Top medics ask union to row back hard stance on doctors' strikes, warning they risk patient safety
The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges (AMoRC), which represents medical colleges across the country, has urged the British Medical Association (BMA) to suspend its guidance for doctors, which suggests they should not inform their employers whether they plan to strike or not.
In a rare intervention on Wednesday, the AMoRC said this would make it extremely difficult for health service leaders and managers to maintain safe patient care.
Resident doctors are set to strike on Friday at 7am for five consecutive days after talks with the government broke down and failed to avert the action.
The BMA is calling for a 29 per cent pay rise, claiming doctors have seen a 20 per cent pay erosion in their salaries since 2008.
Wes Streeting, the health secretary, described the strike action as 'completely unjustified'. He added: 'It shows a complete disdain for patients and the wider recovery of the NHS.' The BMA said the health secretary's offer did not go far enough on pay.
Royal Colleges' pleas come as The Independent understands that in at least one area of the country, Cheltenham, hospital chiefs have been considering reducing one full A&E service, following mandates that NHS trusts must not cancel routine care.
This would likely result in similar measures to those taken during strikes in December 2023, when Cheltenham A&E changed to a minor injury unit during the day due to concerns over the ability to staff the full A&E.
The trust is due to announce whether changes will go ahead on Thursday morning.
Elsewhere, hospital leaders have said they will likely have to cancel some operations and appointments during the strikes, despite NHS England's official mandate to continue with routine care.
Ahead of the strikes, the BMA has published guidance for striking doctors who are asked by trusts if they intend to take industrial action, stating that they are 'not legally required to respond to such questions' and that the BMA has advised them are not obliged to answer.
Now the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges has said it 'recognises the right of resident doctors to take industrial action, including by striking. However, following the disappointing news that talks with the Government seem to have broken down, the Academy is today calling on the BMA to suspend its guidance to doctors, which states they should not inform their employers whether they plan to strike or not.
'We know that legally those striking need not inform their employers, but by withholding this vital information, health service leaders and hospital managers have said it will be extremely difficult to maintain safe patient care when they have no idea how many doctors will be absent during the five days of strike action, which begin on Friday.'
Other senior medics speaking with The Independent have said they do not support the planned strikes this week.
One, who asked to remain anonymous, said: 'I think it's the wrong time. I think the sympathy's gone. So many people are frightened of speaking out, really frightened. They get abused.
'I think [resident doctors] are very angry. I think this is wrong for them to take it out like this – they need to think again. I think about what's good for the country, because what's good for the country is good for the NHS, and what's good for the NHS is good for them.
Ahead of the strikes, the BMA and NHS England have clashed over plans for routine care to go ahead. NHS England chief Jim Mackey told NHS trusts they must not cancel routine operations. However, the BMA has warned that this will put patients at risk as consultants will not be able to manage both emergency and routine care demands.
Several hospital leaders told The Independent they will likely have to cancel some routine care, with emergency care being the priority in terms of safety.
One trust executive said cancelling operations where patients would have to prep was the 'humane thing to do'.
They said: 'Even though we come under a lot of pressure [not to cancel] we've always taken the view that the humane thing to do... It's not responsible to put people through that kind of physical and emotional preparation.'
During the previous round of strikes in June 2024, around 64,000 operations and patient appointments were cancelled.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
11 minutes ago
- The Independent
Weekly spin class ‘better than physio' for people with common hip issue
Weekly group spin classes could be more beneficial than physiotherapy for people with a common hip problem, a study suggests. The approach could also be more cost-effective for the NHS and could help tackle waiting times for physiotherapy, according to researchers. Hip osteoarthritis happens when the cartilage in the hip breaks down, causing pain and stiffness. It it estimated that the condition affects about 3.2 million people in the UK. For the trial, experts from Bournemouth University and University Hospitals Dorset (UHD) compared usual physiotherapy care with an eight-week exercise and education programme known as Chain (cycling against hip pain). The study, published in The Lancet Rheumatology, included 211 people, with roughly half assigned to each group. The Chain group attended weekly education sessions from a physiotherapist, lasting around 30 minutes, followed by a 30-minute session of static cycling led by a gym instructor. The effects of treatment on patients were measured by the Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (HOOS) activities of daily living (ADL) subscale, which assesses how hip problems affect various daily activities. The study found those who completed the cycling classes had a 'statistically significant improvement in patient-reported function after treatment'. Researchers said the method 'showed superior outcomes compared with usual physiotherapy care, and the feasibility of delivering a low-cost, community-based intervention within the NHS was shown'. However, they stress the 'longer-term benefits and broader generalisability warrant further investigation'. Tom Wainwright, a professor of orthopaedics at Bournemouth University and a physiotherapist at UHD, said: 'For the time it takes to treat one patient using standard physiotherapy, we can treat multiple patients in a group session and provide them with better outcomes. 'This has proved to be more cost-effective than standard treatment and so we hope this will contribute to reducing NHS waiting times for physiotherapy treatment in the future.' Professor Rob Middleton, of Bournemouth University and an orthopaedic surgeon at UHD, said: 'Hip replacements cost the NHS over £6,000 per patient, so avoiding surgery for hip problems reduces the burden on the NHS, saves money, and provides better outcomes for patients. 'Now with this new study we can also see the potential for static cycling to save further money for the NHS by bringing down waiting lists for physiotherapy.' Dr Peter Wilson, chief medical officer at UHD, said: 'We are an ageing population and increasingly we are seeing more patients with osteoarthritis that need either surgery or physiotherapy. 'Finding alternative ways to treat these patients could help reduce waiting times and the financial demand on NHS services.' The Chain intervention was first launched in 2013 and patients who wish to take part are referred to UHD from their GP. To bolster access on a national level, experts from Bournemouth University had developed a virtual course on their education app, allowing people to follow the programme from their home or local gym.
Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
Why aren't parents getting their children vaccinated?
👉 Listen to Sky News Daily on your podcast app 👈 Measles vaccination rates are at their lowest level in sixteen years in England and there are fears that it's led to a rise in the number of cases. According to the latest government figures, an additional 145 cases have been reported since the beginning of the month. It comes weeks after the death of a child with measles at the Alder Hey Hospital in Liverpool, a city with low levels of vaccination. On the Sky News Daily, Niall Paterson talks to Helen Bedford, professor of children's health at Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health about why parents aren't getting their children vaccinated, and what it means for the rest of the population.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Powys minor injury units decision to be made later this year
Temporary changes to a county's community hospitals have been "positive" for cost-cutting aims, a health board has been told, as a decision on whether they will remain in place controversial measures at Powys Teaching Health Board (PTHB) - which included reducing the opening hours of two minor injury units - came into force late last Wednesday, health board members unanimously agreed to fold the verdict on whether or not to keep the changes into the health board's wider Better Together transformation programme - meaning a permanent decision will be taken later this in a report, executive medical director Dr Kate Wright recommended the changes remain in place. In December 2024 opening times at the minor injury unit in Brecon were reduced from being open for 24 hours to 12 hours, from 08:00 until 20:00, while the same opening hours were brought in at Llandrindod Wells site, which was previously open from 07:00 until midnight."Workforce utilisation has improved, and expenditure has reduced", while there has been "no use of agency staff and a reduction of using bank staff," said Dr Wright."In Brecon the cost per patient has reduced from £69 to £51 and in Llandrindod from £63 to £54."Dr Wright said the length of patient stay had also reduced by 23% on the Ready To Go Home units, and 7% on the rehabilitation units, compared to the same period in 2023/ added that "no increased attendances to primary care or emergency departments out of county" had been noted as a result of the health board's chairman, Dr Carl Cooper, said he wanted to assure people that postponing the decision on the long-term changes "isn't kicking the can down the road", adding it "didn't make sense" to launch a consultation so close to the Better Together initiative."Decisions will be made soon as part of that programme," he changes, which were made as part of steps taken to address a £23m budget deficit last year, were originally approved by the board last summer, with local people told they were necessary to maintain a quality service and would last a minimum of six the move received significant backlash, leading to a six-week board then met in October and approved the plans for a second time.
