Judge allows 14 states' lawsuit against Elon Musk and DOGE to proceed
A federal judge allowed a lawsuit accusing Elon Musk and the Department of Government Efficiency of illegally exerting power over government operations to move forward Tuesday.
The big picture: The suit filed by more than a dozen Democratic state attorneys general alleges the billionaire and DOGE violated the Constitution by accessing government data systems, terminating federal employees and canceling contracts at federal agencies.
The states also argued Musk exercised "virtually unchecked power" across the executive branch.
Driving the news: U.S. District Court Judge Tanya Chutkan denied a motion to dismiss the case.
She wrote in a 42-page order: "The Constitution does not permit the Executive to commandeer the entire appointments power by unilaterally creating a federal agency pursuant to Executive Order and insulating its principal officer from the Constitution as an 'advisor' in name only," the judge wrote. "This is precisely what Plaintiffs claim the Executive has done."
Chutkan did, however, dismiss President Trump as a defendant, writing that "the court may not enjoin the President in the performance of his official duties."
What they're saying: New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez said in a statement Tuesday that the decision "is an important milestone for preserving America's system of checks and balances."
"We are proud to move this case forward and help bring Elon Musk's reign of terror to an end," Torrez said.
The White House did not immediately respond to Axios' request for comment.
Context: Democratic attorneys general in 14 states sued President Trump, Musk and DOGE in February alleging violations of the Constitution's Appointments Clause and conduct in excess of statutory authority.
The judge in the same month denied a request from the states to temporarily block DOGE from accessing data and terminating federal employees, though she did find that there were valid questions about Musk's authority.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Gov. Lamont: Budget on the ‘1-yard line'
HARTFORD, Conn. (WTNH) — Gov. Ned Lamont said a deal on the next two-year state budget is 'virtually there.' Lamont has been in closed-door negotiations with the Democratic leaders of the state legislature for several days now hammering out the details of the spending plan. Connecticut lawmakers 'close to a deal' on two-year state budget, Speaker Matt Ritter says This is the centerpiece of the legislative session is the culmination of months of deliberation.A two-year, budget over $50 billion dollar that funds everything from Medicaid to UConn to the state police to aid that local school districts rely on. The overarching issue is how to reconcile differences between the governor and his fellow democrats in the legislature over how much to increase spending by. Democrats wanted to present increases that were larger than the ones put forth by Gov. Lamont. Watch the video in the player above. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
State Dept says DOGE's changes will be permanent amid Musk's departure
Elon Musk may no longer be the top dog at DOGE, but his reforms at the State Department will remain permanently in place, a senior agency official told Fox News Digital Thursday. As Musk's 130-day mandate as a "special government employee" comes to an end, the billionaire entrepreneur announced his departure from DOGE in a post on his social media platform X, formerly Twitter, Wednesday night. During Musk's time as the head of DOGE, he helped usher in big reforms at the State Department, which included an effective dismantlement of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), staff reductions, and the cancellation of various foreign aid programs due to lack of oversight, inefficiency, and other reasons. What's Next For Doge After Elon Musk's Departure? 'Only Just Begun' The indication that Musk's DOGE-related work at the State Department will continue was reinforced by a new reorganization effort at the Department of State announced by Secretary Marco Rubio on Thursday. The new reorganization plans are expected to cut or consolidate more than 300 of the State Department's offices and bureaus as part of a massive overhaul aimed at streamlining the department, according to agency officials. The agency currently has about 700 offices, meaning the reorganization effort will slash, or join, more than 40% of its offices. Read On The Fox News App "We have too many godd--- offices," a senior State Department official told Fox News Digital. "We're trying to shrink offices rather than create them." White House Discloses Who Will Lead Doge Efforts After Musk's Departure The State Department submitted a notice to Congress Thursday disclosing plans for the reorganization overhaul, which senior State Department officials said will be the largest restructuring for the agency since the Cold War. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt added Thursday that many DOGE employees will remain part of the Trump administration, despite Musk winding down his work. "Surely the mission of Doge will continue," Leavitt told reporters Thursday. "Many Doge employees are now political employees." One of Musk's DOGE associates, Jeremy Lewin, has recently been tapped for a top role within the State Department. In April, he was placed at State for a different role. For his part, Lewin, however, disputes that he ever did any direct work for Musk's article source: State Dept says DOGE's changes will be permanent amid Musk's departure
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Musk aiming to send uncrewed Starship to Mars by end of 2026
By Steve Gorman and Joey Roulette LOS ANGELES (Reuters) -Two days after the latest in a string of test-flight setbacks for his big new Mars spacecraft, Starship, Elon Musk said on Thursday he foresees the futuristic vehicle making its first uncrewed voyage to the red planet at the end of next year. Musk presented a detailed Starship development timeline in a video posted online by his Los Angeles area-based rocket company, SpaceX, a day after saying he was departing the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump as head of a tumultuous campaign to slash government bureaucracy. The billionaire entrepreneur had said earlier that he was planning to scale back his role in government to focus greater attention on his various businesses, including SpaceX and electric car and battery maker Tesla Inc. Musk acknowledged that his latest timeline for reaching Mars hinged on whether Starship can accomplish a number of challenging technical feats during its flight-test development, particularly a post-launch refueling maneuver in Earth orbit. The end of 2026 would coincide with a slim window that occurs once every two years when Mars and Earth align around the sun for the closest trip between the two planets, which would take seven to nine months to transit by spacecraft. Musk gave his company a 50-50 chance of meeting that deadline. If Starship were not ready by that time, SpaceX would wait another two years before trying again, Musk suggested in the video. The first flight to Mars would carry a simulated crew consisting of one or more robots of the Tesla-built humanoid Optimus design, with the first human crews following in the second or third landings. Musk said he envisioned eventually launching 1,000 to 2,000 ships to Mars every two years to quickly establish a self-sustaining permanent human settlement. NASA is currently aiming to return humans to the surface of the moon aboard Starship as early as 2027 - more than 50 years after its last manned lunar landings of the Apollo era - as a stepping stone toward ultimately launching astronauts to Mars sometime in the 2030s. Musk, who has advocated for a more Mars-focused human spaceflight program, has previously said he was aiming to send an unmanned SpaceX vehicle to the red planet as early as 2018 and was targeting 2024 to launch a first crewed mission there. The SpaceX founder was scheduled to deliver a livestream presentation billed as "The Road to Making Life Multiplanetary" from the company's Starbase, Texas, launch site on Tuesday night, following a ninth test flight of Starship that evening. But the webcast was canceled without notice after Starship spun out of control and disintegrated in a fireball about 30 minutes after launch and roughly halfway through its flight path without achieving some of its most important test goals. Two preceding test flights in January and March failed in more spectacular fashion, with the spacecraft blowing to pieces on ascent moments after liftoff, raining debris over parts of the Caribbean and forcing scores of commercial jetliners to change course as a precaution. Musk shrugged off the latest mishap on Tuesday with a brief post on X, saying it produced a lot of "good data to review" and promising a faster launch "cadence" for the next several test flights.
