Health committee to hear CHI apology over practices
Chief Executive Lucy Nugent will apologise to the children and families impacted by recent revelations about CHI's culture, governance and practices, which she says have "led to great pain being inflicted upon some of those who were in our care".
Ms Nugent is in her current post five months, having started her career as a nurse in CHI Temple Street.
In recent months, members of the opposition have detailed what they called "unnecessary" hip surgeries from an unpublished report into practices at three CHI hospitals.
The review into Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip, or DDH, found that the majority of children who had pelvic osteotomy surgery at CHI Temple Street and the National Orthopaedic Hospital in Cappagh did not meet the threshold for surgery based on the criteria used for the audit.
Children who had surgery at Crumlin were found to have met the threshold.
Ms Nugent will tell the committee that the family of one child they identified who experienced complications due to surgery has been contacted and supported through an open disclosure process.
She will also say that all families have now been contacted about the next steps, and if their child was part of the audit.
Multidisciplinary team review clinics have begun seeing patients, with 60 seen so far.
CHI has said the aim of the review clinics is to assess complications only, and it hopes to have all children seen within six months.
Ms Nugent will say she does "not underestimate the stress and anxiety that families are rightfully feeling throughout this audit process."
"To one family in particular, whose child experienced complications during their care in Children's Health Ireland, I extend my heartfelt apology. I would like to give my assurance to all of the families affected, that they will be directly supported and are being contacted with follow up information and the next steps."
Separately, the HSE is currently developing an independent review into hip surgeries going back to 2010, to determine if harm has occurred for any child, as the original audit does not establish this.
Going forward, any child who is listed for hip surgery with CHI will have their case discussed at multidisciplinary team meetings.
On the recent report into culture and governance issues at CHI and the use of the National Treatment Purchase Fund, Ms Nugent will apologise for not being at liberty to publish the report, saying it is her legal duty not to do so, despite media reports.
Executives at CHI will also update the committee on progress in paediatric spinal surgery services.
At the start of June, 48 patients were waiting over four months for surgery, a decrease since the start of the year.
CHI will also say that 223 spinal procedures have been completed in the year to date, up on 196 such operations at the same point last year.
An additional Consultant Orthopaedic Spinal Surgeon is due to start in August, with recruitment under way for a further three consultant orthopaedic surgeons.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Mum of late Harvey Morrison signs petition calling on Simon Harris to resign
The mum of the late Harvey Morrison Sherratt - a nine-year-old boy who spent years awaiting scoliosis surgery before his death - has signed an online petition calling on former Health Minister Simon Harris to resign. The petition on calling for An Tanaiste Simon Harris' resignation has so far garnered nearly 10,000 signatures so far since it was launched on Tuesday. In a post on X, Gillian Sherratt stated: 'I've just signed this petition calling on Simon Harris to resign as a start to getting #JusticeForHarvey.' Tanaiste Simon Harris is facing calls to resign Ms Sherratt then encouraged her followers to 'please sign and share and show them we will no longer stand for our children being failed by the State.' The petition, which is addressed to Mr Harris entitled 'Simon Harris Resignation', explains how Harvey spent years waiting on scoliosis surgery before his death. Harvey died on July 29 after a short illness and years of pain during which he struggled to breath. Scoliosis patient Harvey Sherratt with his father Stephen Morrison Harvey, from Clondalkin, suffered from severe scoliosis but was forced to wait seven years for surgery. In 2017, while serving as Minister for Health, Mr Harris pledged that no child in Ireland would wait more than four months for scoliosis treatment. Last August, Harvey's mother, Gillian Sherratt, learned that her son had been removed from Children's Health Ireland's active scoliosis surgery waiting list — without the family's knowledge. Harvey eventually underwent surgery in December 2024, but by then the severe progression of his spinal curve meant it could no longer be fully corrected. At the end of July, Harvey's heartbroken parents Gillian and Stephen announced Harvey's death saying 'our little rockstar Harvey passed away in the arms of mum and dad.' 'In his short life Harvey faced more challenges than most, and was the bravest, strongest and most courageous boy. To know him was to love him, and he definitely left his mark on this world.' Both Gillian and Stephen have been calling for the resignation of Mr Harris since Harvey's death. The petition continues: 'Our health service is failing. We also need investment in hospital services and decent pay for those working within them, this includes nurses (who are the foots soldiers of the HSE and we should do all we can to retain the Irish talent and not export it, as it stands nurses can't afford to pay rent, food and travel to and from work on what they are paid, we should give them a salary that would ensure they want to stay, work and live here in Ireland). 'Simon Harris needs to go. He has no interest in any of the above. If he won't listen he should go and not get a pension for all of his failures.," the petition continues. The petition gives eight reasons as to why Mr Harris should resign including the hospital trolley crisis, near one million people on waiting lists to see consultants; cervical smear scandals; Children's Hospital overspend and Fine Gael increasing VAT on health supplements will only make more people ill.' In February 2024, a heartbreaking video of Harvey struggling to breathe due to the curve on his spine was widely shared on social media. And his case was highlighted in the Dail as hundreds of children remain on HSE waiting lists for vital scoliosis surgery. Harvey's parents also highlighted on X that 'On September 18 Simon Harris promised to meet with myself and Stephen to discuss Harvey's lack of care. 10 months on and that meeting never happened and now Harvey is gone. Harvey's father Stephen Morrison wrote: 'For years I have been saying what will it take for an investigation into [Children's Health Ireland] 'The death of another child.' Never in a million years did I think it would be Harvey.' 'Harvey was definitely unique,' his father added. 'But what isn't unique is the way he and other children and people with disabilities are being failed. It is up to us to stop it.' An Tanaiste Simon Harris's Department of Foreign Affairs has been asked for a comment. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
RTÉ News
8 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Tóibín calls for Harris to resign over handling of boy's scoliosis case
Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín has called for Tánaiste Simon Harris to resign over the handling of the case of Harvey Morrison Sherratt. Nine-year-old Harvey, from Clondalkin in Dublin, died on 29 July and had spina bifida and scoliosis. He had been subject to delays in accessing urgent scoliosis surgery. Harvey's mother said last week that they did not currently have a cause of death. Last year, Harvey's parents Gillian Sherratt and Stephen Morrison, said that Harvey had been removed from a Children's Health Ireland (CHI) waiting list for urgent scoliosis surgery without their consent or knowledge. Harvey received spinal surgery in November last year after being first placed on the waiting list in February 2022. Mr Tóibín wrote to the Cathaoirleach of the Oireachtas Committee on Health, calling for it to be reconvened immediately and for Mr Harris to appear before it. Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Mr Tóibín said Mr Harris failed to keep a promised he made as minister for health in 2017 that no child would be waiting for longer than four months for scoliosis surgery. "It's a disaster for any parent to lose their child but the circumstances surrounding Harvey's death are particularly heartbreaking given all he had to endure in his short life. "It's very important in this country that we have some level of accountability and responsibility as well. "When Simon Harris was minister for health, he promised in 2017 that no child would be left waiting for longer than four months for scoliosis surgery - that's a promise he failed to keep. "In his own words, he says 'we don't need ministers to defend the indefensible', he said the waiting lists were indefensible. "And yet we have a situation where Harvey had to spend 33 months on a scoliosis waiting list before he got his surgery. "He was promised surgery back in 2022, he was meant to have it '23, it was cancelled abruptly and then a year ago Harvey's family found out that he was actually removed from the Children's Health Ireland waiting list without their knowledge." A spokesperson for Mr Harris said that when Harvey's case was raised first with the Tánaiste, his office immediately contacted the Department of Health and the HSE and asked for immediate clinical attention. "The Tánaiste expresses his deepest condolences to the family, as he did when he was asked about this matter on Monday," the spokesperson said. "When this issue was brought to his attention during his time as Taoiseach, his overriding focus was making sure that the proper clinical interventions and consultations were made available. "He was informed an additional clinical assessment did then take place and surgery was subsequently scheduled." He added that Mr Harris expects and "has been assured" that the Department of Health, the HSE and CHI will be available to support and engage with the family.
Irish Daily Mirror
11 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Mum fears for five-year-old facing year-long MRI wait for scoliosis
A worried mum, whose five-year-old daughter who has recently been diagnosed with scoliosis, has been told they may have to wait eight months to a year just to get an MRI scan. Carolann Walsh from Kilkenny - who as a teenager fought her own battle with the health service after her planned spinal fusion surgery was cancelled in 2009 due to ward closures - now says she is 'fighting the exact same fight' - this time for her own daughter, Hannah.. Her daughter Hannah was recently diagnosed with scoliosis, a condition where the spine curves abnormally. In Hannah's case, Carolann says the pressure on her spine is causing relentless headaches, sometimes escalating into migraines. 'Yet we have been told it will be nine to twelve months before she can have the MRI scan needed to guide her treatment,' Carolann told Irish Mirror. At the time Carolann's planned surgery was cancelled back in 2009 she couldn't even get an X-ray. 'It took media attention and a huge public outcry before I finally got my surgery date,' Carolann recalls. That was September 2009 — and it changed my life. " But now, 16 years later, I'm fighting the exact same fight — this time for my own child.' 'I am terrified for her future,' says Carolann. 'I've lived this. I know what untreated scoliosis can do. I've already got one child with generalised epilepsy, another with sensory issues — and now my middle child is facing what I went through. How can it be that nothing has changed after all these years?' Carolann is calling for urgent action to address the growing backlog of children waiting for spinal assessments and treatment. 'No child should have to wait in pain. No parent should have to beg the system for care. If the health service could find a way in 2009, it can find a way now.' Children's Health Ireland said in a statement to this paper: 'I cannot comment on individual cases. Every child's care plan is different. An MRI may be postponed to allow for a growth spurt or other clinical factors - these are clinical decisions. There is no waiting list for an urgent MRI for scoliosis treatment.' However, Carolann argues there 'absolutely is' a waiting list. 'My five-year-old experiences headaches every single night, and sometimes they escalate into migraines, caused by her spine putting pressure in the wrong place. 'I went through the same thing as a child and needed an MRI at just four years old. In this case, an MRI is indeed essential. 'When I rang Waterford hospital it stated her GP referred her for an MRI and I asked where she was on the waiting list - I was told there was a waiting list from 8 months to a year, and that was the fastest list available to her I was told.' Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
