"AI Is already better than most doctors," says Elon Musk: How automation could spell trouble for medical professionals
Elon Musk
recently responded on X to a post highlighting a cancer survivor who used
OpenAI
's ChatGPT to advocate for herself, challenge her doctors' opinions, and ultimately make better-informed decisions about her treatment.
Musk stated, 'AI is already better than most doctors.
That's the honest truth. And it will become far better. Same for all jobs tbh, including mine.' Such a candid admission from one of the leading voices in technology underscores a profound challenge for the medical profession: Is AI signalling the gradual obsolescence of doctors as we know them?
At the same time, Demis Hassabis, CEO of Google DeepMind, offers a more nuanced perspective.
He acknowledges that AI may replace doctors in diagnostic tasks but argues that professions requiring empathy, creativity, and human connection, such as nursing, remain fundamentally human. Hassabis envisions a future where humans and AI collaborate, with AI managing data-intensive work while healthcare professionals focus on emotional intelligence and leadership.
The rise of AI as a medical authority
The healthcare sector has long been rooted in the expertise and judgment of human physicians.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
No annual fees for life
UnionBank Credit Card
Apply Now
Undo
However, the proliferation of AI-powered tools such as ChatGPT is altering this dynamic. OpenAI highlighted this shift through the story of a cancer survivor who leveraged ChatGPT to advocate for herself, challenge her doctors' opinions, and ultimately make better-informed decisions about her treatment. This real-life example points to a new reality: Patients increasingly use AI not only for information but as a critical tool to engage with, and sometimes question, their doctors.
This evolution is expected to ruffle feathers in medical circles. Physicians have traditionally been wary of patients who come in with self-diagnoses sourced from internet searches. The introduction of AI in this equation intensifies the situation. Patients armed with AI-generated data may express skepticism toward their doctors' judgment, raising the stakes in the doctor-patient relationship.
A doctor's perspective on the AI surge
Adding nuance to this unfolding narrative is TikTok user @drpark524, a practicing physician who shared a candid reflection on the mounting pressures brought about by AI.
He reveals that for the first time in his career, he feels the medical profession's future is under threat. His patients now arrive with highly granular, nuanced questions, inquiries that reflect detailed knowledge they have acquired from AI chatbots.
Dr. Park recounted a striking example. A patient recently asked him about the incidence rate of retinal detachment in the United States, a question typically outside the scope of usual consultations.
The patient already knew the precise statistic, confirming it was information sourced from AI. This put Dr. Park in a position where he felt 'in the hot seat,' his expertise tested on the spot.
He observed that patients are increasingly using AI to gauge a doctor's competence. For physicians who have not kept pace with rapid medical advancements or relied solely on traditional continuing medical education, this new scrutiny could be daunting.
Dr. Park emphasised that while a lack of knowledge does not equate to poor care, perceived expertise will increasingly influence patient trust.
The changing dynamics of trust and expertise in healthcare
Trust between doctors and patients has always been foundational to effective healthcare. Yet, as Dr. Park warns, this trust is at risk. With AI offering instant access to medical facts, patients may question the value of in-person consultations. This reality elevates patient expectations to new heights.
Patients now ask themselves what unique expertise or empathy a doctor can provide beyond the rapid answers available from their phones.
This shift introduces a career crossroads for doctors. Remaining relevant requires more than clinical skill. It demands digital fluency, the ability to critically assess AI-generated information, and the emotional intelligence to address patients' deeper concerns. The physician of tomorrow must be not only a healer but also an informed interpreter of AI insights.
Adapting to survive in a transformed healthcare world
Across industries, leading technology CEOs have also shared perspectives on AI's workforce impact. Elon Musk's frank statement underscores the disruptive potential AI holds for all professions, including medicine. His warning that AI will surpass human capability calls for urgent reflection within the medical community.
Conversely, Demis Hassabis offers a vision of collaboration rather than replacement.
He emphasises that while AI can take on diagnostic and data-driven tasks, human roles that require empathy, ethical judgment, and leadership will remain essential. This suggests a future where AI augments rather than supplants doctors, enhancing their capacity to provide patient-centred care.
The prognosis for the medical profession hinges on adaptability. AI is not a passing fad but a transformative tool reshaping healthcare delivery.
The future doctor's role will evolve from sole knowledge gatekeeper to a collaborative advisor who integrates AI's capabilities with human judgment and compassion.
Medical education must rise to the occasion, embedding AI literacy and data interpretation into curricula. Physicians who embrace technology as a partner will maintain their indispensability. Those who resist this evolution risk gradual obsolescence in an environment where instant, AI-driven answers become the norm.
Urgency for change
The intersection of AI and medicine is no longer speculative. Stories like the cancer survivor's use of ChatGPT, Elon Musk's forthright comments on X, and Dr. Park's frontline insights reveal a profession at a critical juncture. AI's ability to deliver accurate, comprehensive medical information instantaneously is redefining patient expectations and challenging doctors to elevate their expertise and empathy accordingly.
In 2025, the sustainability of the medical profession depends on embracing change, continuous learning, and integrating AI into patient care. The future will belong to those who can expertly navigate this new terrain, combining advanced technology with the irreplaceable human qualities that define medicine.
TOI Education is on WhatsApp now. Follow us
here.
Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
21 minutes ago
- Time of India
In a 1st among IITs, Kharagpur gets student well-being dean
KOLKATA: Arun Chakraborty, professor at Centre for Ocean, River, Atmosphere and Land Sciences at IIT-Kharagpur, Friday became the institute's first dean of student well-being. TOI had earlier reported that IIT-Kharagpur director Suman Chakraborty announced the appointment during the induction programme for the new BTech batch on July 26. The post was created to ensure students' mental health issues are not left unaddressed, especially after four student suicides on campus in seven months - the latest being fourth-year mechanical engineering student Ritam Mondal, who was found hanging in his hostel room on July 18. "This is possibly the first time in any IIT that a person of a dean's status has been assigned solely to look after students' overall well-being," said the director. "Our institute has a huge number of students, and it is necessary to have a designated dean of student well-being to give special emphasis to welfare activities." Chakraborty told TOI that while the role was challenging, it was essential. "We do not want any tragic incidents. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play this game for 1 minute and see why everyone is addicted. Every student can approach us at any time. Even the smallest issues will be addressed. I've told students I am available 24x7 - they should not panic; we are here like parents," he added. IIT-Kharagpur has 21 hostels housing 16,000 students. While there is a dean of student affairs, the director pointed out that "student affairs" and "student well-being" are distinct. The new dean will focus on identifying and addressing personal issues, while dean of student affairs will handle administrative matters like accommodation and discipline. Measures already in place at the college include the AI-driven mental wellness platform SETU, a restructured counselling centre, "campus mothers," student task forces, and stress management workshops.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
OpenAI's GPT-5 Met With Mixed Reviews, Confusion in First Day
(Bloomberg) -- For months, OpenAI Chief Executive Officer Sam Altman has been hyping up the capabilities of GPT-5, setting up the launch as a seminal moment for the company. But in the first 24 hours after its release, the new model was met with mixed reviews. In its announcement Thursday, OpenAI said GPT-5 was better at coding and reasoning through complex problems, and touted it as advanced enough to turn chatbot ChatGPT into a Ph.D.-level expert. Some with early access praised the model, with caveats. 'It's my new favorite model,' developer Simon Willison wrote in a blog post, calling it 'competent' and 'occasionally impressive.' He added: 'It's not a dramatic departure from what we've had before.' On various social media platforms, however, ChatGPT users expressed frustration that GPT-5 continued to make up information and trip over simple math and spelling questions. Noah Giansiracusa, an associate professor of mathematics at Bentley University, said he felt the launch was 'underwhelming.' While there were 'some improvements,' he said, 'they were much more marginal than I would've hoped.' At least some of the reaction may come down to confusion over what's happening under the hood. Unlike OpenAI's prior software, GPT-5 automatically switches between models of varying levels of sophistication depending on the query. This approach can help maximize the company's computing resources, but it also means users may not always be engaging with the most powerful version of OpenAI's technology. Asked to identify how many times the letter 'b' shows up in 'blueberry,' for example, GPT-5 initially said 'three' in one test. When told to 'think harder,' however, GPT-5 appeared to engage its more advanced reasoning model and came up with the correct answer. On Friday, Altman responded to some of the feedback and said there was an issue with the system. 'GPT-5 will seem smarter starting today,' he said. 'Yesterday, the autoswitcher broke and was out of commission for a chunk of the day, and the result was GPT-5 seemed way dumber.' The stakes are high for the rollout. OpenAI is vying to keep ahead of growing AI competition from rivals in the US and China. The company is also fighting to convince businesses and individual users to pay up for its premium services to help offset the enormous amount it's spending on talent, chips and data centers to support AI development. The San Francisco-based company kicked off the generative AI boom nearly three years ago with the release of ChatGPT, which was originally powered by an earlier model called GPT-3.5. Since then, the company has released a series of increasingly sophisticated systems, including multiple options that mimic the process of human reasoning. As AI systems advance, it's become harder to say definitively how various services stack up. As of midday Friday, GPT-5 had risen to the top of various categories on LMArena, a popular leaderboard for AI models based on user rankings. But a different benchmark, ARC-AGI-2, puts GPT-5 behind the latest version of Grok from Elon Musk's xAI. In the absence of more definitive assessments, the model wars sometimes come down to vibes. And with nearly 700 million people now using ChatGPT each week, some are bound to disagree over how the model feels. It also takes longer than a day to gauge the value of a new AI system in someone's personal and professional life. Ethan Mollick, a professor at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania who frequently experiments with AI models, marveled at GPT-5's ability to do research, come up with clever written responses and make programming simple, even for a novice. 'GPT-5 just does stuff, often extraordinary stuff, sometimes weird stuff, sometimes very AI stuff, on its own,' he wrote in a blog post. 'And that is what makes it so interesting.' On Reddit, however, the reactions were very different. During an 'Ask Me Anything' session Friday on the platform, Altman fielded pushback from users who were frustrated not to have more say and visibility into which model responds to their queries. Altman said OpenAI would take some steps to address these complaints, including making it 'more transparent.' At one point, Altman responded to a Reddit user's question by noting that OpenAI thinks the 'writing quality' in one version of GPT-5 is better than GPT-4.5. Then he asked: 'Do you find it to be worse?' One user after another were quick to respond: yes. More stories like this are available on
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Cyber commandos to spot and prevent AI-driven offences
1 2 Pune: As cybercriminals increasingly employ artificial intelligence (AI) for sophisticated attacks, the Union Ministry of Home Affairs has decided to train "cyber commandos" to effectively identify, intercept, and neutralise AI-driven cyber threats. Training for two batches of commandos, comprising law enforcement personnel, including officers from the Maharashtra Police, will soon commence at the Defence Institute of Advanced Technology (DIAT), a deemed university of the DRDO. Manisha Nene, the head of computer science department at DIAT, said, "As cybercrimes rapidly evolve due to integration of advanced AI tools in criminal activities, we have updated the syllabus for our training programme. We will train them on how to investigate these AI tools used in criminal cases." You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune The first batch of 30 cyber commandos completed the course at the institute in May. "The trained personnel, particularly from the Jammu and Kashmir Police, played a crucial role during Operation Sindoor, utilising their knowledge gained in the course. This feedback was communicated to us," added Nene. The six-month course will cover various aspects of combating a new breed of cybercrimes, including AI-generated deepfakes, automated phishing campaigns, identity spoofing, algorithmic attacks on critical infrastructure, and real-time manipulation of data streams. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 11 Foods That Help In Healing Knee Pain Naturally - Which to Eat (Most People Ignore) Undo According to the report titled, "The State of AI-Powered Cybercrime: Threat & Mitigation Report 2025," recently released by the Global Initiative for Restructuring Environment and Management (GIREM) in Bengaluru, AI tools are implicated in approximately 82.6% of all phishing emails. "AI is not only used to generate realistic email text but also to create convincing dashboards, register typo-squatting domains, and develop dynamic, interactive phishing pages, significantly enhancing the effectiveness of these cyber threats," stated the report. DIAT has involved eight of its professors and engaged DRDO scientists and other experts working in the field. "What is crucial for us is to bring a variety of perspectives and scenarios so that attendees can work on or investigate complex cases in real-time. We also simulate situations by working on specific cases during the class, providing them with exposure to real situations," the official added. Sanjay Shintre, deputy inspector general of the Maharashtra Cyber Cell, told TOI, "The use of AI tools is significant in several cyber cases, and it is often complicated to address these issues at the police station level. Therefore, the role of highly trained police personnel is crucial. These trained cyber commandos will become valuable assets for the force in tackling advanced cybercrimes." Shintre noted that very few personnel from the Maharashtra Police were able to pass the entrance examination for the course due to lack of theoretical knowledge. "There are many police officers and personnel who excel in investigating cybercrime cases, but their lack of theoretical knowledge prevents them from clearing the entrance tests. We are working to change this scenario," he added. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Raksha Bandhan wishes , messages and quotes !
