'Apparent failure' of Windsor police board in dealing with chief's racist remarks, police group says
On Monday, CBC News published information based on a summary of an internal investigation into racism complaints against Windsor police chief Jason Bellaire. That investigation was finished in January.
The internal probe substantiated allegations that Bellaire made comments that violated Windsor police directives, according to the summary, which didn't specify what remarks he's said to have made.
Inspector Ed Armstrong filed that internal complaint. He also filed a Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario complaint outlining his allegations.
Armstrong described several racist comments he said Bellaire made to him at work, including a joke about bananas and Black people, asking him to use his "Black magic" and saying he needed a "Black friend" to accompany him to certain events.
Mark Baxter, president of the Police Association of Ontario, said the group "condemns" such comments.
"This kind of behaviour erodes public trust and undermines the integrity of the work of police service members to ensure the safety and security of our communities," he said in a statement.
"People in Windsor deserve to know that the chief of police — the head of the police service — is being held to the highest standard, is not discriminating against his service members and is serving all people equitably inclusive of race," he added.
The advocacy organization represents the members of 45 police unions across Ontario — some 31,000 officers and civilian employees.
Both Armstrong and Bellaire did not respond to requests from CBC News for a comment.
When asked in an email to confirm whether the allegations against Bellaire were substantiated, Windsor police spokesperson Gary Francoeur said "The information in your message is not entirely accurate."
He refused to clarify what he meant, stating he can't comment further because it's before the human rights tribunal.
A spokesperson for the Windsor Police Services Board wouldn't answer questions about what consequences, if any, Bellaire will face for his comments that violated internal directives.
"The Windsor Police Service Board will make no comment on personnel matters regarding a specific employee," said Norma Coleman, Windsor police board administrative director.
The PAO is demanding "full transparency" so the Windsor police board can "restore confidence in their leadership."
"Equally concerning is the apparent failure of the Windsor Police Services Board to take swift and decisive action in holding the chief accountable. Leadership in policing must be held to the highest standard, and when those in positions of power fail to uphold those values, it sends a damaging message to members and the communities we proudly serve," said Baxter.
'Lack of transparency' is deeply concerning, says PAO
The union representing Windsor police officers, the Windsor Police Association, previously told CBC News that it too is seeking accountability from the board.
"What I do find troubling is that the police services board has been aware of this issue for several weeks and has yet to address it, either with my membership or the public. This lack of transparency and action is deeply concerning," president Kent Rice said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
an hour ago
Heavy-handed use of labour code has painted federal government into a corner, unions say
The federal government's repeated use of the Canada Labour Code to force picketing employees back to work has undermined its ability to end strikes while setting it up for a fight with Canada's labour movement, union officials and experts say. Their comments come days after federal Jobs and Families Minister Patty Hajdu's failed move to send striking Air Canada flight attendants back to work and have the Canadian Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) step in and arbitrate their dispute with the airline. The union representing the airline's 10,000 flight attendants defied the CIRB, saying its members would remain on strike until Air Canada returned to the table to continue negotiating. The fact that we didn't back down — the government and the company got the message that we weren't going to react to their demands, their threats, legal action, jail time, whatever it was, CUPE national president Mark Hancock told CBC News. When they finally figured out that the only place a deal was going to be found was at the table, that's when they came back to the table. Hancock noted that while eight months of negotiations between the airline and the union couldn't land a deal, once it was clear the union was not going to respect the CIRB order, both parties came to an agreement in just seven hours to end the strike which began Aug. 16. Federal labour ministers can exercise their authority under Section 107 of the Canada Labour Code to direct the CIRB to end a strike and take over arbitration of a labour dispute. Section 107 has been a part of the code since 1984 and was rarely used, but in the last year the Liberal government has invoked multiple times. It used the provision to end a labour dispute between the union and Canada's two largest railway companies (new window) , a labour disruption at ports in Montreal and Vancouver (new window) , and to send striking Canada Post workers and the Crown corporation (new window) into binding arbitration. The last couple of years [Section 107] seems to be the government's go-to when a difficult round of bargaining is occurring, Hancock said. I think this experience this past week has shown them that 107 is not effective. Provoking a general strike Canadian Labour Congress president Bea Bruske told CBC News that she thinks the Liberal government made a mistake in using Section 107 so often, and will now have to face the consequences of an emboldened labour movement. They underestimated the workers' demand for a fair collective agreement, and the fact that they were prepared to defy an order by the CIRB in order to make that happen, she said. The union's defiance of the directive from the CIRB means that Section 107 effectively is dead, Bruske added. It means that workers understand that the employer always has a better deal to offer and will push for it. Gilles LeVasseur, a professor of law and management at the University of Ottawa, told CBC News that ignoring a CIRB notice to get back to work and the bargaining table is unlawful. Watch | Section 107 and the Air Canada strike, explained: Individual union members could be fined up to $1,000 a day and unions could face fines of up to $100,000 a day for refusing to comply. But to enforce the order, LeVasseur said, either Air Canada or the CIRB has to file it in federal court — something the CIRB said would be unduly punitive and not conducive to harmonious labour relations and constructive collective bargaining. LeVasseur said when the CIRB announced it would not file the order in federal court, it made it easy for flight attendants and the union to refuse to comply. Going forward, LeVasseur said, the unions know they have the advantage. He said that in future, the CIRB could go to court to enforce a Section 107 order, but that might just result in opposition to the provision rising to the next level. Other unions may say, 'Well, let's put it all together and make it a national strike for all these unions,' he said. That's the danger." A campaign against Sect. 107 Bruske said the failure of Section 107 has sent a message to employers that they should forget about the federal government using the measure to bail them out of labour negotiations. She said that when Parliament resumes, the Canadian Labour Congress, an umbrella organization for labour unions across the country, will work with unions to ensure Section 107 is taken out of the labour code. Everybody in the labour movement, regardless of what union you come from, whether you're private or public sector, or you're a trades union, we are on the same page, Bruske said. Section 107 is a high priority and it's got to go. Hancock agrees, saying that at least if a union is legislated back to work, there is a democratic process because it's debated and voted on in Parliament, whereas Section 107 avoids that step by giving power directly to the minister. LeVasseur points out that is particularly handy during minority parliaments when the party in power may not have the votes to get back-to-work legislation passed, but it comes with the criticism that Charter-protected rights are being violated. In this case … very few people decided to take away our members' rights to free collective bargaining in this process, Hancock said. We will continue to work with others in the labour movement to make sure Section 107 is never used again in any union in and around bargaining. Peter Zimonjic (new window) · CBC News · Senior writer Peter Zimonjic is a senior writer for CBC News who reports for digital, radio and television. He has worked as a reporter and columnist in London, England, for the Telegraph, Times and Daily Mail, and in Canada for the Ottawa Citizen, Torstar and Sun Media. He is the author of Into The Darkness: An Account of 7/7, published by Vintage.
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
Toronto teacher fired for wearing blackface costume should be reinstated: arbitrator
An Ontario arbitrator has ruled that a Toronto high school teacher who was fired after wearing a Halloween costume involving blackface four years ago should be reinstated and compensated for lost wages. In a decision last week, arbitrator Norm Jesin wrote that the teacher had gone to Parkdale Collegiate Institute in October 2021 after dressing in black clothes, wearing a black face mask and painting his face black to present 'a scary persona, like that of a zombie' for Halloween. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The decision says multiple students were upset by the teacher's blackface after he removed the black mask while teaching and later attended a school assembly. It says the Toronto District School Board fired the teacher after an investigation, but the Ontario Secondary School Teachers' Federation called it 'an excessive response' given the teacher did not intend to cause harm and had immediately apologized. Jesin wrote in his decision that the teacher took courses on anti-Black racism and expressed remorse for his actions before he was restored to 'good standing' by the Ontario College of Teachers on Oct. 1, 2023, so he should be reinstated with no loss of seniority and compensated for lost wages since that date. Story continues below advertisement The Canadian Press has reached out to the TDSB and the OSSTF for comment.
Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Toronto teacher fired for wearing blackface costume should be reinstated: arbitrator
TORONTO – An Ontario arbitrator has ruled that a Toronto high school teacher who was fired after wearing a Halloween costume involving blackface four years ago should be reinstated and compensated for lost wages. In a decision last week, arbitrator Norm Jesin wrote that the teacher had gone to Parkdale Collegiate Institute in October 2021 after dressing in black clothes, wearing a black face mask and painting his face black to present 'a scary persona, like that of a zombie' for Halloween. The decision says multiple students were upset by the teacher's blackface after he removed the black mask while teaching and later attended a school assembly. It says the Toronto District School Board fired the teacher after an investigation, but the Ontario Secondary School Teachers' Federation called it 'an excessive response' given the teacher did not intend to cause harm and had immediately apologized. Jesin wrote in his decision that the teacher took courses on anti-Black racism and expressed remorse for his actions before he was restored to 'good standing' by the Ontario College of Teachers on Oct. 1, 2023, so he should be reinstated with no loss of seniority and compensated for lost wages since that date. The Canadian Press has reached out to the TDSB and the OSSTF for comment. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 20, 2025.
