Reading surgeon suspended from duties after three deaths
A hospital consultant has been suspended from surgical duties after the deaths of three patients in three months.Colorectal consultant Daniel McGrath ceased surgery shortly after operating on 52-year-old Lorraine Parker at Royal Berkshire Hospital in Reading in January 2024.In a report on Mrs Parker's death, Senior Berkshire Coroner Heidi Connor said she had raised concerns about the surgeon with the General Medical Council (GMC).The hospital said Mr McGrath was still seeing outpatients under supervision, but had stopped surgical duties 10 months ago.
Mrs Parker, a childminder, died in March 2024 after a surgical join leaked and was not quickly diagnosed and managed, the inquest heard.Independent medical experts were critical of her aftercare rather than the surgery itself, the coroner said.In a Prevention of Future Deaths Report, Ms Connor said: "Lorraine Parker's death was the third in three months following surgery by the same consultant colorectal surgeon."She said one of Mr McGrath's previous patients, Michael Edwards, died in December 2023 following a "significant surgical error" when a healthy part of his bowel was removed instead of a cancerous area.However, an internal hospital review rated his care as either "good" or "excellent", the coroner said.In Mrs Parker's case, the hospital found "no learning points", she added.A third patient died in March 2024, Ms Connor said.
The coroner told Ms Parker's inquest: "Having conducted all three of these inquests and another earlier case back in 2018 [at a private hospital]... I am struck by the lack of reflection on the part of this surgeon."There has been throughout little acceptance of any of the issues and criticisms raised by different independent experts."I am concerned about the risk of future deaths should Mr McGrath continue to operate here or elsewhere."Ms Connor said the surgeon's case was her first ever referral to the GMC.She added: "It appears that the option to return to operating remains open for Mr McGrath, even after a GMC notification by the trust with certain caveats and requirements in place before he may do so."
A spokesperson for the Royal Berkshire NHS Foundation Trust, said: "The trust extends our sincerest condolences to Ms Parker's family."The consultant ceased surgical duties 10 months ago and we have worked closely with the Coroner and the GMC to provide them with assurance about measures put in place to oversee his work which has been restricted to outpatient work."We continue to monitor this arrangement and will implement any further recommendations made following this inquest."The provision of safe and high quality patient care is an absolute priority for the trust and all our clinicians work to rigorous protocols to ensure patient safety. "In 2024, Mr McGrath was ordered to pay £1.2m towards damages and costs following the death of his patient Simon Healey at Berkshire Independent Hospital in Reading.
You can follow BBC Berkshire on Facebook, and X.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
8 hours ago
- BBC News
Canterbury GP's genital exams 'unnecessary', court hears
A former GP conducted "unnecessary" genital examinations on nine male patients, including young teenagers, a court has Manson, 56, is alleged to have carried out the exams for complaints including coughs, headaches and knee accusers said they did not recall him wearing gloves, offering a chaperone or giving "proper explanations" for the examinations before they took at Canterbury Crown Court on Monday, Dr Manson, of Tower Way, Canterbury, denied 18 offences of sexual assault and six of indecent assault. The court heard that Dr Manson worked as a GP between 1994 and 2017, along with working as a GP trainer and programme director of GP training, and as a GP appraiser for the General Medical first complaint of sexual assault against him was filed to Canterbury Police in 2017, followed by an NHS England exercise which saw more alleged victims come a police interview, he said he had never touched a patient for improper or sexual purposes and said every examination was conducted for justified medical reasons, the court was Jennifer Knight KC told jurors Manson also failed to document in patients' notes any potential findings or the the fact such examinations had taken place at all. The first two alleged victims were brothers and both saw Manson before and after they were 16, the court said they were told to pull down their trousers and boxer shorts during a number of Knight said that the elder brother initially "assumed" this was necessary but had gradually become "uncomfortable".Their mother told investigators she never met Dr Manson when her sons were young teenagers as she would always stay in the waiting room, the court heard. Another alleged victim saw Dr Manson twice in 1999 when he was 35 and then 12 years later in 2011, each time with abdominal all three occasions, a genital examination was undertaken and, on both occasions in 1999, his underwear was removed without consent, the court Manson told police this had been necessary to check lymph nodes and femoral pulses in the victim's groin area. However, Ian Wall, a forensic medicine professor and GP, noted there would be no reason to do this, especially without trial continues.
The Independent
5 days ago
- The Independent
Bogus doctor told to pay NHS more than £400,000 or face longer jail term
A bogus psychiatrist has been ordered to pay back the NHS more than £400,000 or face two-and-a-half more years in prison. Zholia Alemi, 62, was jailed in February 2023 for seven years after she committed a string of fraud offences. Alemi claimed to have qualified at the University of Auckland in New Zealand but a jury at Manchester Crown Court found her guilty of forging the degree certificate and letter of verification she used to register with the General Medical Council in 1995. She moved around the country to different posts for more than 20 years to ensure 'the finger of suspicion' did not point at her, the court heard. Alemi, from Burnley, Lancashire, worked 'more or less continuously' for NHS trusts and private providers across the UK in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, earning an estimated £1.3 million. This week a judge ordered her to pay £406,624 in compensation to the NHS or face more time in custody. Adrian Foster, of the Crown Prosecution Service, said: 'We have robustly pursued the proceeds of crime with the NHS Counter Fraud Authority and have identified all the assets that she has available to pay her order. 'Alemi had little regard for patient welfare. She used forged New Zealand medical qualifications to obtain employment as an NHS psychiatrist for 20 years. In doing so, she must have treated hundreds of patients when she was unqualified to do so, potentially putting those patients at risk. 'Her fraudulent actions also enabled her to dishonestly earn income and benefits more than £1 million, to which she was not entitled. She cheated the public purse and £406,624 will be paid in compensation to the NHS.' Alemi was convicted at Carlisle Crown Court in 2018 for three fraud offences and a count of theft after trying to forge the will and powers of attorney of an elderly patient. Following her conviction, journalist Phil Coleman, chief reporter for Cumbrian Newspapers, made inquiries into Alemi's background and found she had never completed her qualification, the court was told. His inquiries led to Cumbria Police further probing Alemi's background. Alemi was born in Iran but in the early 1990s was in Auckland, where she failed to complete the bachelor of medicine, bachelor of surgery degree required to practise as a doctor and was refused permission to resit.
Telegraph
5 days ago
- Telegraph
Fake psychiatrist must pay back £400k to NHS for ‘cheating the public'
A bogus psychiatrist has been ordered to pay back the NHS more than £400,000 or face two-and-a-half more years in prison. Zholia Alemi, 62, was jailed in February 2023 for seven years after she committed a series of fraud offences. Alemi claimed to have qualified at the University of Auckland in New Zealand but a jury at Manchester Crown Court found her guilty of forging the degree certificate and letter of verification she used to register with the General Medical Council in 1995. She moved around England to different posts for more than 20 years to ensure 'the finger of suspicion' did not point at her, the court heard. Alemi worked 'more or less continuously' for NHS trusts and private providers across the UK in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, earning an estimated £1.3 million. This week, a judge ordered her to pay £406,624 in compensation to the NHS or face more time in custody. 'Little regard for patient welfare' Adrian Foster, of the Crown Prosecution Service, said: 'We have robustly pursued the proceeds of crime with the NHS Counter Fraud Authority and have identified all the assets that she has available to pay her order. 'Alemi had little regard for patient welfare. She used forged New Zealand medical qualifications to obtain employment as an NHS psychiatrist for 20 years. 'In doing so, she must have treated hundreds of patients when she was unqualified to do so, potentially putting those patients at risk. 'Her fraudulent actions also enabled her to dishonestly earn income and benefits of more than £1 million, to which she was not entitled. 'She cheated the public purse and £406,624 will be paid in compensation to the NHS.'
