Sturgeon memoir: tribute to Charles Kennedy 'not genuine'
The former First Minister's memoir Frankly, included a tribute to the Liberal Dems' former leader who died in 2015, less than a month after losing his Westminster seat in a bitterly contested election battle.
Kennedy died of an alcohol-related hemorrhage less than one after losing Ross, Skye and Lochaber to the SNP's Ian Blackford.
The convenor of the SNP's Ross, Skye, and Lochaber branch, Brian Smith, later resigned from his post, after he described Kennedy as a 'quisling' and 'drunken slob' during the 2015 election campaign.
Craig Harrow, who served as Convenor of the Scottish Liberal Democrats until 2015 told The Herald he was 'disappointed' that Ms Sturgeon 'did not take the opportunity of her apparently candid memoir to make a genuine heartfelt apology for this disgraceful behaviour' towards his friend Charles Kennedy.
READ MORE:
In the memoir Sturgeon talks about becoming personally close to Kennedy during a 1996 Commonwealth Parliamentary Association trip to Australia.
While in Melbourne, writes Sturgeon, the pair went to see Trainspotting in cinema as 'the only two Scots in the entire cinema, laughing uproariously at jokes that no one else understood.'
The book goes on to discuss Kennedy's election defeat by Ian Blackford: "In the SNP's landslide of 2015, Charlie lost his Westminster seat to lan Blackford, who, a couple of years later, would become our Westminster leader. Obviously I was thrilled by my party's success and by my friend lan's election. But I wish we could have achieved it without the loss of Charlie's presence in Parliament.
"His death, less than a month later, was a tragedy. It genuinely pains me to think that our election triumph, however unintentionally and inadvertently, might have hastened his demise. He was, without doubt, one of the most charismatic and naturally talented individuals ever to grace Scottish politics. Those few days I got to spend with him in Australia were a privilege."
Copies of Nicola Sturgeon's memoir on sale in Glasgow three days before release (Image: Newsquest)
In response to Sturgeon's comments, Craig Harrow told The Herald: 'There is no doubt of Charles Kennedy's charisma, talent and kindliness which contrasts with the current crop of politicians who could never fill his shoes.
'A thoroughly decent man who was popular and loved in equal measure.
'I recall the former First Minister's gracious eulogy at Glasgow University which rightly highlighted Charles' place in our nation's politics.
'But the indefensible bullying and hounding of Charles Kennedy in the 2015 campaign by Sturgeon's party was truly appalling and unacceptable in our public life and not a part of highland politics.
'It is disappointing that Ms Sturgeon did not take the opportunity of her apparently candid memoir to make a genuine heartfelt apology for this disgraceful behaviour which hurt Charles deeply in his last months.
'Recapturing Charles' former seat by the Liberal Democrat's at last year's election from Ms Sturgeon's party was a fitting tribute to him and his amazing legacy.'
Leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats, Alex Cole-Hamilton said: 'Charles was indeed an extremely gifted individual, and he is hugely missed by everyone in my party.
'He met the world and its challenges with an incomparable grace, charm and intellect; it was an approach that many of those in our politics today would do well to learn from.
'That's why it was nothing short of poetry when we returned Charles' old seat back to the Liberal Democrats when Angus MacDonald was elected last year.
'As we look ahead to the next election, we want to keep building on Charles' legacy, showing people all across the Highlands that we can deliver for them on the issues that matter to them."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
30 minutes ago
- The National
Scottish farm fumes as council gives milk contract to German dairy giant
Mossgiel Organic Dairy teamed up with the local authority back in 2021 to provide every school in the area with its organic milk. The farm in Mauchline, where Robert Burns once ploughed the fields and wrote many of his famous verses, aims to provide sustainable, organic milk while challenging the dominance of the bigger dairy companies and their negative impact on the industry. READ MORE: Scottish 85-year-old pens scathing letter to Keir Starmer over immigration rules The farm has won multiple awards and is known for providing a high quality product whilst also being environmentally friendly. For example, it was the first dairy farm in the UK to ditch single-use plastics But, The National can now confirm that the council has decided to award the contract to Müller – a German multinational firm which is considered the largest dairy brand in the UK. Mossgiel took to social media to hit out at the move. In a statement, they claimed: 'On paper, the council saves £6500 a year. In reality, here's the rest of the bill: "Recycling costs: Single-use milk packaging could add £2000–£5000 a year to waste bills, even if they pour from bigger supermarket jugs instead of little cartons. "Jobs lost: Two full-time equivalent local roles gone; £50–55k removed from Ayrshire's economy, plus around £5k less in National Insurance contributions for public services. "Local milk value: £61,000 less per year for our farm and the co-op of organic family farms we work with." They then added: 'Best case? They save a couple of grand up front, but lose around £111,000 from the East Ayrshire economy. Worst case? No saving at all plus the loss of jobs, farm income and the circular economy on top. 'Either way, that's over £100,000 stripped out of our community every year, diesel fumes back in playgrounds, and a prayer that milk cartons actually make it into recycling instead of landfill. Oh, and profits? Straight to a German-owned company. We respect the council's decision but we don't agree with it.' In a statement to The National, East Ayrshire Council confirmed that Mossgiel Milk's bid to keep the contract was unsuccessful and that Müller will replace them. 'The Council remains committed to providing healthy nutritious school meals, and has for the past 20 years, issued fresh and organic food contracts. The contracts are designed to provide a range of produce that meets higher welfare, and health and nutritional value. The successful tenderers have committed to maintain these standards,' the council said. 'The council also has strong links through the Ayrshire Economic Forum that engages with the wider local market to promote opportunity; and there is also direct support from the council's business support team and the Supplier Development Programme, which delivers grant support and expertise to businesses exploring public sector procurement opportunities.'
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Glasgow university building taped off due to 'incident'
In an internal email, students were told that the closure was due to 'an incident yesterday regarding a window at the front of the Govan Mbeki Building'. A member of security staff told our reporter that a 'fault' with one of the building's windows meant the entrance would be closed 'for the foreseeable'. Caution tape covered much of the building's front facade. (Image: Josh Pizzuto-Pomaco) Affected individuals will be able to access classrooms inside the building via the adjacent George Moore Building, and have been asked to approach their programme leaders with any questions. The email reads: 'The main and rear entrances to the Govan Mbeki Building have been closed as a precautionary measure. 'Protective coverings will be put in place at other entrance/exit points in the coming days All fire exits will remain open. 'The accessible entrance from the George Moore Building is by the lift lobby linking to the Deeprose Lecture Theatre.' Students were also told not to open any windows inside the building. A sign posted to the front door of the building read: 'Due to essential maintenance, this entrance is closed.' Read more: World's largest archive of street newspapers gifted to Scottish university Students urged to boycott cybersecurity tech over Israel link 'I left school with nothing but college has changed my life' The Govan Mbeki Building was named after South African politician and anti-apartheid activist Govan Mbeki, a close ally of Nelson Mandela who was imprisoned with him at Robben Island. Mandela had suggested the building be renamed after his comrade upon receiving an honorary degree from the university in June 1996 at Buckingham Palace. The building was officially opened by Mbeki's son, President Thabo Mbeki, at a special ceremony in June 2001. A Glasgow Caledonian University spokesperson said: 'On Wednesday afternoon our staff identified an issue with a single window in our Govan Mbeki Building which had become separated from its frame. The window was reinstated and secured shortly thereafter. "As a precaution a full assessment is now being undertaken of all similar windows. Two entrances to the building have been temporarily closed and a range of actions are being undertaken to ensure the health, safety and wellbeing of all the students and staff who use the building. "We will of course be providing further updates to our staff and students in due course.'
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
Robin McAlpine: Why I won't be reading Nicola Sturgeon's book
Not because I couldn't be fair-minded but because I wasn't sure everyone would think me fair-minded on the topic. But really, that wasn't my main reason for saying no. Much more to the point, I simply do not like political autobiographies and think it is an actively unhelpful genre. I do not read them and I'm not about to start. So, they asked me to explain why. The 'rapid memoir' is now a fundamental part of politics. A successful leader will get a book deal shortly after leaving office. Tony Blair, Gordon Brown, David Cameron, Boris Johnson, Liz Truss – they've all had a shot (Alex Salmond and Theresa May did something slightly different). Nicola Sturgeon at the launch of her memoir, Frankly (Image: PA) As someone who towered over Scottish politics for nearly a decade, there is no question Sturgeon has earned her book. But honestly, I wish none of them had bothered. I can't think of a single useful thing we learned from any of them. There is a simple reason for this. All long-form writing involves an author 'selling you' a story. They want you to believe in their thesis (non-fiction, biography), to buy into their plot (fiction) or to find their lives interesting (autobiography). In every case, the story serves the reader. Only in the political autobiography does the story exist to serve the author. A retired footballer doesn't relive all his key games trying to persuade you the referee robbed him or it was an unfortunate gust of wind and actually he was a better footballer than you thought he was. That's what political autobiographies do. READ MORE: BBC Scotland slammed over 'farcical' Debate Night impartiality ruling There are other problems. Politics is basically self-chronicling as you go along. Politicians tell you what they want you to think in real time. By the time Blair was writing his autobiography, we'd heard his justifications for the Iraq War so many times you wondered why he bothered writing them down again. A biography reveals things the subject doesn't want revealed so those can be useful. If you kept diaries, then they can be worth publishing as a contemporary record. Further down the line, the memoir, which is really a historical reflection, can be interesting and enlightening – if the politician is far enough past the events to no longer be trying to spin them. That's the fundamental problem for me. I was a spin doctor when they were still called spin doctors (pager and everything). I've seen so much narrative manipulation and distraction in my time that I am largely immune. I mean, I've been responsible for some of it and I didn't believe that either. Rapid political autobiographies are, without fail, manipulative and a distraction. They are always obsessed with litigating the legacy of the politician concerned. So, if you have a passionate interest in the minutiae of what happened 10 years ago then knock yourself out. I'm much more concerned with today. Across the Western world, there is a crisis in democracy and the public is losing faith in the system. From Gaza to poverty to climate change to AI, democracy seems incapable of stepping up to the challenges of our era. Abusive oligarchy is replacing the social contract. In Scotland, we're stuck in a constitutional impasse. Worse, there doesn't seem to be a single political party in Scotland capable of generating a convincing (never mind inspiring) new generation of leaders. At the moment, the future doesn't look great. All of this is happening right now and so, for me, looking in the rear-view mirror is an indulgence. Let me therefore offer you the two big pieces of advice I give anyone who cares about politics and cares about the future. READ MORE: Kate Forbes not barred from Summerhall, venue confirms First, ignore what they say and focus on the facts. All that matters is what is done, why it is done, how it is done and what happens as a result. Adjectives don't change facts. Second, just like with a magic trick, ignore the manipulation and distraction. Politics is often a game of distraction, but inside that distraction is the thing that counts, the purpose, the important thing. Stay focused on that and never look where the politician is guiding you to look. With Sturgeon, the facts you choose to look at will define your opinion. If it is electoral success, she was pretty impressive; if it is what was done with the power that resulted, she really wasn't. I am a 'power for a purpose' kind of person and for that reason I have long viewed the Sturgeon era as a criminally wasted opportunity. You may feel differently. Either way, anecdotes about tattoos and panic attacks change nothing at all.
