Former rights council member: Moushira Khattab's resignation is ‘belated attempt' to sidestep poor performance
Former council member Nasser Amin, however, described the move to Mada Masr as a belated attempt by Khattab to 'wash her hands' of what he said was the council's worst performance in two decades.
The council was reconstituted by presidential decree in 2021, as the government worked to stage a shift in how it handles rights and political representation, launching a national human rights strategy, reopening the council, which is tasked with nominating prisoners to the president for amnesty among other roles, and beginning the National Dialogue as a forum for political dialogue.
In a phone call with Mada Masr, Khattab declined to comment on the statement or name the international institution she intends to join.
A source close to the former council head, however, denied to Mada Masr that her resignation had nothing to do with Khattab's future career plans. Since Khattab has already had a long career, an international appointment is unlikely, the source continued.
They described her resignation instead as a long overdue development, adding that through her four-year tenure on the council Khattab has repeatedly voiced frustration over her inability to effect meaningful change in any of its human rights working files.
The source cited Khattab's repeated but unsuccessful attempts to amend the law that governs the council in order to elevate its international ranking, as well as several requests she made to visit prisons which were ultimately rejected. Prison visits are permitted rarely, and often only to limited areas of specific facilities under authorities' supervision.
The source put the lack of achievements down to the council's political position, describing it as lacking any real leverage. Its recommendations are often ignored, they added.
Khattab was also increasingly troubled by the frequent criticism directed at her from various circles, the source said.
Amin, who also heads the Arab Center for the Independence of Judiciary and Legal Professions, warned that the council is very likely to face a downgrade in its international ranking by the end of the year, citing its lack of independence and retreat from its monitoring and advocacy role. 'The talk of her seeking an international post is more wishful thinking than reality,' he said.
On November 20 last year, the Sub-Committee on Accreditation (SCA) at the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions (GANHRI) recommended the council be downgraded to B status, raising serious concerns about its compliance with the Paris Principles — particularly in terms of its independence, effectiveness and transparency.
The SCA flagged the lack of transparency and public participation in the appointment of council members — who are selected by the executive arm of the government — as a factor undermining the body's autonomy and ability to operate free from government interference. It also criticized the council's inadequate response to major human rights concerns, including torture, enforced disappearances, conditions of arbitrary detention, as well as with regard to freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association.
The committee also called for sweeping reforms to bring the council in line with the Paris Principles, including measures to reinforce its independence, amend its appointment mechanism, improve its response to human rights violations and ensure regular distribution of public reports for civil society and other actors to access.
Khattab has previously pushed back against claims that the council lacks independence. In a televised interview in September 2024, she said the council had submitted a request for a presidential pardon for writer and activist Alaa Abd El Fattah, but claimed that the council had been drawn into the issue of its pending downgrade by a complaint questioning the council's independence filed by the writer's father-in-law, prominent human rights advocate Bahey Eddin Hassan.
Domestic and international calls are currently mounting for President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi to pardon the detained activist and writer — whose mother is now hospitalized in critical condition 246 days into a hunger strike.
Khattab had confined her efforts as council head to 'safe zones,' Amin said. She focused on awareness-raising and human rights education while steering clear of applying legal and human rights standards to document violations. Instead, he added, she echoed the narrative advanced by the state and its security agencies.
The constitution grants the NCHR the power to represent victims in court — a power exercised by previous iterations of the council, including in the case of activist Shaimaa al-Sabbagh's killing. The current council, however, has ignored this mandate, which Amin said was a hard-earned achievement of earlier efforts.
Vice President Mahmoud Karem assumed Khattab's responsibilities as of Saturday, the council's statement said, and he will continue in the role until its term ends on December 27.
Sisi reconstituted the council under Khattab's leadership in December 2021 for a four-year term. Under recent amendments to the law governing the NCHR, the House of Representatives is permitted to begin forming a new council two months ahead of the current term's expiration. Nominations are to be submitted by universities, syndicates and other institutions, after which the president and members are selected and approved via presidential decree.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al-Ahram Weekly
8 hours ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
National Council for Human Rights and CAPMAS sign cooperation protocol
The National Council for Human Rights (NCHR) and the Central Agency for Public Mobilisation and Statistics (CAPMAS) signed a cooperation protocol on Sunday at the CAPMAS headquarters to promote the use of accurate data and analytical methodologies to monitor and evaluate human rights issues. The move aligns with Egypt's Vision 2030 for sustainable development and the National Human Rights Strategy (2021–2026), which is rooted in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and relevant international treaties and conventions. The protocol was signed by Ambassador Dr. Mahmoud Karem, President of the NCHR, and Major General Khairat Barakat, President of CAPMAS, in the presence of senior officials from both institutions. In his remarks, Ambassador Karem emphasised that the protocol represents a critical step toward enhancing the human rights landscape in Egypt through institutional partnership based on the use of precise statistical data in assessing and analysing the situation of human rights, particularly for vulnerable and at-risk groups. He noted that the agreement crowns years of constructive coordination and collaboration between the two institutions and will help integrate human rights considerations into public policies and development plans. For his part, President of CAPMAS Major General Khairat Barakat highlighted CAPMAS's central role as the governmental body responsible for providing accurate and reliable statistics on social, economic, and environmental conditions. He stressed the agency's commitment to working with various government entities to serve the needs of decision-makers, policymakers, civil society, media professionals, researchers, and the broader public, while ensuring high-quality and accessible data. Similarly, Dr. Ayman Zohry, NCHR member and liaison officer for cooperation with CAPMAS, explained that the protocol seeks to strengthen the role of data and statistics in supporting national human rights efforts through the collection, classification, analysis, and dissemination of data according to national statistical standards, with a special focus on marginalised populations. He added that the cooperation includes conducting joint studies and research, organising workshops and conferences addressing human rights issues, and exploring the social, economic, demographic, and environmental dimensions of human rights. Following the signing ceremony, both parties agreed to develop a joint action plan to implement the provisions of the protocol to ensure adequate follow-up and tangible impact. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:
Al-Ahram Weekly
3 days ago
- Al-Ahram Weekly
NCHR launches dialogue with civil society organizations on human rights
The National Council for Human Rights (NCHR), in partnership with the European Union, held its inaugural consultative meeting with civil society organizations. The meeting, titled "Mechanisms and Frameworks for Cooperation and Partnership," brought together human rights activists and experts to discuss the NCHR's plan to promote human rights. The event took place both in person and via Zoom, and was attended by several notable figures, including Mahmoud Karem, NCHR Chairman; Mohamed Anwar El-Sadat, an NCHR board member; and Hani Ibrahim, the NCHR Secretary-General. Legal expert Negad El-Borai was also present, along with representatives from the European Union and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. The meeting underscored the NCHR's commitment to creating a consistent dialogue with civil society and to encouraging civil organizations to participate in spreading a culture of human rights, enhancing community oversight, and engaging with human rights issues. Karem emphasized that civil society is a vital pillar of democratic development and a key partner in implementing the National Human Rights Strategy. He stated that human rights organizations act as a crucial link between citizens and the state by identifying needs, monitoring challenges, and proposing solutions. Karem also highlighted the importance of an ongoing partnership with these organizations, recognizing their role in promoting transparency, accountability, and a culture of human rights. He noted that the NCHR plans to expand this cooperation through capacity-building programs and consultative meetings, with support from international partners like the European Union. According to El-Sadat, strengthening partnerships with civil society organizations and human rights activists is a core principle of the NCHR. He explained that the council has recently intervened in various humanitarian and social cases, such as assisting Egyptian citizens abroad who faced difficulties. El-Sadat also mentioned that the council has responded to inquiries from human rights organizations and other parties about the legal and health conditions of several pretrial detainees. He confirmed that the council contacted relevant officials and directly followed up on some of these cases to ensure legal guarantees and human rights standards were upheld. The NCHR's Secretary-General, Hani Ibrahim, stressed that building a trusting, sustainable relationship with civil society organizations requires clarity and discipline when developing and implementing action plans. He noted that the council has organized a series of sessions and dialogues, led by human rights experts and running through November. The goal of these sessions is to create a practical vision for a future action plan that establishes a participatory institutional model for managing human rights issues, he added. For his part, Negad El-Borai emphasized that the council serves as an advisory body that supports human rights reform processes through close cooperation with civil society organizations. He called for continued joint work to formulate realistic paths that activate constitutional provisions, develop practices in a way that meets citizens' aspirations, and consolidate the respect for rights and freedoms in practice. Follow us on: Facebook Instagram Whatsapp Short link:
Mada
4 days ago
- Mada
No aid reaching Gaza's warehouses as Israel derails truck routes, kills convoy security despite humanitarian ‘tactical pauses'
None of the aid trucks entering the Gaza Strip during the 'tactical pause' the Israeli military announced on Sunday are reaching distribution warehouses, eyewitnesses and civilians working to guard the trucks from theft told Mada Masr in recent days. Instead, Israel has blocked the passage of the few trucks being permitted to enter and undermined efforts to secure them from theft, in at least one instance directly targeting and killing civilian companies and volunteers working to guard them. Palestinian security guards accompanying a convoy that entered northern Gaza on Monday night were killed by Israeli drone and tank fire, while the night previously, Israel's military ordered another convoy in south Gaza to stop moving, leaving it exposed to armed theft shortly afterward. In both incidents, huge crowds of people who gathered to obtain aid supplies took what they could; a situation that humanitarian agencies warn will do nothing to guarantee that aid reaches those most in need as famine in the strip worsens. One of the aid convoys derailed before it could reach distribution warehouses entered the strip from Israeli-held territory on Monday night through the northwestern Zikim crossing. Security for the convoy was to be handled by young volunteers who have joined clan committees in northern Gaza, one of the volunteers told Mada Masr, to ensure that aid reaches warehouses and protect the deliveries from looting. 'We headed to the Sudaniyya area on Monday,' the volunteer said, describing a northwestern neighborhood of Gaza near the crossing. The convoy was delayed at the crossing and only entered the strip late at night, they said. As a result, a growing crowd of people gathered in the area to await the supplies. 'We began stopping some looters from approaching the site where aid trucks are often robbed,' the source said. It was then that Israeli forces attacked the security volunteers. 'As soon as the trucks moved out of the Zikim crossing, Israeli surveillance drones targeted an aid security group, killing and injuring several,' they said. 'Then a tank shell struck another group just a few meters ahead of us in the middle of Sudaniyya Street, killing and wounding more.' 'Within moments, it turned into a battlefield,' the volunteer continued, describing Israeli vehicles advancing to the middle of the street and opening fire at the security volunteers. 'Naval vessels also began firing in our direction at the same time, covering the area in heavy gunfire from every direction. Many were killed and wounded in the area.' The volunteer described seeing armed groups, which have sprung up as social cohesion has been eroded after months of starvation, who were spared the Israeli fire at the scene. 'The Israeli forces didn't target the armed gangs who stood to the side, observing the situation,' they said. Essam al-Aydy, who was also in the area and witnessed what took place, said Israeli soldiers opened fire on both the aid convoy's security team and civilians, leaving many dead and wounded. 'I was standing a few meters away from the Khaldy mosque,' he said, 'but I could see the Israeli vehicles advancing into the middle of Sudaniya Street. They shelled the security team, then pulled back toward the vicinity of the Zikim area. Their forces then allowed looters to move in and rob the aid trucks.' Aydy said the trucks were carrying aid from the World Food Program and from the United Arab Emirates' Al-Fares al-Shahm initiative, all of which was looted. The volunteer also saw the supplies looted quickly after the security team's targeting. 'I managed to hide behind a rock and slowly pulled back until I reached a somewhat safe area,' they said. 'I saw looters advancing, stepping over the bodies of the dead to reach the aid trucks.' Eleven of the security personnel, including members of the clans and families organization, were killed in the attack, the Gaza Government Media Office said in a statement on the incident on Monday night. 'After confirming their deaths, the Occupation authorities opened the way for trucks to enter, only to fall into the hands of criminal gangs and thieves under their direct protection,' the media office said. Israel 'is deliberately preventing aid from reaching its warehouses or those who deserve it, which constitutes a deliberate and ongoing crime against besieged civilians,' the office continued. Looting also took place for all of the supplies in a convoy of aid trucks that entered south Gaza on Sunday night. Around 150 aid trucks had set out from Egypt earlier that day and crossed from the Egyptian side of the Karam Abu Salem crossing, a source in the Egyptian Red Crescent told Mada Masr at the time, where they waited for hours before Israel approved their entry. The meager number of trucks ultimately allowed into Gaza never reached distribution warehouses and were diverted by Israeli orders into combat zones, where armed groups looted them under the watch and fire of Occupation forces. A source in a security company tasked with securing the aid entering the strip Sunday night told Mada Masr that the Israeli military ordered the company staff to stop in the Miraj area, which falls within the Israeli-held zone of Rafah and is designated as 'a dangerous combat zone.' The military threatened to target the trucks if the drivers did not comply, the source said. Once stopped in Rafah, residents approached the trucks and began taking what they could, an eyewitness told Mada Masr. Palestinian accounts posted footage of huge crowds trying to take aid supplies from the trucks inbound from Egypt in the early hours of Monday morning. The eyewitness said that as crowds were taking supplies, armed gangs came out from inside the city, seizing the cargo and threatening civilians at gunpoint. The looting took place near Israeli military positions, according to the source, who added that the forces looked on and opened fire intermittently on the crowd, causing deaths and injuries. Meanwhile, the Israeli military said it airdropped 20 boxes of aid into Gaza on Monday in coordination with Jordan and the UAE, following similar airdrops the previous day. Gaza's Government Media Office said that Sunday's airdrops landed in 'red zones' off-limits to civilians under Israeli maps and amounted to no more than two truckloads of aid. While Israel continues to announce 'secure corridors' for aid entry that have never materialized, Palestinians are entering a fifth month of siege and starvation. Civilian testimonies suggest that the only impact of the daily 'tactical' pauses so far is a minimal easing of the soaring inflation that has pushed prices for basic goods in the strip to unaffordable levels. Gaza's Health Ministry said on Monday afternoon that 14 more children died within 24 hours due to hunger and malnutrition, bringing the total number of starvation-related deaths to 147, including 88 children. Though the World Food Program has expressed appreciation for the pauses, it has said previously that distributing food parcels directly to families is the most effective way to prevent widespread starvation and that the lack of facilitations for its drivers and staff has made such efforts impossible. 'We are not getting the needed volume of humanitarian assistance in, despite the assurances that we can do so, ' WFP emergency response director, Will Ross, said on Monday. The agency also announced that famine indicators are at their worst across the strip since 2023, repeating on Tuesday that all crossings need to be opened for multiple deliveries per day, and that the agency needs more routes opened to it.
