‘Napalm Girl' may be work of different photographer, awards body says
Nick Ut won the World Press Photo award for the photograph known colloquially as 'Napalm Girl', but officially titled The Terror Of War, in 1973.
The striking image of a naked and terrified Kim Phuc running away from a napalm attack became a symbol of the war's tragedy, and remains one of the most iconic photographs from America's war in Vietnam.
World Press Photo announced on Friday, however, that it has 'suspended its attribution' to Ut because of doubts over who actually took it.
The body's report adds to the muddle over an issue that has split the photographic community since The Stringer, a movie released earlier this year, questioned Mr Ut's authorship.
World Press Photo said its probe found that two other photographers – Nguyen Thanh Nghe, the subject of the film, and Huynh Cong Phuc – 'may have been better positioned' to take the shot.
'We conclude that the level of doubt is too significant to maintain the existing attribution,' said Joumana El Zein Khoury, executive director of World Press Photo.
'At the same time, lacking conclusive evidence pointing definitively to another photographer, we cannot reassign authorship, either.'
World Press Photo, an organisation whose awards are considered influential in photography, won't attempt to recover the cash award given to Mr Ut, a spokeswoman said.
Mr Ut's lawyer, James Hornstein, said his client hadn't spoken to World Press Photo after some initial contact before The Stringer was released. 'It seems they had already made up their mind to punish Nick Ut from the start,' he said.
Gary Knight, a producer of The Stringer, is a four-time judge of the World Press Photo awards and a consultant to the World Press Photo Foundation.
After two investigations, Associated Press (AP) – who Mr Ut worked for at the time – said it found no definitive evidence to warrant stripping Mr Ut's photo credit.
'Impossible to prove'
The AP said it was possible Mr Ut took the picture, but the passage of time made it impossible to fully prove, and could find no evidence to prove anyone else did.
On Friday, it said that its standards 'require proof and certainty to remove a credit and we have found that it is impossible to prove exactly what happened that day on the road or in the (AP) bureau over 50 years ago.'
'We understand World Press Photo has taken different action based on the same available information, and that is their prerogative,' the statement said. 'There is no question over AP's ownership of the photo.'
Meanwhile, the Pulitzer Prize that Mr Ut was awarded for the photo appears to be safe.
The Pulitzers depend on news agencies who enter the awards to determine authorship and Marjorie Miller, an administrator – and a former AP senior editor – pointed to the AP's study showing insufficient proof to withdraw credit.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
34 minutes ago
- BBC News
Tulip Siddiq: Trial of Labour MP begins in Bangladesh
The trial of Labour MP Tulip Siddiq over corruption allegations has formally begun in former minister did not attend the hearing, where investigators from the country's corruption watchdog set out the case against her and 20 other individuals, including her aunt, her mother, her brother and her is accused of influencing her aunt Sheikh Hasina, who was ousted as Bangladesh's prime minister last year, to secure a plot of land in a suburb of the capital Dhaka for her family MP for Hampstead and Highgate, who denies the allegations, said the "so-called trial" was "a farce" built on "fabricated accusations and driven by a clear political vendetta". Hasina fled Bangladesh for India last August after being ousted amid a crackdown by government forces on student-led protests which saw hundreds killed. A copy of the case alleges that whilst she was a serving MP Ms Siddiq "forced and influenced her aunt and the former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina using her special power to secure [a plot of land] for her mother Rehana Siddiq, sister Azmina Siddiq and brother Radwan Siddiq".As per Bangladeshi law, if an individual has any plot or flat in or around Dhaka, they are not permitted to receive any plot in the lucrative Purbachal project, prosecutors found guilty, the maximum sentence would be a lifetime imprisonment, according to prosecutor for the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC), Tariqul Islam, said Ms Siddiq was being tried as a Bangladeshi citizen as the ACC found her Bangladeshi passport, national ID, and tax identity number. Ms Siddiq's lawyers previously told the Financial Times: "Tulip has never had a Bangladesh national identity card or voter ID and has not held a passport since she was a child." In a statement on X, Ms Siddiq said: "Over the past year, the allegations against me have repeatedly shifted, yet I have never been contacted by the Bangladeshi authorities once."I have never received a court summons, no official communication, and no evidence."If this were a genuine legal process, the authorities would have engaged with me or my legal team, responded to our formal correspondence, and presented the evidence they claim to hold."Instead, they have peddled false and vexatious allegations that have been briefed to the media but never formally put to me by investigators."She added: "I have been clear from the outset that I have done nothing wrong and will respond to any credible evidence that is presented to me. Continuing to smear my name to score political points is both baseless and damaging."The Bangladeshi authorities issued an arrest warrant for Ms Siddiq earlier this next hearing in the case has been scheduled for 28 August. Ms Siddiq resigned as Treasury minister in Sir Keir Starmer's government in January, saying continuing in her role would be a "distraction", although she insisted she had done nothing followed an investigation into the allegations against her by the prime minister's standards adviser, Sir Laurie his report, Sir Laurie said he had "not identified evidence of improprieties".But he said it was "regrettable" that Siddiq had not been more alert to the "potential reputational risks" of her ties to her trial in Bangladesh relates to three charges, while Ms Siddiq also faces another charge of allegedly illegally acquiring a flat in the Gulshan area of ACC is also investigating a separate case against Siddiq and her family over allegations of embezzlement of £3.9bn connected to a Russian-funded nuclear power plant deal with Bangladesh in has denied any involvement in the investigation is based on a series of allegations made by Bobby Hajjaj, a political opponent of authorities estimate that about $234bn (£174bn) was siphoned off from Bangladesh through corrupt means while Hasina was in power. Sign up for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Tulip Siddiq brands Bangladesh trial a ‘farce'
Tulip Siddiq says her corruption trial in Bangladesh is a 'farce' driven by a 'political vendetta'. The former City minister, who is being tried in her absence, accused authorities in Dhaka of 'peddling false and vexatious allegations' and said the case was ' built on fabricated accusations ' Ms Siddiq, along with her mother Sheikh Rehana and sister Azmina Siddique, and brother Radwan Mujib Siddique, known as Bobby, are facing multiple corruption charges in relation to the allocation of plots in one of the largest housing projects in the country. The Labour MP is the niece of Sheikh Hasina, Bangladesh's authoritarian former prime minister, who fled the country after she was ousted last year following a violent crackdown on student protesters. As the trial began on Wednesday, Ms Siddiq launched a fresh attack on the Bangladesh government headed by interim leader Prof Muhammad Yunus, and the legal proceedings, saying she had not even received a court summons. 'False and vexatious' allegations 'The so-called trial now under way in Dhaka is nothing more than a farce – built on fabricated accusations and driven by a clear political vendetta,' she posted on X. 'Over the past year, the allegations against me have repeatedly shifted, yet I have never been contacted by the Bangladeshi authorities once. 'I have never received a court summons, no official communication, and no evidence. If this were a genuine legal process, the authorities would have engaged with me or my legal team, responded to our formal correspondence, and presented the evidence they claim to hold. 'Instead, they have peddled false and vexatious allegations that have been briefed to the media but never formally put to me by investigators.' Ms Siddiq, 42, said that Prof Yunus had refused her offer to meet when he recently visited London and claimed he was smearing her name to 'score political points'. 'Even my offer to meet … Muhammad Yunus during his recent visit to London was refused,' she wrote. 'Such conduct is wholly incompatible with the principles of a fair trial that we uphold in the UK. 'I have been clear from the outset that I have done nothing wrong and will respond to any credible evidence that is presented to me. Continuing to smear my name to score political points is both baseless and damaging.' On the first day of the trial, it was claimed Ms Siddiq 'exerted pressure and influence' on Sheikh Hasina to illegally hand land to her mother and siblings. Bangladesh's Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) alleges Sheikh Hasina, in collusion with senior officials, unlawfully obtained six plots of 7,200sq ft each in the diplomatic zone of Sector 27 of the Purbachal New Town project for herself and her family. Muhammad Salahuddin, the ACC deputy director, who heads the investigation, recorded his statement before Judge Muhammad Rabiul Alam, of Dhaka Special Judge Court-4, saying the former prime minister concealed ownership of housing facilities in Dhaka in violation of existing laws. The ACC has filed six separate cases with Hasina accused in each, while Ms. Siddiq has been named as an abettor in three corruption cases also involving her mother and two siblings. Ms. Siddiq 'manipulated and influenced Sheikh Hasina, who by virtue of her direct influence and under the special powers granted to her, abused the authority vested in her in breach of public trust to attain the property', claimed Mr Salahuddin. 'A perusal of the records collected during the course of the investigation also reveals that the accused, Sheikh Hasina, influenced the allotment of the plots in the Purbachal New City Project in favour of the accused Sheikh Rehana, in violation of the rules,' he added. The court has set the next hearing as Aug 28. The ACC has opened several investigations into Ms Siddiq, alleging corruption in connection with the government of Sheikh Hasina, who fled to India last year after a mass uprising against her dictatorial rule. The ACC has listed all accused as fugitives and on July 31, charges were framed against 28 people, including Ms Siddiq, Sheikh Hasina and other family members, as well as several current and former officials of the ministry of housing and public works. Ms Siddiq has not appeared at any of the pre-trial hearings so far. The court previously issued a warrant for her arrest in April.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Perseid meteor shower — and other news in pictures
PHOTOGRAPHY Times picture editors select the best images from the UK and around the world: which is your favourite? The Times The Times Sakarya, Turkey IBRAHIM YOZOGLU/ANADOLU/GETTY IMAGES Mount Nemrut in Adyaman, southeastern Turkey KEMAL ASLAN/AFP/GETTY IMAGES Sui, aged three, takes a close look at one of the 21 bronze elephants installed in Spitalfields, central London, as a walking trail by the Sheldrick Wildlife Trust DAVID PARRY/PA Niall Johnston tends to the fruiting room at the Yorkshire Mushroom Emporium in Ilkley, which supplies local restaurants and was once run from a garage owned by his co-founder's mother TIMES PHOTOGRAPHER JAMES GLOSSOP Loch Tay in the Highlands provides a welcome plunge off of the HotBoat, billed as Scotland's first floating sauna. Temperatures are expected to peak at 27C in Scotland on Wednesday PHIL WILKINSON Temperatures in London peaked at 33C on Tuesday; some headed straight for the sky pool ANDY RAIN/EPA MARK PASSMORE PHOTOGRAPHY Six sets of twins are starting school in Inverclyde next week and marked the occasion in uniform at St Ninian's primary in Gourock WATTIE CHEUNG Sziget Festival brings hundreds of thousands of people to Budapest for a bill ranging from Chappell Roan and Charli XCX to the Troula Street Theatre TAMAS VASVARI/EPA SWNS The Glorious Twelfth was glorious after all on the West Glenalmond Estate in Perthshire, despite shoots being cancelled elsewhere on the first day of grouse-shooting season JANE BARLOW/PA Mt Marapi spews ash a mile into the sky in West Sumatra, Indonesia. It has erupted more than 460 times in two years ADI PRIMA/GETTY IMAGES Visitors to St James's Park are used to pigeons scurrying around their feet. Pelicans, perhaps not so much YUI MOK/PA NAOKI HIRAOKA/AP Colombian civil servants release balloons in memory of Miguel Uribe, the senator and prospective presidential candidate who was shot at a rally in Bogota in June and died on Monday IVAN VALENCIA/AP A 'rabbit dachshund' cools down with an ice cream in Milan as Italy swelters in 40C temperatures STEFANO RELLANDINI/AFP/GETTY IMAGES Parkour! France's Eloan Hitz competes at the World Games in Chengdu, China, which hosts non-Olympic sports including tug of war, life saving and American football LISI NIESNER/REUTERS It doesn't make for the most flattering photoshoot, but there is a reason these zebras at Lewa wildlife conservancy in Kenya are stood head to tail: they use their tails to swat flies from each others' faces ANDREW CAMPBELL/SOLENT JORDAN PETTITT/PA Rupert Kirkwood ventured off the coast of Devon expecting bluefin tuna to emerge from the water, but it was his son that captured this 3m-long fish taking him by surprise
