Texas model cuts costs and prison numbers
For those in prison, this would also allow for the application of the Texas model – a promising form of prison reform that is not only cost-saving but has also reduced crime and recidivism rates in that state. Its success lies significantly in prioritising incarceration for violent offences.
It also emphasises in-prison and community-based treatment programmes for non-violent offenders, many of whose crimes intersect with substance abuse and/or mental health problems.
Several other US states have found the Texas model fits with their wish to curtail prison numbers without jeopardising public safety.Maurice VanstoneEmeritus professor of criminology and criminal justice, Swansea UniversityAnita Kalunta-CrumptonProfessor of administration of justice, Texas Southern UniversityPhilip Priestley Independent scholar
As welcome as it is that the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has acknowledged the prison crisis, her solutions treat symptoms, not causes (Jail time for recalled offenders to be limited to free up prison places, 14 May). Limiting recall periods to 28 days may provide temporary relief, but the admission that prisons in England and Wales will still be 9,000 places short by 2028 exposes the futility of building our way out of this crisis.
We cannot continue this cycle of emergency releases and quick fixes. The government must prioritise evidence-based alternatives: community sentences, electronic monitoring and intensive supervision programmes that cost less and reduce reoffending more effectively than prison.
Most importantly, we need investment in prevention – addressing the social determinants of crime through education, mental health services and employment support. The current approach is both financially unsustainable and morally bankrupt.James StoddartProject coordinator, the Oswin Project
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Husband of woman, 32, who died sacrificing herself to push daughter, five, out way of falling branch reveals desperate attempts to save her
The heartbroken husband of a woman who died sacrificing herself by pushing her young daughter out the way of a falling tree branch has revealed how he desperately tried to save his wife. Madia Kauser, 32, was tragically crushed to death while out on a family walk with her husband Wasim Khan, 33, and their two children near Witton Country Park in Blackburn, Lancashire, on Monday night. It's understood her five-year-old daughter was in a pushchair which Mrs Kauser managed to push away before taking the full force of the falling branch herself - so that her daughter survived unscathed. Mr Khan, 33, was playing football just yards ahead with the couple's nine-year-old son when the branch fell. Speaking of the moment he battled to save his wife as she lay injured, he said: 'I rushed to her. I tried to save her, she was still breathing.' He also revealed his wife's haunting last post on Snapchat - a picture of a tree which she had taken while they were leaving the park. Describing how the tragedy unfolded, Mr Khan told The Sun: 'I was playing football with my son and kicked the ball in the wrong direction and we were going after it. 'I heard a crack and the tree just came down. There was no wind, nothing. 'She was hit by a branch but it had the full weight of the tree behind it and that is why the council had to cut it all down.' Mr Khan described his wife as the 'most beautiful and loyal person'. Relatives told the Mail how Ms Kauser was a devoted mother who adored her children. One told the Daily Mail: 'Madia would have done anything for her children.' On Wednesday, Blackburn council had completely cut down what remained of the tree from which the branch fell as well as lopping off branches from several other nearby trees. The area was littered with sawdust. The accident happened just yards from the park's Big Cover wood where trees form the majority of the habitat. On Wednesday relatives from all over the country were gathering at Blackburn's Madina mosque where the family were hoping a funeral could take place sometime in the evening. Former mayor and still sitting councillor Zamir Khan MBE, an uncle in the tight-knit family, said Madia's body was still with the coroner. He said: 'Her little girl told me her mother pushed her out of the way as the branch fell. 'Madia was a loving, doting mother and a very caring person. 'The older boy was walking with his father in front and could not believe what happened. 'It is very hard for the children. I do not think they will ever walk in that park again. 'It is tarnished for them. Their father is not in a good way either. He and other members of the family have taken it very hard. 'People have come from all over the country - from Sheffield, Bradford, Birmingham, London and other places - to be at her funeral which we hoped to have this afternoon in accordance with Muslim tradition. 'But until her body is released by the coroner, we cannot move forward. We are hoping it will be released today. 'What happened was an act of nature but it is unbelievable.' In a statement, the council said it was 'deeply saddened' after the accident on Monday. The authority's chief executive Denise Park said: 'Our thoughts and heartfelt condolence are with the family and friends of the person who has lost their life at this very difficult time. 'Emergency services including paramedics and the air ambulance attended the scene. Council staff also supported by cordoning off the area to ensure public safety. 'As part of precautionary safety measures, the tree involved was being felled this morning. 'Witton Park is a much-loved community space, and the safety of everyone who visits is of the utmost importance to us. 'Our thoughts remain first and foremost with the family at this very sad time.' A Lancashire Police spokesman said the woman's death was not being treated as suspicious and a file would be prepared for the coroner. A cyclist who rides through the park every day said: 'I have seen loads of fallen branches before but it is mainly because of high winds. 'There wasn't even a breeze when this poor woman was killed. It is utterly heartbreaking. 'I shudder to think what her poor children and husband are going through.' Many people walking there today were unaware of the tragedy and thought the council were carrying out unnecessary tree work. One said: 'I was initially cross that they had cut the tree down until someone told me what had happened. It doesn't bear thinking about.' Local councillor Paul Marrow said: 'There have been concerns about ash dieback disease and the number of dead trees in Witton Park and across the borough.
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
Man in court charged over house explosion in Derby
A man charged in connection with a house blast in Derby which destroyed a terraced property has appeared in court via a video link from houses were damaged and one man was taken to hospital after the blast in Eden Street, Alvaston, on 10 Thursday, Paul Solway was remanded in custody when he appeared at Southern Derbyshire Magistrates' Court charged with destroying property with intent to endanger life and a count of 57-year-old, of no fixed address, made a brief appearance from HMP Nottingham and was ordered to appear for a further hearing at Derby Crown Court on 11 September. Mr Solway appeared at the magistrates' court earlier this summer when he was remanded in reporting by PA Media.
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
Yafai to fight champion Sandoval after WBC U-turn
The WBC have made Galal Yafai the mandatory challenger to unified flyweight world champion Ricardo Sandoval amid an ongoing anti-doping Yafai was beaten by Francisco Rodriguez Jr in June in Birmingham before the Mexican failed a drug test on fight WBC initially stated Rodriguez was not guilty of intentionally doping and ordered an immediate rematch with then emerged Rodriguez had also failed a drug test in December in Texas, testing positive for THC, the primary compound in cannabis. He was given a 90-day suspension and neither the WBC or Yafai's team were aware of the incident before the fight in promoter Eddie Hearn publicly lobbied for the WBC to change its ruling as the fight was ruled a president Mauricio Suliaman on Thursday confirmed to the Ring Magazine, external the sanctioning body had changed its mind and installed Yafai as the mandatory test was conducted on fight night and administered by the Voluntary Anti-Doping Association (Vada), as part of the WBC's Clean Boxing fighter in the top 15 of the WBC's rankings must register for drug testing and Yafai v Rodriguez was for the sanctioning body's interim flyweight British Boxing Board of Control is yet to make a decision on any suspension for Rodriguez.
