Land and Environment Court dismisses Martins Creek Quarry expansion appeal
In 2022 resources company Daracon lodged plans to expand the Martins Creek Quarry, north-west of Newcastle, to allow it to extract more than a million tonnes of rock materials, like gravel, each year.
It was expected the expansion would generate up to 160 truck movements a day through several Hunter Valley towns, including the historic Paterson village and Bolwarra.
In February 2023, the NSW Independent Planning Commission (IPC) refused the expansion finding it would have "unreasonable" and "unacceptable" impacts for communities on the haulage route.
Daracon appealed the decision, arguing it would benefit the workforce and provide materials for local infrastructure projects in the construction and roads industries, but that appeal was knocked back again by the Land and Environment Court on Wednesday.
In the court's judgement, Commissioner Peter Walsh and Acting Commissioner Michael Young said negative consequences of the project outweighed the positives.
"The beneficial impacts of the [application] relate principally to the supply of the quarry's product for the construction sector and particularly for infrastructure projects of public significance," the commissioners said.
"The negative consequences are particularly in relation to adverse traffic and pedestrian safety implications, and social and amenity-related impacts in the local area.
The Martins Creek Quarry Action Group have lobbied against the expansion of the quarry for more than a decade.
Its president, Luke Barker, told ABC Newcastle Drive the majority of the community would be "in high spirits" hearing the news.
He said the main reason many in the community had been against expanding the quarry was due to safety concerns and the impact on small roads in the area.
"It's fantastic that the commissioner has seen what that impact has been and what that impact would be for not only this current generation of people but the generations to come," Mr Barker said.
"There's people moving through the township all the time, crossing roads between the post office, the chemist, the local eateries, the pubs, supermarket.
"Then we have a very high tourism aspect. It's a great stopover spot for people coming through.
"It's just the impacts on the community were just too much to bear."
He said the group was not against the quarry remaining operational into the future at its current size and scope.
In a statement a Daracon spokesperson told the ABC the company was disappointed by the IPC's decision.
"For more than a decade Daracon has led a rigorous process of environmental studies and stakeholder engagement which has seen the application amended a multitude of times to create compromises, resulting in a recommendation for approval by the then-NSW Department of Planning and Infrastructure in 2022," the spokesperson said.
"It is disappointing that today's decision does not uphold that.
The spokesperson said the company was disappointed it would not be able to supply construction materials from the site to local infrastructure projects.
"We will now take time to assess the future of the quarry," the spokesperson said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
28 minutes ago
- News.com.au
MoneyTalks: Why Cygnet Capital is backing Heavy Rare Earths and critical minerals
MoneyTalks is Stockhead's drill down into what stocks investors are looking at right now. We tap our list of experts to hear what's hot, their top picks, and what they're looking out for. Today we hear from Cygnet Capital founding director Jonathan Rosham. Cygnet Capital describes itself as a hybrid between a traditional stock broking firm (with a limited number of high-net worth clientele) and a fund manager. The privately owned boutique investment and advisory group has been around for 25 years, focused on two sweet spots of the ASX – tech and resources micro-cap stocks. Within the resources space, Cygnet Capital is particularly bullish on gold, silver, copper and critical minerals, with the latter topical of late following executive orders from US President Donald Trump urging an immediate boost in domestic mineral production. In June, Trump announced a deal with China to resume exports of rare earth minerals and magnets after a two-month period of severe export restrictions that had disrupted critical supply chains across the automotive, robotics and defence industries. Those export restrictions amplified the urgency for countries to secure alternative, domestic or allied sources of supply. At the same time, demand for critical minerals is skyrocketing but supply isn't keeping pace, raising alarm bells for future shortages. Top picks Heavy Rare Earths (ASX:HRE) Cygnet Capital assisted HRE with its acquisition of three assets from Havilah Resources (ASX:HAV) in one of the world's premier uranium producing jurisdictions, South Australia. Australia leads globally in uranium reserves and ranks fourth in production, with South Australia standing out as the core of the nation's uranium sector, housing 80% of its economic demonstrated resources and close to a quarter of the world's uranium supply. Rosham reckons the market is unaware of the potential world-class characteristics at Radium Hill and believes that the best place to find economic deposits are next to old ones. 'We note the historical mining undertaken at Radium Hill as a good indication of the potential,' he said. 'The historical information on Radium Hill highlights the contents of the tailings of mining from Radium Hill at Port Pirie, which gives valuable insight of the waste material from mining uranium in the 1950s/'60s. 'It shows extremely high quantities of scandium and rare earths,' he said. 'There were a number of studies carried out in the '90s and focused on extracting the scandium and rare earths but were constrained at the time with prices and capital. 'Now, in 2025, we are in a very different environment both in prices for the critical minerals and the future demand.' Most importantly, Rosham says HRE already knows what is in the rocks at Radium Hill, which is a massive advantage for any junior. 'Their job now is certainly to go and drill and find sufficient enough quantities to be able to potentially prove up an economic deposit and build a mine,' he said. 'The interesting part is that 50 to 60 odd years ago the market for those materials – being a lot of the lanthalites and scandium – was very different in that now, they are in demand. 'Radium Hill has been totally overlooked from a critical mineral point of view, and the company does have to do some work on the metallurgy, but metallurgy could really unlock the scandium potential,' he added. 'We do think there's a treasure chest there, they need to drill but we feel like the company has a nice head start.' Cygnet Capital is also backing Warriedar, having recently acted as one of two joint lead managers, alongside Bell Potter, in a $20 million capital raise. The firm was drawn to the company based on the scale of its Ricciardo mine, the antimony potential and the large, underexplored tenement package. 'The previous owner encountered a problem with the ore, which eventually sent it broke – the company focused on oxide material at Ricciardo, with the transition and primary sulphides mineralisation not systemically explored,' he said. 'As a consequence of that, the ground was totally underexplored, and we took the view internally and came up with a valuation well in excess of 20 cents and still maintain that view today. 'Warriedar has been well-funded to go and drill and create value for shareholders, and we think the takeover bid by Capricorn Metals (ASX:CMM) has come in at an interesting time – we think there's more to potentially happen there before that game plays itself out.' In May, the company announced what it believes is Australia's largest open-pit antimony resource at Ricciardo, totalling 12.2Mt at 0.5%. Warridar also reported a 107% increase in the projects' total resource estimate to 1.96Moz of gold equivalent at an average grade of 2.5g/t. Carnaby Resources (ASX:CNB) A Queensland copper play, Carnaby – like many players up near Mt Isa – took a bit of a hit following Glencore's news that it was going to close its smelter. But Rosham likes the look of the stock due to its substantial resource base and highly attractive portfolio, including the recently acquired Trekelano copper-gold deposit from Chinova Resources. Trekelano is within a 20km radium of Carnaby's Greater Duchess project, making it a highly complementary acquisition. 'Trekelano looks really interesting… it was an old mine, high-grade and Glencore previously owned it,' he said. 'We started taking a position in the company about 12 months ago but they recently reported an intersection of 150 metres at well over 1% of copper, which says to me that the project has a lot more scope and scale than perhaps the market is giving it credit for. 'The company is set to benefit if the government help Glencore out with the smelter up in Mt Isa, they will benefit a lot,' he said. 'They are looking to get into production, they have access to all transport, it's a low capital cost to get into production and if copper continues going the way it is, this is one company that could definitely bubble from here.' Petratherm (ASX:PTR) Cygnet Capital identified Petratherm before it made its high-grade, titanium-rich heavy minerals sands discovery at the Rosewood and Claypan prospects within the Muckanippe project in South Australia's Gawler Craton. Petratherm has quickly become a hot topic among fundies and investors, who see the $130 million explorer as a possible takeover target for heavyweights like Iluka Resources (ASX:ILU), Tronox Minerals, or even Rio Tinto (ASX:RIO). Muckanippie is yet to host a resource estimate and unlike Iluka's nearby Jacinth Ambrosia mine is not expected to be a major zircon producer, but early drill hits suggest it's rich in titanium-dioxide-bearing material, which should translate to a premium basket price. Titanium dioxide is a key material for paint pigments, but is also a critical mineral used in welding, aerospace, aviation and defence. Rosham likes Petratherm for the titanium content at Muckanippie. New drilling results include 9m at 15.1% heavy minerals (HM) from 10m, including 26.4% HM from 12m and 12m at 12.7% HM from 4m, including 7m at 17.1% HM from 5m. 'Obviously it's just huge grade, there's still a lot of work to do but that grade is amazing if they can actually come up with some continuity,' he said. 'The material looks like it's a direct shipping ore, high titanium content, very big scale at surface, very low strip – it's a world-class discovery, we think there's massive scale and fairly easy to treat. 'We definitely think it's a takeover target for one of the big boys who would be paying a lot of attention to what they are doing,' Rosham added. 'They are currently in the process of drilling, they are going to do some metallurgical testwork, which we will hear about shortly, but if they continue with what they doing and can demonstrate the scale which we think they can, we can see multiples from here.'
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Geelong CBD freehold offers multiple income options
Geelong's emerging laneways could become the key to unlocking the value of a CBD landmark formerly home to Duffs Jewellers. The two-storey freehold is up for grabs with a new expressions of interest campaign to test the market for city centre real estate. Colliers, Geelong agents Jonathon Lumsden, Ned Tansey and Jackson Carrick are handling the sale for 134 Moorabool St, Geelong, with offers closing August 14. Mr Lumsden said price expectations were $2m-plus. The 180sq m ground floor comprises retail and office space, along with amenities and the original strongroom. The first floor has been converted to a luxury four bedroom, three-bathroom apartment, flooded with natural light from an atrium. The property is opposite Geelong's Bright & Hitchcocks building where developer Hamilton Group has started a multimillion dollar redevelopment. 'The owners ran their own business from there – they've closed that office down and are using it for storage themselves while they were running upstairs as their Airbnb,' Mr Lumsden said. 'Since they've got other interests, now is the time to divest.' The building offers the potential for a new owner to create dual income streams, and activate frontages to Moorabool St and Shorts Place at the rear, Mr Lumsden said. 'It also gives someone the potential to reconfigure the ground floor so they could activate a space with direct access of Moorabool St, and then activate a space that's accessed off Shorts Place,' Mr Lumsden said. Geelong developer Bill Votsaris has already unlocked Shorts Place for neighbouring projects, including a 24-hour Anytime Fitness gym. 'I think there's some appeal to that, to create those dual access points. Does that mean someone looks to do something more retail on the Moorabool St frontage and then more hospitality from Shorts Place? 'There's a few different things you can those around and meanwhile you can maintain that Airbnb, whether it's leased out through Airbnb or you put a long-term tenant in there.' Mr Lumsden said one potential buyer had flagged reconfiguring the first floor into commercial office space and then look to activate the retail space on the ground floor. 'You could easily give the ground floor a facelift. That's a pretty simple process.' Interest has been from parties in Geelong and Melbourne, Mr Lumsden said. 'I must say the interest that's coming through are generally parties that we've seen look at other options in the CBD. 'I think people can still see the CBD is going through a bit of adjustment and they can see the investment that other landowners are investing in the CBD. 'Opposite with Cam Hamilton's development and with what Bill Votsaris is doing in Little Malop St, there's good stories to tell within that precinct. 'We got through property cycles, Moorabool St is the main thoroughfare running north-south to Belmont and attracts an enormous amount of traffic and with the property cycle we're going through at the moment where you're not buying at the peak of the market, I believe there's long-term growth to get out of it.'
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Farmers seek direct partnerships with meal kit and ready-made meal makers
Boxes of produce fly out the door at a food distribution centre in Sydney's west, with a conveyer belt whisking away packed meal kits in a high-tech warehouse. The meal kits typically include portioned ingredients such as fresh vegetables, meat, sauces, spices and a recipe card with step-by-step instructions. HelloFresh was one of the first entrants into the Australian meal kit market, now estimated to be worth more than $1 billion a year, with new brands continuing to enter the competitive space. Chief executive Tom Rutledge said the company's new distribution centre opened in 2024. "We handle 250 tonnes of fruit and veg every week through this facility," he said. "We get that from a network of suppliers." The rising popularity of meal kits in Australia has created new opportunities for farmers to bypass traditional supply chains and sell their produce directly to those companies. Bundaberg-based farming operation Sunripe has diversified its business by growing tomatoes, capsicums and zucchinis for HelloFresh. Director Luke De Paoli said prices were locked in for 12 months at a time, in contrast to the more common week-to-week negotiations. "We get an eight-week forecast on volume, so we can adjust what we're doing elsewhere to make sure we've got the volume for HelloFresh." Tomatoes have recently been in short supply across Australia, reaching as high as $100 a box, the highest price since Cyclone Debbie hit in 2017, according to Mr De Paoli. But Sunripe has no regrets about its fixed price arrangements and is more interested in the long game and setting up long-term relationships. Mr Rutledge established HelloFresh in Australia in 2012 and said the connections built with growers have been "hugely important". "To make sure we're getting sufficient volumes, we want to have long-standing relationships with our suppliers, so they understand what our needs are and are able to supply us in time with the right, quality ingredients," Mr Rutledge said. He said the business model, which included extensive planning and seasonal menus, allowed them to accept more varied specifications from producers. "We can take a different spec to what is required by supermarkets because we know the intended use of those items [in recipes]," he said. This gives Sunripe more flexibility when fulfilling orders. Mr De Paoli said it meant his customers — which also include major retailers and food service suppliers — were less likely to be competing for produce with the same specifications. "If it's a capsicum they [HelloFresh] will take a half-red, half-green one [at the] mid-ripening stage," he said. Ready-made meal offerings are also growing in Australia, both in supermarkets and via home delivery. Options are vast and include calorie-controlled, high-protein and vegan meals. The Dinner Ladies is a Sydney-based food service that specialises in "home-style" cooking at scale. One of its key target markets is young families and the home-delivered meals are particularly popular with new mothers. The Dinner Ladies CEO Brad Rom said their kitchens produced more than 40,000 frozen meals each week, with plans to double that in coming years. He said the COVID-19 pandemic had changed many people's opinions and created positive perceptions about home deliveries. "Our customers who are busy, who are time poor and who like good quality food are prepared to pay for a service such as ours," he said. Mr Rom said when dealing with direct suppliers it was important to have similar values. "It's also really important to our customers. We get questioned quite a lot about where our ingredients come from," he said. Farmer Luke Winder owns Tathra Place Free Range and supplies free-range ducks to The Dinner Ladies. Each week he delivers about 150 kilograms of duck from his farm near Taralga. "That can go right up to well over 200 kilos a week so it's pretty amazing," Mr Winder said. He said cutting out the intermediary and layers of logistics meant a better, cheaper, and more consistent product. "It's very cost effective and they're getting their margin and I'm getting mine and there's no-one in between and it's fantastic." The ducks are used in a rotating menu of duck confit, duck ragu and duck red curry with lychee. Rendered fat is also used for duck fat potatoes. Joshua Guild is the head of planning at The Dinner Ladies and said waste was kept to a minimum. "[We also make] duck confit of course and duck sausage rolls." Mr Guild would like to emulate this type of direct relationship with more suppliers, particularly local ones. "We want to partner up with as many feel-good producers and people who are doing good things for the environment and good things for the animal," he said. Watch ABC TV's Landline at 12:30pm AEST on Sunday or stream anytime on ABC iview.
