said without crossing the Line of Control or harming civilians, the armed forces destroyed nine major terror camps, including those of the Lashkar-e-Taiba and Jaish-e-Mohammed, within minutes. Bihar SIR: Rationalisation of polling stations, change in BLOs spark confusion on ground Amid the ongoing Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, the Election Commission of India (ECI) has carried out rationalisation and reorganisation of polling stations in the entire State, a move which political parties claim has added to the confusion on the ground. The ECI has said that Bihar is the first State to implement this new ceiling of voters for each polling station. Rahul Gandhi accused of making false statements in Savarkar defamation proceedings A perjury application has been filed in the Special MP/MLA Court in Pune against Congress MP and Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, accusing him of misleading the court in a defamation case over his remarks on Vinayak Damodar 'Veer' Savarkar, made in London. The application has been filed by Satyaki Savarkar, the grandnephew of Veer Savarkar, through advocate Sangram Kolhatkar. It alleges that Mr. Gandhi falsely claimed in a 15-page pursis, or statement to the court, on July 29 that he had not received the defamatory video which forms the crux of the complaint. The plea states that Mr. Gandhi's advocate had acknowledged receipt of the documents, including a CD containing the speech, on May 9. India and U.S. to hold joint military exercise in Alaska this month, says MEA Amid trade uncertainties, India and United States will hold a joint military exercise in Alaska this month. According on Ministry of External Affairs, the India–U.S. defence partnership, underpinned by foundational defence agreements, is an important pillar of the bilateral partnership. This robust cooperation has strengthened across all domains. Bombay High Court to hear plea alleging threats to north Indians by Raj Thackeray, MNS A criminal writ petition has been filed on Thursday in the Bombay High Court against the Maharashtra government, the Mumbai Commissioner of Police, the Election Commission, and MNS chief Raj Thackeray. The petition filed by Sunil Shukla, national president of the Uttar Bhartiya Vikas Sena, a political party, alleges that he and the north Indian community in Maharashtra have been subjected to repeated incidents of hate speech, targeted violence, and serious threats to their lives and liberty. 11K security personnel, snipers on high-rises to keep Delhi safe on I-Day A day before the country celebrates its 78th Independence Day, security measures in the Capital were stepped up with snipers being deployed at high-rise buildings and camera surveillance being increased across the city. 11,000 security personnel and 3,000 traffic police have been posted for security in and around the Red Fort, from where Prime Minister Narendra Modi will address the nation on Friday. At least 40 dead in Sudan's worst cholera outbreak in years: Doctors Without Borders Cholera has claimed at least 40 lives in Sudan's Darfur region over the last week as the country weathers its worst outbreak of the illness in years, Doctors Without Borders (MSF) said on Thursday. The medical charity said the vast western region, which has been a major battleground over more than two years of fighting between the regular army and the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces, had been hardest hit by the year-old outbreak. BJP is stealing rights of tribals by 'erasing papers', says Rahul Gandhi Rahul Gandhi, Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, on Thursday (August 14, 2025) said that the Bharatiya Janata Party had made 'Erase the papers, steal the rights' its new 'weapon to oppress Bahujans' in India, reacting to a report in The Hindu that showed several thousands of forest rights titles across three districts had seemingly disappeared from the Chhattisgarh government's records over the last 17 months. Uncertainty looms over Devil release after actor Darshan's arrest 'Idre Nemdi Agirbek'(You should be at peace always), the first song from Kannada actor Darshan's upcoming film, Devil, was supposed to release on Independence Day. Ironically, on Thursday, Darshan's career hit the pause button again after he was arrested in connection with the Renukaswamy murder case, following the Supreme Court order cancelling the bail granted to him and the other accused. Chennai Grandmasters | Keymer seals title with a miraculous draw Vincent Keymer didn't appear to be at his serene best. His eighth-round game against Dutchman Jorden van Foreest was heading for an exciting finish and the German was close to suffering his first defeat in the Masters section of the Quantbox Chennai Grandmasters chess tournament.


Hans India
25 minutes ago
- Hans India
MyVoice: Views of our readers 15th August 2025
Enjoy an incident-free I-Day I am sincerely praying for an eco-friendly, cost-effective and safer Independence Day celebrations, particularly given the rising cases of stampedes wherever crowds are gathering in large numbers. There should be a blanket ban on use of plastic balloons and items that are harmful to the environment and birds, like piling of garbage at every stretch. Moreover, people should prefer to watch the live telecast, including on the big screen put up at vantage positions, as this can help save on time, money, fuel consumption (thereby reducing pollution levels) and large gatherings at the venues. These will go a long way as viable preventive measures. PVP Madhu Nivriti, Secunderabad-61 Good move to protect Kancha forest I am writing to express my appreciation of the government's decision to preserve Kancha forest in Gachibowli (Restore green cover at Kancha, Gachibowli, THI, Aug 14). This is a highly appreciable initiative towards safeguarding our environment, at a time when urbanisation is reducing our green spaces. Restoring this forest would also enhance the quality of life for those residing in and around Gachibowli apart from saving the habitat of many animals. Anhaar Majid, St Francis College for Women A 'green' battle at Kancha Gachibowli In an era where urban skylines are celebrated as symbols of progress, the Supreme Court's firm stand on restoring green cover at Kancha Gachibowli comes as a much-needed reminder that development cannot come at the cost of environmental destruction. The Chief Justice's stern warning, even hinting at jail time for top officials, sends a strong message that accountability in environmental matters is non-negotiable. The alleged destruction of the area's natural green belt not only threatens biodiversity but also jeopardizes the ecological balance of a city already gasping for cleaner air and cooler temperatures. Kancha Gachibowli is more than just a patch of green, it is a living ecosystem, a climate shield, and a legacy for future generations. If we lose it now, no amount of compensation will bring it back. The question is simple: will we protect our roots or pave over them? Aditi Rao, St Francis College for Women Not revising the Class X exam pattern deserves a pat I appreciate your article 'Existing exam pattern to continue for Class X' (THI, Aug 12). The order issued by the State government about continuing the existing pattern of examination for Class X is commendable. This pattern enhances the performance levels of students and gives more scope for improvement through tasks like unit tests, written assignments, projects and practical tests. The internal assessment being awarded 20 marks also reduces the stress on the students, which allows them to give their best shot in the external examination. Kashmira Konduparty, Hyderabad Kudos to HMRL's drug-free pledge In reference to your article 'All must chip in to banish drugs from society: HMRL MD' (August 14,) the Hyderabad Metro Rail's pledge to support the Nasha Mukt Bharat Abhiyaan is exemplary. This proves that public institutions can lead the way in tackling pressing social issues. Such actions remind us that the fight against drugs is not the sole responsibility of the authorities but a collective social mission for the well-being of our communities. Drug abuse is not merely a legal offence but a deep-rooted social threat that destroys families, disrupts communities, and endangers the future of our youth. Combating it demands unity across all sections of society. Government bodies, educational institutions, workplaces, neighbourhoods, and families must join forces to create awareness, remain alert, and take swift action when needed. Moreover, every small step counts whether it is about educating the young, reporting suspicious activities, or extending support to those seeking to break free from the addiction. If more organisations follow the HMRL precedent, our combined efforts could become a powerful force for change. Kalisetti Soumya, St Francis College for Women