
Family of American killed on Malaysian Airlines flight can sue Russian bank, US court rules
NEW YORK, Feb 4 (Reuters) - The family of an American killed when a Malaysian Airlines plane was shot down over Ukraine in 2014 can sue Russia's largest bank for allegedly providing money transfers to a group blamed for downing the plane, a U.S. appeals court ruled on Tuesday.
In a 3-0 decision, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan said state-controlled Sberbank was not entitled to sovereign immunity, after being accused of using the U.S. banking system to funnel donor money to the Russia-backed separatist group Donetsk People's Republic.
A U.S.-based lawyer for Sberbank had no immediate comment. Sberbank was not immediately available for comment after business hours in Moscow.
The case was brought by the family of Quinn Schansman, who was 18 when he boarded Malaysian flight MH17 to Kuala Lumpur from Amsterdam on July 17, 2014, for a planned family vacation.
The flight was shot down over DPR-controlled territory in eastern Ukraine by a surface-to-air missile, killing all 298 people on board.
Russia has denied involvement. Ukraine had previously declared the DPR a terrorist organization, while the United States had imposed sanctions on the group.
Schansman's family sued Sberbank, another Russian bank and two U.S. money transfer companies in April 2019, saying they should be liable for doing business with the DPR.
A year later, Russia's Ministry of Finance bought a majority stake in Sberbank from the country's central bank.
In Tuesday's decision, Circuit Judge Joseph Bianco called Sberbank's alleged handling of money transfers "quintessentially commercial activity," triggering an exception to protections under the federal Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA).
Sberbank had argued it deserved a presumption of immunity as a state agency or instrumentality.
The bank also said another U.S. law, the Anti-Terrorism Act, provided immunity regardless of when it came under state control, with no exception for commercial activity.
Bianco disagreed. He said the FSIA comprehensively governed sovereign immunity in civil cases, and its framework was not "silently repealed" by the anti-terrorism law.
Adopting Sberbank's position, the judge wrote, would negate Congress' intent to give civil litigants the "broadest possible" legal basis to sue entities that materially support foreign entities that engage in terrorism against the United States.
Jenner & Block, a law firm representing the Schansman family, welcomed the court's rejection of what it called Russia's effort to immunize Sberbank by "strategically acquiring" a majority stake.
"We look forward to pursuing further evidence of Sberbank's wrongdoing in the district court and finally achieving justice for the Schansman family," the firm said.
The case is Schansman et al v Sberbank of Russia PJSC, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 22-3097.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time Out Dubai
28 minutes ago
- Time Out Dubai
6 facts you need to know about the Dubai Metro Blue Line
Work is finally underway on the Dubai Metro Blue Line – one of the biggest public transport projects in the emirate. The Blue Line will provide greater transport links for several busy residential neighbourhoods and allow visitors to explore Dubai more easily. Passenger numbers are expected to exceed 200,000 per day by 2030, rising to 320,000 per day by 2040 as Dubai continues to grow. The new line will consist of two routes – one 21km route and a smaller 9km route – and is scheduled to be completed on the 20th anniversary of the Dubai Metro in 2029. The Blue Line will have the world's tallest metro station Emaar Properties Station will be the world's tallest metro station (Credit: Dubai Media Office) In June, His Highness Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Vice President and Prime Minister of the UAE, and Ruler of Dubai approved the design of the 'iconic' Emaar Properties Station on the Blue Line. The station, which will serve Dubai Creek Harbour, has been described as the 'highest metro station in the world' as it will stand at 74 metres tall. It was designed by the American architectural firm Skidmore, Owings & Merrill, which is the same studio behind the Burj Khalifa. The exterior design was inspired by the shape of a seashell, and the interior reflects thematic models like heritage, earth, air, fire and water. More Dubai Metro stations will be named after brands (Credit: Dubai Media Office) When the design was approved for the Emaar Properties Station in Dubai Creek Harbour, it was revealed that the property developer would hold the naming rights for at least the first decade of operations. It will be the first but not the last station to be named after a brand on the Blue Line. In the next phase of the Dubai Metro Blue Line, the RTA will announce naming rights for other stations along the Blue Line. It is common for Dubai Metro stations to be named after brands, so you'll need to check ahead when planning any trips. Once completed, the Dubai Metro and Tram will have 78 stations Dubai Metro expansion plans have been announced (Credit: Dubai Media Office) With the addition of 14 brand new stations on the Blue Line, the Dubai Metro and Tram will have 78 stations. This will be an increase from 64 to 78 stations, with 67 of these serving the Dubai Metro. In 2024, the Dubai Government revealed that the Dubai Metro will have 140 stations by 2040. Currently, the Dubai Metro Blue Line is the only additional line that has been announced. Journey times will be up to 25 minutes The Dubai Metro Blue Line will have a direct link to Dubai International Airport (Credit: DXB) The new line will offer direct connectivity between Dubai International Airport and nine key areas once completed. Mirdif, Al Warqa, International City, Dubai Silicon Oasis, Academic City, Ras Al Khor Industrial Area, Dubai Creek Harbour and Dubai Festival City will all have a faster route to DXB. And the RTA says that travel time along the route will range from 10 minutes to 25 minutes, allowing more people to get to the airport in a flash. There will be 9 stations above ground and 5 underground Plans for a Dubai Metro Blue Line Station have been revealed (Credit: Dubai Media Office) The Blue Line will span 30km and consist of 14 stations – nine above ground and five underground. Exact plans for which stations will be on the surface and which will be underground have not been fully revealed. We do know that it will be home to the largest underground interchange station in the Dubai Metro network, spanning over 44,000 square metres, and that International City is the only announced interchange station on the line. Stations along the Blue Line will include public bus bays, taxi stands, dedicated areas for bike and electric scooter racks and parking spaces for people of determination. International City will have 3 stations The new route provides a better connection to Dragon Mart in International City (Credit: Supplied) One of the areas to benefit the most from the Dubai Metro Blue Line will be International City. There will be three stations based in International City, including one underground interchange station allowing for greater connectivity across the existing Metro lines. All three stations will be included on the bigger 21km route. The area is home to Dragon Mart and is visited by more than 200,000 residents and visitors. More Dubai Metro Blue Line news Dubai reveals plans for world's tallest metro station Here's what it means for your commute Dubai confirms a Blue Line Metro station name And more details you need to know Dubai Metro Blue Line: 14 station locations revealed What to expect when the route arrives


Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Russia says it is ready to remove excess nuclear materials from Iran
MOSCOW, June 11 (Reuters) - Russia said on Wednesday it was ready to remove nuclear materials from Iran and convert them into fuel as a potential way to help narrow differences between the United States and Iran over the Islamic Republic's nuclear programme. Tehran says it has the right to peaceful nuclear power, but its swiftly-advancing uranium enrichment programme has raised fears in the West and across the Gulf that it wants to build a nuclear weapon. The fate of Iran's uranium enrichment is at the heart of the disagreement between Washington and Tehran: U.S. President Donald Trump says that Iran cannot be allowed to develop nuclear weapons, while Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei says Iran cannot abandon enrichment. President Vladimir Putin told Trump in a phone call that he was ready to use Russia's close partnership with Iran to help with negotiations over Iran's nuclear programme, the Kremlin said last week. Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov, who oversees arms control and U.S. relations, told Russian media on Wednesday that efforts to reach a solution should be redoubled and that Moscow was willing to help with ideas and in practical ways. "We are ready to provide assistance to both Washington and Tehran, not only politically, not only in the form of ideas that could be of use in the negotiation process, but also practically: for example, through the export of excess nuclear material produced by Iran and its subsequent adaptation to the production of fuel for reactors," Ryabkov said. The United States wants all of Iran's highly enriched uranium (HEU) to be shipped out of the country. Tehran says it should only send out any excess amount above a ceiling that was agreed in a 2015 deal. Russia, the world's biggest nuclear power, does not want to see Iran acquire nuclear weapons, but believes it has every right to develop its own civilian nuclear programme and that any use of military force against it would be illegal and unacceptable. Moscow has bought weapons from Iran for its war in Ukraine and signed a 20-year strategic partnership deal with Tehran earlier this year.


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Russia is planning an attack on NATO territory to test the Western alliance's joint defence, German spy chief warns
Vladimir Putin is plotting to attack a NATO territory to test the bloc's mutual assistance clause, Germany 's spy chief has warned. Bruno Kahl, the outgoing head of Germany's federal intelligence service (BND), said in a rare interview that it has 'concrete' evidence that Russia no longer believes NATO's Article 5 will be honoured. This is the clause which guarantees that if one member is attacked, all others will come to its aid. He told the German podcast Table Briefings: 'We see that NATO is supposed to be tested in its mutual assistance promise. There are people in Moscow who don't believe that NATO article 5 still works.' He said: 'We are very sure, and we have intelligence evidence to back this up, that [Russia's full-scale invasion of] Ukraine is only one step on Russia's path towards the west.' But Kahl was quick to say: 'This doesn't mean that we expect large tank battalions to roll from the east to the west.' He added that Russia didn't need to do this, as they could simply send 'little green men to Estonia to protect supposedly oppressed Russian minorities.' Russia's 2014 annexation of Crimea involved occupation of buildings and offices by Russian soldiers in unmarked uniforms and civilian clothes, who came to be known as the 'little green men' when Moscow initially denied their identity. Kahl, who is set to become Germany's ambassador to the Vatican, did not specify which officials in Moscow were thinking along these lines. He said that Moscow's ultimate aim was to push NATO back to its 1990s borders, 'kick out' the US from Europe and aggressively expand its influence. 'We need to nip this in the bud', he said. Key to NATO cooperation, he pointed out, was the US and its enormous army. Kahl said his contacts with U.S. counterparts had left him convinced they took the Russian threat seriously. 'They take it as seriously as us, thank God,' he said. It comes after NATO boss Mark Rutte warned that Britons should start learning Russian if the UK doesn't ramp up defence spending. Mark Rutte issued the chilling message while in London for talks with PM Sir Keir Starmer, ahead of a NATO summit later this month. NATO allies are expected to be asked at the gathering to agree a commitment on allocating 3.5 per cent of GDP to core defence spending by the 2030s. A further 1.5 per cent of GDP would be required for 'defence-related expenditure' under Mr Rutte's plan to strengthen the alliance. Mark Rutte issued the chilling message after travelling to London for talks with PM Sir Keir Starmer, ahead of a NATO summit later this month It follows pressure from US President Donald Trump on European members of NATO to hike their military budgets. There are questions about how the UK would fund such an huge increase - roughly equivalent to an extra £30billion annually. Britain allocated 2.33 per cent of GDP to defence last year, and Sir Keir has only committed to reaching 2.5 per cent by April 2027. The Labour Government has an 'ambition' of increasing that to 3 per cent in the next parliament - likely to run to 2034. Speaking at Chatham House on Monday, Mr Rutte was asked if he believed Chancellor Rachel Reeves should raise taxes to meet NATO's commitments. The NATO secretary-general replied: 'It's not up to me to decide, of course, how countries pay the bill. 'Look, if you do not do this, if you would not go to the 5 per cent, including the 3.5 per cent core defence spending, you could still have the NHS... the pension system etc., but you had better learn to speak Russian.' Mr Rutte would not reveal the deadline for when he hopes NATO allies will spend 5 per cent of GDP on defence. Asked about a deadline, he told reporters: 'I have a clear view on when we should achieve that. 'I keep that to myself, because we are having these consultations now with allies, and these discussions are ongoing. 'We will in the end agree on a date when we have to be there.'