Parents struggling with inflated baby formula prices and misleading health claims
Jess Brown-Fuller, a Liberal Democrat MP and chairwoman of the All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Infant Feeding, highlighted how new parents are particularly vulnerable.
She asserted that firms are "exploiting a legal loophole" to circumvent advertising regulations, further alleging that discounted product offerings to hospitals create the misleading impression of an NHS endorsement.
The report noted formula manufacturers hiked prices by an average of 25 per cent in the two years leading up to November 2023, with costs remaining at near-record levels.
This occurs despite the common parental misconception that a higher price tag equates to a more nutritious product, when regulations mandate all formula on the market must be nutritionally equivalent.
Ms Brown-Fuller told the PA news agency: 'There are parents who believe that by buying the more expensive formula, they are supporting their child's feeding or growth or potential more when actually all of those milks are nutritionally equivalent.'
There are even reports of parents buying more expensive formula but using fewer scoops per bottle to try and make it last longer, which Ms Brown-Fuller branded 'dangerous'.
These parents are doing what they think is best for their children, she said, when in reality there is 'no difference' between the £14 tub and £7 tub of formula.
The Liberal Democrat noted that companies will use their packaging to 'imply a nutritional superiority', with phrases like 'nutritionally complete' or 'supports a healthy immune system'.
She asked: 'Where is the evidence that suggests that that formula is in any way a boost to an infant's immune system above any others?'
Meanwhile, other formulas will write 'with added…' and name ingredients like Omega 3, certain vitamins, or iron.
Ms Brown-Fuller said: 'It has to have a certain number of nutrients in it anyway. And anything that is additional potentially shouldn't be in there because they are working around a very strict compliance code.'
She explained: 'They wouldn't be able to make these bold claims if they were a medication but, because it's a food, it's a source of nutrition, they're not held to the same standards.'
Meanwhile, it is illegal to advertise newborn formula in the UK but firms are allowed to advertise follow-on milk for babies that are six months and older.
This is because World Health Organisation (WHO) guidance is that breast milk should be the main source of nutrition for all infants until they are six months old, and a lack of advertising regulation is linked to lower breastfeeding rates.
Ms Brown-Fuller said: 'There is a direct correlation between countries that have no regulation around formula marketing and drastic reductions in breastfeeding.
'So that is why the Government did introduce regulation around advertising of formula milk because the numbers of breastfeeding mothers was dramatically reducing.'
The UK scores just 48 out of 100 overall on a range of infant-feeding metrics, according to the World Breastfeeding Trends Initiative.
However, to get around these regulations, formula companies advertise for their follow-on milk and 'make all their packaging look exactly the same to anybody that was just perusing the shelves'.
The Chichester MP said: 'They're exploiting a legal loophole, because it is a legal loophole, but they've totally blurred the lines through similar branding.'
Another form of 'exploitative' marketing, she argued, is that formula companies will sell their formula into healthcare professional environments like maternity units or neonatal units for a hugely reduced price.
Purchase habits show strong brand loyalty when it comes to formula, with parents rarely switching brands once they have introduced a particular one to their baby.
It is also argued that brand presence in a healthcare setting gives the 'fake impression of an NHS endorsement'.
Ms Brown-Fuller told PA: 'They know that if they get the parents to use that in a hospital setting, the likelihood is that that is the formula they will then use when they go home.'
The CMA has put forward 11 recommendations to address these issues, aiming to strengthen labelling and advertising rules, better inform parents to make choices in retail environments and to eliminate brand influence in healthcare settings with standardised packaging.
Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: 'As part of our Plan for Change, we're determined to ensure every child has the best start to life.
'There are many benefits of breastfeeding but for those mothers that cannot or choose not to breastfeed, it is vital parents can access infant formula that is affordable and high quality. Families should not be paying over the odds to feed their babies.
'We are working closely with the devolved governments to carefully consider the CMA's recommendations and will respond fully in due course.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
The best supermarket cakes to bring with you to a Macmillan Coffee Morning
Macmillan Coffee Morning is celebrating 35 years of bringing people together to raise money for those living with cancer. Since 1990, the fundraising event has raised more than £300m for Macmillan Cancer Support. In 2024 alone, the charity provided vital support to around 2.4 million people affected by cancer across the UK. The charity's famous Coffee Morning event is a chance for people to get involved and donate to the cause. The idea is simple: bring baked treats for the group to eat while enjoying a cup of coffee or tea and ask everyone to donate money while having a good time. You can make it as wild or as simple as you like; whether it's organised among teachers and parents at a school, a sober rave with a group of colleagues at work or in your living room with friends. And there's no reason to stick to coffee and cakes, mix things up by organising a Coffee Morning with a difference. Macmillan Cancer Support makes it easy for hosts with information and advice online on how to organise the event, and a fundraising kit that contains everything from balloons and bunting to posters and food labels. Want to be a Coffee Morning Host? Traditionally, people bake their own cakes to take to Macmillan Coffee Mornings. But if you're strapped for time (or skills), then this shouldn't dissuade you from taking part. Requiring minimal effort but often tasting just as nice, supermarket cakes are equally well-received. But with all the biggest supermarkets vying for your attention, which cake should you buy? If you're joining a Macmillan Coffee Morning soon and need some inspiration, the IndyBest team has tried and tasted the best supermarket cakes to enjoy with a cuppa (someone had to do it). How we tested The team sampled these cakes one by one, considering freshness, flavour, ingredients and the concept behind each. From classic carrot cake and tiered extravaganzas to rich red velvet and a spongey take on Eton mess, these are our favourites. The best supermarket cakes for 2025 are: Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Joanna Lyall obituary
During her long journalistic career, my friend Joanna Lyall, who has died aged 76, challenged preconceptions about what people with cancer needed to know about their illness. She also raised awareness about health and social issues such as bereavement, child carers and living with chronic illness. In the mid 1980s, when she proposed a book to enable people with cancer to make informed decisions about their care, patient-focused information was limited. In Living With Cancer (1987), which we co-authored, Joanna dug deep into the emotional, social and financial challenges, and told the human story of cancer through patient experiences with her trademark compassion. Born in Pimlico, central London, to Joan (nee Kenny) and Robert Lyall, an advertising executive, Joanna attended Our Lady of Sion Convent, in Bayswater, and later studied English and French at University College Dublin. After working for the Kensington Post and the Western Daily Press in Bristol, Joanna joined General Practitioner (GP) in 1977, before turning freelance in 1980. By subsequently writing for both healthcare users, in newspapers such as the Guardian and Sunday Times, and care providers in GP, Nursing Times and the Health Service Journal, Joanna took her message about the need for jargon-free communication, shared decision making, and both specialist care, to a wide audience. Joanna had strong French roots; an aunt was in the French Resistance during the second world war, and an uncle helped run an escape line across occupied France. Another uncle, Desmond Knox-Leet, co-founded Diptyque, which Joanna saw grow from a small shop in Paris in the 1960s to a global luxury perfume brand. From 2010 to 2020, Joanna was honorary secretary of the Pugin Society and, through her writing, highlighted the significance of Pugin in 19th-century architecture and design. Her genuine interest in other people's lives led her into obituary writing for the Guardian and the British Medical Journal. When diagnosed with pancreatic cancer earlier this year, Joanna refused to ask: 'Why me?' and said she didn't feel 'shortchanged in the longevity stakes'. Like many of the people she had interviewed nearly four decades earlier, her request was for effective symptom control and her long-held belief in the importance of good palliative care proved justified. Joanna was a much loved friend to a large circle of people. She is survived by her brother, Michael, her nieces, Alexandra and Katharine, her great-niece, Julia, and great-nephews, George and László.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Urgent warning after synthetic opioids linked to 38 deaths in Scotland over just three months
Public Health Scotland has issued a warning over nitazenes, a synthetic opioid, after the drug was linked to 38 deaths in Scotland in just three months. These laboratory-made substances are most commonly found as contaminants in drugs sold as heroin, benzodiazepines, and oxycodone. They have been increasingly identified in post-mortem examinations. An alert, issued through the Rapid Actions Drug Alerts and Response (Radar) led by PHS, highlights the "substantial risk of overdose, hospitalisation and death." PHS stated the alert was issued "to respond to increasing harms and availability in the drugs supply," citing recent Radar data indicating increased detection of nitazene-type opioids in hospital and post-mortem toxicology. Between January and March 2025, nitazenes were detected in 38 deaths. Drugs minister Maree Todd said the synthetic drugs could be 'hundreds' of times stronger than typical drugs. Ms Todd said: 'Every drug death is a tragedy, and my condolences go to anyone who has lost a loved one. 'We are working hard to respond to the growing threat from highly dangerous synthetic opioids like nitazenes. 'These synthetic drugs can be hundreds of times more potent than heroin and can increase the risk of overdose, hospitalisation and death. 'Because of their strength, I would urge anyone who carries naloxone to have extra life-saving kits with them and follow guidance on the Public Health Scotland and Scottish Drugs Forum websites. 'I am determined to do more to tackle the harm caused by drugs and that is why we are providing record levels of funding for drugs and alcohol programmes, including widening access to treatment, residential rehabilitation and life-saving naloxone. 'We have also opened the UK's first safer drug consumption facility, which is saving lives, and are working at pace to deliver drug-checking facilities.'
