Amid immigration crackdowns, student newspapers grapple with how to cover campus without making targets of their peers
'I've been working here for over three decades, and these are times we have never seen before,' said Mike Hiestand, senior legal counsel at the Student Press Law Center. 'We've crossed a line with the situation at Tufts.'
Situated at the intersection of the Trump administration's targeting of higher education, immigration, and First Amendment rights, student journalists are having to question of the very basics of news gathering: should they
omit the names of some students who express pro-Palestinian views, obscure faces of protesters in pictures, or otherwise self-censor information that could be used to attack and detain their classmates and professors?
Advertisement
The arrest at Tufts is particularly significant for student media given that Öztürk
Advertisement
A pair approach West Hall on the Tufts University campus in Medford on April 2.
Craig F. Walker/Globe Staff
A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security previously said she 'engaged in support of Hamas' and Secretary of State Marco Rubio
'Criticizing U.S. foreign policy and human rights violations is neither illegal nor grounds for detention,' said Öztürk's attorney, Mahsa Khanbabai, in a
The threats students face are more pronounced than in previous eras of protest because of the Internet. The names of students and faculty with pro-Palestinian views are readily available from websites such as Canary Mission, which compiles profiles of campus protesters and people like Öztürk who wrote op-eds or appeared in student news articles.
Related
:
That could put student news outlets in an impossible position — where even when they report responsibly or follow the standard ethics in publishing op-eds, their work can be used as a tool to hunt down and punish their peers.
Hiestand estimated the Student Press Law Center has seen a roughly 50 percent jump in requests from student media for legal and reporting advice compared to a year ago. His organization is advising student news outlets not to share anonymous sources with advisors or school officials, keep confidential information off school emails, and revisit policies on when to remove certain information.
He added that while journalists know they are sacrificing a degree of accuracy by using anonymous sources, that could be the only way to tell the story of what's happening while protecting sources, because the stakes are so high.
Advertisement
'I think that we need to really rethink what's up on our pages right now, and what we're going to put up on our pages in the future,' Hiestand said.
Now, with the stark threats against students like Öztürk, student media outlets are increasingly using unnamed sources or removing names of students from stories to protect sources who might risk more than just public criticism for speaking out. That is particularly true at Boston-area universities with a high concentration of international students.
'For now, the anonymous policy has definitely loosened,' said Brendan Galvin, editor-in-chief of the Daily Free Press at Boston University.
One example is by using only the first names or nicknames of students who declined to share their last names, such as in a
organized by the Boston University Students for Justice in Palestine, Galvin said.
A demonstrator raises a fist while holding a sign that reads "DEFEND STUDENT VOICES" during a protest at Powder House Park in Somerville.
Erin Clark/Globe Staff
The student newspaper at Northeastern University, the Huntington News, has also been more lenient with granting anonymity to sources in news articles, but not so with op-eds, said Sonel Cutler, the paper's editor-in-chief. Photographers have also been trying not to take close-up photos of protesters at rallies, Cutler added, especially following the arrest of Öztürk. (Cutler is a former Globe co-op.)
Additionally, the Huntington News has
tried to be more specific in describing to readers why some sources won't be named.
'Last year we did a lot of 'fear of retaliation.' This year we've tried to start doing more of 'fear of retaliation,' of what?' Cutler said. 'Do they actually face any retaliation for saying the content of the quote?'
Advertisement
Caroline Hendrie, executive director of the Society of Professional Journalists, said all news organizations should consider such practices in the current environment.
'The idea of minimizing harm — right at the heart of that is balancing the public's need for information against the potential harm that can come from reporting,' Hendrie said.
Even with an added layer of caution, some student outlets are using the moment to reaffirm their commitments to covering political speech on campus. The Huntington News even relaunched a version of its editorial board that had been dormant since 2019 to speak out as an institution at this moment. Its first editorial was titled,
'This is the time to speak up,' said Rachana Madhav, the publication's opinion editor. 'With the formation of the editorial board, we've been really trying to push that.'
The editors at Tufts Daily, where Öztürk's op-ed was published, declined interview requests from the Globe.
But in a
'The Daily has the ability to conduct its work because of the rights enshrined in the First Amendment — rights that not only allow us to publish freely, but also encourage participation in debate, the expression of ideas and the pursuit of truth,' the student journalists wrote. 'It is our core belief that journalism is one of the critical tenets that upholds our democracy.'
The Tufts editors also reaffirmed that protecting its staff and sources is top of mind, while assuring they will continue to share a diverse array of viewpoints.
Advertisement
'[T]he withholding of ideas and abstinence from debate will only contribute to the erosion of free expression,' they wrote.
A pedestrian walks on the Tufts University Campus in Medford on April 2.
Craig F. Walker/Globe Staff
Antero Mejr, a first-year computer science PhD student at Tufts who
'I think the actions of ICE actually show that people do care about these student publications. They're important,' he said. 'And that's even more reason to keep on it.'
Some student outlets, however, are trying to minimize exposure out of fear they could harm people on their campuses. At least one student paper declined an interview request from the Globe
out of fear that it could put their staff at risk.
Those are valid fears, Hiestand said, who added it's hard for student journalists to tell schoolmates to speak out at this precarious moment, particularly for international students. But he also said it's the job of journalists to speak up, and student media is critical to understanding what's happening on college campuses.
'We rely upon them for a lot of the reporting that just professional media is not able to do anymore,' he said.
Aidan Ryan can be reached at
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Associated Press seeks full appeals court hearing on access to Trump administration events
The Associated Press on Tuesday asked for a hearing before the full U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, seeking to overturn a three-judge panel's ruling that allowed the Trump administration to continue blocking AP access to some presidential events — a four-month case that has raised questions about what level of journalistic access to the presidency the First Amendment permits. Three judges of that court on Friday, in a 2-1 decision, said it was OK for Trump to continue keeping AP journalists out of Oval Office or other small events out in retaliation over the news outlet's decision not to follow his lead in changing the Gulf of Mexico's name. He had sought a pause of a lower court's ruling in AP's favor in April that the administration was improperly punishing the news organization for the content of its speech. 'The decision of the appellate panel to pause the district court's order allows the White House to discriminate and retaliate over words it does not like, a violation of the First Amendment,' AP spokesman Patrick Maks said. 'We are seeking a rehearing of this decision by the full appellate court because an essential American principle is at stake.' A hearing before the full court would change the landscape — and possibly the outcome as well. The two judges who ruled in Trump's favor on Friday had been appointed to the bench by him. The full court consists of nine members appointed by Democratic presidents, and six by Republicans. The news outlet's access to events in the Oval Office and Air Force One was cut back starting in February after the AP said it would continue referring to the Gulf of Mexico in its copy, while noting Trump's wishes that it instead be renamed the Gulf of America. For decades, a reporter and photographer for the AP — a 179-year-old wire service whose material is sent to thousands of news outlets across the world and carried on its own website, reaching billions of people — had been part of a small-group 'pool' that covers a president in places where space is limited. Now, an AP photographer routinely gets access to these events, while text reporters rarely do. ___ David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at and

Associated Press
39 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Associated Press seeks full appeals court hearing on access to Trump administration events
The Associated Press on Tuesday asked for a hearing before the full U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, seeking to overturn a three-judge panel's ruling that allowed the Trump administration to continue blocking AP access to some presidential events — a four-month case that has raised questions about what level of journalistic access to the presidency the First Amendment permits. Three judges of that court on Friday, in a 2-1 decision, said it was OK for Trump to continue keeping AP journalists out of Oval Office or other small events out in retaliation over the news outlet's decision not to follow his lead in changing the Gulf of Mexico's name. He had sought a pause of a lower court's ruling in AP's favor in April that the administration was improperly punishing the news organization for the content of its speech. 'The decision of the appellate panel to pause the district court's order allows the White House to discriminate and retaliate over words it does not like, a violation of the First Amendment,' AP spokesman Patrick Maks said. 'We are seeking a rehearing of this decision by the full appellate court because an essential American principle is at stake.' A hearing before the full court would change the landscape — and possibly the outcome as well. The two judges who ruled in Trump's favor on Friday had been appointed to the bench by him. The full court consists of nine members appointed by Democratic presidents, and six by Republicans. The news outlet's access to events in the Oval Office and Air Force One was cut back starting in February after the AP said it would continue referring to the Gulf of Mexico in its copy, while noting Trump's wishes that it instead be renamed the Gulf of America. For decades, a reporter and photographer for the AP — a 179-year-old wire service whose material is sent to thousands of news outlets across the world and carried on its own website, reaching billions of people — had been part of a small-group 'pool' that covers a president in places where space is limited. Now, an AP photographer routinely gets access to these events, while text reporters rarely do. ___ David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at and


Politico
41 minutes ago
- Politico
Don't rain on my parade
Presented by Bayer Welcome to POLITICO's West Wing Playbook: Remaking Government, your guide to Donald Trump's unprecedented overhaul of the federal government — the key decisions, the critical characters and the power dynamics that are upending Washington and beyond. Send tips | Subscribe | Email Sophia | Email Irie | Email Ben President DONALD TRUMP has a message for anyone thinking of spoiling his military parade on Saturday: Don't. 'If there's any protester who wants to come out, they will be met with very big force,' the president said during an impromptu Oval Office press conference today. 'I haven't even heard about a protest, but [there are] people that hate our country.' Trump's threat carries additional weight with some 700 Marines and thousands of National Guard troops on the streets of Los Angeles clashing with protesters of his immigration agenda. It also highlights how important the parade — the first of its kind in at least a generation — is to Trump and how its unprecedented nature is affecting not only Washington, but the larger resistance to Trump's presidency. Locally, as barricades went up around the White House and law enforcement readied more than 100 metal detectors and multiple drones, officials said they were tracking a handful of demonstrations planned for Saturday. But they 'don't have any significant concerns,' JESSICA TAYLOR, chief of the U.S. Park Police, told reporters earlier this week. 'As far as the First Amendment activity from a Secret Service perspective, it's simply people using their First Amendment right to protest. We're not going to do anything with that,' said MATT McCOOL, the agent in charge of the U.S. Secret Service's Washington office. 'But if that turns violent or if any laws are broken, that's when [Metro Police], Park Police, Secret Service will get involved, and that will be handled swiftly.' The military parade, which coincides with the Army's 250th — and Trump's 79th — birthday, is expected to inspire large 'No Kings' protests around the country. Read the full story here. MESSAGE US — West Wing Playbook is obsessively covering the Trump administration's reshaping of the federal government. Are you a federal worker? A DOGE staffer? Have you picked up on any upcoming DOGE moves? We want to hear from you on how this is playing out. Email us at westwingtips@ Did someone forward this email to you? Subscribe! POTUS PUZZLER Which first lady was passionate about historic preservation and helped establish the White House Endowment Trust? (Answer at bottom.) Knives Out CALIFORNIA DREAMIN': The Trump administration is considering pulling federal education funds to California amid Trump's feud with Gov. GAVIN NEWSOM over the president's deployment of the National Guard to Los Angeles to stop immigration protests, our REBECCA CARBALLO, JUAN PEREZ JR. and ERIC HE report. The Education Department may stop the disbursement of 'formula funds,' which are awards based on a formula created by Congress, according to an administration official. A final decision has not been reached, and there is some uncertainty over the department's ability to pull funding that is not directly connected to the California Department of Education. 'No taxpayer should be forced to fund the demise of our country, and that's what California is doing through its lunatic anti-energy, soft-on-crime, pro-child mutilation and pro-sanctuary policies,' said KUSH DESAI, a White House spokesperson. 'The Trump administration is committed to ending this nightmare and restoring the California Dream.' Agenda Setting RAMPING IT UP: The Trump administration is planning to send thousands of undocumented migrants to Guantanamo Bay this week, with at least 9,000 people being vetted for transfer, according to documents obtained by our NAHAL TOOSI and MYAH WARD. It would be a dramatic escalation from the roughly 500 migrants who have been held for short periods at the base since February and a major step toward realizing the president's plan to use the facility to house as many as 30,000 migrants. WHO'S UP? With ELON MUSK and his right-hand man STEVE DAVIS largely out of the fold, the question of who will lead DOGE is underway, NYT's THEODORE SCHLEIFER, KATE CONGER and NICHOLAS NEHAMAS report. In the first few days after Musk's departure, the search centered around fellow billionaire JOE GEBBIA, one of Musk's close friends and a board member at Tesla. Gebbia, who co-founded Airbnb, joined DOGE in February, but has told others he's not interested in leading the effort alone due to the intense scrutiny. The plan is for a small council of advisers, including Gabbia, to oversee DOGE. Investment banker ANTHONY ARMSTRONG, another DOGE veteran, could join this leadership group, the Times reports. ALL ABOUT DOGE: The new head of the Social Security Administration plans to utilize DOGE, including deploying DOGE staffers to help SSA personnel revamp customer service to rely more on tech and AI, WSJ's ANNE TERGESEN reports. 'I look at them as a resource to help me,' said FRANK BISIGNANO, who has described himself as 'fundamentally a DOGE person,' in an interview which took place after Musk's exit from DOGE but before his social media feud with Trump. HOLD IT RIGHT THERE: The Trump administration, with OMB Director RUSS VOUGHT leading the charge, is working on a new effort to both weaken Congress' grip on the federal budget and freeze billions of dollars in spending at several government agencies, POLITICO's E&E News' SCOTT WALDMAN and CORBIN HIAR report. Last week, Vought's office directed several agencies, including EPA, the Interior and HHS, as well as the National Science Foundation, to freeze upward of $30 billion in spending on a variety of programs. OMB's targets include NSF research and education programs that operate using funding leftover from 2024, as well as tens of millions of dollars for national park operations. It also looks at cutting more than $100 million in science spending at NASA, which includes climate research. HEAR US OUT: Days before HHS Secretary ROBERT F. KENNEDY JR. fired all 17 members of the CDC's vaccine advisory committee on Monday, agency officials began circulating a document on Capitol Hill explaining its decision to remove the Covid-19 vaccine recommendation for pregnant women, our SOPHIE GARDNER and LAUREN GARDNER report. The document says that studies have shown that women who got the vaccine during pregnancy had higher rates of various complications, including 'higher rates of fetal loss if vaccination was received before 20 weeks of pregnancy.' But Dr. MARIA P. VELEZ, a professor at McGill University and lead author of one of the studies, told POLITICO that 'the results of our manuscript were misinterpreted' and that researchers found 'no association between SARS-CoV-2 vaccination and an increased risk of miscarriage.' Musk Radar BEEN WATCHING YOU: Several government agencies, including DHS and DOJ, in 2022 and 2023 tracked foreign nationals coming and going from Musk's properties, WSJ's DANA MATTIOLI, MICHELLE HACKMAN, JOSH DAWSEY and EMILY GLAZER report. The investigation focused on people visiting Musk from Eastern European countries and elsewhere who may have been trying to influence him. No charges were brought from the investigation, the current status of which is unclear. WHO'S IN, WHO'S OUT ON HIS OWN TERMS: A Democratic member of the Federal Trade Commission who refused to accept his March firing by the president has resigned from his post, our ALFRED NG reports. ALVARO BEDOYA submitted his resignation letter to the White House on Monday, saying he is immediately stepping down. It comes months after Trump fired him and fellow Democratic Commissioner REBECCA KELLY SLAUGHTER. Both commissioners sued to overturn their dismissal in federal court, arguing Trump fired them for political reasons. Bedoya said he will continue to pursue the case. What We're Reading Inside the MAGA vs. hawk battle to sway Trump on bombing Iran (POLITICO's Rachael Bade and Felicia Schwartz) The White House Marching Orders That Sparked the L.A. Migrant Crackdown (WSJ's Elizabeth Findell, Ruth Simon, Michelle Hackman and Tarini Parti) Rural Republicans used to back NPR. Then MAGA changed everything. (WaPo's Patrick Marley) Opinion | Musk and Trump's Social-Media Fight Reveals How Power Works Today (Virginia Heffernan for POLITICO Magazine) In Trump's 'Patriotic' Hiring Plan, Experts See a Politicized Federal Work Force (NYT's Eileen Sullivan) POTUS PUZZLER ANSWER First lady BARBARA BUSH was passionate about historic preservation. She helped establish the White House Endowment Trust and revived the Committee for the Preservation of the White House, which worked to preserve the rooms of the White House, according to The White House Historical Association. To learn more about the life and legacy of Barbara Bush, listen to the White House Historical Association's new podcast episode 'The Tradition of First Lady Forever Stamps: Barbara Bush.'