Ramaphosa reviews R700 million National Dialogue costs amid Starlink discussions
President Cyril Ramaphosa met with South African-born tech billionaire Elon Musk on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly in New York on September 24, 2024.
Image: Presidency
President Cyril Ramaphosa on Wednesday said he has ordered the Cabinet to review the R700 million price tag for the National Dialogue.
Responding to questions in the National Council of Provinces, Ramaphosa said many people have become fixated on what the National Dialogue is going to cost.
'We are going to make sure that it is driven down. It is just an estimate,' he said.
Ramaphosa said they are going to make sure that they spend as little as possible, but at the same time, have as much consultation as possible.
'What has been put out as the budgeted amount is going to be looked at. I have said to my colleagues that the cost that has been put out must be driven down, and we must get to the bare bones and make sure that we have a very rich process of coming up of giving South Africans an opportunity of coming up with a very good outcome of the dialogue.'
Ramaphosa said the National Dialogue was well-conceived, articulated, and embraced by several people in the country.
'I would say that those who are developing doubts about the efficacy or ability of the National Dialogue to yield any results need to look at how we have forged social compacts in the past, and how they have moved us forward in the way of progress,' he said.
Meanwhile, Ramaphosa said Minister of Communications Solly Malatsi indicated that there would be public hearings around relaxing broad-based economic empowerment regulations in the ICT sector, viewed by some as a backdoor entrance to billionaire Elon Musk's Starlink to operate in the country.
'There are going to be public hearings where our people will make inputs on the efficacy of what he has announced.'
He was responding to EFF MP Meisie Kennedy, who raised her concerns that the ruling elite have used black economic empowerment policy as a way to legally funnel billions of rand into politically connected elites.
'The EFF was, therefore, also not surprised when just last month, Mr President, you were set to offer regulatory assurance to Elon Musk, starting by bypassing necessary black economic empowerment,' said Kennedy, before asking about measures that will ensure foreign companies do not by-pass black economic empowerment laws to operate in the country.
'What he (Malatsi) has announced is very much in line with our laws. There is no violation as far as he is concerned and as far as I am concerned with regard to our laws, and it's not specifically aimed at one or any company. It is aimed at ensuring that those who would be, whether local or from any other country, who want to participate in this process, may find greater ease in doing so.'
He assured that the government will never take any measures that are going to militate against the Constitution or violate the laws of the country wilfully.
'We will always seek to act in accordance with our laws, and always seek to act in accordance with our Constitution. We are a country and a government that is governed by the rule of law, so the rule of law applies, and we will follow the law as much as we possibly can. So be assured, if you ever had any fears, do not fear that we will violate the law,' he added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
GNU remains committed to transformation agenda, says Ramaphosa
Taking questions in the National Council of Provinces on Wednesday, President Cyril Ramaphosa was bullish about the Government of National Unity's commitment to transformation. President Cyril Ramaphosa says while parties in the Government of National Unity (GNU) may differ on certain policy issues, 'the fundamental commitment to the GNU's transformational agenda remains in place. 'At a broader level, through the Statement of Intent, which was signed by various parties as part of the Government of National Unity, we are committed to translate the values of our Constitution into focus — particularly with regard to the achievement of social justice, redress and equity. That is what we all signed up for when we entered into the Government of National Unity,' Ramaphosa told delegates in the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) on Wednesday, 25 June. He was responding to a question from the DA's Nicolaas Pienaar on whether, with reference to his recent working visit to the United States, he conceded that the GNU had to rework its Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) policies to attract more international investment. Ramaphosa said Pretoria's visit to the US had not focused on BEE. But not before poking fun at the Oval Office meeting with US President Donald Trump, in which Trump dimmed the lights to show a video splicing EFF leader Julius Malema's rendition of 'Dubul' Ibhunu' and AfriForum's white-cross farm protests to 'prove' his false claims of a genocide in SA. 'I would've thought that we would not be making any reference to the United States, but, be that as it may, I'm rather pleased that the lights here have not been dimmed, because any act of dimming lights continues to worry me,' said Ramaphosa. He continued: 'Our visit to the United States did not focus on issues of Black Economic Empowerment. It focused on resetting our relationship with the United States and ensuring that we continue to open conversations with our major trading partners, and our commitment to Black Economic Empowerment — as expressed through various policy documents and statements — remains steadfast.' The issue of BEE has once again become increasingly prominent for reasons involving the Trump administration's focus on SA's transformation policies and the recent publication of a B-BBEE policy direction that could allow Elon Musk's Starlink internet service provider to operate in the country without ceding ownership. At the same time, the DA, a GNU partner and SA's second-largest party, is challenging section 15A of the Employment Equity Amendment Act in the Gauteng Division of the High Court, arguing it violates section 9 of the Constitution by enabling discrimination based on race. The DA's legal challenges to key pieces of legislation the ANC believes will further transformation, such as the Employment Equity Act, National Health Insurance, the Expropriation Act and the Basic Laws Amendment Act, have highlighted divisions within the GNU. Last month, Ramaphosa defended South Africa's redress policies in Parliament, arguing it was not BEE holding South Africa's economy back but exclusive ownership. Transformation should be seen as a 'national project' Echoing his previous comments, Ramaphosa on Wednesday said that SA needn't choose between transformation and economic growth. 'We must dispense with the false notion that we must make a choice between transformation and growth. Black Economic Empowerment is not only compatible with investment and growth, but is essential to the achievement of broad-based growth, as well as prosperity. It must be seen as a process through which we take measures — direct measures — to bring those who were excluded from economic activity into the economic mainstream. 'To think that it will happen on its own, when in the past measures were taken — including laws [that] were passed to ensure that only a minority benefits — we would be deceiving ourselves,' he said. Ramaphosa said that although the government had made progress on transformation 'across a range of measures, … we can do better. 'As with any other policy, we must constantly assess whether we are achieving our goals and whether we are making the improvements that we wanted. 'Various departments in our government, including the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition, are continuing to review the various measures that are in place, to align these with the priorities of our government in ensuring that we have industrialisation, inclusive growth and also that we facilitate access to finance for emerging black-owned and managed enterprises,' he said. Transformation, he said, should be seen 'as a national project'. 'It should never be seen as a project that belongs to just a few amongst us. All of us must be involved in this, including those who benefited under the previous system. They must be seen to be actively involved in advancing the system of all, because failing to do so could lead to lack of growth in our economy — it could lead to reversals. So all hands — black and white — must be on deck to promote transformation in our country, to enable all South Africans to play a role in the economy of their country,' he said. Starlink deal In an appearance before Parliament last month, following his department's publication of the policy direction that could significantly alter the way SA regulates empowerment in the information and communication technology sector, Communications and Digital Technologies Minister Solly Malatsi maintained the direction was not giving Starlink 'special dispensation'. The proposed direction provides communications licence applicants with a workaround to a rule in the Electronic Communications Act that requires licence-holders to be 30% owned by historically disadvantaged groups. Musk has previously criticised SA's ownership laws ad nauseam. This is the main barrier that has prevented Starlink from applying for a licence to operate in South Africa, as it does not comply with the rule, according to a News24 report. Malatsi faced backlash from several MPs, who called for the withdrawal of the proposal, which has been published for public comment. On Wednesday, Ramaphosa said that as far as he was concerned, Malatsi had not violated any of the country's laws in publishing the policy direction. 'There are going to be hearings — there are going to be public hearings — where our people will make inputs on the efficacy of what he has announced. What he has announced is very much in line with our laws. There is no violation as far as he's concerned and as far as I'm concerned with regard to our laws, and it's not specifically aimed at one or any company,' said Ramaphosa. He said the policy direction was aimed at ensuring that those who wanted to participate in this process 'may find greater ease to do so', and it was also aimed at 'synchronising that communications [legislation]' with other laws. DM
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
Macroeconomic uncertainty drags South Africa's manufacturing sector into deep decline
According to Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) on Tuesday, the decline was broad based and was driven by contractions in nine out of 10 manufacturing divisions. Image: Simphiwe Mbokazi/Independent Newspapers Economists have warned that the ongoing macroeconomic and policy uncertainty will continue to leave operating conditions unfavourable for manufacturing production and drag the sector's contribution to South Africa's economic growth. This comes after manufacturing output fell 6.3% year-on-year in April following a revised 1.2% contraction in March. This was the sixth consecutive monthly contraction and the sharpest drop since March 2024. Maarten Ackerman, chief economist at Citadel, expressed deep concern over the sector's trajectory, emphasising its vital role in job creation and economic stimulation. Manufacturing remains one of the few sectors in the South African economy with significant potential to create jobs, stimulate broader economic growth, and provide opportunities for the unemployed. In 2024, the manufacturing sector contributed 13% to South Africa's gross domestic product (GDP). with the sector's nominal GDP forecast to grow by an average rate of 5.7% per annum over the next decade. This sector also employs over 1.6 million people and is a significant driver of the country's export economy. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading South African industries have benefited from high carbon intensity and lower export prices, but the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and similar policies will erode this advantage, leading to higher costs, lower demand and increased pressure from EU importers for carbon footprint and sustainability compliance. However, Ackerman said the sector continued to grapple with deep-rooted structural challenges. He said these included unreliable electricity and water supply, as well as ongoing issues with the country's logistical infrastructure, particularly the rail network, freight trains, and port systems. 'These constraints are effectively limiting the sector's capacity to expand. While this data reflects monthly high-frequency indicators, it aligns closely with quarterly trends showing that manufacturing is no longer a driver of economic growth, Ackerman said. 'Since the 2008 global financial crisis, the industry has largely failed to contribute positively to South Africa's GDP. In fact, manufacturing output volumes have stagnated, returning to levels last seen in early 2010. Over the past 15 years, the sector has shown no real growth.' Ackerman said this unfortunate trend underscored a broader issue: South Africa's urgent need for fixed investment to tackle these structural barriers. 'Without meaningful and sustained investment, the country will struggle to unlock higher, more inclusive, and sustainable economic growth,' he said. According to Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) on Tuesday, the decline was broad based and was driven by contractions in nine out of 10 manufacturing divisions. Nicolai Klaassen, director of industry statistics at Stats SA, said the food and beverages and metals and machinery divisions were the largest negative contributors to the print. 'Together, the two divisions subtracted 3.2 percentage points from overall manufacturing growth. Four divisions contracted by more than 10%. These were electrical machinery, the automotive division, communication and professional equipment, and the miscellaneous category, furniture and manufacturing not elsewhere classified,' Klaasen said. 'Glass and non-metallic mineral products was the only division that recorded positive growth, expanding by 2.3% year-on-year.' On a month-on-month basis, seasonally adjusted manufacturing production increased by 1.9% in April compared with March, marking a moderately better start to the second quarter of 2025. On a quarterly basis, industrial production contracted by 1.4% in the three months to April. The manufacturing sector's lacklustre outcome is in line with the performance of the ABSA Purchasing Managers Index (PMI). Specifically, the PMI index moved further into contractionary territory in April, with both the business activity and new sales orders' indices declining. Broad-based weakness in manufacturing activity has persisted through the first four months of the year, with output down by 3.4% compared to the same period last year. FNB senior economist Thanda Sithole said the persistent annual decline underscored ongoing unfavourable operating conditions and was consistent with their assessment of downside risks to the near-term economic growth outlook. 'Operating conditions for domestic manufacturers remain unfavourable, as reflected in the continued decline in the manufacturing PMI. While the manufacturing PMI expected business conditions index improved to 62.5 points in May from 48.6 in April, indicating better near-term sentiment, conditions remain fluid amid ongoing macroeconomic and policy uncertainty,' Sithole said. 'Domestic demand, particularly private sector fixed investment, remains weak, and external economic conditions are not conducive to growth in manufacturing merchandise exports.' BUSINESS REPORT
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Did SA bend BEE rules for Elon Musk's Starlink? Ramaphosa says no
President Cyril Ramaphosa denied relaxing BBBEE to benefit South African-born tech billionaire Elon Musk after his visit to the US. Image: Presidency President Cyril Ramaphosa has again poured cold water on claims that South Africa proposed relaxing its black empowerment rules solely for Elon Musk's Starlink, despite the move coming days after his meeting with US President Donald Trump last month. 'Our visit to the United States did not focus on issues of Black Economic Empowerment,' Ramaphosa told Parliament on Wednesday afternoon. 'It focused on resetting the relationship with the United States and ensuring that we continue open conversations with our major trading partners.' He was responding to a question from Nicholaas Hendricks Pienaar of the Democratic Alliance (DA) in Limpopo. Pienaar asked whether the Government of National Unity (GNU) should revise Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (BBBEE) policies to attract more international investment and stimulate economic growth and job creation. Ramaphosa reiterated the government's commitment to economic transformation. 'Our commitment to black economic empowerment, as expressed through various policy documents and statements, remains steadfast,' he said. 'Through the Statement of Intent signed by various parties in the GNU, we are committed to translating the values of our Constitution into reality - particularly social justice, redress, and equity.' Last month, IOL News reported that, just days after a high-level meeting at the White House, attended by South African billionaire Johann Rupert and Tesla CEO Elon Musk, the South African government appeared to be easing regulations to facilitate the entry of Starlink, Musk's satellite internet service. The alleged shift in policy has sparked debate over the influence of global business elites on national legislation and whether diplomatic lobbying is steering South Africa's tech and telecommunications framework. Rupert, citing rising crime and economic stagnation, called for Starlink's launch to be fast-tracked. 'We need Starlink in South Africa,' he said. Meanwhile, Ramaphosa pointed to the Constitution's Equality Clause as a foundation for transformation policies like BBBEE. 'There are a number of measures that the Equality Clause calls on us to embark on - legislative measures to protect or advance persons disadvantaged by unfair discrimination,' he said. He emphasised that the BEE Act remains a central lever for inclusive, sustainable growth. 'We must dispense with the false notion that we must choose between transformation and growth,' Ramaphosa said. 'Black economic empowerment is not only compatible with investment and growth - it is essential to achieving broad-based prosperity.' Ramaphosa added that BEE should not be seen as a project for a select few. 'It must be a national project. Everyone, including those who benefited under apartheid, must be involved,' he said. 'Failing to do so risks economic stagnation.' In a follow-up question, Pienaar asked Ramaphosa if he would support foreign investments like Starlink without requiring a 30% ownership stake for local partners. However, Ramaphosa responded by pointing to the country's equity-equivalent model, which allows foreign companies that cannot meet direct ownership requirements to instead contribute to transformation initiatives. 'For offshore-based companies with global ownership structures, we've come up with an innovative, equity-equivalent solution,' Ramaphosa said. 'They embark on initiatives that support transformation and get involved in economic development without handing over equity. And many have embraced this approach.' He added that while South Africa is not unique in requiring local ownership, it may be the only country offering a flexible equity-equivalent system - which many multinational companies have welcomed. 'We are not averse to coming up with good solutions, so long as there is commitment to transformation,' Ramaphosa said. 'That, to us, is not negotiable.' He reiterated the historical rationale for transformation policies. 'Our economy was structured for the benefit of a white minority,' he said. 'They passed laws to exclude others, even from menial jobs. We are turning the tables. We want all South Africans to benefit, not just a few.' [email protected] IOL Politics
