Reading surgeon suspended from duties after three deaths
Mrs Parker, a childminder, died in March 2024 after a surgical join leaked and was not quickly diagnosed and managed, the inquest heard.Independent medical experts were critical of her aftercare rather than the surgery itself, the coroner said.In a Prevention of Future Deaths Report, Ms Connor said: "Lorraine Parker's death was the third in three months following surgery by the same consultant colorectal surgeon."She said one of Mr McGrath's previous patients, Michael Edwards, died in December 2023 following a "significant surgical error" when a healthy part of his bowel was removed instead of a cancerous area.However, an internal hospital review rated his care as either "good" or "excellent", the coroner said.In Mrs Parker's case, the hospital found "no learning points", she added.A third patient died in March 2024, Ms Connor said.
The coroner told Ms Parker's inquest: "Having conducted all three of these inquests and another earlier case back in 2018 [at a private hospital]... I am struck by the lack of reflection on the part of this surgeon."There has been throughout little acceptance of any of the issues and criticisms raised by different independent experts."I am concerned about the risk of future deaths should Mr McGrath continue to operate here or elsewhere."Ms Connor said the surgeon's case was her first ever referral to the GMC.She added: "It appears that the option to return to operating remains open for Mr McGrath, even after a GMC notification by the trust with certain caveats and requirements in place before he may do so."
A spokesperson for the Royal Berkshire NHS Foundation Trust, said: "The trust extends our sincerest condolences to Ms Parker's family."The consultant ceased surgical duties 10 months ago and we have worked closely with the Coroner and the GMC to provide them with assurance about measures put in place to oversee his work which has been restricted to outpatient work."We continue to monitor this arrangement and will implement any further recommendations made following this inquest."The provision of safe and high quality patient care is an absolute priority for the trust and all our clinicians work to rigorous protocols to ensure patient safety. "In 2024, Mr McGrath was ordered to pay £1.2m towards damages and costs following the death of his patient Simon Healey at Berkshire Independent Hospital in Reading.
You can follow BBC Berkshire on Facebook, and X.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
6 days ago
- South Wales Argus
Calls for doctors pay and funding to be increased in Wales
Dr Iona Collins, chair of the BMA's Welsh Council, said the findings from the General Medical Council's (GMC) workplace experiences report, published on Thursday, August 7, highlight long-standing concerns in Wales. Dr Collins said: "The GMC's findings highlight the concerns that BMA Cymru Wales repeatedly raise. "It is disappointing, yet unsurprising that the report found doctors in Wales more likely than the UK average to identify a range of barriers to providing good patient care." She pointed to higher salaries and better working conditions in countries such as Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and the USA as factors driving doctors away from NHS Wales. Dr Collins said: "The NHS will retain its doctors by improving pay and conditions, as well as providing training opportunities." She described it as 'inconceivable' that doctors feel forced to leave NHS employment while waiting lists remain at record highs and patients urgently need care. A recent BMA Cymru Wales survey found that 40 per cent of resident doctors are concerned about unemployment from August due to a lack of training opportunities, despite ongoing staff shortages. The report also identified GPs as the most pressurised group in the medical workforce. Dr Collins said general practice is being 'failed by insufficient funding' and called on the Welsh Government to 'commit to a rescue package for general practice' to ensure GPs have the resources needed to care for patients.
Daily Mirror
6 days ago
- Daily Mirror
'I'm a doctor and can earn £10k more a month after quitting NHS for Australia'
'Any doctor who says it's not about money is usually coming from a position of privilege - they've not had money worries like the rest of us' One in five doctors are considering leaving the UK to work abroad, the regulator has found. The General Medical Council has warned without more being done to keep doctors in the NHS the Government's pledge to cut hospital waiting lists is at risk. The GMC poll of 4,700 doctors showed 19% were considering a move abroad and the main reason given was that they are "treated better" in other countries. Better pay was cited as the second most common reason for plans to emigrate. The Mirror has spoken to a former NHS resident doctor who moved to Australia in 2023 who has explained why doctors are choosing to work Down Under. Dr Simon Fleming, 42, had worked a placement in Australia during his earlier training years before making the decision to permanently emigrate. He said: 'During my training it was a real shock to me quite how stark the differences are for doctors in Australia compared to the UK. 'Here there is a better appreciation of work life balance and the remuneration is significantly better. A lot of people who say 'it's not about money, being a doctor is a vocation' are usually coming from a position of privilege. They haven't had money worries like a lot of us do. 'I moved from London where I was struggling to pay my electric bills in a two-bed apartment. I now live in a house with a pool. I feel extremely privileged to be very comfortable now. When I first came here I was still training and I was earning more than a consultant salary in the UK in a better resourced department.' Simon had worked in the NHS since 2006 and upon completing his training in the UK in 2023 says he took home £4,200 a month. He then moved to be a doctor in Sydney where, with on-call work, he would earn between £5,000 and £7,000 a month. Now after qualifying as a consultant and working in Queensland, with on-call work he brings home a salary of between £9,000 and £14,000 a month. And that is without doing private work. It comes amid a bitter dispute between resident doctors and Health Secretary Wes Streeting which resulted in a five-day strike last month. The British Medical Association insists their pay must be improved to stop an exodus of doctors from the NHS. The GMC report concluded: "We must be alive to the ongoing risks to retention of doctors and the impact of losing talented staff. This could threaten Government ambitions to reduce waiting times and deliver better care to patients." Some 43% of doctors told the GMC that they had researched career opportunities in other countries. It reports that 15% of doctors had taken "hard steps" towards leaving UK practice - such as applying for roles overseas or contacting recruiters. Dr Fleming stresses that Australian salaries do vary by state and there are financial incentives to work at hospitals outside of the five biggest cities. He told the Mirror: 'I'm a hand surgeon responsible for a large geographical area here so you really can make a difference to a lot of people's lives. And that's worth more than the money. 'All my colleagues back home in the UK were describing being overstretched and burnt out. They were worried about not being able to provide the standard of care they wanted. The number of my colleagues who had been working so hard for five, ten, sometimes 20 years in training. I just got tired of setting fire to myself to keep other people warm.' Resident doctors work in the NHS typically for between three and eight years while training on the job to become specialists and consultants. Under the current system they are rotated between posts with little say over where they go and how long they will work there. Doctors say this constant upheaval makes it harder to settle and start a family, as well as build professional relationships. The GMC reports that one in three doctors said they are unable to progress their education, training and careers in the way they want. Those who did not feel as though their careers were progressing the way they would wish were at higher risk of burnout and were less satisfied with their work. Simon, who is married and has a three-year-old daughter, added: 'Coming to Australia was a decision I felt that was not just best for me but for my family. It's that balance between live-to-work and work-to-live. It's ok to say 'my daughter's got a dance show, can I move things around so I can go to that?' 'There are other things like, as a consultant I get a vehicle allowance. It's bonkers really but they recognise that a significant part of our job is getting between different hospitals. In the UK we are hit by daily parking charges whereas over here I'm supported to buy a car. 'Around 30% to 40% of all the healthcare staff are not from Australia and that's because of how we are looked after - and it really is the NHS's loss. You don't hear about many Australians looking to move.' Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has pledged that by 2029 the NHS in England will again meet a key target of 92% of patients being seen within 18 weeks for routine hospital treatment such as hip and knee replacements. This had been missed for a decade under previous Tory governments. The GMC report comes as Health Secretary Wes Streeting and the British Medical Association (BMA) are locked in talks to avert further strike action by resident doctors after a five-day walkout in July. Resident doctors, formerly known as junior doctors, are in a dispute with the Government over pay and a lack of places for doctors in training. Mr Streeting has said the Government cannot afford to improve on resident doctors' headline pay rise of 5.4% for 2025/26 - which is the highest in the public sector - but he wants to improve progression and working conditions. A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: "The Secretary of State had a constructive conversation with the BMA resident doctors co-chairs on tuesday and agreed to continue engagement through the summer with the aim of preventing further disruption to the NHS and patients. "We have been clear that, following a 28.9% pay rise for resident doctors, we cannot go further on pay this year, but there is shared ambition to explore and address some of the unique additional costs that resident doctors incur through their training and work."
Telegraph
7 days ago
- Telegraph
Disgruntled doctors should stop wasting their time striking
Like many NHS doctors, I have seriously considered moving abroad in search of better working conditions. It was therefore no surprise to read the recent report from the General Medical Council (GMC), highlighting that 43 per cent of UK doctors have explored career opportunities overseas. Reportedly, 15 per cent of these doctors have taken 'hard steps' towards leaving UK practice. I have taken these very steps – attending interviews in Australia, visiting schools for my children, and exploring different neighbourhoods. For the time being, family commitments have led me to remain in the UK. According to the GMC report, one in eight (12 per cent) of doctors are considering leaving the UK to work abroad, with nearly one in five (19 per cent) said to be considering quitting the profession altogether. Of course, there is always a gulf between stated intentions and ultimate actions. But the question still remains: why are UK medics so unhappy? Hot on the heels of recent junior doctor strike action, these statistics are yet another reminder of the precarious state of the nation's health service. Many doctors find their working conditions unsustainable and are disillusioned by the substandard care they are forced to deliver to patients. So much so many will choose to leave friends and loved ones, moving ten thousand miles across the globe, in order to work in better resourced hospitals and GP surgeries (where they also receive better pay). Australia – the main beneficiary of the NHS's failure to retain its medical trainees – naturally welcomes British doctors: with streamlined pathways for GPs to relocate, and recruitment agents advertising at picket lines outside NHS hospitals. The exodus of UK doctors from the NHS has been celebrated by Nicole Higgins, the president of the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. She has stated: 'They've made a huge difference to rural and regional Australia… to our workforce as a whole.' I have been told by friends that in some Australian hospitals, at least half of the doctors in the emergency departments are British-trained, NHS escapees. The 'brain drain' of doctors leaving the NHS is estimated to cost the UK taxpayer billions of pounds annually; it is a symptom of a health service on its knees. It goes without saying that Streeting and Starmer need to get a grip on the retention of the UK's medical workforce. However, ongoing disputes between the government and the British Medical Association suggest there is no treaty on the horizon. The irony is that many of the doctors who choose to emigrate to Australia continue to support the founding principles of the NHS; despite finding the conditions in the UK intolerable, and preferring to work in a mixed public-private health care system that is primarily funded through health insurance. Arguably, disgruntled British doctors should stop wasting their time striking for higher pay and start demanding root and branch reform of the NHS. International comparisons suggest they would be able to deliver higher quality healthcare while potentially standing to benefit from better pay and conditions. Yet the ideological hold the NHS has on the population, successive governments, and doctors past and present, means that these arguments rarely gain any traction. Instead British doctors lament the 'underfunding' of the NHS while complaining about poor pay and unsafe patient care. The Labour Government find themselves struggling to square the circle of providing a universal, state-funded healthcare system which does not bankrupt the public finances. Meanwhile, the Australians look on in bemusement and rub their hands in glee.
