Court rules against Peruvian farmer in landmark climate lawsuit against RWE
A German court has thrown out a Peruvian farmer's landmark climate lawsuit, which sought damages from energy company RWE, claiming its historical greenhouse gas emissions put his home at risk.
Farmer and mountain guide Saúl Luciano Lliuya claimed that Andean glaciers above his hometown of Huaraz, Peru, are melting, increasing the risk of catastrophic flooding to his home.
The 44-year-old farmer, whose family grows corn, wheat, barley and potatoes, said he chose to sue RWE because it is one of the biggest polluters in Europe, rather than any particular company projects near his home.
Using data from the Carbon Majors database, which tracks historic emissions from major fossil fuel producers, Lliuya has said that RWE is responsible for nearly 0.5 per cent of global man-made emissions since the industrial revolution and must pay a proportional share of the costs needed to adapt to climate change.
For a $3.5 million flood defence project needed in his region, RWE's share would be around $17,500, according to Lliuya's calculations.
RWE, which has never operated in Peru and is phasing out its coal-fired power plants, denies legal responsibility and argues that climate change is a global issue caused by many contributors.
The state court in Hamm, in western Germany, dismissed the lawsuit on Wednesday and said no appeal was possible in the decade-old case.
Presiding judge Rolf Meyer said the experts' estimate of the 30-year damage risk to the plaintiff's house of 1 per cent was not enough to take the case further. Had there been a larger adverse effect, a polluter could have been made to slash emissions or pay damages, Meyer said.
Meyer said the plaintiff's case was argued coherently and that it was "like a microcosm of the world's problems between people of the southern and the northern hemisphere, between the poor and the rich."
Experts said that the case had the potential to set a significant precedent in the fight to hold major polluters accountable for climate change.
RWE argued that the lawsuit is legally inadmissible and that it sets a dangerous precedent by holding individual emitters accountable for global climate change. It insists climate solutions should be addressed through state and international policies, not the courts.
Judges and experts from Germany visited Peru in 2022 as part of the case.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Fees start for extra garden waste collections in Medway
Medway Council has introduced new charges for additional garden waste collections from waste collections now require a £40 per year subscription, which buys a permit to be fixed to an additional brown local authority says it will continue its standard weekly garden waste collections and residents can continue taking their extra waste to its three tips for Curry, cabinet member for climate change, said the council is "proud" of its service and Medway is "one of the few places in the country that still offer a free garden waste collection service". The councillor added: "This change won't impact most residents, however, those that do produce more garden waste than average will be able to sign up." Household that requires an additional brown bin will receive it within three weeks of signing up for the service, according to Medway local authority's cabinet agreed in 2024 to implement the scheme.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Anthony Albanese's government considering a new tax to help Australia acheive its climate targets
Chris Bowen has refused to rule out a possible 'carbon tariff' on dirty cement or steel as he acknowledged that Australia must 'do more' to achieve its climate targets. The Energy and Climate Change Minister was quizzed by the ABC's David Speers about whether he would bring in a carbon tariff. This would see levies placed on carbon-intensive products such as steel, cement and lime imported from abroad and could make the building process more expensive. It is a way of ensuring that Australian companies do not outsource carbon-emitting activities to other countries with less ambitious carbon-reduction targets. 'We have been clear that we want to ensure Australian industry is best placed to compete in a decarbonising world,' Bowen told the program. 'What could be the case is … we look at particular sectors first around cement and lime, [which] are places that we looked at in particular, but I'm not going to get in front of the process… 'We'll have more to say during the course of this term.' The Australian Government appointed Professor Frank Jotzo to lead a review into carbon leakage and what policy options were available to address it. This would see levies placed on carbon-intensive products such as steel, cement and lime imported from abroad and could make the building process more expensive His preliminary report identified cement, clinker and lime as industries in which there was a high leakage risk, while steel, glass and ammonia posed a moderate risk. The European Union has brought in a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, which will imposes a carbon tax on imports from countries with less strict climate policies. Bowen's refusal to rule it out was criticised by the Coalition's new energy spokesperson Dan Tehan. 'Now before the election, Chris Bowen, this arrogant minister, said nothing about carbon tariffs,' he said. 'Yet here he is immediately after the election talking about putting them in place.' Tehan accused Bowen of putting Australia's 'energy security at risk' and putting gas and electricity prices up. 'Now he wants to follow Donald Trump's lead and put in tariffs. What a mess,' he added. Bowen said Australia was 'by and large on track' to meet its target of reducing emissions by 43 per cent by 2030. This is despite figueres last week showing little progress was made in 2024. 'We've never suggested it's a linear line … But with the right approach from government, yes, we can continue to be on track (despite) facing headwinds and challenges from time to time,' he said. Labor was criticised by environmental groups for approving a 40-year extended licence to WA's North West Shelf, the largest oil and gas project in the country. The government has a deadline this year to set its 2035 emissions reduction target.
The Independent
9 hours ago
- The Independent
Police officer fatally shoots person at Atlanta apartment complex
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging. At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story. The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it. Your support makes all the difference.
