logo
'The State Duma Has Proposed Banning...'

'The State Duma Has Proposed Banning...'

Memri16-07-2025
"The State Duma has proposed banning..." – this phrase, like a broken record, has been topping the news about Russian legislative activity for years. It seems that there is nothing left that our parliamentarians could not try to ban, and with severe consequences for violators! But now they have set their sights on something sacred – everything!
An initiative has been "wandering" in the corridors of the State Duma for a long time, trying to eliminate freedom of choice.
Deputy Speaker of the State Duma and former ombudsman for children's rights Anna Kuznetsova is lobbying for a bill aimed at eradicating "destructive ideology as a whole." Can you imagine the scale? Two volumes of research have already been prepared with the support of the Ministry of Science! It turns out that all of this is laid down in presidential decree No. 809 "On approval of the Fundamentals of state policy for the preservation and strengthening of traditional Russian spiritual and moral values." Until now, the decree was recalled to cite the list of "traditional values," so beloved by officials and clergy. And now, if Kuznetsova's initiative is implemented, ABSOLUTELY EVERYTHING can be banned! After all, "fundamentals" are not a joke, but a "strategic planning document in the sphere of ensuring national security of the Russian Federation." Everything is serious!
Elvira Kikhareva
They Intend To Ban Almost Anything
The list of "traditional values" in itself, it seems, is quite decent: life, dignity, patriotism, family, humanism, justice... Who would argue? But, as they say, the devil is in the details! It turns out to be a cognitive dissonance: either this is a traditional value, or a tool of the West for the destruction of sovereignty (and everything Western, in the opinion of the Russian elite, is pure evil).
After all, for some reason, the State Duma is in no hurry to discuss how to implement these values. It is much easier to ban something! And here comes the decree, which lists all the "enemies" that threaten our values: extremists (they are those who go out to the squares with a poster saying "no to war"), the media (numerous liberal publications that have been dispersed and banned by the authorities), the United States, and even some organizations and individuals within the country. Well, you get the idea – enemies are everywhere! At the same time, the very concept of "destructive ideology" is vague to the point of impossibility, which allows it to include absolutely everything that the Kremlin does not like. As a result, they intend to ban almost anything, and punish violations to the fullest extent of the law!
Who benefits from this? Yes, everyone who wants to curry favor with the authorities, the "experts" of Putin's pool, and, of course, law enforcement agencies. After all, it is much easier to catch "violators of ideology" than real criminals! Sleight of hand – and no miracles!
But in addition to the "bans" that Russians are accustomed to, there are also proposals. According to parliamentarians, they are very useful.
Russian lawmakers, no doubt motivated by concern for the welfare of citizens, have recently decided to expand the practice of forced labor for those who have committed minor offenses. Of course, this has nothing to do with the desperate shortage of labor in the economy, which the government modestly estimates at two million people. Just a coincidence...
So, the State Duma, in a fit of extraordinary generosity, on July 8 adopted a package of amendments that effectively introduce forced labor as a new type of punishment for as many as 45 articles of the code. Now, if you accidentally cause moderate harm to health or, say, involve a minor in innocent pranks, the court will happily give you the chance to work for the good of society in a correctional center for up to five years.
It is especially touching that "corrective labor" will also be applied to economic articles. Did you delay your employees' salaries for three months? Welcome to re-education through labor! Did you falsify reports? No big deal, forced labor will help you realize the depth of your fall.
The authors of this "brilliant" initiative claim that forced labor has an exclusively positive effect on crime prevention. Convicts, as one, demonstrate simply inhuman motivation to work, acquire valuable skills and, of course, are spiritually enriched.
It seems that it is time to open a network of free labor camps – those who want to will certainly line up!
We Get A Clear Example Of Slavery
As Russian legislative practice shows, at least in these few seemingly sarcastic, but in fact very symptomatic examples, any expansion of state powers can lead not only to selective application of the law in relation to citizens of a particular country, but also to the desire to expand these powers in foreign, neighboring, sovereign territories.
Undesirable officials, leaders of neighboring states, entrepreneurs, oppositionists or simply "wrong" citizens can end up in a correctional center for far-fetched reasons, be expelled from the country or forcibly sent to the front for the sake of someone's geopolitical ambitions. Today, there is practically no one to protect them from tyranny – they should have thought about this earlier.
As a result, we get a clear example of slavery: people are forced to live according to pre-written rules under the threat of punishment and a constant feeling of anxiety. And this is completely incompatible with the proclaimed values of freedom, justice and humanism.
The growth of state control over life and the suppression of dissent, which we see in the example of Russia, create an atmosphere of fear and suspicion. In such an environment, a constructive dialogue between the authorities and society is practically impossible, and any disagreement is dangerous for "national security."
It is especially alarming that such practices are increasingly justified by ideological cliches about "traditional values" and a "special path." These slogans serve as a cover for authoritarian methods of governance and suppression of freedoms under the pretext of the uniqueness of national character, allegedly incompatible with Western democracy.
Leading The Multi-Million Nation Into A Dead End
However, history proves that rights and freedoms are universal values, independent of geography or culture. The desire for justice, equality, and dignity is inherent in every person, regardless of nationality and beliefs. Attempts to justify restrictions on rights by referring to a "special path" and the adoption of dubious laws are just a disguise for the usurpation of power and the protection of the selfish interests of the ruling elite.
Ultimately, a strong and prosperous state can only be built by respecting rights and freedoms. An open society with guaranteed freedom of speech, assembly and an independent judicial system is the basis of the economy, science, and culture. Otherwise, the country is doomed to many years of stagnation, and legislators have no choice but to continue to strengthen control, passing more and more odious laws that help to preserve and extend their influence, but lead the multi-million nation into a dead end.
*Elvira Vikhareva is a renowned Russian opposition politician based in Russia. In 2023, she was poisoned with heavy metal salts.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Iraq expresses solidarity with Russia after plane crash
Iraq expresses solidarity with Russia after plane crash

Shafaq News

time4 hours ago

  • Shafaq News

Iraq expresses solidarity with Russia after plane crash

Shafaq News – Baghdad Iraq's Foreign Ministry expressed solidarity with Russia following the crash of an Antonov An-24 passenger plane in Tynda, Amur Oblast, in the Russian Far East, which claimed the lives of all on board. In a statement released on Thursday, the ministry extended 'its deepest condolences and sympathy to the families of the victims and the Russian people,' affirming Iraq's support for Russia 'in facing this painful tragedy.' Earlier in the day, the An-24 aircraft crashed while attempting to land at Tynda Airport during a flight from Blagoveshchensk. The plane was carrying 43 passengers and six crew members when contact was lost.

Rising Again To The Historical Moment
Rising Again To The Historical Moment

Memri

time6 hours ago

  • Memri

Rising Again To The Historical Moment

Although he deservedly prides himself on being a dealmaker, President Trump is an ideological leader defending Western civilization and its values. Realizing that he was facing an historical moment, he understood that he needed to make an ideological decision against Iran, and bombed the Iranian nuclear project – despite the opinion of Europeans who are collaborating with evil, and despite some opposition from his isolationist supporters. Thus, he set the ideological principle that a country ruled by jihadi ayatollahs cannot have nuclear weapons. This was a leadership decision. Like Franklin D. Roosevelt and Winston Churchill in World War II who decided to fight the ideological ambitions of Nazi Germany, Imperial Japan, and Fascist Italy, President Trump decided to fight the jihadi ayatollahs in Iran who openly strive to become a world power confronting the West. Now, President Trump needs to rise again to the historical moment, and make an ideological decision against Islamist powers – despite the Westerners who are collaborating with Islamism and despite the supporters of isolationism at home. It was relatively easy to rise up against Iran, which has incessantly proclaimed its hatred of America (even planning to assassinate him) and which built itself up with nuclear capabilities, missiles that reach America, and proxies that will attack American bases. It is far more difficult to do this when your Islamist enemies – Erdoğan, Qatar, and now Al-Sharaa, aka Al-Jolani – pretend to be your allies. There is no propaganda trick that they would not play to pretend to be America's friends. By now, Qatar's trick is well known: Create a problem, like supporting the Taliban for years up to their takeover of Afghanistan with American casualties, then help move American troops to safety, in what Trump called the "the greatest foreign policy humiliation" in U.S. history. Qatar does this everywhere on the planet. It supports Hamas, which committed the atrocities of October 7, and then presents itself as a mediator. Qatar supports every Islamist terrorist organization against its Westernized opponents. Erdoğan is an Islamist who seeks to revive the Ottoman Empire – note his occasional clashes with Greece and Cyprus, his enabling of foreign fighters to cross Turkish territory to reach the Islamic State, his hosting of the Hamas and Muslim Brotherhood headquarters in Turkey, his dispatch of troops to Libya to support the Islamist ruler in Tripoli, and more. Erdoğan acted like an ally of Trump by helping him eliminate the ISIS commander Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi, and thereby won Trump's trust. However, Erdoğan did it for his own sake, because Al-Baghdadi had claimed the role of leader of the believers (amir al-mu'minim ) – which Erdoğan saw as unnecessary rivalry. He was not doing Trump any favors. In the same way, Qatar's hosting of the CENTCOM base is no favor to Trump – on the contrary, it guarantees the very survival of the Qatari ruling family. Without the CENTCOM base, they would be wiped out by their neighbors in no time. As soon as they took over Syria, Al-Jolani's extremist jihadis in the guise of a legitimate army showed their fundamental ideology, putting into motion a process of massacring the country's minorities. First, the Alawites, then the Christians, and now the Druze. Next, it will be the Kurds – and, finally, the Jews in Israel. This is deeply entrenched in the Islamist DNA of jihadi terrorists like ISIS, Al-Qaeda, and, most recently, Pakistani jihadis in Kashmir. To the Islamists' bad luck, it blew up in their faces. The news of the horrible massacre of the Druze in Syria went viral all over the West, showing President Trump that he had perhaps been duped by Erdoğan, Qatar, and Al-Jolani. The massacre in Syria was no tribal accident, as the Islamists will probably tell Trump. Al-Jolani praised the jihadi perpetrators in his speech. They had carried out a deliberate Islamist attack on minorities. Earlier, in March, Al-Jolani had already penned a "constitutional" declaration setting out the ideological-religious grounds for such massacres. The isolationists in Trump's camp hastened to criticize Israel for its stopping of the massacre, calling Netanyahu a madman. How can Netanyahu be criticized for stopping a massacre? It is only isolationists who would criticize such a thing. But Trump is not fooled; he understands that something here stinks – that he has been duped by Erdoğan, Qatar, and Al-Jolani who posed as his allies and as guardians of human rights. President Trump will probably give Al-Jolani another chance. But the next massacre is already on its way. The Christians in Syria are seeking Trump's support, after they were bombed in their church in Damascus. They have already paid with their blood – and they know more is coming. Sometimes historical events are symbolized by individual cases. The real Al-Jolani, Erdoğan, and Qatar are represented by the execution of Hosam Saraya, a Syria-born Druze from Oklahoma, by Syrian government forces. American Druze Hosam Saraya executed by Syria government forces. President Trump now realizes that he must make a tough historical decision against Islamists who, unlike Iran, masquerade as allies of America. He already knows the bitter price he has to pay with his own supporters for rising up yet again to make an ideological historical decision for Western civilization. * Yigal Carmon is President and Founder of MEMRI.

Iraqi Resistance leader accuses US of "blatant interference" over PMF legislation
Iraqi Resistance leader accuses US of "blatant interference" over PMF legislation

Shafaq News

time6 hours ago

  • Shafaq News

Iraqi Resistance leader accuses US of "blatant interference" over PMF legislation

Shafaq News – Baghdad Qais al-Khazali, Secretary-General of Asaib Ahl al-Haq, a powerful Iran-aligned Shiite faction within the PMF, warned against US pressure on legislation related to the Popular Mobilization Forces (PMF). 'What is happening today is no longer mere diplomatic overreach—it is a clear assault on Iraqi sovereignty and a direct blow to the democratic process so often championed by the West,' al-Khazali stated. He criticized American efforts to influence the Iraqi legislative process, claiming they amount to political blackmail and the disruption of state institutions. 'Preventing parliament from fulfilling its legislative and oversight duties under American pressure is unacceptable,' he said, adding that yielding to such pressure would be tantamount to 'surrendering national decision-making and abandoning the will of the Iraqi people.' Al-Khazali also defended the rights of PMF fighters, saying they are not up for negotiation, insisting that passing legislation to protect their entitlements is a national and moral obligation, 'not a political option.' His remarks follow a statement by US State Department spokesperson Tammy Bruce, who said Secretary of State Marco Rubio had raised serious concerns with Iraqi Prime Minister Mohammed Shia al-Sudani over the proposed PMF law. According to Bruce, Rubio warned that the legislation would strengthen the role of armed groups. — قيس الخزعلي (@Qais_alkhazali) July 24, 2025

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store