Quebec to review files of immigrant children facing daycare expulsion
MONTREAL — The Quebec government says it will review cases involving children facing expulsion from daycare after the province moved to restrict access to subsidized spots for certain immigrants.
The concession comes following pushback to a new government directive, issued earlier this month, that said foreign workers with open work permits are not eligible for the province's subsidized daycare rate, currently set at $9.35 per day. A union representing daycare workers says the policy has taken the sector by surprise, and could result in hundreds of children losing their spots.
On Tuesday, two sets of immigrant parents from France and Ukraine threatened Quebec's Families Department with legal action, calling the directive 'invalid and illegal.' Their children, who have been attending a subsidized home daycare for more than a year, were facing expulsion on Wednesday.
In a social media statement on Wednesday, Families Minister Suzanne Roy stood by the government directive, saying the province is merely enforcing an existing rule.
'That said, before any action is taken, the (department) will analyze the files of children already receiving services,' she said.
According to the directive, dated July 9, foreign workers with a closed work permit, which names a specific employer and duration of employment, are eligible to enrol their children in Quebec's subsidized daycare system. But those with open work permits, which allow them to work for any employer in Canada, are not.
The government maintains this is a long-standing rule that must be enforced. The directive advised daycares that have enrolled children of parents with open work permits to 'rectify the situation without delay.'
But in a statement earlier this month, a Quebec union representing daycare workers said the policy offers a 'new interpretation' of existing regulations, 'which goes against the practices in force for several years.'
The union says the directive could cause hundreds of children across the province to be expelled from their daycare spots, and could force their parents to stop working to care for them.
Lawyers for the families from France and Ukraine are calling on the government to 'correct' the policy, which they say is illegal and discriminatory.
The couple from France had a son in Quebec in 2023, who has been attending a home daycare since March 2024. The couple from Ukraine fled their country due to the war with Russia, and their son has attended the same daycare since last July.
Both children were deemed eligible in 2024. But according to a formal notice sent by the families' lawyers to the government on Tuesday, the daycare was informed on July 18 that parents with open work permits were no longer eligible, and that their children should be removed from the daycare by July 23.
The lawyers argue that existing rules do not preclude foreign workers with open work permits from enrolling their children in the subsidized system. They say the new directive adds 'additional requirements that were not foreseen and that run counter to the text of the regulation, which has not changed for years.'
They also say the directive violates Canadian and Quebec charter rights, 'since exclusion from the subsidized daycare program results in disproportionate discriminatory effects on women.'
In a social media statement on Tuesday, a spokesperson for the office of Quebec Premier François Legault defended the restriction, saying it has existed since the province's subsidized daycare system was created in 1997.
'A reminder has been issued to childcare providers, and it must be respected, period,' said Florence Plourde. 'Too many families are looking for a daycare space. The rules must be clear, fair, and consistently applied. It's a matter of fairness, nothing more, nothing less.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025.
By Maura Forrest, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
How will Canadian consumers be affected by Trump's de minimis changes?
U.S. President Donald Trump's executive order suspending the de minimis exemption for imports could have blowback for Canadian consumers as some smaller sellers pull back from the country, larger players focus on this market and deliveries temporarily slow for everyone. The order signed on Wednesday means imports valued at or under US$800 soon will no longer be exempt from tariffs and instead be subject to the blanket fees the U.S. has imposed on trading partners. 'The de minimis rule was a golden ticket for smaller Canadian exporters,' said Markus Giesler, a marketing professor at the Schulich School of Business. 'Right now, without this, they may be forced to pay high prices, reroute logistics or walk away from the world's biggest market.' For many small Canadian businesses selling lower-value goods, such as arts and craft businesses and Etsy sellers, the suspension makes the U.S. market unviable, said David Nagy, founder of consulting firm eCommerce Canada. The paperwork and brokerage fees may not make sense for lower-value transactions, he said, adding that a $55 order could now require an additional 45 minutes spent on documentation, with no added financial benefit. Trump to suspend duty-free exemption for low-value shipments Chris Jarvis, chief operating officer at Ecom Logistics, said Canadian small e-commerce businesses he works with rely heavily on U.S. sales, and their need to maintain U.S. customers may lead them to leave the Canadian market entirely. 'Any small Canadian merchant who got traction in the Canadian market … ends up seeing 90 per cent of their sales happening in America,' he said. To maintain that customer base, some businesses will need to move inventory into the U.S. and effectively run a U.S.-based business. Options are even more limited for businesses importing some of their goods or materials from China or other tariffed countries, leaving them exposed to additional tariffs with less of a chance at becoming compliant with the United States-Mexico-Canada free-trade agreement. Many up-and-coming American and Canadian creators selling niche products via Instagram, TikTok or Etsy, for example, may elect not to come to Canada or stay here. They're thinking, 'Why would I want to open up another inventory position in the country of Canada, when 90 per cent of my volume is going to come from the US anyway,' said Mr. Jarvis. How U.S. duties targeted at China are disrupting Canadian businesses If they pull away, this will limit product availability in Canada and consumers will have fewer opportunities to access unique or small-batch goods they once could easily order. On the other hand, U.S. restrictions may push larger companies such as Temu and Shein to 'aggressively look at other markets,' including Canada, said Jonathan Calof, a professor of international business and strategy at the University of Ottawa's Telfer School of Management. Data provided to The Globe and Mail by marketing-intelligence firm Sensor Tower shows Temu's Canadian ad spend jumped 61 per cent year-over-year in the second quarter of 2025 following Mr. Trump's tariff threats, while Shein's rose 34 per cent. Whether doubling down on markets outside of the U.S. would mean lower prices for Canadian consumers depends on how companies react. 'They're going to try to gain market share, and they're going to try to stay competitive … some will lower prices, some will try better quality, some will diversify,' said Prof. Calof. But when it comes to small e-commerce businesses, they don't have much runway to sustain long-term price cuts, he said. The bigger risk is that their business may disappear altogether. In addition to reduced selection, the de minimis suspension on U.S. imports could mean that Canadians ordering from the U.S. will face slightly longer waiting times because of increased border scrutiny more broadly, said Matthew Melvin, a spokesperson for Canadian shipping company Chit Chats. Shoppers trying to return something that they bought from the U.S. could also be hit with added hurdles, he said. While the effect to Canadians' wallets from the de minimis change may not be immediate, the economic ripple effects will ultimately be significant, said Steve Bozicevic, CEO of A&A Customs Brokers. 'If Americans start buying less, then you'll just have less jobs, and you'll have more inflation,' he said. 'It's more the macroeconomic impact.'
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Two of Canada's most senior ministers head to Mexico to talk discuss trade
The flags of Mexico and Canada fly near the Ambassador Bridge, Monday, Feb. 3, 2025, in Detroit. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya) Two of Canada's most senior cabinet ministers will be in Mexico City this week holding bilateral meetings with government officials and the Mexican president, as Canada looks to improve its trading partnerships outside the United States. Senior government officials confirmed to CTV News that the meeting, which will involve Finance Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne and Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand, will take place Tuesday and Wednesday. The talks are expected to cover trade and the larger relationship between the two countries. That relationship suffered in the past year, when Ontario Premier Doug Ford called on Canada to seek a unilateral trade deal with the United States – without Mexico – and accused the country of undercutting North American manufacturers. Canadian business leaders say the upcoming talks show an effort to strengthen ties at a time when both countries are facing volatility from the United States. 'When we talk to Mexico, when we talk to their embassies in Canada, they are very eager to reset the relationship,' Catherine Fortin-LeFaivre, senior vice-president of International Policy and Global Partnerships at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, said Sunday. While Canada faces new blanket 35 per cent tariffs on Canadian goods that aren't covered under the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, Mexico received a 90-day extension to continue trade talks with the U.S. before it sees blanket tariffs increase from 25 per cent to 35 per cent. Last month, Prime Minister Mark Carney and Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum spoke over the phone, with the two leaders agreeing to improve trade collaboration between the two nations. Carlo Dade, director of international policy at the University of Calgary's School of Public Police, said Canada having open dialogue and strong ties with Mexico is 'a good sign.' 'If we weren't talking to Mexico, there would be reason to be concerned and worried,' Dade told CTV News. He added that Canada hasn't taken advantage of being in close proximity to a country like Mexico that has a higher per-capita GDP than China. 'The infrastructure is there, we have CPKC - Canada-Pacific Kansas City Railroad - so there's (an) integrated North American railroad,' Dade said. 'We have a trade agreement, we have decades of strong, strong, political and economic relations – the only missing factor has been a willingness of Canadian business to seize the opportunities. Mexico has been marked as a priority market to expand trade with by Export Development Canada. While it is already Canada's third-largest trading partner, with nearly $56 billion dollars in two-way merchandise crossing the border in 2024, it represented just over one per cent of Canadian exports that year. Fortin-LeFaivre says those relations will be crucial, particularly if the United States looks to move from a trilateral free trade agreement to two bilateral deals. 'It will be imperative that if that is happening that we have a very strong connection with Mexico directly, without the U.S. being there,' she said. Friday, Carney reiterated Canada's commitment to the CUSMA agreement while condemning Trump's recent tariff increase.
CBC
3 hours ago
- CBC
Champagne, Anand travelling to Mexico to strengthen Canada's trade ties
Social Sharing Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne says he and Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand will travel to Mexico City to look at strengthening Canada's economic partnership with Mexico. "The meetings will be constructive in that respect — looking at markets, looking at diversification, looking at strengthening our partnership with our Mexican colleagues," Champagne told Radio-Canada in Trois-Rivières, Que., on Monday afternoon. The news was first reported Sunday evening by the Globe and Mail. Two senior Canadian government sources told CBC News the meetings will be Tuesday and Wednesday. The ministers are expected to return to Canada on Thursday. The sources say the goal of the visit is to advance Canada's bilateral relationship with Mexico and strengthen trade ties. Champagne and Anand are expected to meet with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum on Tuesday morning. Champagne said the visit "is all complementary to what we've been saying — that we need to engage with strategic partners around the world. And if you look at the [Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement] as a trading bloc, that's the second largest trading bloc in the world." "So it is important for us to engage with our Mexican friends," the finance minister added. One source told CBC that the trip "is all about relationship building," and the two ministers' expected meeting with Sheinbaum will lay the groundwork for a future bilateral meeting between the Mexican president and Prime Minister Mark Carney. Carney and Sheinbaum have spoken at least four times since the prime minister came into office. In June, the two met at the G7 Leaders' Summit in Alberta. A news release posted on Carney's website said he and Sheinbaum agreed to "deepen bilateral collaboration at the ministerial level" and they "looked forward to meeting again in Mexico in the coming months." Arturo Sarukhan, former ambassador of Mexico to the United States, told CBC News he thinks "it's high time that that co-ordination between the Mexican and Canadian governments kicks off in earnest." "There's really been very little engagement in terms of how we can both engage together vis-a-vis a common trade partner that is eviscerating all the rules of trade that have built this incredible success story of North American trade over the past three decades," Sarukhan said. Trump extends tariff deal with Mexico The Canadians' visit comes days after U.S. President Donald Trump announced he had agreed with Sheinbaum to extend an existing trade deal with Mexico for 90 days and continue talks over the period with a goal of signing a new deal. "Mexico will continue to pay a 25% Fentanyl Tariff, 25% Tariff on Cars, and 50% Tariff on Steel, Aluminum and Copper," Trump said in a Truth Social post. "Additionally, Mexico has agreed to immediately terminate its Non Tariff Trade Barriers, of which there were many." Canada did not get an extension. Trump signed an executive order raising tariffs on Canadian goods that are not compliant with CUSMA to 35 per cent. The carve-out for CUSMA-compliant goods means very few Canadian products will actually be subjected to the elevated tariff. The U.S. president criticized Canada's "lack of co-operation" in curbing the flow of fentanyl southward and for retaliating against his existing tariffs. Sarukhan said Sheinbuam has "avoided grandstanding from the presidential bully pulpit, engaging in the back and forth that Trump loves," but Mexico has also bent its knee to Trump. American officials have called out Canada and China as the only countries to retaliate against Trump's tariffs. On Sunday, Canada-U.S. Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc said he expects Carney and Trump will have a conversation with each other "over the next couple of days." LeBlanc left Washington earlier this week without a trade deal, but told host Margaret Brennan, host of CBS's Face The Nation, that he came out of discussions "with a better understanding of the American concerns in the trading relationship.
