
Family of American killed on Malaysian Airlines flight can sue Russian bank, US court rules
NEW YORK, Feb 4 (Reuters) - The family of an American killed when a Malaysian Airlines plane was shot down over Ukraine in 2014 can sue Russia's largest bank for allegedly providing money transfers to a group blamed for downing the plane, a U.S. appeals court ruled on Tuesday.
In a 3-0 decision, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan said state-controlled Sberbank was not entitled to sovereign immunity, after being accused of using the U.S. banking system to funnel donor money to the Russia-backed separatist group Donetsk People's Republic.
A U.S.-based lawyer for Sberbank had no immediate comment. Sberbank was not immediately available for comment after business hours in Moscow.
The case was brought by the family of Quinn Schansman, who was 18 when he boarded Malaysian flight MH17 to Kuala Lumpur from Amsterdam on July 17, 2014, for a planned family vacation.
The flight was shot down over DPR-controlled territory in eastern Ukraine by a surface-to-air missile, killing all 298 people on board.
Russia has denied involvement. Ukraine had previously declared the DPR a terrorist organization, while the United States had imposed sanctions on the group.
Schansman's family sued Sberbank, another Russian bank and two U.S. money transfer companies in April 2019, saying they should be liable for doing business with the DPR.
A year later, Russia's Ministry of Finance bought a majority stake in Sberbank from the country's central bank.
In Tuesday's decision, Circuit Judge Joseph Bianco called Sberbank's alleged handling of money transfers "quintessentially commercial activity," triggering an exception to protections under the federal Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA).
Sberbank had argued it deserved a presumption of immunity as a state agency or instrumentality.
The bank also said another U.S. law, the Anti-Terrorism Act, provided immunity regardless of when it came under state control, with no exception for commercial activity.
Bianco disagreed. He said the FSIA comprehensively governed sovereign immunity in civil cases, and its framework was not "silently repealed" by the anti-terrorism law.
Adopting Sberbank's position, the judge wrote, would negate Congress' intent to give civil litigants the "broadest possible" legal basis to sue entities that materially support foreign entities that engage in terrorism against the United States.
Jenner & Block, a law firm representing the Schansman family, welcomed the court's rejection of what it called Russia's effort to immunize Sberbank by "strategically acquiring" a majority stake.
"We look forward to pursuing further evidence of Sberbank's wrongdoing in the district court and finally achieving justice for the Schansman family," the firm said.
The case is Schansman et al v Sberbank of Russia PJSC, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 22-3097.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Sky News
21 minutes ago
- Sky News
NATO chief to call for 400% increase in air and missile defence to maintain credible deterrent
NATO needs a 400% increase in air and missile defence to maintain a credible deterrence, its secretary general will say in a speech in London today. Mark Rutte will call for a "quantum leap" in collective security, warning threats facing the alliance "will not disappear even when the war in Ukraine ends". It comes ahead of a summit in The Hague later this month, when the UK and its NATO allies are expected to agree to a Donald Trump-inspired pledge to spend 5% of GDP on defence and related areas. 👉 Search for The Wargame on your podcast app 👈 Speaking at Chatham House, Mr Rutte will say the investment plan is "grounded in hard facts". He will add: " The fact is, we need a quantum leap in our collective defence. The fact is, we must have more forces and capabilities to implement our defence plans in full. The fact is, danger will not disappear even when the war in Ukraine ends". Mr Rutte will argue that to maintain credible deterrence and defence, NATO needs "a 400% increase in air and missile defence". "We see in Ukraine how Russia delivers terror from above, so we will strengthen the shield that protects our skies," he will say. "Our militaries also need thousands more armoured vehicles and tanks, millions more artillery shells, and we must double our enabling capabilities, such as logistics, supply, transportation, and medical support." On threats against the alliance, he will warn: "Wishful thinking will not keep us safe. We cannot dream away the danger. Hope is not a strategy. So NATO has to become a stronger, fairer and more lethal alliance." 5:09 Mr Rutte is also due to meet with Sir Keir Starmer and visit Sheffield Forgemasters with Defence Secretary John Healey today. The prime minister has committed to spend 2.5% of gross domestic product (GDP) on defence from April 2027, with a goal of increasing that to 3% over the next parliament. Although the government's language has been cloudy on the 3% figure, describing it as an ambition rather than a commitment, Sky News understands the UK will in fact agree to increase defence spending to 3.5% of national income within a decade as part of Mr Rutte's push to rearm NATO and keep the US on side. As reported by our Security and Defence editor Deborah Haynes, Sir Keir will also likely be forced to commit a further 1.5% of GDP to defence-related areas such as spy agencies and infrastructure. This would bolster total broader defence spending to 5%, in what is being described as the "Hague investment plan". 👉Listen to Politics at Sam and Anne's on your podcast app👈 NATO countries have faced pressure from US President Donald Trump, who has repeatedly hit out at European allies for not spending enough on defence and taking advantage of American taxpayers. However, Sir Keir is also facing pressure at home on where his priorities lie, with many of his own MPs wanting to see more funding on welfare. Chancellor Rachel Reeves will deliver her spending review on Wednesday, when health and defence are expected to be the winners in the process to allocate cash to government departments.


Daily Mirror
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Harrowing images of Los Angeles as city burns over Trump's migrant crackdown
Crowds have rampaged through the streets of LA following clashes with ICE immigration officials as Donald Trump called in the National Guard with cars burned in the streets and businesses looted Donald Trump has called for anyone wearing a mask to be arrested during violent clashes between protestors and federal law enforcement in Los Angeles. Shocking images showed crowds clashing with authorities and cars set ablaze as Trump sent in National Guard troops to try and restore order - a move California Governor Gavin Newsom blasted as 'illegal'. Meanwhile law enforcement officers have reportedly fired tear gas and rubber bullets at the crowds. 'Bring in the troops,' declared Trump, taking to his Truth Social platform to blast the scenes of violence on the streets of downtown LA. The violent clashes have rocked the American city with cars set alight and reports of looting after a crackdown by the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officers sparked protests. Shocking images showed police vehicles ablaze as rioters clashed with authorities, including 2,000 National Guard troops sent in by the White House. President Trump called for further crackdowns on protests overnight, urging LA police chief Jim McDonnell to bring troops into LA. Writing on Truth Social, Trump said: 'Looking really bad in L.A. BRING IN THE TROOPS!!!" In another post he added: "ARREST THE PEOPLE IN FACE MASKS, NOW!" Meanwhile tempers have flared after California's Governor, Democrat Gavin Newsom, accused President Trump's border czar Tom Homan of threatening to arrest him. 'Trump's border czar is threatening to arrest me for speaking out. Come and get me, tough guy. I don't give a damn,' Newsom vowed in a post on X. 'It won't stop me from standing up for California.' Governor Newsom blasted Trump for overstepping his boundaries by deploying National Guard troopers to the city, in a separate post, stating: 'local law enforcement didn't need help.' Newsom wrote: 'Let's get this straight: 1) Local law enforcement didn't need help. 2) Trump sent troops anyway — to manufacture chaos and violence. 3) Trump succeeded. 4) Now things are destabilized, and we need to send in more law enforcement just to clean up Trump's mess.' LAPD Central Division said businesses had reported looters rampaging through stores. Posting on X the force said: "Business owners are reporting stores are being looted in the area of 6th St and Broadway. Officers are en route to the location to investigate." Meanwhile on Sunday night the Los Angeles Police Department declared an 'unlawful assembly' in the downtown area as protesters continued to rampage through the streets. 'Agitators have splintered into and throughout the Downtown Area," the LAPD's Central Division wrote on X. "Residents, businesses and visitors to the Downtown Area should be alert and report any criminal activity. Officers are responding to several different locations to disperse crowds.' "An UNLAWFUL ASSEMBLY has been declared for the Downtown Los Angeles area," the department added. Police said a phone alert has been sent to people in the Civic Center area of the city demanding crowds disperse.


Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
NATO needs 400% increase in air and missile defence, Rutte will say in London
LONDON, June 9 (Reuters) - NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte will use a speech in London on Monday to say the military alliance needs a 400% increase in air and missile defence, one of the priorities for a summit of members in the Hague later this month. Rutte will argue in a speech at London's Chatham House think tank that for NATO to maintain credible deterrence and defence, it needs "a 400% increase in air and missile defence". "We see in Ukraine how Russia delivers terror from above, so we will strengthen the shield that protects our skies. Our militaries also need thousands more armoured vehicles and tanks, millions more artillery shells, and we must double our enabling capabilities, such as logistics, supply, transportation, and medical support," he will say, according to extracts of his speech provided by his office.