logo
No charges for VPD jail guards in case that left drunk man with skull fracture: BCPS

No charges for VPD jail guards in case that left drunk man with skull fracture: BCPS

CTV News7 days ago
The Vancouver Police Department's headquarters on Cambie Street are seen in a Shutterstock image.
The B.C. Prosecution Service has decided not to prosecute a Vancouver jail guard in connection to an incident that left an intoxicated man with a skull fracture in April 2021.
The Independent Investigations Office of B.C. forwarded a report to Crown counsel last year recommending consideration of a charge of assault causing bodily harm against a special municipal constable working for the Vancouver Police Department.
On Friday, more than a year after the IIO submitted its report and more than four years after the incident itself, the BCPS published a so-called "clear statement" document summarizing the incident and the service's reasons for not laying charges.
The prosecution service determined that the available evidence against the jail guard – referred to in the document as the 'subject officer' or 'SO' – did not meet the charge assessment standard.
What happened
The document indicates that the injured man – referred to as the 'affected person' or 'AP' – was taken into custody by VPD officers on the evening of April 19, 2021.
He was intoxicated, and the arrest was for 'the offences of indecent act and breach of peace,' which were alleged to have occurred near the intersection of Cambie Street and West Broadway, according to the document.
He was taken to the VPD jail in a prisoner transport van.
'Upon arrival, the AP was still intoxicated,' the document reads. 'Security video footage shows that his jeans fell down repeatedly, and at one point his private parts were exposed. The video also shows that at all times following his arrival at the VPD jail the AP was moderately unsteady on his feet.'
Police reported, and the surveillance video appeared to confirm, that the man was 'unco-operative, particularly with regard to instructions to keep his hands on the wall while being searched,' according to the document.
The subject officer and a witness officer walked the man to his cell, where he lost his balance, fell and hit his head.
Both officers were touching the man at the time he fell, but the BCPS statement says the surveillance video evidence was insufficient to establish that either officer caused the fall.
Charge assessment
When deciding whether to approve charges, the BCPS considers a two-part test. First, prosecutors must determine whether there is 'a substantial likelihood of conviction.' If there is, prosecutors must believe that 'the public interest requires a prosecution.'
In this case, prosecutors found the available evidence did not meet the charge assessment standard.
Beyond concluding that it was not clear that either officer had caused the man's fall, Crown prosecutors determined that they would be 'unable to disprove' a defence that the officers' use of force was reasonable and justified in the circumstances.
Under the Criminal Code, peace officers acting in their lawful duties and on 'reasonable grounds' are 'justified in doing what (they are) required or authorized to do and in using as much force as necessary for that purpose,' according to the BCPS statement.
'In a prosecution, the onus is on the Crown to prove that the legal defences provided under the Criminal Code to peace officers acting in the course of their duties have not been established,' the document reads.
In this case, that means prosecutors would have had to prove that the force an accused officer used went beyond what was necessary in the circumstances.
'The force employed by the SO against the AP for purposes of escorting and securing the AP into cell 1 aligned with VPD jail guards' training,' the statement reads.
'The available evidence does not otherwise establish that the SO employed force against the AP beyond that which was reasonable, necessary, or proportionate for purposes of securing the AP into cell 1.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Woman wakes to find unknown man in her bed: EPS
Woman wakes to find unknown man in her bed: EPS

CTV News

time13 minutes ago

  • CTV News

Woman wakes to find unknown man in her bed: EPS

Edmonton police have released the composite sketch of a man who fled the scene of a sexual assault in the Aster neighbourhood on May 28, 2025. (Source: EPS) The Edmonton Police Service (EPS) is looking for a man who fled the scene of an assault after a woman woke up to find him in her bed. It happened in the Aster neighbourhood in southeast Edmonton at around 7 a.m. on May 28. According to police, the woman immediately left her home after finding the unknown man in her bed. The man was gone when she returned home. EPS released a composite sketch of the suspect and they hope to get help finding the man. Edmonton police release sketch of sexual assault suspect Edmonton police have released the composite sketch of a man who fled the scene of a sexual assault in the Aster neighbourhood on May 28, 2025. (Source: EPS) He is described as: Hispanic or south asian; possibly in his early 20s; clean shaven; and 5'6 to 5'7 tall with a slight build. Police said they believe this is an isolated incident. A canvas of surveillance video in the area was unsuccessful. Anyone with information about the suspect or his whereabouts is asked to contact EPS at 780-423-4567 or #377 from a cell phone. Those wishing to remain anonymous can contact Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477 or go online.

Former City of Ottawa lawyer pleads guilty to defacing National Holocaust Monument
Former City of Ottawa lawyer pleads guilty to defacing National Holocaust Monument

CTV News

time13 minutes ago

  • CTV News

Former City of Ottawa lawyer pleads guilty to defacing National Holocaust Monument

The words 'FEED ME' are seen painted in red on the National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa on Monday, June 9, 2025. (Sean Kilpatrick/THE CANADIAN PRESS) A former City of Ottawa lawyer has pleaded guilty to a charge of mischief to a war memorial in connection with vandalism to the National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa. The words 'feed me' were painted on the side of the memorial west of downtown Ottawa on June 9. The paint was quickly removed, but the act prompted widespread condemnation from residents, Jewish groups, and political leaders. Ottawa police charged Iain Aspenlieder on June 27 with mischief to a war memorial, mischief exceeding $5,000, and harassment by threatening conduct. The remaining two charges are being withdrawn. The Crown is consenting to his release on bail pending his sentence. Police did not initially release his name in a news release announcing his arrest, but he was identified in court documents. According to the Ontario Salary Disclosure list, Aspenlieder was a 'Legal Counsel' with the City of Ottawa. Mayor Mark Sutcliffe said in late June that Aspenlieder had been fired. 'The city's legal department has confirmed that the individual charged, who was on leave at the time of the incident, is no longer employed by the City of Ottawa,' Sutcliffe said on social media. The National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa commemorates the six million Jewish men, women and children who were murdered by the Nazis during the Holocaust, and the millions of other victims of Nazi Germany and its collaborators. The monument was inaugurated by former prime minister Justin Trudeau in September 2017. With files from CTV News Ottawa's Joshua Marano

Video captures boat theft in Meaford, police warn of recent increase in trailer thefts
Video captures boat theft in Meaford, police warn of recent increase in trailer thefts

CTV News

time13 minutes ago

  • CTV News

Video captures boat theft in Meaford, police warn of recent increase in trailer thefts

A boat was stolen off a property in Meaford on Thursday afternoon, one of multiple recent trailer thefts in the area. Video surveillance shows two suspects in two separate vehicles drive onto the property near Grey Road 12 at around 2:11 p.m. The 20-foot Smoker Craft Phantom was on trailer at the time. The suspects exited a white Buick Enclave and blue Ford 250, attached the boat to the truck and drove off. Boat Theft Alert – Meaford, ON On Thursday, July 24 at around 2:11 p.m., a 20-foot Smoker Craft Phantom boat with a 175hp Suzuki motor was stolen from a property near Grey Road 12 in Meaford. Surveillance footage captured: Two suspects wearing red or pink shirts with tan or… — OPP West Region (@OPP_WR) July 25, 2025 This incident is one of multiple in the area, as police warn residents of an increase in trailer thefts. Thieves are taking utility, boat and enclosed cargo trailer from driveways, farm properties and business lots. Police urge residents to remain vigilant, even in rural areas.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store