Can Trump revoke Musk and Mamdani of their US citizenship?
While Mamdani has been accused by conservative lawmakers of harbouring extremist sympathies, Musk has drawn Trump's ire over his criticism of the newly passed 'Big Beautiful Bill,' which curbs electric vehicle tax credits that largely benefit Musk's businesses, among other changes such as tax cuts.
But can the US government actually strip Musk and Mamdani of their citizenship?
Zohran Mamdani, 33, was born in Kampala, Uganda, to Indian-origin parents. He moved to New York at the age of seven.
At a news conference this week, Trump said if Mamdani 'prevents ICE from doing its job, then we'll have to arrest him.' He further added, 'We don't need a communist in this country, but if we have one, I'm going to be watching over him very carefully on behalf of the nation.'
Mamdani, who became a naturalised citizen in 2018, responded by saying, 'The President of the United States just threatened to have me arrested, stripped of my citizenship, put in a detention camp and deported—not because I have broken any law but because I will refuse to let ICE terrorise our city.'
My statement on Donald Trump's threat to deport me and his praise for Eric Adams, who the President 'helped out' of legal accountability. https://t.co/m7pNcT2DFS pic.twitter.com/UcYakMx4lI
— Zohran Kwame Mamdani (@ZohranKMamdani) July 1, 2025
On June 26, Republican Representative Andy Ogles wrote to Attorney General Pam Bondi requesting a Department of Justice probe into Mamdani's naturalisation, citing allegations of support for individuals linked to terrorism.
In a public post, Ogles referred to Mamdani as a 'communist who will destroy the great City of New York' and claimed he had shown 'material support for terrorism.' He cited a rap lyric by Mamdani referencing the 'Holy Land Five,' a group convicted in 2008 for providing support to Hamas. Mamdani had rapped: 'Free the Holy Land Five / My guys.'
Zohran 'little muhammad' Mamdani is an antisemitic, socialist, communist who will destroy the great City of New York. He needs to be DEPORTED. Which is why I am calling for him to be subject to denaturalization proceedings.
Attached is my letter to @AGPamBondi. pic.twitter.com/RWCZm67VOr
— Rep. Andy Ogles (@RepOgles) June 26, 2025
However, even if Mamdani is denaturalised, he wouldn't automatically be deported. He would revert to his previous status as a lawful permanent resident—a green card holder.
Once a close ally and major donor to his re-election campaign, Musk has now found himself at odds with the Trump administration over fiscal policy. The newly passed spending bill slashes EV tax credits, threatening the profitability of Tesla vehicles in the US.
Trump, in a Truth Social post, wrote: 'Without subsidies, Elon would probably have to close up shop and head back home to South Africa.' He later told reporters: 'We'll have to take a look. We might have to put DOGE on Elon,' referring to the Department of Government Efficiency once led by Musk.
Musk, born in 1971 in Pretoria, South Africa, also holds Canadian citizenship through his mother. He moved to Canada at 17, and later to the US in 1992 to study at the University of Pennsylvania. Musk became a US citizen in 2002.
Although Musk was reported to have started working in the US without proper authorisation, he has denied any violations. 'I was in fact allowed to work in the US,' Musk posted on X. 'I was on a J-1 visa that transitioned to an H-1B.'
Yes—but only on specific legal grounds.
Naturalised citizens can be denaturalised if they obtained citizenship through fraud, willful misrepresentation, or concealment of a material fact. Other rare cases include involvement in terrorism, war crimes, or joining a foreign military/government.
On June 11, the Justice Department issued a memo prioritising denaturalisation for individuals who illegally obtained citizenship. The department also cited cases of concealment of serious criminal activity during the naturalisation process.
For example, in June, the Justice Department denaturalised Elliott Duke, a UK-born former US soldier convicted of child sex abuse crimes. He was found to have concealed his offences during his 2013 citizenship application.
Legal experts say it's extremely unlikely. Michael Kagan, a professor of law at the University of Nevada, told Time: 'Denaturalisation is limited to cases where the government can prove material fraud in their original applications. It is rare and unlikely for either Musk or Mamdani. This appears to be irresponsible rhetoric designed to intimidate political opponents.'
As per a report by Time, currently, denaturalisation is legally permitted only in very limited cases:
The Immigrant Legal Resource Center (ILRC) explains that the federal government must prove fraud by 'clear, convincing, and unequivocal evidence' in civil court—or 'beyond a reasonable doubt' in criminal cases, Time reported.
'Many of the cases for denaturalisation based on lack of good moral character involve individuals who committed crimes prior to naturalisation, but were not arrested or charged until afterward,' the ILRC noted.
Denaturalisation has historically been rare in the US and often linked to proven fraud or serious crimes like war crimes or terrorism. According to the Department of Justice, the process involves either 'illegally procured' naturalisation or naturalisation gained through 'concealment of a material fact or by willful misrepresentation.'
Famous denaturalisation cases include: Emma Goldman, an anarchist activist deported in 1919 for opposing World War I and military conscription. Another was of Paul Knauer, a naturalised German American denaturalised in 1946 for concealing his ties to a Nazi-linked organisation.
An Al Jazeera report also pointed out that denaturalisation cases surged during the 'Red Scare' and World War II era, but declined significantly after a landmark 1967 Supreme Court ruling in Afroyim v. Rusk, which limited the government's ability to revoke citizenship without clear legal grounds.
And, as the Sovereign Citizen and Supreme Court precedent make clear, 'being a 'loyal American'' is no longer a legal requirement for citizenship.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
13 minutes ago
- Mint
GST rate cut hopes drive nearly ₹1 lakh crore rally in Nifty auto stocks
Maruti Suzuki, Hyundai Motor, TVS Motor Company, and other auto stocks saw a massive rally in Monday's session after the government announced plans for sweeping changes to the goods and services tax (GST) regime. Analysts believe the reforms could revive demand in the auto sector, which has remained muted in recent quarters. Fourteen out of the 15 constituents of the Nifty Auto index closed with sharp gains, led by Maruti Suzuki, which surged 8.8% to ₹ 14,068 apiece, its biggest intraday jump in the last five years. Other major gainers included Ashok Leyland, TVS Motor Company, Hero MotoCorp, MRF, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Eicher Motors, all rising between 2.6% and 8%. The rally boosted the combined market capitalization of the 14 auto stocks by nearly ₹ 1 lakh crore, taking the sector's total m-cap to ₹ 22.56 lakh crore. In his Independence Day address, Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced significant GST reforms, the most comprehensive since the rollout in 2017, announcing the ushering in of a two-tier GST structure—a reform billed as the 'next generation of GST,' expected to take shape by Diwali, as per sources. The current GST tax structure has four main categories of rates, at 5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%. The proposed changes will see the number of categories reduced to two, with most goods that were taxed at 12% and 28% now taxed at the lower rate of 5% and 18%, respectively. Even though changes to the GST had been discussed for years, the timing of the announcement in Modi's Independence Day speech was a surprise to many. The move comes against the backdrop of President Donald Trump's threat to double tariffs on Indian exports to the US to 50% by August 27 to penalize the country for buying oil from Russia. Automobiles, currently under the 28% slab, would move to 18% if the proposal is approved, which analysts believe could lead to price cuts and potentially revive sales. Auto manufacturers have been struggling in recent quarters amid weak urban demand, with many shifting focus to exports to sustain growth. Hero MotoCorp and Bajaj Auto both reported muted sales growth in the June quarter, while Maruti Suzuki and Hyundai Motor also posted flat passenger vehicle sales. If implemented, the GST cut would offer much-needed relief for the Indian automobile sector. 'Autos fall under the 28% GST bracket. If autos move to 18% and we see sharp price drops, this could drive the next auto upcycle, similar to 2008,' said Morgan Stanley. 'Currently, GST on passenger vehicles ranges from 29% to 50%, as a cess is imposed on top of GST based on the vehicle's size and engine capacity. In the new regime, the government may reduce the tax on smaller cars to 18% (from 28%) and move bigger cars to a 'special rate' of 40% while scrapping the cess. This could lower prices of smaller cars by around 8% and larger cars by 3–5%,' HSBC noted. GST reduction would negatively impact government revenues in the near term but drive-up Auto demand and hence job creation in India. PVs generate USD14-15 billion in GST collection, and 2Ws USD 5 billion, said the brokerage. Domestic brokerage Motilal Oswal added that passenger vehicles and commercial vehicles, currently taxed at 28%, will benefit most from the cut. Maruti Suzuki, Tata Motors, and Ashok Leyland are well positioned to gain from lower effective prices and higher volumes. Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations made above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, and not of Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Hindustan Times
14 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
'Ended 6 wars in 6 months': Trump's big claim as he calls for destruction of Hamas
US President Donald Trump has made a big claim ahead of his meeting with Ukrainian president Zelensky. Taking to Truth Social on Monday, Trump claimed he was the one who ended 'six wars in six months". Trump's remarks come after he claimed that the destruction of Hamas was the only way to get the remaining Gaza hostages back home in the same post.(AFP) Trump's remarks come after he claimed that the destruction of Hamas was the only way to get the remaining Gaza hostages back home in the same post. 'We will only see the returnof the remaining hostages when Hamas is confronted and destroyed!!!" wrote Trump. 'The sooner this takes place, the better the chances of success will be. Remember, I was the one who negotiated and got hundreds of hostages freed and released into Israel (and America!). I was the one who ended 6 wars, in just 6 months." Trump added. "I was the one who OBLITERATED Iran's Nuclear facilities. Play to WIN, or don't play at all! Thank you for your attention to this matter!' POTUS added further.
The Hindu
15 minutes ago
- The Hindu
50% tariffs on Indian exports to the U.S. will reduce demand 'very substantially': Moody's Analytics
The combined 50% tariff on Indian exports to the U.S. will reduce demand for Indian goods 'very substantially', Moody's Analytics said in a report. The report was talking about the combined effect of the ongoing 25% tariff on Indian imports imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump, as well as the secondary tariff of 25% he imposed for India's economic dealings with Russia, which are set to come into force on August 27. 'India has experienced a sudden deterioration in its relations with the U.S. and has been threatened with 50% tariffs, a rate that will reduce demand for Indian goods very substantially,' the report said. It added that the tariffs imposed by the U.S. have left countries across Europe and the Asia-Pacific region 'feeling bruised' since the U.S. is the largest trading partner for most of them, and a decline in sales to their largest customer 'will hurt'. 'Some firms in these countries may be willing to slash prices to maintain volumes, but this will affect firm performance through lower margins, a squeeze on wages and investment,' Moody's Analytics added. 'Given that we now expect tariffs to remain in place for the remainder of Trump's presidency, the drag on growth, particularly on investments and exports, will be notable,' it said.
