Supreme Court Sides With Teenager in School Disability Discrimination Case
The case hinged on what standard of proof was required to show discrimination by public schools in education-related disability lawsuits.
In a unanimous decision written by Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., the court held that the student and her family needed to show only that the school system had acted with 'deliberate indifference' to her educational needs when they sued.
That is the same standard that applies when people sue other institutions for discrimination based on disability.
The school district argued that a higher standard — a stringent requirement that the institution had acted with 'bad faith or gross misjudgment' — should apply. Had the district prevailed, the new standard might have applied broadly to all kinds disability rights claims filed under the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act.
That argument had unnerved some disability rights groups, which had cautioned that a ruling for the school could make it much harder for Americans with disabilities to successfully bring court challenges.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
Man who killed 3 people in Polk County in 1990 could be Florida's 12th execution this year
A man who killed three family members in Mulberry in 1990 is now scheduled to be the state's 12th execution this year. David Joseph Pittman, 63, will be executed Sept. 17 at Florida State Prison, according to a death warrant signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis on Aug. 15. The warrant was posted on the Florida Supreme Court website, along with court documents. In 1991, Pittman was convicted of the murders of Clarence and Barbara Knowles and their daughter, Bonnie Knowles, the previous year. According to records, the Knowles family was related to Pittman's ex-wife. Pittman killed the three family members before setting their home on fire with them in it. He also set fire to Bonnie Knowles' car. He was sentenced to death for each and also charged with two counts of arson and grand theft. In a 6-1 decision in April 2022, the Supreme Court denied Pittman's claim that he's intellectually disabled as well as arguments that his death sentences are illegal because he hasn't received an evidentiary hearing on his disability claim. Pittman's first appeal was in 2015, and the Supreme Court said Pittman did not appeal the denial of his first two appeals, successive motions, and his third, amended appeal was mistitled as his "second" appeal. "We agree with the postconviction court that Pittman is not entitled to postconviction relief on his intellectual disability claim because that claim is untimely," the Supreme Court said in a news release. The Supreme Court said he would have been required to raise his intellectual disability claim no later than 60 days after October 1, 2004, because the laws don't apply backward. Pittman argued that his IQ score of 70 from 2015 is newly discovered evidence, so the Supreme Court deemed his motion untimely because it wasn't filed within one year of the date the claim was discoverable. The Supreme Court said records refute Pittman's claim that the IQ information could not have been discoverable before 2015. DeSantis has already signed a record number of death warrants this year. On July 31, the execution of Edward Zakrzewski was Florida's ninth this year, surpassing state records of eight executions in 1984 and 2014, when Democrat Bob Graham and now-U.S. Sen. Rick Scott, a Republican, were the governors signing death warrants. Two others are scheduled before Sept. 17. Kayle B. Bates, 67, convicted of killing of a Bay County woman in 1992, is scheduled for execution on Aug. 19 after the Florida Supreme Court denied a last-minute appeal on Aug. 13. Curtis Windom, 59, is scheduled to be executed Aug. 28 for the murders of three people in Orange County in 1992. Information from Ledger archives and the USA TODAY Network-Florida was used in this report.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Iowa attorney general signs letter calling on DEA to ban ‘designer Xanax'
Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird. (Photo by Aaron Sanderford/Nebraska Examiner) Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird is calling on the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) in a joint letter to take emergency action to schedule a drug that has been linked to deaths in the state and across the country. Bromazolam is described in the letter penned by Sunday and 20 other state attorneys general as a 'designer Xanax.' The prosecutors say the drug is increasingly contributing to overdose deaths and posing a growing threat to public health. It is also highly potent and unpredictable, Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday's office wrote, especially when mixed with opioids. Narcan, which is used to reverse an overdose, is ineffective against the drug in such emergencies. Bromazolam is unscheduled under the federal Controlled Substances Act. 'Despite its clear dangers, bromazolam remains unscheduled at the federal level, creating significant challenges for law enforcement and public health officials trying to respond to this emerging crisis,' the attorneys generals wrote. 'Without scheduling, this drug continues to evade traditional regulatory and prosecutorial tools, hindering interdiction efforts and enabling continued distribution through illicit channels.' 'Taking emergency action to schedule bromazolam will help law enforcement remove it from circulation, give prosecutors the tools to hold traffickers accountable, and send a clear signal that this dangerous substance has no place on our streets,' the attorneys general wrote. 'Bromazolam, or 'Designer Xanax' is a lethal, counterfeit drug with no medical use that is highly addictive and killing Americans,' Bird said in a statement. 'It is already an illegal drug in Iowa, and I strongly urge the DEA to take swift and definite action at the federal level to give law enforcement the tools they need to stop this crisis, save lives, and hold traffickers accountable.' This story was originally published by Pennsylvania Capital-Star, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Pennsylvania Capital-Star maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Tim Lambert for questions: info@ Solve the daily Crossword
The Hill
2 hours ago
- The Hill
IRS wrongfully fired thousands, watchdog finds
The terminated employees were not given proper notice, nor was their performance taken into account when getting rid of them, the office of the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) concluded in a report released. 'Internal procedures were not followed when sending the termination notices. Policies and procedures require the IRS to give probationary employees a 30-day notice and consider their performance prior to terminating them,' TIGTA found. In February, the IRS fired 6,700 employees designated as probationary, meaning they were working for the agency on a trial basis prior to becoming full staff members. The hires were part of a large-scale overhaul of the agency initiated by Democrats in 2022 as part of their Inflation Reduction Act. That legislation awarded the agency an initial $80 billion funding boost to be spent over the subsequent decade. More than half of the initial money — $45 billion — was earmarked for extra tax enforcement, specifically increased audits for wealthy Americans. The IRS even set up a new division to go after complex partnerships, or nested legal entities that can shelter funds that are owed to the government. The Hill's Tobias Burns has more here.
