Ugly truth for Storm and Dragons fans amid claims they were both 'robbed'
Dragons and Storm fans were both left crying foul on Saturday night amid claims they were 'robbed' by contentious calls in their NRL losses to the Bulldogs and Sea Eagles. For the Dragons it was what Shane Flanagan described as an 'outrageous' penalty given to the Bulldogs that allowed them to march downfield and score the match-winning try at the death.
And it was also a penalty awarded to Manly that had Melbourne fans up in arms. But in both instances, one could make a very good argument they both had themselves to blame.
I'm a diehard Dragons fan, and I completely agree the Bunker got it wrong when Luciano Leilua was deemed to have crowded the ruck and caused Jacob Kiraz to lose the ball with five minutes to play. Leilua was simply standing up rather than "moving his foot forward" as the Bunker official claimed, and Kiraz should have paid the price for showing no care for the ball while trying to play it quickly. It also looked like Kiraz didn't get to his feet properly before trying to play it.
Kiraz is on his knees and tries to play the ball I thought that wasn't allowed ?#NRLBulldogsDragons pic.twitter.com/klkYAn0czF
— ClippersSeason (@FunnyCants) July 19, 2025
What should have been a knock-on and Dragons ball in good field position was instead a Bulldogs penalty that allowed them to go downfield and score the winner. But the truth of the matter is the Dragons still should have won if not for a couple of diabolical decisions they made.
Corey Allan inexplicably dived back into his own in-goal with three minutes remaining to force a line drop-out, rather than diving forward into the field of play to retain possession. Captain Clint Gutherson then made a questionable decision to attempt a short drop-out rather than pump it long - gifting the Bulldogs the ball just 10m out when it didn't go the distance.
Why on earth Gutherson didn't go for a long drop-out and make the Bulldogs try and score from long-range is anyone's guess. Not to mention Tyrell Sloan rushing in from his wing and leaving Jethro Rinakama unmarked to score the match-winning try.
Jethro Rinakama scores the match-winner! 🤯Telstra Moment of the Match pic.twitter.com/Q3rYHsSHgT
— NRL (@NRL) July 19, 2025
Dragons' poor decision-making late in games
The penalty call on the Kiraz dropped ball was a shocker, but the Dragons shot themselves in the foot with how they responded. They've lost three games by a single point this season, and another by two points. At times they've been desperately unlucky, but their decision-making late in games hasn't been good enough.
They were certifiably robbed in Round 18 against Canberra when a try was disallowed for a forward pass that was nowhere near forward, which saw the touch-judge axed for the remainder of the season. But Saturday night's loss to the Bulldogs wasn't the same.
Damien Cook also questioned a try that was disallowed for Sloan pushing Rinakama in the back. But the Dragons winger has gotten away with the same act multiple times this season, and it caught up with him on Saturday night.
Bunker got it exactly right to penalise Harry Grant
As for the Storm, the Bunker official got it exactly right when he pinged Harry Grant for running through the kicking leg of Luke Brooks on an attempted field-goal. The ensuing penalty allowed the Sea Eagles to kick two points for a 20-18 victory.
Storm fans claimed it was a soft penalty and questioned the rule, but Lachlan Ilias' broken leg last year shows why it's needed. And once again the Storm only had themselves to blame.
Nelson Asofa-Solomona's elbow to the head of Jake Simpkin proved a game-changing moment when a try for Grant was overturned because of it. If Asofa-Solomona hadn't lashed out, the Storm would have reduced the deficit and gone on to win.
Melbourne coach Craig Bellamy admitted his side's ill-discipline was a bigger factor than any refereeing decision. 'You just see the error rate, at half-time our completions was 65 per cent and theirs was 92 per cent or something, so it's hard to be competitive if you're completing at that and the opposition is completing at that high rate,' Bellamy said.
'I don't know whether we were looking for a soft performance, but having said that, you've got to give a lot of credit to Manly too. How we started, it's like we were looking for short cuts straight away."
On the Grant penalty late in the game, the Storm coach said: "I suppose, within what the rules say, that's what it was."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
3 hours ago
- New York Times
U.S. swim team dealing with ‘acute gastroenteritis' at world championships
The U.S. swimming team is dealing with a bout of 'acute gastroenteritis' at the world championships in Singapore, a spokesperson for USA Swimming confirmed Sunday, that began at a recent training camp and is now impacting the competition. The team held a training camp in Phuket, Thailand, where the illness began, before traveling to Singapore last week. It was not clear how much of the team was impacted, but several U.S. swimmers either were pulled from races or noticeably struggled on the first day of competition. Advertisement Gretchen Walsh was a surprise late scratch from the women's 4×100-meter freestyle relay final Sunday. She had posted the top time in the 100-meter butterfly semifinals earlier in the day but was then pulled from the relay and replaced by Erin Gemmell. USA Swimming confirmed the move was 'illness related.' Walsh competed in the relay at last year's Paris Olympics, posting the Americans' second-fastest time in their silver-medal run in the final. She was also on the silver-medal team at the 2023 world championships. Without Walsh, the U.S. team of Simone Manuel, Kate Douglass, Gemmell and Torri Huske finished second to Australia in a tight race Sunday. Australia won in 3:30.60, with the Americans finishing in 3:31.04. It was Australia's fourth world title in the last five tries at worlds, only missing out at the 2024 worlds that several top swimmers skipped ahead of the Olympics. Huske, 22, swam the relay despite being pulled from the 100-meter butterfly heats earlier in the day. Huske won gold in that event in Paris. Claire Weinstein, 18, was pulled from the 400-meter freestyle heats. She was part of the Americans' silver-medal team in the 4×200-meter freestyle relay in Paris and one of the world's top 400-meter swimmers. Luca Mijatovic — at 16, the youngest American men's swimmer to compete at the world championships since Michael Phelps in 2001 — finished 36th in his heats for the men's 400-meter freestyle in a time of 3:59.68, almost 14 seconds off his time from the U.S. national championships in June. There, he set national age-group records in the 200- and 400-meter freestyles — even besting the 17- and 18-year-old group record times. Katie Ledecky, the 28-year-old with more Olympic and world championship medals than any women's swimmer, competed as scheduled in her 400-meter freestyle heats and final. She took bronze behind Canada's Summer McIntosh and China's Li Bingjie. (Photo of Gretchen Walsh competing in the 100-meter butterfly heats Sunday at world championships: Quinn Rooney / Getty Images)
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Double golden joy as Australia triumph at world champs
Australia have ended the opening night of the swimming world championships with a dose of double golden joy after the country's men and women prevailed in the 4x100m freestyle relay events. The night started with heartbreak, with Australian Sam Short falling agonisingly short of adding a second world title to his name when pipped by German world record holder Lukas Maertens in a thrilling 400m men's freestyle showdown in Singapore. But the relay events proved to be Australia's saviour. First, Olivia Wunsch pulled off a huge late comeback to fire Australia to an upset victory over the US in the women's 4x100m freestyle relay. Then Kyle Chalmers achieved the same result for Australia's men, reeling in a sizeable lead from the US to snare gold. The Australian coaching staff celebrated wildly upon each victory. Australia entered Sunday night's 4x100m women's relay with a new-look team featuring Mollie O'Callaghan, Meg Harris, Milla Jansen and Wunsch. The US were favourites to win, but Australia threw a spanner into the works by clawing their way into the lead by the time Wunsch dived into the water for the final leg. American Torri Huske quickly re-took the lead and held a half length margin with 50m remaining before Woods came storming home to snatch victory. Australia finished in a time of 3:30.60, with the US (3:31.04) in second. Earlier, in the first medal event of the championships, Short overcame an early deficit to hit the lead with less than half the race remaining. The 21-year-old still led by a fingernail with 50m to go, and was neck-and-neck with Maertens right until the end. Short, the 2023 world champion who finished fourth at the Paris Olympics, couldn't hide his disappointment upon touching the wall and seeing he lost by two hundredths of a second. 🇩🇪 Lukas Martens activating the afterburners for a sprint finish to claim gold in the Men's 400m free 🤯 #Swimming #AQUASingapore25 — World Aquatics (@WorldAquatics) July 27, 2025 Maertens, the Olympic champion, posted 3:42.35 to narrowly beat Short (3:42.37). South Korea's Kim Woomin finished third in 3:42.60. "I won two years ago by 0.02 and today I just lost by 0.02," Short told channel 9. "I'm happy to be back on the podium after a hard last year. So, you know, I can't complain. "I just want to dedicate that performance there to my auntie who passed away a couple weeks ago, "As bad I was hurting there, it's nowhere near as bad as her battling cancer for 10 years. "So I had to toughen up and get it done." And the winner is: Summer McIntosh!This is her first World Aquatics Championships's Gold Medal on the 400m Freestyle!#AQUASingapore #Swimming — World Aquatics (@WorldAquatics) July 27, 2025 Australian Olympic silver medallist Elijah Winnington failed to qualify for the final of the 400m freestyle after posting a time of 3:46.37 to finish 10th overall during the preliminary sessions earlier in the day. In a stacked women's 400m freestyle field, Australian Lani Pallister (3:58.87) produced a personal-best effort but it was only enough to finish fourth. Canadian world record holder Summer McIntosh (3:56.26) blitzed the field to win gold, China's Li Bingjie surged late to finish second, while the legendary Katie Ledecky had to be content with bronze. Australia's 400m Olympic champion Ariarne Titmus didn't feature after deciding to skip the world championships to give herself a mental and physical breather.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Finn Russell's redemption at the heart of different Scottish Lions story
Any Welsh fans seeking solace in their current British and Irish Lions plight need only look eight years into the past and a few hundred miles north for something like succour. For the first time since 1899, a Lions Test team has been named without a constituent from Wales; Jac Morgan, the last remaining representative on tour, out by a nose despite being one of the form horses since arriving in Australia. There is a natural hand-wringing that will come with a perceived slight of a nation but even the most ardent of Welsh fans will accept that this is a reflection of their wretched form. An 18-match losing streak may just have been ended in Japan but Wales remain without coach or positive direction, with the slightly frightening sight of back-to-back meetings with New Zealand and South Africa to come in November. But the wheel of fortune can spin quickly. While an eight-strong Irish contingent in the starting XV is evidence of Andy Farrell trusting in those he knows have been there and done it before, the deployment of Finn Russell, Sione Tuipulotu and Huw Jones as an all-Scottish midfield – for the first time in Lions Test history – was recognition of how far Scotland have come. Huw Jones and Sione Tuipulotu have thrived together in the Scottish midfield (Getty Images) Flash back to the 2017 tour and it was Scots feeling a lack of love from the tourists. While strides had been made under Vern Cotter, Scotland were in a state of regime change with Gregor Townsend stepping up to the top job from Glasgow. In his initial squad for the trip to New Zealand, Warren Gatland included just two players from the nation; while Greig Laidlaw and – to much controversy and criticism – Allan Dell and Finn Russell were later summoned, not a single Scot featured in the Tests against the All Blacks. In truth, after Stuart Hogg fractured his cheekbone, they didn't really have a proper contender, however much support Tommy Seymour garnered back home. The total snub followed trips in 2005, 2009 and 2013 where the only Scottish Test involvement had come off the bench. It was, like for Wales now, a reflection of a tough time in a proud nation's rugby history – yet a Lions concept that thrives on the bringing together of four unions was losing some of its lustre. "I think that is a danger, if you continually don't select Scottish players, Scottish people will become disenchanted with the Lions," two-time tourist John Beattie said at the time. "There's no doubt about it.' Russell, Tuipulotu and Jones may be the only three involved in Brisbane this weekend but stand as evidence of the progress made. If not for injury, Blair Kinghorn would likely have joined the trio in the starting side; with Ben White and Darcy Graham now with the squad in Australia, the Lions could conceivably name an entire Scottish backline were they to so choose, a distinction not enjoyed by any other nation. For Russell, there has been a sense of redemption about this entire trip. As early as last August, the Scottish fly half was talking about what making this tour would mean and how keen he was to rip in, his two previous Lions experiences tainted by the Geography Six scandal (2017), and the twin troubles of the pandemic and an Achilles injury (2021). His third Test cameo in the third Test in South Africa left plenty wanting more. Finn Russell last two Lions trips have been disrupted (Getty Images) Russell has looked at total ease in Australia, taking ownership of the group. He can look laid-back but the fly half is meticulous in his preparation and, coming off a fine season with Bath, he has led the Lions well. Scotland's struggles against Ireland in recent years has led to an inaccurate perception of Russell within the Irish squad, voiced to some extent by Johnny Sexton last November, but Farrell was effusive in his praise after naming him at No 10 on Thursday. 'I've thoroughly enjoyed working with him,' the head coach said. 'He is what he says on the tin. He's a chilled-out character that just enjoys playing rugby, and training as well. He's been great as far as leadership is concerned as well. You can tell that it means a lot to him.' So, too, the Scottish centres, known by the sobriquet 'Huwipulotu'. The pair marry nicely having taken slightly sinuous paths into a Scottish shirt: Tuipulotu is back in his native land during this tour but proud of his heritage and his now famous 'Greenock Granny', while Edinburgh-born Jones is Welsh by name, English by schooling and spent his formative professional rugby days in South Africa. It may have been that Bundee Aki and Garry Ringrose were pencilled in by Farrell before the latter's injury but there is confidence in what a midfield already highly familiar with each other can do behind a pack expected to provide front foot ball. 'We've seen [Tuipulotu] perform many times in big games,' Farrell said. 'He seems to be that type of player that when he gets over the whitewash, he's just being himself. His energy that he gives off to his teammates is certainly infectious. Sione Tuipulotu and Huw Jones have complementary skillsets (Getty Images) 'I've enjoyed watching him and Huw get to own the plan, but also be comfortable enough over the last couple of weeks to be themselves as well, understanding what they can bring to the team individually. Both of them have got pretty freakish ability in terms of individual athleticism. We want to see that come out from them.'
