Perth and Kinross politicians urge Transport Minister to take Swallow Roundabout issues seriously
Road users have not only faced delays but found the new layout both confusing and dangerous
A Perth and Kinross councillor says almost 1500 residents have told him they have faced delays due to the Swallow Roundabout's new traffic lights.
As well as delays, drivers have complained the Invergowrie roundabout's lanes and signage are both confusing and dangerous.
Cllr Angus Forbes and local MSP Murdo Fraser have urged Scotland's Transport Minister to "start taking this issue seriously".
The Swallow Roundabout is on the A90 next to the boundary between Perth and Kinross and Dundee.
As part of the planning conditions for its Western Gateway development, housebuilder Springfield was asked by Dundee City Council to make improvements to the Swallow Roundabout. The developer appointed Luddon Construction Ltd to carry out the roundabout improvements. But the results have left road users seeing red.
Approaching the roundabout from Perth, drivers are told there are two lanes which point straight on. It is only when the third lane appears, there is another sign saying there are three lanes and drivers can turn right towards Dundee/Invergowrie. But the traffic signals have a no right-turn sign on them.
One Carse of Gowrie resident described the new layout as both "potentially life-threatening" and "mind-blowingly stupid (and yet eminently fixable)".
Conservative councillor Angus Forbes and Murdo Fraser MSP wrote to Transport Minister Fiona Hyslop raising drivers' concerns.
In her reply, the Ms Hyslop said: "It is likely to take some time for drivers to fully adapt to the new road layout at what is already an extremely busy part of the trunk road network and we would encourage road users to plan their journeys accordingly as some delays may be anticipated, particularly at peak times.
"The noted observations in the Road Safety Audit carried out in March and any post-construction review observations including those made by road users regarding road markings and signs, are currently being reviewed and considered by the developer, their designer Amey and the local authority. All organisations are working together to resolve this matter."
Cllr Forbes was "bitterly disappointed" with the Transport Secretary's response.
He said: "It is absolutely clear that the signage is confusing and whilst I can't understand why a safety audit was needed to establish this, I am nevertheless grateful that it has flagged this up.
"However, what this safety audit does not address are the long queues that my constituents face day after day trying to get to work and medical appointments. Almost 1,500 people reported to me that they faced increased journey times as a result of the new traffic light system, this is unsustainable in the long-term. I am already seeing increased traffic in local villages."
Mid Scotland and Fife Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser accused Fiona Hyslop of "washing her hands of the problem".
Mr Fraser added: "Her response to my letter about the issues experienced by many motorists at the roundabout is very vague and doesn't address all the issues there.
"It is very clear that the new traffic system is causing many problems for motorists - the road markings cause confusion and it is no surprise there has been so much concern. We really need the SNP Transport Secretary to step up to the mark and start taking this issue seriously."
Fellow Carse of Gowrie councillor Alasdair Bailey made a Freedom of Information (FOI) request to Transport Scotland to see the road safety audit, arguing - given it was about public safety - its findings should be made public.
The road safety audit conducted by Stewart Paton Associates for Transport Scotland, on behalf of Springfield, made several safety recommendations which are currently being reviewed by Springfield.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
4 days ago
- Scottish Sun
Major change kicks in for EVERY driveway in England ‘to save months of delays and cut costs'
It hopes to accelerate the rollout of EVs CHARGING AHEAD Major change kicks in for EVERY driveway in England 'to save months of delays and cut costs' Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MAJOR rule change has come for drivers around the UK in a positive move for home and vehicle owners. The change involves the installation of electric vehicle (EV) chargers for both public and private use. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The new driveway law is for every household in the UK Credit: Alamy 2 It is expected to save thousands of pounds a year and wait times Credit: Alamy There is a current target to install 300,000 chargers across the UK by 2030, a goal set out by the previous Conservative government. From this week, those wanting to install an EV charger will no longer require planning permission from a local authority. The new move by Labour is expected to save driver £1,100 a year, as well as months of delays. Liberty to install EV chargers was already the case for most on a private property with off-street parking. But for larger public developments, a green light from local authorities was required. CEO of charger provider Osprey, Ian Johnston, told Autocar last year: "The problem is you've got to go through a process which is under-resourced and takes six to nine months to get planning permission.' The process has been deemed a key bottleneck in the roll-out of the nation's EV and charging network. The Future of Roads Minister, Lilian Greenwood, said: "We're cutting down on paperwork to power up the EV revolution so that drivers, businesses and those looking to make the switch will have more charge points to power from and less red tape to deal with." These rule changes hope to help the "EV revolution" by what Ms Greenwood considers making it "easier than ever to install EV chargers" for EV drivers across the UK. The Labour MP continued: "We continue to make the switch to EVs easier, cheaper and better by investing over £2.3billion to support drivers and back British carmakers through international trade deals - creating jobs, boosting investment and securing our future as part of our Plan for Change." Audi launches NEW superfast charging hybrid with eye-watering price Operations Director at Osprey Charging Network, Lewis Gardiner welcomed the government's "practical change" in policy which he believes will make a "huge difference" for the industry. He added: "Removing the need for planning permission for essential electrical infrastructure like substations across the majority of sites will save months of delays, reduce costs and accelerate the delivery of the rapid charging hubs drivers need." Jack Counsens, head of roads policy at The AA, praised the positive step but said the government should be doing all it can: "The crucial element is ensuring grid connection in a timely manner. "This is especially important in rural locations and areas where there is no dedicated off-street parking." A charger mapping by firm Zap-Map has shown there were more than 79,000 publicly accessible charge points across the UK at the end of last month. This is an increase of 6,000 since the end of 2024, but just a quarter of the final goal for the next five years.
Daily Record
7 days ago
- Daily Record
Rules on 'blinding' LED headlights could change within weeks
The government is looking into these type of headlights which 91 percent of people say 'dazzle' them. Motorists who struggle with the glare from LED headlights could see rules around them change in a matter of weeks. The Department of Transport is currently investigating the headlamps amid growing concerns of drivers being temporarily 'blinded' on the roads. And the government is set to publish its findings into LED headlights and road safety this summer meaning a change to rules surrounding the 'dazzling' headlights could be just around the corner. This has since been confirmed by an update on the UK Parliament website. It read: "In response to a petition launched during the 2019–24 parliament which attracted 14,107 signatures, the previous Conservative government said it intended to commission independent research into headlights dazzling oncoming drivers. The Labour government subsequently commissioned research in October 2024 and a report is expected in summer 2025." Future roads minister Lilian Greenwood confirmed that research was in progress and is "due to deliver in summer 2025". The independent research comes as a survey conducted at the end of 2023 found that around 90 percent of drivers in the UK have complained that modern headlights are 'too bright'. This study will look at the factors affecting headlight glare and determine if something can be done to reduce the impact of drivers being blinded, reports The Express. Ms Greenwood said: "All types of road vehicle headlamps are designed, tested, and approved to internationally recognised standards to help prevent undue glare and ensure safety on a broad range of roads and environments." However, AA president Edmund King said he believes the piercing headlights are a major contributing factor in collisions on the roads and a quarter of motorists say they avoid driving at nigh t because of them. The issue is also on the radar of the United Nations international expert group on vehicle lighting, with additional measures expected to be introduced by September 2027. A DFT spokesperson explained that this independent research would contribute significantly to grasping the primary reasons behind driver glare and formulating "appropriate mitigations". Research by the RAC in December 2023 found that 85 percent of drivers believe the problem of bright headlights is 'getting worse'. The survey of 2,000 drivers found 89 percent think at least some headlights on cars on the road today are 'too bright', of which 28 percent think 'most are'. Of the motorists who complain about the brightness of car headlights, 91 percent said they get 'dazzled' when driving, with 74 percent saying this happens 'regularly'. And 64 percent believe some headlights are so bright they risk causing accidents. In fact, five percent of these drivers revealed they have nearly been involved in a collision themselves. Seven percent said they find headlight glare so bad that they avoid driving at night altogether, which rises to 14 percent for drivers aged 65 and over. The Department for Transport records how many times each year a police officer has noted 'dazzling headlights' as a factor contributing to an accident. Over a decade, the data shows the highest number of collisions in 2013 at 369, and the lowest in 2020 at 196 - which was influenced by the Covid lockdowns. LED (light emitting diode) headlights are significantly brighter than traditional halogen bulbs. This is worsened if headlights are not properly aligned and the increasing popularity of taller vehicles like SUVs, which can direct the light beam more directly into the eyes of drivers in lower cars.
Leader Live
26-05-2025
- Leader Live
‘Badenoch has questions to answer over car hire security concerns'
The Conservative leader has denied there were security concerns about a private car hire arrangement she had when she was a senior minister, first reported by the Sunday Times. According to the newspaper, Mrs Badenoch had access to a black Jaguar XJ and a driver throughout her time as business secretary through a car hire firm in her constituency at the time, Saffron Walden. Officials wrote to her and said the arrangement was 'not recommended', and repeatedly warned her of the security risks of not using a car and driver provided by the Government Car Service (GCS), the Sunday Times said. Civil servants were said to be wary the car could be bugged, and were concerned it was not maintained in a Government garage. Mrs Badenoch was asked about the story as she appeared on the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg. She told the BBC: 'I never ignored security advice – the driver was security cleared. Actually, recommended by GCS. 'It was a contract that had been in place for about five years, and I renewed that contract. 'A memo was sent by someone who was unfamiliar with the contract asking about security concerns, and other civil servants said there were no security concerns, and that's the end of the matter,' Ms Badenoch said. Leaking of the memo from civil servants warning of the security concerns was 'destructive', she said, adding: 'It's a nonsense story.' But a Labour party spokesperson suggested the opposition leader still had questions to answer. They said: 'Kemi Badenoch must explain why she hired a private chauffeur at taxpayers' expense rather than relying on the Government Car Service like other ministers. 'The Tory leader cannot just dismiss the security concerns that were raised at the time and hard working families deserve to know how much this extravagant arrangement cost. 'Kemi Badenoch has no plan for our country. The Tories have not listened and have not learned from their defeat last year.'
