Inquiry to consider if judge should be removed after alleged conduct at NZ First event
A judicial conduct panel will inquire into the alleged conduct of acting District Court Judge Ema Aitken at a New Zealand First function at Auckland's Northern Club last year.
It's alleged that last November Judge Aitken disrupted a NZ First party event being held at the prestigious club, where
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
4 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Unlicensed driver bit, lunged at police during arrest
An unlicensed French driver who performed a U-turn in front of oncoming traffic became agitated when he was pulled over by police, lunging at officers and biting them as he was arrested. The driving incident near Nelson earlier this year led to a series of charges being laid against Ulysse Felician, who went on to seek a discharge without conviction. However, the 30-year-old teacher was convicted of the charges after Judge Noel Sainsbury yesterday declined his application. Felician, who wanted to remain in New Zealand where he hoped to teach physical education, now faces deportation. In sentencing Felician in the Nelson District Court, Judge Sainsbury said he did not see a conviction would prohibit him from remaining in New Zealand, but that would be a decision for immigration authorities. "He may be the subject of a deportation order, regardless of what happens today. It will be up to Immigration New Zealand to make an assessment of his character and whether this was a one-off stupid piece of behaviour that doesn't reflect who he is," the judge said. None of what happened would have resulted in more than a warning if Felician had stopped and spoken civilly to the police. Instead, he continued to drive off, and to make matters worse, bit two police officers while restrained, he said. Defence lawyer Emma Riddell said the incident was out of character and the result of Felician being tired and burnt out to the point he reacted in an "emotionally unstable way". "He was hard working and living a good life until this day. He has a lot going for him, aside from this one incident that escalated," Ms Riddell said. Felician, 30, was in the country on a tourist working visa, which his lawyer said during his plea appearance in April had expired. The court heard that matters had unravelled for Felician on the morning of January 28 this year. He was driving a grey Mazda station wagon on SH6 when he was seen by police doing a U-turn in front of oncoming traffic. It ended with him being taken to the ground before he bit two police officers and then tried to remove a Taser from the holster of one. Police opposed Felician's application for a discharge without conviction and said a "strong message" needed to be sent that there were laws in this country the police stood by, and the court should not downplay that. Police prosecutor Sergeant Malcolm York said Felician needed to be held to account. Sgt York said the Frenchman's recollections in an affidavit in support of his application were "far from what the summary of facts said" and the photos of the officers' injuries on file. "The police stand by the fact this was serious offending. It put the officers at risk and other road users at risk." Felician was convicted and fined $250 on each of the two charges of assaulting police and two charges of resisting police and failing to stop. On the charge of possession of cannabis, he was discharged without conviction. Judge Sainsbury said there was a danger of that being "disproportionately punitive". By Tracy Neal
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Inquiry to consider if judge should be removed after alleged conduct at NZ First event
A judicial conduct panel will inquire into the alleged conduct of acting District Court Judge Ema Aitken at a New Zealand First function at Auckland's Northern Club last year. It's alleged that last November Judge Aitken disrupted a NZ First party event being held at the prestigious club, where
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Chch court told of man's ‘campaign of violence and terror'
Christchurch District Court Photo / Nate McKinnon, RNZ By Al Williams WARNING: This story is about family violence and may be distressing. A mother was in tears as she shut her eyes and blocked her ears when a man's campaign of terror over her family was revealed in court. She had endured ongoing violence from him over a six-month period, before he turned his attention to her daughter. The woman's tears continued as her daughter went on to describe how his actions had affected her too. 'It has changed my life, since the abuse happened, I don't feel like a normal kid anymore, I feel nervous. The girl was 11 when the man, who has name suppression, showed her online pornography, told her to undress and then indecently assaulted her. 'I don't trust people like I used to, I have a hard time focusing on school now, I try to pay attention, but my head goes blank, I feel like I can't keep up anymore,' she told the court during his sentencing this week. 'I just get angry, other times I start crying, people think I am being dramatic, but they don't know what is going on inside. 'I can't be around crowds, I used to be happier, more outgoing and confident, I have been diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. 'I didn't deserve what happened and I don't want to feel like this forever.' The pair were caught up in what was described by Judge Raoul Neave in the Christchurch District Court as a campaign of violence and terror. Judge Neave said the offending occurred during a sustained period of violence, fear and control. 'They must have been living in fear.' Weekly beatings The court heard of numerous assaults; the man had initially accused the girl's mother of cheating and pushed her up against a wall, about six months into their relationship. He then backhand punched her while she was holding a baby in the back seat of a car he was driving. After that he started verbally abusing her almost every day . 'She would get a hiding at least once a week,' Judge Neave said. He would punch her while she was holding an infant, and sometimes in the face. Another incident resulted in a permanent scar on her neck. On yet another occasion, he held a kitchen knife to her neck and applied pressure. 'She thought you were going to kill her,' the judge said. The assaults continued after she discovered she was pregnant. The woman told the man in a statement she read in court that she 'walked on eggshells' around him as the assaults happened while the children were present. One thing that could not be excused was the sexual abuse of her daughter, she said. 'She was 11, the fact she looked up to her, you have caused trauma that will never be erased. 'I am terrified of seeing you again, it is essential for everyone here to understand the impact of his actions.' Victim shuts her eyes and blocks her ears The woman, who was visibly emotional throughout the proceedings, shut her eyes and blocked her ears as Judge Neave started to sentence the man. 'I have received a lot of information about you; there is lack of empathy and minimisation.' Some of the offending occurred while the man was coming down from methamphetamine, the judge said. There had been a background of health difficulties, family problems and a history of drug use. Judge Neave said it was possible other factors were paired in the man's inability to make sound judgments, but not a 'huge' link. 'This was sustained violence, assault in varying types, use of weapons, any number of household items available to you. 'The victim suffered from a number of injuries; they were varied and numerous and repeated.' At times the victim was very vulnerable because of her pregnancy, especially when she was on the ground during the assaults, the judge said. Judge Neave said the assault against the child victim was aggravated by the viewing of pornography. 'It was sustained and intrusive.' Violent and sexual offending Crown prosecutor Penny Brown said it was both violent and sexual offending with numerous and extensive attacks to the neck and in the presence of children. There was also a risk to an unborn child, she said. 'I want to say the guilty plea was extremely late, it spared the young victim from giving evidence at trial.' Defence lawyer Kathy Basire said there were multiple reports and letters of support and she described him as a 'different man now'. She said a sentence of home detention could be reached. There was a 'nexus' with his background issues in terms of the offending, she said. Judge Neave responded, saying the man had turned into a 'violent terrorist in the home'. Basire said he was coming down off methamphetamine. 'It doesn't justify or explain six months of violence,' the judge said. Judge Neave jailed the man for two years and 10 months on charges of an indecent act with a child, exposure of a young person to indecent material, assault with a weapon (representative), assault on a person in a family relationship (representative) and assault on a person in a family relationship. FAMILY VIOLENCE How to get help: If you're in danger now: • Phone the police on 111 or ask neighbours or friends to ring for you. • Run outside and head for where there are other people. Scream for help so your neighbours can hear you. • Take the children with you. Don't stop to get anything else. • If you are being abused, remember it's not your fault. Violence is never okay.
