Nurses aren't seeing results on front lines, despite NDP plan to fix health-care system: Nurses' Union
The Manitoba Nurses Union is calling for the provincial government to be more transparent about the state of health care as nurses aren't seeing any significant changes, despite the NDP's plan to fix the system.
Union president Darlene Jackson said the level of transparency is comparable to the previous government even though NDP Premier Wab Kinew, who was elected in October 2023, assured workers struggling with burnout at understaffed hospitals that help was on the way.
"What we're finding is there's very little transparency from this government. There's almost no collaborative effort with this government and … we need our members' voices heard out there," Jackson said during a news conference at the MNU building on Thursday.
She said the Manitoba government must end reliance on private agency nurses and reinvest in permanent staff to make nursing a lifelong career.
The government announced Friday it has hired 1,255 net new health care workers — which includes 481 nurses — since April last year. Kinew previously clarified that the net new number accounts for departures that happened over the same period.
But union president Darlene Jackson said nurses aren't seeing an increase in staff and continue to be overworked.
"The day that announcement came out, I had messages from members asking me where are they?"
Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara addressed the union's concerns on transparency during a news conference at the Manitoba Legislative Building on Thursday afternoon.
"I can tell you as a nurse myself, as somebody who worked on the front lines under the previous PC administration, our government's approach is completely different than the previous PC government. We respect nurses, we value nurses and we've actively been listening to nurses in their workplaces," Asagwara said.
The minister said the provincial government has been listening to nurses since "Day 1" and is making sure they are getting fairly bargained collective agreements along with more hired health-care staff.
Asagwara also said the 481 net new nurses are working in the public health-care system.
"We know that the changes that Manitobans want to see, that nurses want to see, the big changes are going to take time," Asagwara said.
"The previous government broke the trust of health-care workers and now the NDP is trying to restore that trust."
Issues have increased: report
Issues involving emergency and urgent care wait times, staffing vacancies, overtime, violence in hospitals and agency spending on private nurses have increased, according to a white paper the Manitoba Nurses Union released Wednesday.
The 36-page report addresses the realities nurses have been seeing for years — that they are drowning in a health-care system that is failing front-line workers and the patients they care for, Jackson said.
"There is no doubt that our health-care system is in crisis," she said.
"Our hospitals are becoming unsafe places to work and unsafe places to receive care all over the province."
In 2020, nearly one in six nursing positions remained unfilled which worsened in the summer of 2024 with approximately one in five nursing positions left vacant provincewide, the report said, which credited the data to a freedom of information request to various health authorities.
The rise in vacancies has resulted in an increase in nurses working overtime hours, which is linked to greater risks in more critical incidents involving medical errors, injuries, toxic workplace culture and higher mortality rates, Jackson said.
From the 2023-24 fiscal year, nurses worked more than 1.1 million overtime hours compared to 800,000 overtime hours during the 2020-21 fiscal year, the report said.
"This is not just a staffing crisis, this is a patient safety crisis," she said.
According to the Canadian Institute for Health Information, Winnipeg's Health Sciences Centre is ranked as the largest community teaching hospital to have the highest standardized mortality rate in Canada.
St. Boniface Hospital, Grace Hospital and Brandon Regional Health Centre were also listed in the top eight largest community teaching hospitals with high mortality rates, the report said.
Union survey
The union sent out a survey to its 13,000 members in late 2024 which got a response from 1,326 people.
The survey showed 23 per cent of nurses who responded believed overall health care and patient outcomes had gotten worse, whereas 35 per cent said they had seen some improvements in the past year. The survey said 42 per cent of nurses saw no improvements or noted the overall health care and patient outcomes were the same as before.
Wait times for emergency and urgent care centres have more than doubled, resulting in approximately one in seven patients leaving without being seen by a health provider, the report said.
Jackson said Manitoba is losing nurses to other provinces, the private sector, retirement and those who are leaving the profession.
The province also needs nurses to help mentor and support new graduates. While the province has increased the number of seats in schools, Jackson said the health-care system won't likely see the impacts for another year or two because nursing programs run for four years.
The only thing workers can do is "tread water" until they have adequate nurses in the system, she said.
The Manitoba Nurses Union has multiple recommendations, including improving Manitoba's Provincial Travel Nurse Team, hospital safety, increasing transparency and more incentives for senior nurses to support new nursing graduates.
Asagwara said the province is already making progress on them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
8 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Volunteering in her blood
Canadian Red Cross staff and volunteers are ready to help when disaster strikes. Debbie Blair is one of those helpers. The 52-year-old volunteers with the personal disaster assistance team at the organization's Winnipeg office. Personal disasters typically affect one household; house fires are one of the most common examples. 'I'm not a wealthy person… but I can give my time and because of that, that's what I do,' Blair said. 'It makes me happy. I think time is the most valuable gift you can give to somebody.' The personal disaster assistance team provides services to people who have been displaced, including emergency lodging, food and clothing. Blair has multiple sclerosis and has been unable to work since 2015 as a result. She started volunteering with the Red Cross in 2021 after seeing an advertisement on social media. It was not the first time she contributed to the organization. When Blair was a teenager, the Red Cross operated a blood program. She worked at the Winnipeg office by calling previous donors and inviting them to return to make another donation. 'I've come full circle, right?' Blair said with a chuckle. 'Now that I'm no longer working, I'm volunteering with them again.' Over the last four years, she's become a trusted member of the Winnipeg office. In addition to her work with the personal disaster assistance team, Blair trains volunteers. In recent weeks, she's given her time supervising Red Cross volunteers who are registering and assisting Manitobans displaced by wildfires. The following is a list of volunteer opportunities for Winnipeg and surrounding areas. For more information about these listings, contact the organization directly. Volunteer Manitoba does not place volunteers with organizations but can help people find opportunities. To learn more about its programs and services, go to or call 204-477-5180. The following is a list of volunteer opportunities for Winnipeg and surrounding areas. For more information about these listings, contact the organization directly. Volunteer Manitoba does not place volunteers with organizations but can help people find opportunities. To learn more about its programs and services, go to or call 204-477-5180. Misericordia Health Centre needs gardener volunteers to help staff members maintain and beautify the Misericordia Place personal care home courtyard in the summer. The shifts are Mondays, Wednesdays or Fridays, 9 a.m. to noon. Apply at 204-788-8134 or volunteer@ by June 16. Marlene Street Community Resource Centre needs help to set up its garden boxes. That involves transporting the boxes, filling them with dirt and planting seeds. Refreshments will be provided. Volunteers must be able to lift up to 50 pounds, able to move around for a few hours and have knowledge in gardening. They must be available from early morning to noon in mid-June. Email lcirujales@ by June 20. Initiatives for Just Communities needs a board treasurer. The organization supports people with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder and intellectual disabilities, and those who are or have been incarcerated. The treasurer will be part of the executive committee, overseeing finances, the annual budget and chairing the finance committee. A CPA with at least 12 years of experience is required. The three-year term involves bimonthly meetings alternating between Winnipeg and the Steinbach area, and an annual board retreat. Evening meetings and some travel are required, with mileage outside the city reimbursed. Email by June 30. Mennonite Central Committee's Kildonan Thrift Shop needs people with a skill set in assessing and repairing electronic devices. Volunteers are needed to sort, test, clean and price electronic items such as record players, amplifiers, radios and DVD players that have been donated for resale. The shop is open Monday through Saturday from 9:30 a.m. to 5 p.m., with shifts from 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. or 1 p.m. to 5 p.m. Apply at or 204-668-0967, ext. 5, by June 30. The Manitoba Indigenous Summer Games will host more than 2,000 athletes at Sagkeeng Anicinabe Nation. Volunteers are needed for roles such as registration, food services and cultural services. They will also help with security, medical aid and special events. Skills such as organization, communication and attention to detail are essential. Volunteers must be 13 or older. Flexible shifts are available from Aug. 17 to Aug. 23 at Brokenhead Ojibway Nation. Apply online at by Aug. 10. The Brain Tumour Foundation of Canada needs volunteers for its walk at the Teddy Bass Athletic Field in Kildonan Park on June 28. They will help with setup, registration and participant motivation. No experience is required. Apply at by June 16. Parkinson Canada is recruiting support group facilitators for Brandon. The facilitator plays a critical role in the delivery of support services at the community level. They create a confidential and welcoming space, where people living with Parkinson's or their care partners can share their experiences and develop supportive relationships in a group setting. The group meets from 1:30 p.m. to 3:30 p.m. on the third Thursday of every month. Apply at or volunteer@ by June 30. Shelter Movers — a national charity providing free moving and storage services to people and families fleeing abuse — needs movers and drivers. Movers must be 18 or older, and drivers must be 21 or older. Email by June 30. Apathy is Boring needs people ages 18 to 30 for Winnipeg RISE. The program provides training, resources and funding to support youth in designing and leading a community project. No experience is required. Apply at by July 6. The St. Vital Agricultural Fair is seeking volunteers for its 114th annual Fair and Display on Aug. 8 and Aug. 9. Opportunities include serving as greeters, setting up and taking down tables and chairs, and serving meals in a cafeteria style. Volunteers are also needed at the children's craft table and in helping exhibitors place their entries, and to help with cleaning duties such as garbage removal. More information about the event is available at Apply at PjMcFarlane@ or to 204-487-4597, ext. 1, by July 29. The Leftovers Foundation, a food-rescue charity with a mission of reducing food waste and increasing access to food for people facing barriers, is gearing up for Home Harvest. The program facilitates the rescue of homegrown food. Community members can participate by signing up through the website or mobile app to become a donor (grower) or volunteer to complete routes. Growers with excess produce can submit a request any time, and volunteers can harvest and deliver the produce to local service agencies and keep a portion for themselves. Volunteers can sign up in groups or individually. Email alyssa@ or go to for more information. Apply by Aug. 2. Some days Blair's volunteer work is as simple as spending 10 minutes answering texts from volunteers who need assistance. Other days it means spending a couple of hours helping people who have just lost their homes. 'It's not always extremely time-consuming, but it's amazing work to be able to do when you're able to do it,' Blair said. On a Friday afternoon at the end of May, Blair spent a few hours driving to and from Portage la Prairie with her sons, Riley and Noah. They delivered a pre-paid card to an elderly couple who had recently escaped from a house fire. 'It was a pretty big fire so we put them up in a hotel and delivered further financial assistance,' Blair said. 'They were extremely nice people. A few tears were involved because they're overwhelmed, right? I explained further options and who they can call for assistance above and beyond what we can provide, because we always try to help people with that as well.' Blair also volunteers with Transplant Manitoba and the Kidney Foundation of Canada. Noah is a kidney transplant recipient, so the cause is close to her heart. 'I always encourage people to volunteer,' she said. 'Volunteering is amazing.' Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. Blair is one of more than 14,000 active Red Cross volunteers across the country, said spokesperson Jason Small. 'Our volunteers are the heart of the organization and bring the mission of the Canadian Red Cross to life,' Small wrote in an email. 'We rely on volunteers from all walks of life who bring different skills and experience to the Canadian Red Cross.' The organization is constantly recruiting volunteers to support its responses across Canada, Small said. Visit the Canadian Red Cross website for details. If you know a special volunteer, email Aaron EppReporter Aaron Epp reports on business for the Free Press. After freelancing for the paper for a decade, he joined the staff full-time in 2024. He was previously the associate editor at Canadian Mennonite. Read more about Aaron. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Winnipeg Free Press
4 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Nurse college must be able to pivot: health minister
Manitoba's health minister says the regulatory body for nursing is blocking internationally educated nurses who want to practise in the province and driving them away. 'What we're hearing from nurses — not just IENs but across the board — is that the college continues to be a barrier to nurses successfully joining the front lines and they're leaving Manitoba as a result, or not considering Manitoba as an option,' Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara said late Thursday. The health minister was defending their directive that the College of Registered Nurses of Manitoba stop requiring 'labour mobility applicants' have 450 hours of nursing experience in Canada over the past two years or 1,225 hours over the past five years. MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES Health Minister Uzoma Asagwara: 'If Manitoba wants to be competitive in the health care staffing market, we have to be willing to adapt and evolve.' In 2022, the Progressive Conservative government directed the college to stop requiring out-of-province applicants have recent Canadian experience. The college said it then tracked a significant increase in complaints about nursing incompetence linked to labour mobility applicants, and that two patients have died as a result. It cited complaints about a lack of nursing knowledge, skill and judgment, the inability to take or interpret vital signs, perform a health assessment, safely administer medication or prioritize patient care. In December, the college reinstated the requirement for nurses to have recent Canadian experience. Asagwara ordered the college to stop, saying it was breaking internal trade laws, including the Canadian Free Trade Agreement and the New West Partnership Trade Agreement's labour mobility rules, and legislation requiring regulated professions to ensure their registration practices comply with obligations of a domestic trade agreement. College registrar Deb Elias said Wednesday the province is putting labour mobility and its support for interprovincial free trade ahead of patient safety and lives. The health minister — who is also a registered psychiatric nurse — said the college's complaints have been taken 'very seriously'and 'immediate steps' were taken to keep patients safe. The province is working with regional health authorities and employers to make sure there are pathways for internationally educated nurses to get more support or resources so they can succeed as a nurse or elsewhere on the front line, said Asagwara. The minister said the college is also rejecting qualified nurses. 'We've heard from a number of nurses in the U.S., nurse academics, federal nurses who've been trying to get licensed in Manitoba to practise in nursing stations. We've heard of cases where nurses who practised in Manitoba for over 30 years — in one case, a nurse who practised for 35 years and was short one hour in her recency was denied a licence to return to the front lines as a recently retired nurse.' Winnipeg Jets Game Days On Winnipeg Jets game days, hockey writers Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe send news, notes and quotes from the morning skate, as well as injury updates and lineup decisions. Arrives a few hours prior to puck drop. Asagwara said the health department's recruitment and retention office is triaging 'literally dozens of nurses who've come to us because they have not been supported by the college.' The minister said Manitoba has to be able to pivot. 'We have to be able to evolve. The college, I know, has historically been unwilling to do so. That's not the landscape of health care in Canada anymore,' Asagawara said. 'If Manitoba wants to be competitive in the health care staffing market, we have to be willing to adapt and evolve and meet the growing needs and economic realities.' Carol SandersLegislature reporter Carol Sanders is a reporter at the Free Press legislature bureau. The former general assignment reporter and copy editor joined the paper in 1997. Read more about Carol. Every piece of reporting Carol produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Global News
4 days ago
- Global News
BC Conservatives question $1M contract for B.C. drug and mental illness adviser
The BC Conservative opposition is raising concerns about the contract the NDP government has awarded to its top adviser on mental health and the drug crisis. It has been one year since the B.C. government appointed Dr. Daniel Vigo as its chief scientific adviser for psychiatry, toxic drugs and concurrent disorders. Vigo has been responsible for developing solutions for people suffering from mental health, addictions and brain injuries due to toxic drugs. According to his contract, Vigo is eligible to receive $250,000 each quarter he works, up to $1 million for the year. In addition, he is eligible to receive 12 per cent of his salary as administrative fees or expenses. 2:07 B.C. government opens more involuntary care beds 'It was very clear during the election that involuntary care was one of the pieces that was needed in this system. I think the government was already aware of that, and I think that because they knew they were facing some pushback from some of their more ideological supporters, they decided to spend a million dollars hiring a doctor as a consultant to tell us what we already knew so that they could fall back on, 'Well, this is the science behind it,'' said Claire Rattée, BC Conservative MLA for Skeena. Story continues below advertisement 'At the end of the day, it's a million dollars that could have been spent on treatment.' Rattée added she was concerned about a 'lack of deliverables' in the contract. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy She said that according to the document, Vigo should have already submitted three quarterly reports, none of which have been made public. 'We're talking about a government that has spent well over $1 billion on addictions and the overdose emergency that we have here, but where are the measurable outcomes? What are the outcomes of any of the things that they have done?' added BC Conservative public safety critic Elenore Sturko. 'We have seen some announcements, we've seen some piecemeal work, even the stuff that's been announced by Dr. Vigo over the last couple of months here — It looks like something is happening, but what's the outcome and where have we gone and what should British Columbians expect from this huge expenditure?' B.C.'s health minister says the BC Conservatives aren't telling the whole story. The $1 million is earmarked for Vigo to build out a team of four people and to cover the cost of data collection and legal advice, Health Minister Josie Osborne told Global News. 1:52 New involuntary care beds are opening in Maple Ridge She said Vigo was retained because the toxic drug crisis and the intersection of addicitons medicine and psychiatry are evolving quickly, and the province wants to be on the cutting edge. Story continues below advertisement 'This is a fresh, innovative look using the professional experience that they have to help us identify the people who need help the most to help us identify the solutions,' Osborne said. 'It is a very challenging situation to see people that are suffering, to see and know that people need treatment and care and that we need the very best clinical expertise, the very medical advice that we can and the appropriate settings and care and therapies for these people — we don't have experts in that inside the ministry.' In his year on the job, Vigo has provided significant advice to the province, including a determination that the B.C. Mental Health Act does not need to be amended to allow for involuntary treatment. He led the development of new guidance to B.C. doctors, laying out the scenarios under which someone can be treated involuntarily under the Mental Health Act, all of them involving mental impairment. 1:54 Success of forced addictions treatment lacks evidence, minister says And he has been involved in the rollout of B.C.'s first two involuntary treatment facilities, one in the South Fraser Pretrial Centre and one in the Alouette Homes in Maple Ridge for people who aren't in contact with the justice system. Story continues below advertisement He has also been made available to media to answer questions about the province's involuntary treatment policy. Rattée said the progress for the price tag simply isn't good value. 'So far, they've only moved on. You know, 18 beds at Alouette, I believe it is, and 10 at Surrey pre-trial, and nothing to do with voluntary treatment services,' she said. 'This is a drop in the bucket when it comes to actually addressing the issue that we are facing right now.' Last month, the province terminated the contract of another adviser halfway through the planned six-month term. Michael Bryant had been hired on a $150,000 contract to consult on the province's policies and service delivery in the Downtown Eastside.
