Woman gives birth to another couple's child after IVF mix-up
Monash IVF, which operates more than 100 clinics across Australia, said in a statement staff were 'devastated' by the mistake, believed to be the first of its kind in Australia.
It's not clear whether either of the couples suspected a mix-up before the clinic discovered the error in February.
'On behalf of Monash IVF, I want to say how truly sorry I am for what has happened,' said CEO Michael Knaap in the statement.
'We will continue to support the patients through this extremely distressing time,' he added.
Monash IVF has not named the couples involved, nor has it responded to questions about when the baby was born, or who has custody of the child.
The error occurred at Monash IVF's Brisbane clinic, in the state of Queensland, where the law recognizes the birth mother and her partner as the child's legal parents.
How did it happen?
The mistake was discovered in February after the birth parents requested to transfer their remaining embryos to another IVF provider.
After an extra embryo was found in their storage compartment, an internal inquiry discovered they'd received the wrong embryo.
It's not clear how the error was made but according to the Monash IVF statement, another patient's embryo was 'incorrectly thawed and transferred to the birth parents.'
Knaap, the company's CEO, said he was confident it was 'an isolated incident.'
'We are reinforcing all our safeguards across our clinics – we also commissioned an independent investigation and are committed to implementing its recommendations in full,' he added.
The Fertility Society of Australia and New Zealand (FSANZ) said in a statement that it was 'aware of the serious incident' and its immediate thoughts were with the families affected.
It said such incidents are rare and require 'the highest standards of transparency.'
Similar errors have been made in the United States, including a recent case where a White woman discovered she'd been given the wrong embryo after giving birth to a Black infant.
This is not the first time Monash IVF has been accused of wrongdoing.
Last year, the company agreed to pay 56 million Australian dollars ($35 million) to settle a class action suit brought by 700 former patients.
The patients alleged the company didn't disclose the risk of false positives in genetic testing on embryos, which led them to discard potentially viable embryos.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
Deadly NYC Legionnaires' disease outbreak fueled by negligence, lawsuit says
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump has filed lawsuits against two construction companies over what he called a "completely preventable" outbreak of Legionnaires' disease that has killed five people and sickened more than 100 others in New York City. Legionnaires' disease is a severe pneumonia caused by a type of bacteria called Legionella, which grows in warm or hot water, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. An outbreak of the disease, which began on July 25, has been clustered across five zip codes in Central Harlem. The city health department said the outbreak is linked to cooling towers, heat exchangers that use fans and water to cool down buildings. On Aug. 14, health officials confirmed that 12 cooling towers at buildings including NYC Health + Hospitals/Harlem tested positive for the Legionella bacteria. Crump and other attorneys filed complaints on behalf of two construction workers who were hospitalized with Legionnaire's disease in July after working near the hospital in Harlem, according to a news release. Crump said the legal team has also filed a notice of claim and intend to sue the city as well. "It is believed that the cooling towers at Harlem Hospital were filled with rainwater after several large July storms," the release said. "The water was left untreated, which permitted bacteria to spread causing workers at the site to become sick." Construction companies, city accused of negligence Crump accused Skanska USA Building, Inc., Rising Sun Construction LLC and the city of negligence at a news conference on Aug. 20, announcing the lawsuits. The attorneys said the construction companies were put on notice about the possibility of Legionella bacteria through bulletins after the storms, but failed to take action to keep those working near the hospital safe. "When corporations cut corners, tragedies like this happen. Preventable tragedies, unnecessary tragedies," Crump said. Crump said the lawsuit is seeking not only compensation for the workers but also accountability and answers about why this outbreak occurred in Harlem — a historically Black neighborhood in Upper Manhattan. Skanska and Rising Sun did not immediatedly respond to a request for comment from USA TODAY. When asked about Crump's claims about the source of the outbreak, a spokesperson for the city's health department said the investigation is ongoing. "Molecular testing may help us determine which cooling tower — or cooling towers — were the source of the bacteria in the Central Harlem cluster," spokesperson Chantal Gomez said in a statement. "The Public Health Lab is still determining a match through DNA sequencing and we expect final results soon.' Electrian describes gasping for air while hospitalized with Legionnaire's Nunzio Quinto, a union electrian who worked at a ground-up construction of the NewYork City Public Health Laboratory, a 10-story facility adjacent to the hospital complex, said he thought he had food poisoning when he first started feeling lethargic in late July. Quinto said his family took him to the hospital, where he was immediately diagnosed with Legionnaire's disease. He suffered breathing problems, pain and internal bleeding during a five-day stay in the hospital, but said his coworkers weren't notified of his illness. "I want answers to what's going on. I can't have a safe place to work? This is New York City," Quinto said at the news conference. Contributing: Thao Nguyen
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
How does Legionnaires' disease spread? What to know about NYC outbreak
NEW YORK − Health officials are still finding cases in one of the city's largest Legionnaires' disease outbreaks in years as they continue monitoring Harlem cooling towers suspected of sickening more than a hundred people. On Aug. 19, New York City health officials identified a fifth person died before mid-August from the central Harlem outbreak of Legionnaires' disease, which is a severe type of pneumonia. Since the outbreak began in late July, 108 people have been identified as sickened, according to the New York City health department. The outbreak is concentrated across five ZIP codes in central Harlem, a historically Black neighborhood in Manhattan. New cases continue to decline as officials remediate cooling towers suspected to harbor the Legionella bacteria that causes the disease. When was the last large Legionnaires' outbreak in NYC? The health department identifies cases each year, sometimes resulting in death. The city saw its largest recent outbreak in 2015. Then, 138 cases and 16 deaths were linked to a single cooling tower in the South Bronx, just across the Harlem River from the Harlem neighborhood. A more recent outbreak in 2022 in the Bronx's Highbridge neighborhood saw 30 people sickened, a city health department report said. Decades earlier, a large outbreak in Pennsylvania gave Legionnaires' disease its name. In 1976, an outbreak at an American Legion veterans organization state convention in a Philadelphia hotel infected 180 people and killed 29. How does Legionnaires' disease spread? The bacteria − found naturally in freshwater − grows in warm or hot water, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The disease doesn't spread between people, but from mist containing bacteria that people inhale, city health officials said. Without maintenance, water systems, such as hot tubs, cooling towers, hot water tanks or big plumbing systems give the bacteria ideal places to grow. CDC estimates nine in 10 outbreaks were caused by preventable problems with effective water management. In New York, officials suspect a dozen cooling towers, used atop 10 larger buildings to control the temperature of cooling systems using fans and water as heat exchangers, caused the current outbreak. The cooling towers sprayed mist containing from the tops of buildings. Legionnaires' disease doesn't spread by drinking water, or from cooled air from air conditioners. Window AC units, ubiquitous on many buildings in New York, also aren't a risk for bacterial growth, since they don't use water to cool the air. City health officials have sampled and tested water from the cooling towers and treated affected buildings in the five ZIP codes (10027, 10030, 10035, 10037 and 10039). What are Legionnaires' disease symptoms? Most people exposed to the bacteria don't develop Legionnaires' disease. The risk to most people in central Harlem ZIP codes is low, but people who live or work in the area and have flu-like symptoms are urged to seek care right away, city health officials said in an Aug. 6 notice to residents. As a severe form of pneumonia, symptoms include fever, chills, muscle aches and cough, city health officials said. People can also get headaches, fatigue, loss of appetite, confusion or diarrhea. Symptoms develop between two and 10 days after exposure, but it can be up to two weeks. People at higher risk include those ages 50 and older, smokers, have chronic lung disease and have weakened immune systems from a condition or medication. Possible complications can include lung failure and death, with about one in 10 people who get sick dying from the disease due to complications from illness, CDC said. The disease is easily treatable with antibiotics. If people develop symptoms, they should seek medical care right away. What is risk ahead? With hotter, more humid temperatures in a warming climate, Legionnaires' disease is a growing health concern. CDC data shows the condition is becoming more common in recent decades. In New York, outbreaks tend to oscillate between predominantly lower income Black and Latino neighborhoods, a former health official previously told USA TODAY. Contributing: Thao Nguyen, USA TODAY Eduardo Cuevas is a reporter for USA TODAY based in New York City. Reach him by email at emcuevas1@ or on Signal at emcuevas.01. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: What is Legionnaires' disease? What to know about NYC outbreak
USA Today
4 hours ago
- USA Today
NYC identifies more cases, death in large Legionnaires' disease outbreak. What to know.
NEW YORK − Health officials are still finding cases in one of the city's largest Legionnaires' disease outbreaks in years as they continue monitoring Harlem cooling towers suspected of sickening more than a hundred people. On Aug. 19, New York City health officials identified a fifth person died before mid-August from the central Harlem outbreak of Legionnaires' disease, which is a severe type of pneumonia. Since the outbreak began in late July, 108 people have been identified as sickened, according to the New York City health department. The outbreak is concentrated across five ZIP codes in central Harlem, a historically Black neighborhood in Manhattan. New cases continue to decline as officials remediate cooling towers suspected to harbor the Legionella bacteria that causes the disease. When was the last large Legionnaires' outbreak in NYC? The health department identifies cases each year, sometimes resulting in death. The city saw its largest recent outbreak in 2015. Then, 138 cases and 16 deaths were linked to a single cooling tower in the South Bronx, just across the Harlem River from the Harlem neighborhood. A more recent outbreak in 2022 in the Bronx's Highbridge neighborhood saw 30 people sickened, a city health department report said. Decades earlier, a large outbreak in Pennsylvania gave Legionnaires' disease its name. In 1976, an outbreak at an American Legion veterans organization state convention in a Philadelphia hotel infected 180 people and killed 29. How does Legionnaires' disease spread? The bacteria − found naturally in freshwater − grows in warm or hot water, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The disease doesn't spread between people, but from mist containing bacteria that people inhale, city health officials said. Without maintenance, water systems, such as hot tubs, cooling towers, hot water tanks or big plumbing systems give the bacteria ideal places to grow. CDC estimates nine in 10 outbreaks were caused by preventable problems with effective water management. In New York, officials suspect a dozen cooling towers, used atop 10 larger buildings to control the temperature of cooling systems using fans and water as heat exchangers, caused the current outbreak. The cooling towers sprayed mist containing from the tops of buildings. Legionnaires' disease doesn't spread by drinking water, or from cooled air from air conditioners. Window AC units, ubiquitous on many buildings in New York, also aren't a risk for bacterial growth, since they don't use water to cool the air. City health officials have sampled and tested water from the cooling towers and treated affected buildings in the five ZIP codes (10027, 10030, 10035, 10037 and 10039). How do you know you have Legionnaires' disease? Most people exposed to the bacteria don't develop Legionnaires' disease. The risk to most people in central Harlem ZIP codes is low, but people who live or work in the area and have flu-like symptoms are urged to seek care right away, city health officials said in an Aug. 6 notice to residents. As a severe form of pneumonia, symptoms include fever, chills, muscle aches and cough, city health officials said. People can also get headaches, fatigue, loss of appetite, confusion or diarrhea. Symptoms develop between two and 10 days after exposure, but it can be up to two weeks. People at higher risk include those ages 50 and older, smokers, have chronic lung disease and have weakened immune systems from a condition or medication. Possible complications can include lung failure and death, with about one in 10 people who get sick dying from the disease due to complications from illness, CDC said. The disease is easily treatable with antibiotics. If people develop symptoms, they should seek medical care right away. What is risk ahead? With hotter, more humid temperatures in a warming climate, Legionnaires' disease is a growing health concern. CDC data shows the condition is becoming more common in recent decades. In New York, outbreaks tend to oscillate between predominantly lower income Black and Latino neighborhoods, a former health official previously told USA TODAY. Contributing: Thao Nguyen, USA TODAY Eduardo Cuevas is a reporter for USA TODAY based in New York City. Reach him by email at emcuevas1@ or on Signal at emcuevas.01.
