
BREAKING NEWS Flagship Prevent anti-extremism scheme blasted in yet ANOTHER official review, in wake of Southport attack and murder of Sir David Amess MP
An official review of the Prevent scheme said 'the jury is still out' on whether a series of changes will improve its operation.
The report by Interim Independent Prevent Commissioner, Lord Anderson, said: 'Prevent failed in both cases; and from these failures, lessons must be learned.'
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper commissioned the peer, a leading barrister, to scrutinise Prevent's work in the wake of the last summer's Southport murders.
Knifeman Axel Rudakubana killed Bebe King, six, Elsie Dot Stancombe, seven, and nine-year-old Alice da Silva Aguiar at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class, and injured 10 others.
A previous review, published in February, found Rudakubana had been referred to the programme Prevent three times.
But in a catalogue of blunders – including spelling his name wrong – experts failed to put the teenager on a de-radicalisation scheme before he embarked on his rampage.
In the case of Sir David's 2021 murder, another earlier report revealed his killer Ali Harbi Ali was dismissed as a 'very low' terror threat just months before he bought a foot-long carving knife and started planning a terrorist atrocity.
The murdered MP's daughter Katie Amess said earlier this year that Prevent was 'not fit for purpose' after Ali, 29, was discharged by Prevent 'too quickly '.
Now Lord Anderson has declined to give Prevent a clean bill of health.
His report said: 'An intensive series of efforts has been made by both the Home Office and CTP [counter-terrorism policing] to improve the relevant processes, training and guidance.
'The jury is still out on some of these initiatives, and none of them can substitute for human judgement or remove the possibility of human error.'
But he added that several changes already made to the scheme last year 'have the potential to improve in material respects the inner workings of the machine'.
The review urged Prevent to ensure its work addresses individuals who are obsessed with violence but do not fall into a clear terrorist category.
The recommendation reflects how the threat posed by Rudakubana was partly ignored by police and officials because of the 'absence of a distinct ideology'.
Lord Anderson also said Prevent should be far more open about its activities.
'Public transparency about the structures, systems and statistics of Prevent should be the default position,' it said, and the Home Office and counter terrorism police should 'adopt a pro-active approach to the release of such information'.
A Cabinet Office task force should be set up to begin looking at whether Prevent should be formally linked to 'broader safeguarding and violence prevention system', the report went on.
Lord Anderson's 156-page review suggested ministers should look at 'finding ways for young people to discuss and feed in ideas about Prevent' and 'addressing the particular circumstances of black and mixed heritage boys who are less likely to have been referred for early help'.
Lord Anderson said: 'More needs to be done.
'It has to be clear that people with a fascination with extreme violence can be suitable subjects for Prevent, even when they have no discernible ideology.
'Prevent needs to up its game in the online world, where most radicalisation now takes place.
'It needs to get better at information-sharing, and be more open with the public to gain the trust on which it depends.'
The latest review comes just over two years after serious failings in the anti-extremism programme were exposed by another major inquiry.
An independent review of Prevent by William Shawcross, former head of the Charity Commission, warns the scheme applied a 'double standard' to Islamist and far-Right threats.
It found Prevent was failing to tackle radicalisation and that Islamist ideology had been 'misinterpreted, misunderstood or even overlooked' by officials.
It prioritised countering far-Right activity above the prime Islamist threat.
In some cases, the £49million-a-year programme set up in 2006 had directly funded or engaged with extremists and was 'out of kilter with the rest of the counter-terrorism system', Mr Shawcross said.
The number of individuals referred to Prevent had become 'politicised' because officials feared being labelled Islamophobic or racist, it went on.
The Home Secretary said today she would 'act immediately' on the findings of Lord Anderson's review.
Ms Cooper told MPs in a written statement:
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
16 minutes ago
- The Independent
Lammy and Healey to sign bilateral Aukus deal during trip to Australia
The UK will sign a new 50-year bilateral Aukus treaty with Australia as the Foreign and Defence Secretaries visit the country on Friday. David Lammy and John Healey will meet their counterparts at the annual Australia-UK ministerial meeting, or Aukmin, in Sydney, and then travel on to Melbourne to meet businesses involved in the Aukus submarine programme. They will also visit Darwin as the Carrier Strike Group docks in the Northern Territory. The Aukus partnership between the UK, US and Australia involves building nuclear-powered attack submarines – including Australia acquiring its first such fleet – and co-operating in other areas of defence. It was agreed by the three countries in 2021, but the Trump administration has put it under review, raising fears it could pull out. The deal now being signed by the UK and Australia sets out the bilateral aspects of the partnership and how the two countries will work together to deliver their Aukus submarine programmes over the next half century. Defence Secretary Mr Healey said: 'Aukus is one of Britain's most important defence partnerships, strengthening global security while driving growth at home. 'This historic treaty confirms our Aukus commitment for the next half century.' He said people 'not yet born' will benefit from jobs secured through the deal. More than 21,000 people in the UK are expected to be working on the programme at its peak. Foreign Secretary Mr Lammy said the UK-Australia relationship is 'like no other'. He added: 'In our increasingly volatile and dangerous world, our anchoring friendship has real impact in the protection of global peace and prosperity. 'Our new bilateral Aukus treaty is an embodiment of that – safeguarding a free and open Indo-Pacific whilst catalysing growth for both our countries.' The UK's Carrier Strike Group – an international formation of Royal Navy warships, submarines and aircraft – has been taking part in the Talisman Sabre military exercise hosted in Australia. The Australia and US-led military exercise involves more than 35,000 military personnel from 19 countries. Shadow defence secretary James Cartlidge said: 'Aukus was a landmark achievement of the last Conservative government and it's essential that Labour keeps up the momentum, including on industrial collaboration. 'We welcome further progress but this must deliver in practice, both in terms of jobs and strengthened mutual security, at a time of heightened threats.'

Rhyl Journal
21 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Lammy and Healey to sign bilateral Aukus deal during trip to Australia
David Lammy and John Healey will meet their counterparts at the annual Australia-UK ministerial meeting, or Aukmin, in Sydney, and then travel on to Melbourne to meet businesses involved in the Aukus submarine programme. They will also visit Darwin as the Carrier Strike Group docks in the Northern Territory. The Aukus partnership between the UK, US and Australia involves building nuclear-powered attack submarines – including Australia acquiring its first such fleet – and co-operating in other areas of defence. It was agreed by the three countries in 2021, but the Trump administration has put it under review, raising fears it could pull out. The deal now being signed by the UK and Australia sets out the bilateral aspects of the partnership and how the two countries will work together to deliver their Aukus submarine programmes over the next half century. Defence Secretary Mr Healey said: 'Aukus is one of Britain's most important defence partnerships, strengthening global security while driving growth at home. 'This historic treaty confirms our Aukus commitment for the next half century.' He said people 'not yet born' will benefit from jobs secured through the deal. More than 21,000 people in the UK are expected to be working on the programme at its peak. Foreign Secretary Mr Lammy said the UK-Australia relationship is 'like no other'. He added: 'In our increasingly volatile and dangerous world, our anchoring friendship has real impact in the protection of global peace and prosperity. 'Our new bilateral Aukus treaty is an embodiment of that – safeguarding a free and open Indo-Pacific whilst catalysing growth for both our countries.' The UK's Carrier Strike Group – an international formation of Royal Navy warships, submarines and aircraft – has been taking part in the Talisman Sabre military exercise hosted in Australia. The Australia and US-led military exercise involves more than 35,000 military personnel from 19 countries. Shadow defence secretary James Cartlidge said: 'Aukus was a landmark achievement of the last Conservative government and it's essential that Labour keeps up the momentum, including on industrial collaboration. 'We welcome further progress but this must deliver in practice, both in terms of jobs and strengthened mutual security, at a time of heightened threats.'

Western Telegraph
34 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Lammy and Healey to sign bilateral Aukus deal during trip to Australia
David Lammy and John Healey will meet their counterparts at the annual Australia-UK ministerial meeting, or Aukmin, in Sydney, and then travel on to Melbourne to meet businesses involved in the Aukus submarine programme. They will also visit Darwin as the Carrier Strike Group docks in the Northern Territory. The Aukus partnership between the UK, US and Australia involves building nuclear-powered attack submarines – including Australia acquiring its first such fleet – and co-operating in other areas of defence. It was agreed by the three countries in 2021, but the Trump administration has put it under review, raising fears it could pull out. The deal now being signed by the UK and Australia sets out the bilateral aspects of the partnership and how the two countries will work together to deliver their Aukus submarine programmes over the next half century. Defence Secretary Mr Healey said: 'Aukus is one of Britain's most important defence partnerships, strengthening global security while driving growth at home. 'This historic treaty confirms our Aukus commitment for the next half century.' He said people 'not yet born' will benefit from jobs secured through the deal. Defence Secretary John Healey hailed the importance of the Aukus partnership (James Manning/PA) More than 21,000 people in the UK are expected to be working on the programme at its peak. Foreign Secretary Mr Lammy said the UK-Australia relationship is 'like no other'. He added: 'In our increasingly volatile and dangerous world, our anchoring friendship has real impact in the protection of global peace and prosperity. 'Our new bilateral Aukus treaty is an embodiment of that – safeguarding a free and open Indo-Pacific whilst catalysing growth for both our countries.' The UK's Carrier Strike Group – an international formation of Royal Navy warships, submarines and aircraft – has been taking part in the Talisman Sabre military exercise hosted in Australia. The Australia and US-led military exercise involves more than 35,000 military personnel from 19 countries. Shadow defence secretary James Cartlidge said: 'Aukus was a landmark achievement of the last Conservative government and it's essential that Labour keeps up the momentum, including on industrial collaboration. 'We welcome further progress but this must deliver in practice, both in terms of jobs and strengthened mutual security, at a time of heightened threats.'