NYU withholds diploma of student who condemned Israel in graduation speech
New York University is withholding a student's diploma after he condemned Israel's deadly war on Gaza during his graduation ceremony speech.
On Wednesday, Logan Rozos, an undergraduate student speaker from NYU's Gallatin School of Individualized Study, delivered his commencement speech in which he said: 'The only thing that is appropriate to say in this time and to a group this large is a recognition of the atrocities currently happening in Palestine.'
Rozos told the crowd that 'as I search my heart today in addressing you all', it is his 'moral and political commitments [that] guide me' into condemning Israel's onslaught on Gaza, which has killed at least 53,000 Palestinians over the last year and a half.
Rozos went on to say: 'The genocide currently occurring is supported politically and militarily by the United States, is paid for by our tax dollars and has been livestreamed to our phones for the past 18 months. And that I do not wish to speak only to my own politics today, but to speak for all people of conscience, and all people who feel the moral injury of this atrocity.'
Related: More than 1,000 US students punished over speech since 2020, report finds
Rozos's anti-war speech was met with widespread cheers and applause from students across the auditorium. Some attendees booed Rozos, with one person appearing to yell 'bullshit!' from the crowd.
Following Rozos's speech, NYU released a statement saying that it 'strongly denounces the choice by a student at the Gallatin School's graduation today … to misuse his role as student speaker to express his personal and one-sided political views'.
'He lied about the speech he was going to deliver and violated the commitment he made to comply with our rules. The university is withholding his diploma while we pursue disciplinary actions. NYU is deeply sorry that the audience was subjected to these remarks and that this moment was stolen by someone who abused a privilege that was conferred upon him,' the university added.
As of Thursday morning, Rozos's student profile on NYU Gallatin's website appeared to have been taken down, with a message saying: 'Page or File Not Found (404 Error)'.
Rozos and NYU did not immediately return a request for comment.
Last August, NYU updated its student conduct guidelines to include 'code words, like 'Zionist'' as examples of discriminatory speech.
'For many Jewish people, Zionism is a part of their Jewish identity. Speech and conduct that would violate the [nondiscrimination and anti-harassment policy] if targeting Jewish or Israeli people can also violate the NDAH if directed toward Zionists,' the university said.
The updated guidelines came months after anti-war students at NYU and other college campuses across the country demonstrated in solidarity with Palestine. As a result, NYU administrators called police to campus, leading to widespread arrests of students and faculty members.
Last December, two tenured professors who were declared 'personae non gratae' by NYU accused the university of escalating its suppression of anti-war speech under pressure from donors, politicians and pro-Israel organizations.
Related: California State students protest aid blockade in Gaza with hunger strike
The two professors, Andrew Ross and Sonya Posmentier, were barred from entering certain university buildings. The PNG declarations came after Ross and Posmentier joined a sit-in at the university library in calls for the university to divest from companies profiting off of Israel's war in Gaza.
A few months later, the university canceled a talk on USAID cuts after it deemed the lecture as 'anti-governmental'. According to Dr Joanne Liu, a pediatric emergency physician at Sainte-Justine hospital and former international president of Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders), NYU'S vice-chair of the education department called her the evening before her presentation in March.
Liu said the vice-chair voiced concerns about the content of some of her slides, including ones that mentioned USAID cuts by the Trump administration, as well as slides that cited Palestinian casualties in Gaza as a result of Israel's war across the strip. Liu said she was told that the slides on Gaza 'could be perceived as antisemitic'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
New York City Democratic mayoral rivals clash in first TV debate
NEW YORK — Two main targets emerged by the end of the two-hour New York City mayoral debate: Frontrunner Andrew Cuomo and Donald Trump. Cuomo's eight opponents — desperate to cut into his consistent polling advantage — attacked him throughout Wednesday night by seizing on the controversies that preceded his fall from power four years ago: Allegations of sexual harassment and a Covid record that's reportedly under federal investigation. Former Assemblymember Michael Blake — polling in the single digits — leveled one of the sharpest barbs at Cuomo linking those controversies: 'The people who don't feel safe are the young women, mothers and grandmothers around Andrew Cuomo — that's the greatest threat to public safety.' The attacks on Cuomo during the first televised debate of the boisterous Big Apple Democratic mayoral primary underscored the strategic need of his opponents to swing hard and fast against the prohibitive favorite to win the party's nomination. They parried with early voting set to begin in 10 days. Nine candidates — Cuomo, Blake, City Comptroller Brad Lander, state Sens. Zellnor Myrie and Jessica Ramos, former City Comptroller Scott Stringer, Assemblymember Zohran Mamdani, City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams and businessperson Whitney Tilson — squared off in the debate co-sponsored by POLITICO and WNBC. The crowded forum was marked by periods of extensive crosstalk from the candidates mostly trying to pile on Cuomo, who is mounting a comeback bid after scandal-induced resignation four years ago. The candidates all pledged to tackle issues that have resonated with voters, like affordability and housing, while vowing to fight Trump's meddling in his native city — especially with targeting undocumented people for deportation. They uniformly condemned Trump's threats against Columbia University over charges the school failed to protect Jewish students. Lander turned the Trump talk back to Cuomo. 'With all the corruption that's in Washington, we can't have corruption back here in New York City as well,' he said before blasting Cuomo's controversial $5 million contract for a Covid-era memoir. The criticisms of Cuomo flowed forth from there. Attacking Cuomo, who has largely shied away from speaking with reporters and attending candidate forums, was an imperative for his opponents Wednesday as voting fast approaches. But it was the longshot Blake, a former Democratic National Committee vice chair, who frequently laced into Cuomo with cutting criticism. Mamdani accused the former governor of being 'allergic to accountability' when Blake re-surfaced a 2008 Cuomo quote who criticized candidates who 'shuck and jive' as Barack Obama was running for president. Adrienne Adams was incredulous when Cuomo could not name a 'personal regret' in politics, summoning a cinematic rebuke: 'No regrets when it comes to cutting Medicaid or health care? No regrets when it comes to cutting child care? No regrets when it comes to slow walking PPE and vaccinations in the season of Covid in Black and brown communities?' Stringer blasted the former governor's approval of a controversial cashless bail law. The ex-governor counterpunched at points. He accused his opponents of supporting defunding the police and attacked Mamdani's lack of experience in government — saying that it would hinder the democratic socialist's ability to fight Trump. 'Mr. Trump would go through Mr. Mamdani like a hot knife through butter,' Cuomo said. 'He would be Trump's delight.' Hitting back at Lander, Cuomo asserted the city comptroller approved contracts for organizations with ties to Lander's wife. 'Mr. Lander knows corruption,' Cuomo said. Lander called the claim 'a lie.' Trump, who is highly unpopular in this deep blue city, has affected the race during the last several months. Stringer has called him 'a schmuck' while Cuomo — who's been accused of his own overbearing behavior — has said the president is 'a bully.' Democratic Mayor Eric Adams is skipping his party's primary after he announced in April he would run as an independent in the general election. Eric Adams' perceived coziness with Trump before and after the Department of Justice dropped its corruption case against him earlier this year made it politically untenable to seek his party's nomination for a second term. Eric Adams was victorious four years ago running on a public safety platform as voters became preoccupied with Covid-era crime concerns. The mayor was barely mentioned Wednesday night, though Adrienne Adams, who is no relation, said she regretted supporting him in 2021. The Eric Adams-Trump saga has threatened to torch Cuomo as well. The reported Department of Justice probe of Cuomo followed a House GOP criminal referral that alleged the ex-governor lied during congressional testimony about his administration's report on Covid nursing home deaths. Cuomo insisted on the debate stage he didn't lie in his testimony. But asked directly if he had reviewed or edited the report, Cuomo dodged. 'I was very aware of the report,' Cuomo said to groans from several of his opponents. 'I stand by the report.' Cuomo's order to require that nursing homes admit Covid-positive patients has been a long running controversy for him. He's maintained that the state followed federal guidance, but reports by the state attorney general and comptroller found Cuomo's gubernatorial administration undercounted thousands of nursing home deaths. Cuomo's campaign has tried to leverage the federal probe into a political benefit to distance himself from Trump — even though as of Sunday he has yet to receive a subpoena or be contacted by investigators. He released an ad last month that highlighted fellow Democrats — including his foe, state Attorney General Letitia James — who are also under investigation by Trump's DOJ. Cuomo resigned in 2021 after James' office released a bombshell report that determined he sexually harassed 11 women. He has subsequently denied any wrongdoing after initially apologizing for his behavior. And he has expressed remorse for resigning — most recently with The New York Times — as the state Assembly was preparing to impeach him. On Wednesday, Cuomo denied the allegations were true: 'I said at the time it was political and it was false.' His name recognition, early endorsements and position in voter surveys — including surveys paid for by a lobbying firm that has provided free services to the ex-governor's campaign — have stoked a Cuomo narrative that his victory is inevitable. But polls have shown the former governor is highly unpopular. And critics have tried to undermine his claim of being a capable manager, pointing to his policies while governor on homelessness and mass transit — policies they assert have hurt the city. Cuomo's advantages remain numerous. A super PAC boosting Cuomo's candidacy, Fix the City, has spent more than $8 million on TV advertising, easily outpacing the other campaigns. The former governor has also received crucial endorsements from politically influential unions like 32BJ SEIU and the Hotel Trades and Gaming Council. The PAC has received donations from Trump supporters like William Ackman and DoorDash, a food delivery app that has lobbied on city regulations. Cuomo defended the support to Fix the City, which has come under scrutiny from campaign finance regulators who have accused him of illegally coordinating with the PAC. 'I work for the people of the state of New York, the people of the city of New York. I don't care who gave me what,' he said. 'I do what is right.' His campaign has portrayed New York as a city in crisis, beset with crime and homelessness that the former governor will be able to solve. Cuomo has leaned on a base that overlaps with Eric Adams: Blue-collar people of color and Jewish New Yorkers — blocs that are crucial to win citywide office. Mamdani, a state assemblymember, has emerged as Cuomo's most persistent electoral threat, placing second in most polls. An Emerson College survey found Cuomo defeating Mamdani by single digits in the final round of a ranked-choice voter simulation. Mamdani has gained attention through slickly produced videos on social media, though his proposals like government-run grocery stores, no-cost child care and free buses would run into cost realities at City Hall. The Queens state lawmaker wants to generate $10 billion in new taxes on rich New Yorkers and businesses, which would require Albany's approval. Mamdani has called for a rent freeze — and faulted Cuomo in the Wednesday debate for less-than-fulsome support for taxing the rich when he was governor. The democratic socialist has also come under scrutiny for his staunch criticisms of Israel and support for the boycott, divest and sanction movement. Courting Jewish voters, Cuomo has criticized Mamdani, along with opponents Lander and Adrienne Adams for what he has framed as less-than-fervent support for Israel. There was a carnival-like atmosphere outside of NBC's studios at 30 Rockefeller Center, where supporters of the candidates cheered their arrival. Mamdani walked in, backed by a brass band dubbed 'Horns for Zohran,' playing 'This Land is Your Land.' Cuomo had the biggest cheering section made up of union members from Laborers Local 79, the Hotel and Gaming Trades Council and the carpenters union. But the former governor kept them waiting. 'You sure he's coming? We're waiting for him,' an HTC member said. Candidates were asked to show up before 5:30 — Cuomo rolled up in his Dodge Charger almost an hour late and greeted the cheering crowd. Jeff Coltin contributed to this report.
Yahoo
40 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump administration ramps up attack on Harvard, Columbia
President Donald Trump ramped up his campaign against top US universities Wednesday, banning visas for all foreign students coming to attend Harvard and threatening to strip Columbia of its academic accreditation. Trump is seeking to bring the universities to heel with claims their international students pose a national security threat, and that they ignored anti-Semitism on campus, and perpetuate liberal bias. A proclamation issued by the White House late Wednesday declared that the entrance of international students to begin a course at Harvard would be "suspended and limited" for six months, and that existing overseas enrollees could have their visas terminated. "Harvard's conduct has rendered it an unsuitable destination for foreign students and researchers," said the order. "I'm trembling. This is outrageous," Karl Molden, a Harvard government and classics student from Austria, told AFP. "He is abusing his executive power to harm Harvard as much as he can." "My god!" said another international student at Harvard, who declined to be named for fear of retribution, on learning of the executive order. "This is such a disgrace." - 'Retaliatory' - The announcement came after the Trump administration's earlier efforts to terminate Harvard's right to enroll and host foreign students were stalled by a judge. The government already cut around $3.2 billion of federal grants and contracts benefiting Harvard and pledged to exclude the Cambridge, Massachusetts institution from any future federal funding. Harvard has been at the forefront of Trump's campaign against top universities after it defied his calls to submit to oversight of its curriculum, staffing, student recruitment and "viewpoint diversity." Trump has also singled out international students at Harvard, who in the 2024-2025 academic year accounted for 27 percent of total enrollment, and a major source of income. "This is yet another illegal retaliatory step taken by the Administration in violation of Harvard's First Amendment rights," a university spokesman said. "Harvard will continue to protect its international students." The latest sweeping action against Harvard came as Trump's education secretary threatened Wednesday to strip Columbia University of its accreditation. The Republican has targeted the New York Ivy League institution for allegedly ignoring harassment of Jewish students, throwing all of its federal funding into doubt. Unlike Harvard, several top institutions -- including Columbia -- have already bowed to far-reaching demands from the Trump administration, which claims that the educational elite is too left-wing. - 'Combating anti-Semitism' - But Wednesday's official action suggested it was not enough for Trump. "Columbia University looked the other way as Jewish students faced harassment," US Education Secretary Linda McMahon said on X. She accused the school of breaking rules prohibiting recipients of federal funding from discriminating on the basis of race, color, or national origin. "After Hamas' October 7, 2023, terror attack on Israel, Columbia University's leadership acted with deliberate indifference towards the harassment of Jewish students on its campus," McMahon said in a statement. "This is not only immoral, but also unlawful." In the statement, the US Education Department said its civil rights office had contacted Columbia's accreditation body about the alleged violation. Withdrawing Columbia's accreditation would see it lose access to all federal funding -- a very significant proportion of the university's income. Students attending the university would also not be able to receive federal grants and loans towards tuition. Critics accuse the Trump administration of using allegations of anti-Semitism to target educational elites and bring universities to their knees. The administration has already put $400 million of Columbia's funding under review, prompting the university in March to announce a package of concessions to the government around defining anti-Semitism, policing protests and conducting oversight for specific academic departments. Following Wednesday's announcement, a Columbia spokesperson said the university "aware of the concerns" raised by the government with its accreditation body. "We have addressed those concerns directly with Middle States," the spokesperson said, adding that "Columbia is deeply committed to combating anti-Semitism on our campus." "We take this issue seriously and are continuing to work with the federal government to address it." bur-gw/st
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Trump Hits Columbia With Big New Threat Even After It Caved
Surrender wasn't enough to spare Columbia University from Donald Trump's wrath. The Department of Education issued a new threat against Columbia Wednesday, this time targeting its accreditation. The department alleged that the elite New York City school was 'in violation of federal anti-discrimination laws' for failing to stamp out antisemitism on campus. The DOE's press release revealed that it had notified the organization responsible for ensuring that Columbia is in compliance with accreditation standards of the alleged violation. 'After Hamas' October 7, 2023, terror attack on Israel, Columbia University's leadership acted with deliberate indifference towards the harassment of Jewish students on its campus,' said Linda McMahon, Trump's education secretary. 'This is not only immoral, but also unlawful. Accreditors have an enormous public responsibility as gatekeepers of federal student aid.' The move is an escalation in Trump's war on top universities. Since March, the president's administration has frozen $400 million in federal funding to Columbia. The university acquiesced to Trump's list of demands that month—including a ban on face masks and a vow to harshly protest pro-Palestinian student protesters. Losing accreditation would strip the university of state and federal financial funding, such as Pell Grants for low-income students. It could also inflict damage to Columbia's reputation and make its undergraduates ineligible for many graduate programs. Columbia's accreditor, Middle States Commission on Higher Education (MSCHE), requires that it follow relevant laws. The Education Department is alleging that the university has violated the Civil Rights Act of 1964 by failing to 'meaningfully protect Jewish students against severe and pervasive harassment on Columbia's campus.' While the Department of Education plays a role in setting accreditation standards, the organizations that determine whether a university is following them, like the MSCHE, operate independently. The MSCHE told the Daily Beast in a statement that it had received the letter from the Education Department but declined to comment further. Columbia did not immediately return a request for comment. Last week, Trump praised Columbia's deference and said that the school had earned a reprieve from his attacks. 'You know, Columbia has been really—they were very, very bad, what they've done. They're very antisemitic and lots of other things,' he said. 'But they're working with us on finding a solution, and, you know, they're taken off that hot seat.' In the months since Columbia gave into Trump's demands, one of its peers, Harvard University, has fought a fierce legal battle to avoid following suit. Harvard's defiance has earned it an escalating series of punishments—$2.5 billion in frozen funds, a threat against its tax-exempt status, and a push to strip its ability enroll international students. Despite suffering losses in court, Trump has declared that he is winning the war. 'But Harvard wants to fight. They want to show how smart they are, and they're getting their a-- kicked,' the president said. Harvard's president, Alan Garber, has urged other colleges and universities to fight back against Trump. 'I would say that we need to be firm in our commitments to what we stand for,' he told NPR.
