Health Professionals Concerned At Further Delays To Gender Affirming Healthcare Guidelines
PATHA has been informed by Te Whatu Ora | Health New Zealand that the updated Guidelines will not be published until the Minister of Health decides on whether to introduce regulations on the ability of medical professionals to prescribe puberty blockers as part of gender affirming healthcare.
The guideline's advice on prescribing puberty blockers was updated in November 2024 to reflect the Ministry of Health's position statement on the use of these medications. This advice spans just 6 of the total 182 pages of information contained in the guidelines. The guidance is evidence-based, aligns with international best practice and guidelines, and supports a holistic approach to gender affirming medical care for young people who need it.
'Medical professionals working in this area are constantly being asked by colleagues for clinical guidance on gender-affirming healthcare,' says Dr Rona Carroll, a Specialist General Practitioner and Vice-President of PATHA. 'By not publishing the updated guidelines, the government is stopping healthcare providers from being guided by evidence-based, up-to-date New Zealand specific information. We have been given no timeframe for when to expect a decision about the puberty blocker consultation or the updated guidelines. Considering how many other areas of health these guidelines include, and that the advice on prescribing puberty blockers is in line with the Ministry's position statement, the updated guidelines should be published immediately. I think clinicians would be providing safer care if they had access to these guidelines today.'
On Wednesday, 28 May, PATHA published an open letter calling on the Minister of Health, Simeon Brown and the Associate Minister for Health, Matt Doocey, to release the updated guidance.
This letter was signed by over 500 medical bodies, clinicians and community organisations. Signatories include the Royal New Zealand College of General Practitioners, the New Zealand Society of Endocrinology, the College of Child and Youth Nurses, and the Paediatric Society of New Zealand.
The evidence-based guidelines, which have been peer reviewed by clinicians with expertise in this care from within New Zealand and internationally, provide detailed information on a wide range of topics relevant to healthcare for transgender and non-binary people. This includes several revised chapters from the 2018 edition in line with emerging medical research.
'I'm proud of the amount of work the authors have put into these guidelines, bringing their extensive collective expertise into creating guidance that is broad and has a holistic view of transgender health,' says Jennifer Shields, PATHA President. 'These guidelines cover so much more than puberty blocker medication, and this information is important for all healthcare workers to have.'
'It is clear that there is no evidence-based justification for considering restrictions on prescribing puberty blockers to transgender young people,' Shields says. 'These medications continue to be prescribed to children for other indications, and limitations in the quality of the academic evidence are not unique to this care. Healthcare professionals are now left wondering if this government is being pulled into alarming 'culture war' trends away from best practice medical care, and into anti-transgender policies that lead to a reduction in patients' rights and freedoms, and set precedent for making clinical decisions based on political beliefs rather than what's best for patients.'
'This is clear evidence of ideological interference in an operational, professional frontline medical resource that is being requested by the health sector,' Carroll said. 'We reiterate our call for the Government to allow Te Whatu Ora Health New Zealand to publish these updated guidelines immediately.'
Background information
Statement on puberty blockers
On 21st November 2024, the Ministry of Health published a position statement on the use of puberty blockers in gender affirming care, emphasising that puberty blockers could continue to be prescribed when needed as part of interdisciplinary teams. The Government expressed an intention to explore further restrictions on access to this care, and opened public consultation on possible restrictions. This consultation closed on 20th January 2025.
A memo sent to then Minister of Health Shane Reti on 30 April 2024 was released to PATHA under the Official Information Act. In this memo, the Ministry of Health clarified that:
'There is currently no evidence that individual clinicians are prescribing [puberty blockers] outside of an interprofessional team.'
This shows that concerns about individual professionals prescribing puberty blockers inappropriately are unfounded, and current prescribing practices are already in line with the Ministry's position statement.
PATHA previously published a collective statement opposing the restrictions the Government is considering on the prescription of puberty blockers to transgender young people. This statement also received broad support from medical bodies, including the New Zealand Paediatrics Society and the New Zealand Society of Endocrinology. The statement reads [in part]:
'The Ministry of Health Evidence Brief identified that any evidence of harm associated with providing puberty-blocking medication is limited and inconclusive, and withholding this care may exacerbate gender dysphoria and negatively impact mental health. Equitable and non-discriminatory access to this care should be provided and maintained throughout the country.
Decisions about prescribing puberty blockers should continue to be made collaboratively between young people, their families or support people, and the health professionals involved in their care. These decisions are individualised, based on informed consent, and guided by professional training, clinical experience, and the best available evidence. Any move to restrict access to puberty blockers would be a political decision and not one based on clinical guidance from health experts in New Zealand and international best practice. Medical decisions should remain free from political interference.'
Background on puberty blockers
Puberty blockers are a medication called gonadotrophic releasing hormone (GnRH) agonists. They were developed in the 1980s for use in much younger children with precocious (early) puberty, and have been used in gender affirming care for over 20 years. They halt the development of secondary sexual characteristics, such as breast growth or voice deepening, and can relieve distress associated with these bodily changes for transgender young people. Puberty blockers have the benefit of allowing the young person time before making any decisions regarding starting on gender affirming hormone therapy.
The effect puberty blockers have on pausing pubertal changes is reversible. Once the puberty blocker medication has been stopped, puberty will resume as it would have done without medication.
All medications have known or potential risks, but evidence and experience to date does not raise significant concerns about the safety of puberty blockers. As is the case in all medical prescribing, risks, side effects and benefits of medications are discussed with patients as part of the informed consent process before prescribing.
There are also risks to not prescribing medications when they are indicated. Puberty results in irreversible physical changes, which can result in lifelong distress and gender dysphoria for some transgender people.
In every area of healthcare, decisions about treatment and medication prescribing take all of these aspects into account, and health professionals support patients and their families to weigh up the pros and cons for their individual situation. Gender affirming healthcare is no different. Decisions about whether to start puberty blockers are made between health professionals, young people and their whānau. These are healthcare decisions which should remain free from ideological political interference.
Clinicians who initiate puberty blockers should be experienced in providing gender affirming healthcare and working within an interdisciplinary team. It is essential that access to this care and to puberty blocker medication is maintained.
Topics covered by the updated Guidelines
Advice on the prescription of puberty blockers is a small portion of the content covered by the updated guidelines. The updated guidance also includes detailed information on a broad number of other areas of transgender health, including whānau support, creating inclusive clinical environments, non-medical and non-surgical gender affirmation, speech and language therapy, fertility and sexual health, mental wellbeing, gender-affirming hormone therapy, and detransition, as well as specific guidance for Māori, Pasifika, and refugee and asylum seeker trans people.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
Canterbury Mental Health Review Released
A formal regulatory inspection of Canterbury-based mental health services has set out a series of recommended changes for Health New Zealand and is continuing checks over the next 12 months. Ministry of Health Director of Mental Health Dr John Crawshaw, who undertook the inspection under Section 99 of the Mental Health Act, acknowledges the tragic circumstances prompting this work. He expressed his deep sympathy for the family mourning the loss of Laisa Waka Tunidau who was murdered by a patient on community leave from Christchurch's Hillmorton hospital in June 2022. The Ministry's inspection began the following month in July 2022. Sadly, there was a second tragic incident in 2024 involving a patient under the care of mental health services at Hillmorton – underscoring the urgency of addressing underlying issues facing the Canterbury service. Dr Crawshaw says the circumstances of both incidents were separately investigated by Health NZ and are not directly covered by the Ministry's report, which looked more deeply into the underlying issues related to governance, the care model, and resourcing. He says the report recognised the difficulties for mental health services brought by COVID-19 during the pandemic on top of a legacy of events in the region that have stretched mental health services and exacerbated existing systemic issues, and the findings of the review should be seen in that light. Dr Crawshaw says the goal of mental health services is to support, care for, and treat individuals affected by serious mental illness to keep both them and the community safe. Where there are serious service failures, such as in this instance, the legislation provides significant investigative powers to find causes, make recommendations and then monitor progress. The report makes 18 recommendations covering governance, the care model, and resourcing. The overall theme of the report is the need for better cooperation between service leadership and service delivery to prioritise service, enable staff to do their best, improve the models of care, and planning. 'There have already been significant improvements made by Health New Zealand in many areas.' Dr Crawshaw notes that the use of leave plans and leave protocols have been assessed and updated following an independent review. Safeguards now include a detailed leave procedure, an updated safety and risk assessment framework for leave, an amended missing person policy, and a review of the electronic clinical record system. As of next week, for patients under the Mental Health Act who are cared for in Hillmorton's forensic services (but are not special patients), all leave requests, which follow a very robust, carefully considered process, will also require final review by the Director of Mental Health. This arrangement will be in place while the report's recommendations are being implemented. Dr Crawshaw says Health New Zealand's work in quality improvement and progressing the report's recommendations will be carefully monitored over the next 12 months. He says this will help provide the public with a stronger degree of assurance that underlying issues are being addressed and progress continues to be made.
1News
11 hours ago
- 1News
Inquiry finds 'significant' problems in Canterbury's Mental Health Services
An inquiry into Canterbury's Mental Health Services found "significant" problems in the service's governance, care model and resourcing. The findings included "critical staff shortages", staffing vacancies affecting admissions and discharge processes, a "siloed culture and care model", concerns about the service's governance and delayed resourcing decisions at the regional governance level. The final report, released three years after it began, has 18 recommendations aimed at addressing the key issues. Health New Zealand (HNZ) has acknowledged the "significant failings" and is committed to implementing the recommendations. The daughter of a woman murdered by a mental health patient last year says the report "confirms a very broken mental health system". ADVERTISEMENT "I think it's a tragedy this report has taken so long so long to be finalised and released. I can see numerous aspects in it that, if they had been remedied earlier, could have prevented the death of my mother." Director of Mental Health Dr John Crawshaw began his inquiry under section 99 of the Mental Health Act in June 2022 after Hillmorton forensic mental health patient Zakariye Mohamed Hussein murdered Laisa Waka Tunidau as she walked home from work. Hussein was on community leave at the time of the killing. It is only the second time such an inquiry has taken place. Dr Crawshaw released his review on Tuesday. He said drafting of the report took longer than anticipated due to several factors including the extreme weather events in 2023 and delays in receiving key information. Dr Crawshaw said in his report the inspection arose from concerns he held "as to whether there were systemic issues in these services". "The Director needed assurance that the services were complying with legislation and related guidelines, and were able to deliver appropriate care and treatment for tāngata whaiora [patients or consumers] under their care." ADVERTISEMENT Daughter of a woman murdered by a mental health patient last year says the report "confirms a very broken mental health system". (Source: 1News) 'Critical' staff shortages Dr Crawshaw said at the time of the inspection the then-Canterbury District Health Board (DHB) had a population of nearly 600,000 people and was one of the largest DHBs. The district had been exposed to several significant events including the earthquakes of 2010/2011, several serious floods, the Kaikōura earthquakes, Port Hills Fire, the Christchurch terror attack and Covid-19. The events contributed to "increased strain" on specialist mental health services and said the mental health services were "not well placed" to meet the additional strain. His report said the "most significant and prevailing issue" concerned staffing in the clinical areas, especially the adult inpatient, community and forensic services. "In the inpatient areas, there were daily issues in ensuring minimum safe staffing levels." The divisional leadership team had "significant concerns" about the number of staff vacancies and the "relatively junior nature" of the clinical staff in some areas. ADVERTISEMENT When the inspection took place the impact of Covid-19 was a "significant exacerbating factor". Nemani Tunidau, Eparama Tunidau and Laisa Waka Tunidau. (Source: "While the effects were different across the various disciplines, it was evident that all disciplines … were affected. In addition, it was clear that not all disciplines felt heard and involved in clinical decisions. "There were reports of impacts on clinical care. Forensic mental health services were particularly challenged. Not only were there issues in maintaining minimum safe staffing levels, there were issues associated with the experience and seniority of staff." There were "critical shortages" of staff in many areas of the service, particularly inpatient units. "Clinicians frequently used the phrase 'on numbers', referring to being deployed to an inpatient unit to bring up the numbers of staff on a roster to a perceived safe capacity. "The inspection team heard concerns that people were working overtime and double shifts, to meet the 'on numbers' expectation. While the magnitude of the issue was unclear, it was raised repeatedly by staff in interviews. Some staff stated that they no longer wished to do overtime and double shifts due to the level of personal stress and strain it caused them." ADVERTISEMENT Dr Crawshaw said in some interviews a "palpable level of distress was evident". The staffing shortages appeared to particularly impact forensic mental health services, he said. "The clinicians seemed tired. There was a sense that many of them were no longer putting in discretionary effort, due to fatigue and burnout. Many clinicians spoke of the 'moral injury' they experienced by being obliged to provide suboptimal care to tāngata whaiora." Staff 'afraid to come to work' In relation to nursing staff, Canterbury, like other services across the country, had a challenge with a "missing middle" – nurses who were "competent and experienced but still have a long career in front of them". When the inspection was carried out there was a group of staff nearing retirement. They appeared "fatigued and were possibly experiencing burnout". Some of the new graduates had been placed in "unsafe situations". ADVERTISEMENT "For example, a newly graduated registered nurse spoke of arriving for a shift at the forensic mental health inpatient unit and being told that they would be the shift leader, a task they felt wholly unprepared for." Some nursing staff were "afraid to come to work" with an "unacceptably high rate" of assaults on nursing staff by patients. "Staff reports of experiencing the clinical environment as unsafe were particularly prevalent in forensic services. There, staff described how a number of senior staff had recently left, particularly from the acute medium secure unit. "This had left both a gap in staff numbers and a gap in expertise. Some staff appeared to be distressed by and angry at the situation; particularly those working in the acute medium secure forensic ward." The service capped inpatient beds to ensure minimum staffing levels, with 193 beds. At the time of the inspection there were 178 in use or available. Dr Crawshaw said the response, while "understandable" from the desire to maintain minimum safe staffing levels, had "brought challenges". Some staff said there were occasions when patients needed to be managed overnight in a unit or ward different to the one they were admitted to, and others felt there was "general pressure" for early discharge or delayed admission. ADVERTISEMENT "Community staff raised concerns regarding the perceived risks they were holding and managing as a result. Some expressed concern that this was resulting in suboptimal care for tāngata whaiora." The bed number caps also meant that sometimes people with serious mental illness who had not entered treatment through the justice system "fell out of care or were unable to be admitted". Frontline forensic mental health staff expressed "significant concern" about their safety and ability to provide a service. "The inspection team heard there was a particular difficulty in the acute medium-secure unit. Apparently, a significant number of senior staff had retired or left that unit, affecting both staff numbers and experience levels." Of the staff in the unit 50% had less than three years' experience working in health services. 'Culture of blame' Dr Crawshaw said that on numerous occasions, the forensic mental health clinical governance team raised concerns to senior management about shortages of staff in the service. ADVERTISEMENT The inspection team also heard there was a tendency to blame individuals. "Interviewees used the term 'a culture of blame' and described situations where bullying had occurred and staff had been prevented from escalating issues due to a fear of repercussions." He said overall the staff appeared "dedicated to providing the best care they were able to". However, they felt care was compromised in several ways including staff limitations, and the increased pressure for early discharge. "In some cases, people required readmission following discharge, or, where they were not readmitted, their mental state and care deteriorated in the community. "Sometimes, staffing and bed capacity issues meant admission was delayed for people who required care." Dr Crawshaw said the observations were similar to what he had heard from other services around the country. ADVERTISEMENT "However, staff in Canterbury - Waitaha were particularly stressed." The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including poll numbers paint grim picture for leaders, Trump sending the National Guard into Washington, and where have all the coaches gone? (Source: 1News) There were also concerns about how the service was incorporating te ao Māori into their model of care. "This was of particular concern to the inspection team given the cultural needs of the people accessing the forensic mental health services at the time of the inspection." The inspection team had "significant concerns" about the functioning of operational and clinical governance within the service. He was also told that clinical governance at a district level was not working effectively and that an emergency framework had been put in place. Dr Crawshaw did not receive a draft clinical governance structure at a level above the service until March 2024. ADVERTISEMENT "Staff reported difficulties in the escalation and consultation processes and gave examples of issues that had not been effectively resolved." He said there was an "overall reactive mode of governance". "Senior leadership was aware of the impact of staffing issues and had been putting reactive plans in place under urgency to address this (often daily). However, this very short-term focus compounded governance and communication issues." He said nationally all mental health, addiction and intellectual disability services are "under pressure". Several common challenges included mental health services struggling to improve access for Māori, the need for mental health services being greater than available sources and a "shortage" of suitably qualified mental health clinicians, as well as a need for investment in facilities. "When things go wrong during the delivery of mental health services, service providers are subject to intense scrutiny and criticism. As a result, many mental health clinicians practice in a risk-averse manner. This also affects staff recruitment and retention." Dr Crawshaw's 18 recommendations looked at three of the main concerns raised: governance, care model and resourcing. "The uniting thread across these recommendations is the need for better cooperation between leadership and service delivery to prioritise these services, enable staff to do their best, improve the models of care and plan for the future." ADVERTISEMENT His recommendations included prioritising and focusing on mental health service performance, implementing clear pathways of decision-making and governance, and reviewing the care model. He also recommended the organisation focus "maximum effort" on staff recruitment, retention, supervision, training and mentoring. There also needed to be strategies developed long-term management, budget, staffing and facilities as well as establishing and investing in a Māori mental health service. Hillmorton Hospital, in Christchurch. (Source: 1News) 'Significant failings' HNZ national director of mental health and addiction Phil Grady acknowledged the "significant failings" identified in the report. HNZ was "committed" to implementing the recommendations to "prevent the tragic events of 2022 and 2024 from happening again". "We recognise the loss and grief these families have and continue to experience and express our sincere condolences to them. We are deeply sorry for the failings in our systems. "We have reached out to these families to apologise and discuss Dr Crawshaw's report, and will remain in contact, if that is their choice, to update them on progress to implement actions from the report." ADVERTISEMENT HNZ accepted all of Dr Crawshaw's findings and had an action plan in place to implement the recommendations, which focused on the underlying issues related to governance, the care model, and resourcing. "We are focused on continuing to provide senior leadership oversight of planning for the service, building a framework, and ensuring there is sufficient staff with the right level of training and experience to safely and effectively deliver services." Grady said there had been "demonstrable progress" on key recommendations including establishing a clinical governance framework and increasing clinical staffing by 11 per cent since 2022. Clinical decision making on patient leave was "consistent with policies" and there were weekly audits of compliance in place. "There are clear pathways both within the service and nationally within Health New Zealand to escalate and manage risk. " In addition to recommendations identified in the report, HNZ had already made improvements to embed regional planning, decision making and information flow, increase staff recruitment, upskilling and training across the service, develop a cultural narrative to include a te ao Māori perspective, and upgrade a range of facilities. "To ensure progress of the recommendations continue, we welcome Dr Crawshaw's increased oversight of the service over the next 12 months. "We are committed to improving the service and our actions will be closely measured against this report, and two other event reviews conducted by Health New Zealand." ADVERTISEMENT Elliot Cameron appears in the High Court in Christchurch this morning for sentencing for murder. (Source: Pool/ NZME / George Heard). (Source: 'A very broken mental health system' In June another Hillmorton mental health patient, Elliot Cameron was sentenced in the High Court at Christchurch to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 10 years for murdering 83-year-old Frances Anne Phelps, known as Faye in October last year. Phelps' daughter, Karen Phelps, told RNZ that while the report did not specifically address her mother's case there were "many serious issues" identified that had "negatively impacted the ability to deliver services". "Most of these issues are no surprise as they were blatantly apparent in my mother's case namely staff shortages, communication and governance issues, pressure for early discharge and not enough funding to provide adequate services and care. "It's no surprise that Elliot Cameron was encouraged to move out of Hillmorton, that he was not being supervised or under treatment and his aggravated symptoms were not addressed. This report confirms a very broken mental health system. "So now the question remains will this be remedied, which will require significant funding, and that doesn't seem to be a priority for this government, or will another member of the public be killed? I think it's a tragedy this report has taken so long to be finalised and released as I can see numerous aspects in it that, if they had been remedied earlier, could have prevented the death of my mother. It's a timely reminder that every day counts when serious mental health service issues are identified and every day they are not remedied puts the public at risk." ADVERTISEMENT Following his sentencing a suppression order was lifted allowing RNZ to report Cameron killed his brother Jeffrey Cameron in 1975. A jury found him not guilty of murder by reason of insanity and he was detained as a special patient. Cameron was made a voluntary patient at Hillmorton Hospital in 2016, and then in October last year murdered Phelps, striking her with an axe. RNZ exclusively obtained emails from Cameron to his cousin Alan Cameron sent over more than a decade, detailing his concerns that he might kill again. In response to the revelations, Chief Victims Adviser Ruth Money said it was hard to see Phelps' death as "anything other than preventable". RNZ earlier revealed another case involving a man who was made a special patient under the Mental Health Act after his first killing was recently found not guilty of murder by reason of insanity for a second time, after killing someone he believed was possessed. After that article, Money called for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into forensic mental health facilities. After Cameron's first killing was revealed, Money said she stood by her recommendation. "The public deserves an inquiry that can give actionable expert recommendations, as opposed to multiple Coroners' inquests and recommendations that do not have the same binding influence. The patients themselves, and the public will be best served by an independent inquiry, not another internal review that changes nothing."
RNZ News
14 hours ago
- RNZ News
102,446 people on radiology wait list
102,446. That's the number of people around the country on the radiology wait list in the queue in the public health system for M-R-I's, X-rays, C-T scans and other diagnostic tests. That's according to a report by the union representing medical imaging technologists and sonographers. APEX says radiology services are unravelling, with 50 % of the patients waiting concentrated in just five districts according to data from March this year. It also says Te Whatu ora Health New Zealand has spent more than a hundred million dollars in the past year outsourcing radiology services to private providers. Meanwhile 45 percent of the health workers who answered the APEX survey say they are working with broken, outdated or unsafe equipment. Omar Hamed is an APEX Advocate based in Auckland. He joined Lisa Owen Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
