TD: Food regulator has done ‘tangible' work but concern remains
Independent TD Carol Nolan has described the work of the regulator to date as 'a tangible and hopeful indication that real progress is being made on redressing the financial power imbalance that has traditionally existed between farmers, suppliers and the retail sector'.
She was speaking after attending the inaugural conference of the Agri-Food Regulator today (Tuesday, May 20).
'I have been consistently engaging with the work of the regulator, and indeed its precursor structure, the unfair trading practices (UTP) Enforcement Authority… So I'm delighted that it continues to operate with the level of forceful commitment that we all need to see.'
However, Nolan also said: 'I do find it concerning, however, that issues I would have raised in June 2022 around fear of retaliation from the large retailers is still leading to lower-than expected levels of complaints being made.'
Today's conference saw the presentation of the regulator's first Supplier Survey, which the body is aiming to carry out on an annual basis going forward.
'The feedback from the Supplier Survey findings that were discussed at the conference made it clear that there is still quite a way to go in terms of gaining the trust of farmers to lodge complaints if they feel they are being targeted with unfair trading practices,' she added.
The Offaly TD acknowledged that some retailers 'are being much more proactive about this'.
'But what we really need to see is an equality of approach right across the board from all of the major [retailers].
Nolan called for the Agri-Food Regulator to be sufficiently staffed and resourced.
'We have the skeleton of an enforcement authority that is doing great work with what it has, but we now need to put proper flesh on the bones. That means more funding and more staff and if need be, more wide-ranging statutory powers,' she said.
Agri-Food Regulator
The chairperson of the Agri-Food Regulator has indicated that he is confident that the regulator will be afforded further powers in order to carry out its functions.
Speaking to Agriland at the inaugural conference of the Agri-Food Regulator today (Tuesday, May 20), Joe Healy said that, with the powers the regulator currently has, it is not possible to 'get the full picture'.
'We're very straight, very independent and very honest with the businesses, but we want them to give us the information as well,' Healy said.
'We are happy, having met the minister…[that] the government is committed in the Programme for Government to giving us enough power to do our job, he said his department are treating it as a priority…and that it his intention as minister for agriculture to ensure that the Agri-Food Regulator has the powers to carry out the duties it was set up to do,' the regulator chairperson added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
11 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Tourism in Ireland at a 'tipping point', warns ITIC
The Irish Tourism Industry Confederation (ITIC) is calling for the lifting of the Dublin Airport passenger cap, increased Government spending, as well as the restoration of the 9% hospitality VAT rate in order to boost tourism in the country, which it said is at a "tipping point". In its Budget submission, the ITIC warns of "double-digit" declines in tourists coming to Ireland and that the country is overdependent on US visitors. In order to address this, the confederation - which represents 20,000 tourism and hospitality businesses - wants to see annual Government spending on tourism services increased by €90 million to around €340 million. This funding, it said, would support a market diversification strategy to reduce the reliance on American tourists. In addition, the ITIC not only wants the restoration of the 9% hospitality VAT rate, but also said it should be extended to visitor attractions and adventure operators. In relation to the passenger cap at Dublin Airport, the organisation notes that 70% of the tourist economy is dependent on international visitors. The cap limits the number of passengers travelling through the airport terminals to 32 million per year. The ITIC is calling for this limit, which is included in the Programme for Government, to be lifted and said this "should happen in tandem with supporting the regional state airports of Cork and Shannon". ITIC Chief Executive Eoghan O'Mara Walsh said that "with unprecedented geopolitical and macroeconomic uncertainty, now is the time for Government to control the controllables and focus on domestic home-grown sectors. "Tourism is the largest indigenous industry and biggest regional employer, and needs to be supported in October's budget. "The case for investment in tourism is indisputable with a return on investment unparalleled by other sectors," he added.
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Louth TD criticises regulator's ‘clean bill of health' for supermarkets amid soaring grocery prices
Labour's Ged Nash said he was skeptical at the verdict of the Competition & Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC), which ruled the big Irish food retailers are no more or no less profitable than comparable EU supermarket chains. Irish supermarkets do not publish their profits publicly, but the Drogheda TD and his party have recently sponsored a private members' bill in the Dáil forcing the Irish supermarkets to do so. He demanded that his new bill be enacted so data on their profits is revealed publicly and for the government to order the CCPC to carry out an in-depth study of the Irish grocery market in the interests of transparency. Deputy Nash said: "Given the limited reliable data that is publicly available on supermarket profits, it is a big stretch for the CCPC to definitely claim that the Irish arms of global retailers are no more or less profitable than their EU counterparts. This is a peculiar conclusion to reach under the circumstances. "This is exactly why Labour's Unfair Pricing Bill, which could compel operators to share data on profit margins with the CCPC so they can undertake more robust market analysis and surveillance to ensure competition is working and consumers are treated fairly, must be enacted by the government. "Because the CCPC says that current prices in Ireland are in line with other EU countries is little comfort to hard-pressed Irish households where salaries are not rising as quickly as prices. "We need to get a better understanding of why prices for the basics in Ireland have remained high for so long; why they are not coming down and why there is only moderate competition with no new, major entrants in 25 years. "This report does not have the answers and it reveals in stark relief how limited the actual functions of the CCPC are. "Farmers have the Agri-Food Regulator to stand up for their interests, while the limited interest the government has in how competition and consumer protection works in the interest of citizens and small retailers means citizens are left to suck up high prices."
Agriland
5 days ago
- Agriland
Climate progress report shows action on nutrient storage
The government has published a new progress report which outlines the actions taken or completed as part of the Climate Action Plan for the first quarter of 2025, including those related to agriculture. In total, four of the six new Q1 actions have been delivered on time, according to the progress report. High impact actions delayed from 2023 and 2024 are also included in the report to retain accountability to their completion, according to the government. Of the 64 legacy actions remaining, 10 of these were completed in Q1 2025. The report states that the Programme for Government makes key commitments supporting a sustainable transition in agriculture including: Reducing emissions and improving sustainability; Helping farmers adopt practical measures to cut emissions; Offering sustainable income diversification options; Promoting carbon reducing activities like forestry planting; Partnering with farmers and rural communities to embrace opportunities in energy efficiency, renewables, and nature-based solutions. The report acknowledges the launch of the 60% grant-aided Nutrient Storage Scheme in Q1 of 2025 to "support reduced reliance on chemical fertiliser". This was one of the scheduled actions which was on the list for completion. The Nutrient Importation Storage Scheme (NISS) is aimed at improving the production conditions on farms, improving competitiveness and contributing to the improvement of agricultural incomes and helping farmers on the storage of imported animal excreta, soiled water and other farmyard manures and related facilities. The scheme is open to farmers with at least 5ha of owned, leased or rented lands which has been declared under the Basic Income Support for Sustainability (BISS) or equivalent in the year of application or preceding year, or in the case of intensive enterprises, generate a minimum of 20 production units from farming. The associated investment ceilings are €90,000 for individuals, or €160,000 for Registered Farm Partnerships. It is a standalone scheme and does not impact other Targeted Agricultural Modernisation Scheme (TAMS) 3 investment limits and multiple applications per tranche are allowed. Other "legacy" actions in agriculture, which are listed in the report include: Establish a group and finalise an implementation report for a just climate transition in agriculture - completed ; ; Review maximum nitrogen (N) limits - completed ; ; New/updated measures from the Teagasc Marginal Abatement Cost Curve (MACC) included in the Climate Action Plan - completed ; ; Publish draft carbon farming framework - delayed ; ; Industry agreement for tracking the use of methane-reducing ingredients - delayed. An action which had previously been suggested has now been ruled out altogether, and that was the cow reduction scheme. Gap to target. Source: Climate Action Plan Progress Report Q1 2025 Other actions scheduled for completion before the end of 2025 in relation to agriculture include developing an action plan on reducing the age of slaughter, as well as the implementation of the Lisheen Bioeconomy Scaleup Initiative and the Circular Bioeconomy Aquaculture Demonstration Initiative projects. In terms of Land Use, Land Use Change and Forestry (LULUCF), the report states that this sector has been an emissions source in Ireland since 1990. "It has a challenging future profile for emissions generation due to the ageing profile of existing trees, continued low planting rates and large areas of drained emissive peat soils used for farming, forestry and peat extraction," according to the progress report. The government has stated that emissions from land use are expected to rise between 5.5 and 7.8MT CO 2 eq in WAM (with additional measures) and WEM (with existing measures) scenarios respectively by 2030. The progress report states that the projected increase in emissions may be moderated through planned interventions such as expanded afforestation, improved water table management on organic soils used for agriculture, and the rehabilitation of peatlands. There is a target of 8,000ha per year until 2030 for afforestation, however 2024's figure only reached 1,573. One action included in the Climate Action Plan which has been delayed is a review of proposed Teagasc MACC measures to determine which actions are possible to deliver sustainably across all land use types. As part of this, providing a detailed mapping exercise to achieve the EU LULUCF regulation target has also been delayed. The report outlines that while agriculture is the largest greenhouse gas (GHG) emitting sector in Ireland, emissions decreased by 20.7Mt CO2eq in 2023. This was driven by reductions in fertiliser use, liming and decreased milk production due to poor weather and grazing conditions, according to the progress report. The report said that delays in climate action delivery stem from several factors including: Technical complexity or data gaps; Dependencies on other actions or policies; Issues caused by problems resourcing areas requiring specific technical expertise; Time required for legislative responses, including parliamentary time; Staff resourcing supply problems; Delays regarding public consultation; Administrative hold-ups such as approval processes; The need for additional analysis. These delays threaten Ireland's ability to meet binding emissions targets and risk increasing future pressures, costs, and reputational harm. All delayed actions will continue to be reported as a part of the 2025 reporting process, maintaining commitment to their delivery alongside new measures, according to the government.
