The highs and lows of Canada Day free agency for Maple Leafs
Make that a lower-case 'f' in what's usually Free Agent Frenzy on Canada Day.
Given some of the biggest decisions were settled before noon on July 1, there's not a lot of thunder expected from teams such as the Maple Leafs.
Article content
But Toronto has never shied away from significant UFA moves in the past, some with the desired boost , others that were busts.
Article content
HITS
2024 – G Anthony Stolarz.
From a back-up role in Florida to the NHL's regular seasoin save percentage leader at .926.
2018 – C John Tavares
His almost point-a-game production in regular season, went a long way to mitigating the seven-year, $77 million price tag Leafs had to out-bid everyone and bring him home. Now they keep him at a discount.
2016 — F Matt Martin.
His job, as coach Mike Babcock described it, 'keep the flies away' from young stars.
2009 – F Colton Orr
Added some needed muscle for a few years after Tie Domi retired.
2006 — D Hal Gill/D Pavel Kubina
Not blockbusters, but incoming GM John Ferguson went a long way to propping up the blueline.
1998 — RW Steve Thomas
Happy homecoming helped Leafs to the 1999 Cup semifinal.
1998– G Curtis Joseph
Sweet deal that began with chance meeting in an ice cream parlour with president Ken Dryden. Signed a second time in 2008.
Article content
MISSES
2021 – G Petr Mrazek
His three-year contract ended in a salary dump.
2021 – RW Nick Ritchie
Had a shot on he first line, much more was expected before Leafs demoted and eventually traded him.
2017 – C Patrick Marleau
Established player and great mentor for the young Leafs, but three years at $18.75 million came back to haunt their accountants,.
2013– F David Clarkson
GM Dave Nonis misjudged Clarkson's impact, but not before awarding seven years at $36.75 million..
2009 – D Mike Komisarek
Tried too hard to make an immediate impact.
2008 – D Jeff Finger
A four-year, $14 million mistake for Cliff Fletcher in his second incarnation as GM.
2007 — LW Jason Blake
Was not the answer for Mats Sundin on the first line.
X: @sunhornby
Latest National Stories
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
a day ago
- National Post
Could Mitch Marner join Nazem Kadri in the Stanley Cup-winning ex-Leafs club?
There are certainly more former Maple Leafs in the salary-cap era who've won the Stanley Cup — or been to the final — than there are title banners on Bay Street. Article content Among those who had an awkward exit but later lifted the trophy, Nazem Kadri had the most memorable quote. Article content Article content While in Toronto, his recklessness in the name of sticking up for teammates or sending foes a message each spring eventually resulted in a trade. Article content 'For everyone who thought I was a liability in playoffs, you can kiss my ass,' the 2022 champion shouted as his Colorado Avalanche celebrated. Article content Amid an NHL-worst 58-year drought, lack of success has been particularly hard to swallow for Leafs Nation loyalists who fawned over then fell out with several stars. Article content Four years before Kadri, Phil Kessel celebrated his second Cup in Pittsburgh after relations soured with the team and fans, followed in 2019 by the highly regarded Tyler Bozak with the Blues and Kessel again with a small role for Vegas in '23. Article content Since 2021, Zach Hyman has done everything but win it after the beloved home-towner priced himself out of the Leafs budget. He moved from left wing with Auston Matthews to Connor McDavid's flank in Edmonton, where he scored 50 and helped the Oilers to two Stanley Cup finals. Article content Article content Now the concern is whether winger Mitch Marner will haunt the franchise. The fifth-highest scorer in franchise history preferred a deal sending him to the Golden Knights over an extended contract in Toronto, where his lack of playoff production has been under relentless scrutiny. Article content Article content 'It was his time to move on,' Kadri said of his ex-teammate during a chat with the Toronto Sun ahead of the Hockey Diversity Alliance's SummerFest event, taking place this Saturday. 'Maybe every player needs that fresh start. Article content Article content 'Mitchy played a lot of good hockey here, a dynamic player to watch with the puck on his stick. Fans should be proud of what he did. Article content 'I want him, all of them, to do well, but not because of (trying to prove fans wrong). It's because you've been in the trenches with them, how all that brought you together. We're still good buddies. I just mentioned to him to watch out because now we're in the same (Pacific) division.' Article content Kadri revealed he was at a couple of the Toronto-Florida Panthers second-round playoff games. The Leafs have not made it to the third round of the playoffs since 2002. Article content 'Sure, I was cheering for them as I always do, but they faced a really great team. I have lot of friends who are still big Leafs fans and I've tried to watch them on TV, too.'
Edmonton Journal
a day ago
- Edmonton Journal
Could Mitch Marner join Nazem Kadri in the Stanley Cup-winning ex-Leafs club?
There are certainly more former Maple Leafs in the salary-cap era who've won the Stanley Cup — or been to the final — than there are title banners on Bay Street. Article content Among those who had an awkward exit but later lifted the trophy, Nazem Kadri had the most memorable quote. Article content While in Toronto, his recklessness in the name of sticking up for teammates or sending foes a message each spring eventually resulted in a trade. Article content Amid an NHL-worst 58-year drought, lack of success has been particularly hard to swallow for Leafs Nation loyalists who fawned over then fell out with several stars. Article content Four years before Kadri, Phil Kessel celebrated his second Cup in Pittsburgh after relations soured with the team and fans, followed in 2019 by the highly regarded Tyler Bozak with the Blues and Kessel again with a small role for Vegas in '23. Article content Since 2021, Zach Hyman has done everything but win it after the beloved home-towner priced himself out of the Leafs budget. He moved from left wing with Auston Matthews to Connor McDavid's flank in Edmonton, where he scored 50 and helped the Oilers to two Stanley Cup finals. Article content Article content Now the concern is whether winger Mitch Marner will haunt the franchise. The fifth-highest scorer in franchise history preferred a deal sending him to the Golden Knights over an extended contract in Toronto, where his lack of playoff production has been under relentless scrutiny. Article content Article content 'It was his time to move on,' Kadri said of his ex-teammate during a chat with the Toronto Sun ahead of the Hockey Diversity Alliance's SummerFest event, taking place this Saturday. 'Maybe every player needs that fresh start. Article content Article content 'Mitchy played a lot of good hockey here, a dynamic player to watch with the puck on his stick. Fans should be proud of what he did. Article content 'I want him, all of them, to do well, but not because of (trying to prove fans wrong). It's because you've been in the trenches with them, how all that brought you together. We're still good buddies. I just mentioned to him to watch out because now we're in the same (Pacific) division.' Article content Kadri revealed he was at a couple of the Toronto-Florida Panthers second-round playoff games. The Leafs have not made it to the third round of the playoffs since 2002. Article content 'Sure, I was cheering for them as I always do, but they faced a really great team. I have lot of friends who are still big Leafs fans and I've tried to watch them on TV, too.'
Edmonton Journal
2 days ago
- Edmonton Journal
Former Leafs GM Kyle Dubas shares biggest regret, comments on Mitch Marner and Mike Babcock
Article content 'I don't think it's because of the pressure of the marketplace or the fans. That was my impression. Maybe the players would disagree, but I don't think it was ever a factor to the group not reaching its potential.' Article content On the difficulty of building a team when the Matthews, Marner, Tavares and Nylander contracts were a significant portion of the Leafs' finances: Article content 'I think the thing that handcuffed it was the salary cap was flat. That's life. No one could have predicted (the COVID impact) and we just had to adapt. After 2021, I thought we started to become much better at identifying what we needed to support the group and give the team a better chance. Article content 'We took a lot of shots in 2020 and 2021 and weren't as successful. It was on us to make the right decisions around that group of players and I think everyone wishes the team would have performed better as a group and individually and in the playoffs. I don't point to any one situation or one thing, but we didn't get it done and that's as simple as I can put it.' Article content Article content On the tenure of Mike Babcock, who was hired as coach in 2015 and fired in 2019, 4 1/2 years into his eight-year contract: Article content 'The reason why the team was able to get into the playoffs in 2017 and stay there, and maybe people don't want to give the credit to (Babcock) in retrospect, but he brought in a tremendous amount of accountability, a tremendous amount of detail, and his work ethic and what he was willing to put in to be prepared, was … I still haven't seen anything quite like it. Article content 'At the end, it just became clear that the group wasn't going to take the next steps with him … it was clear we were going to have to try to find another voice to push us ahead both in the regular season and the playoffs. Article content 'Lou (Lamoriello) was the GM. Nobody else with the team really knew that. Lou handled it with Mike. The fact it was never a topic again until I think the few days after Mike was fired, I think speaks to Lou's ability to handle everything. Article content Article content 'It never came up again in my time there and when I read the story, it was the Toronto Sun, I remember (assistant GM) Brandon Pridham and I saying we didn't know that it had happened.' Article content 'You've seen the evolution as a leader and the evolution on the defensive side as well. Everyone knows about the goal scoring. To see him named captain there, captain of Team USA, he puts a lot into his craft. His (biggest) pressure is probably internal in trying to be the absolute best.' Article content 'We could talk forever about Lou and how great a mentor he was for me and how great our relationship still is and how close he is with my family. He's the best. That was a great experience. I leaned on him a lot. (In his first meeting with Lamoriello), I was 29 years old. I was scared s***less.' Article content
