Withdrawal of Takeover Proposal for Seven & i: How to Increase Corporate Value Remains a Challenge
Leading Canadian convenience store operator Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. has withdrawn its proposal to acquire Seven & i Holdings Co. for about ¥7 trillion. The Canadian company made the proposal in July last year and continued negotiations, but it broke them off, citing a 'lack of constructive engagement' as the reason for the withdrawal.
In response, Seven & i countered that the criticism missed the mark.
The public was highly interested in the developments of the takeover bid. Would the meticulous management of the Seven-Eleven convenience store chain, which has become a part of the social infrastructure, be maintained under the umbrella of a foreign company?
However, the reality is likely that the talks between Seven & i, which insisted on pursuing its growth independently, and Couche-Tard ended without deepening substantive discussions on specific measures to improve corporate value. The negative side of the situation was that the two sides were so busy in a tug-of-war with each other that they were unable to sufficiently work out business improvement measures.
Going forward, Seven & i will need to quickly improve its corporate value. This is because the company has been pursuing structural reforms, including the separation of struggling Ito-Yokado Co., but is only halfway through to restoring profitability.
The recent share prices of Seven & i are more than 20% lower than the acquisition prices offered by Couche-Tard. If the growth strategy stalls and the stock prices remain stagnant, Seven & i could become a takeover target again.
The biggest challenge for Seven & i is to rebuild its overseas convenience store business, which accounts for about 70% of its total sales. It has over 10,000 stores in the United States, more than any other convenience store company, but the firm is unable to fully grasp the needs of the local market.
On the other hand, the Seven-Eleven convenience store chain, which ranks top in Japan, has increased sales at relatively high prices with the selling points of its brand power and the quality of its products.
Has the long experience of success caused Seven & i to become complacent? It has been pointed out that, amid prolonged high prices, the company was slow to introduce products with the sense of affordability demanded by consumers. To accelerate growth, it will be necessary to consider measures to form a new partnership, among other steps.
In recent years, mergers and acquisitions of Japanese companies by foreign firms have become prominent, partly due to the trend of the yen's depreciation. It can be said that the current times are an era in which even well-known companies have become targets of acquisition by foreign companies.
Companies will be required to consider takeover proposals impartially from the standpoint of shareholders. It will also be vital to thoroughly fulfill their accountability and work to implement highly transparent management.
Japanese companies' internal reserves have grown to about ¥600 trillion, but the money is not allocated to investment in growth. This is also reflected in the form of undervalued stock prices. Companies should develop growth strategies and actively promote investment.
(From The Yomiuri Shimbun, July 23, 2025)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Asahi Shimbun
3 hours ago
- Asahi Shimbun
Royal Holdings in tie-up to open 21 luxury hotels in Japan by 2035
An architectural rendering of a high-end hotel and resort facility under Minor Hotels' Anantara brand, slated to open in 2030 in Karuizawa, Nagano Prefecture. The facility overlooking Mount Asamayama will boast a 100-meter-long roof. (Provided by Royal Holdings Co.) Restaurant operator Royal Holdings Co. is teaming up with Minor Hotels, the largest hotel group in Southeast Asia, to develop luxury hotel accommodation in the Japanese market. The company plans to open 21 hotels across Japan by 2035, targeting wealthy foreign tourists from the more than 36 million people who visit each year. Based in Thailand, Minor Hotels operates more than 560 luxury hotels and resort facilities in 57 countries. It is also a member of the Global Hotel Alliance, the world's largest alliance of independent hotel brands, serving 30 million members. It will be Minor Hotels' first foray into Japan. Royal Holdings and Minor Hotels established a joint venture earlier this year. On July 10, they unveiled plans to open Anantara Karuizawa Retreat, a hotel and resort facility, in Karuizawa, Nagano Prefecture, in 2030, partnering with general real estate firm List Group. Anantara is Minor Hotels' flagship brand. Situated on a 42,000-square-meter plot overlooking Mount Asamayama, the facility will have 51 guest rooms, of which 23 are suites, It will also boast a spa, swimming pool and restaurants. The companies are preparing to apply for confirmation for construction. Accommodation fees and other details have yet to be determined. William Heinecke, founder and chairman of Minor International, which operates Minor Hotels under its umbrella, told a news conference in Tokyo that Japan is the first choice of overseas destination for Thai people. He expressed gratitude that the globally recognized hotel brand of Anantara had been accepted in the Japanese market. Royal Holdings started in-flight catering services and operating a cafe at Fukuoka Airport in 1951. The company has operated the Royal Host family restaurant chain as well as the Shakey's pizza chain since the 1970s. In addition, it operates restaurants at airports, expressway facilities and hospitals, and runs Tenya, a restaurant chain specializing in tempura rice bowls. As for its hotel business, the company opened its first Roynet Hotel (present-day Richmond Hotel) in 1995. It currently manages 43 Richmond Hotels, which target business travelers. 'We want to operate hotels aimed at wealthy visitors from abroad in tourism destinations and cities around the country as a way to expand the scope of our business,' said Royal Holdings President Masataka Abe.
Yomiuri Shimbun
4 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Trump Executive Order Sets No Date to Cut Auto Tariff;U.S., Japan Begin to Diverge on What Agreement Means
Uncertainty has yet to be dispelled over details of an agreed-upon automobile tariff to be imposed on Japan by the United States. An executive order issued Thursday by the White House to impose a 15% tariff on Japan will place a heavy burden on Japanese companies. But the order did not specify an actual date for when the duty on automobiles will be reduced from the current 27.5% to 15%. The Japanese government has boasted of that reduction as the key result of its recent tariff negotiations with the United States. 'It is so disappointing, as we were hoping that [the auto tariff] would be reduced at the same time as the reduction of the 'reciprocal tariff,'' an executive of a leading automaker said after learning that the executive order issued by U.S. President Donald Trump made no mention of an automobile tariff. Since April, a 27.5% tariff has been levied on automobiles. The recent Japan-U.S. agreement is supposed to reduce the tariff to 15%, but when it will be implemented is uncertain. The car tariff squeezes manufacturers' bottom lines. 'It is becoming a burden day by day,' said a senior automaker official. 'We hope the updated tariff rate will be applied as soon as possible.' Economic revitalization minister Ryosei Akazawa said Friday, 'We will urge [the United States] to take steps to fulfill the agreement as soon as possible.' However, the reciprocal tariff and the car tariff are based on different laws. The United Kingdom waited more than a month to see a lower tariff levied on its cars after reaching an agreement with the United States. Many products affected Meanwhile, the reciprocal tariff on most Japanese exports will be set at 15% from Thursday. 'While the hurdle has been lowered [from the initially announced rate], the impact of the tariff remains unclear,' said Hitoshi Suzuki, president of sake brewery Ichinokura Co. in Osaki, Miyagi Prefecture. Riding a Japanese cuisine boom, Ichinokura has built up its exports to the United States, and the tariff hike comes as a significant blow. Sake was subject to nearly zero tariffs at 3 cents per liter, but that will now rise to 15%. Tariffs on fishery products will also increase. A seafood processing company in Mombetsu, Hokkaido, has doubled its scallop exports to the United States since China imposed an import ban on Japanese seafood products in 2023. 'If we pass on the tariff increase through our prices, customers in the United States may hesitate to buy,' the president of the company said. According to the Japanese government, products with original tariff rates of 15% or higher will continue to be subject to the same tariff rates. This was a special measure agreed upon between the European Union and the United States, and Japan had also agreed to the same mechanism. However, this was not explicitly stated in Thursday's executive order. Even Akazawa, who led the negotiations, told reporters Friday, 'We need to examine the details' of the agreements. No joint document made The lack of a joint agreement document has also made the deal unclear. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said in an interview with Fox News on July 23, 'We'll evaluate [Japan's performance] every quarter and if the president's unhappy then we'll boomerang it back to the 25% tariff rate, both on cars and the rest of their products.' Itochu Corp. Executive Vice President Tsuyoshi Hachimura said Friday at a press conference: 'The agreement has not been put into writing, and there is even talk of evaluating [Japan's performance], so nothing has been decided yet. At this stage, it is better not to be too positive.' The government also intends to take domestic measures. 'We will make every effort to mitigate the impact on industry and employment, such as providing financial support,' Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba said when he heard opinions from the automobile industry in Tokyo on Thursday. Saisuke Sakai of Mizuho Research & Technologies, Ltd. pointed out uncertainty for companies, saying that the impact on small and medium-sized enterprises would be particularly significant. 'It is necessary for the public and private sectors to work together not only to provide financial support to companies but also to help them shift away from dependence on exports to the United States and develop products with high added value,' Sakai said.
Nikkei Asia
16 hours ago
- Nikkei Asia
Toyota expands procurement of Chinese parts in Thailand
Toyota Motor looks to use more Chinese components in Thailand, the home of its biggest production hub in Southeast Asia. (Photo by Yuki Kohara) KENYA AKAMA BANGKOK -- Toyota Motor is expanding procurement of Chinese parts in Thailand, home to its largest Southeast Asian production hub, seeking less costly components to improve the competitiveness of a new electrified model scheduled for 2028. The Japanese automaker has begun full-fledged procurement of components made by Chinese companies in Thailand, sources say. It connected Thailand's Summit Group, a major supplier in the country, with China's Wuhu Yuefei Sound-absorbing New Materials. The two companies formed a joint venture in January and plan to build a Thai plant that produces parts for Toyota, a source said.
