Demolition of Smyth's pub in D4 gets go-ahead despite locals' super-pub fears
ACP has granted planning permission despite concerns expressed by the Pembroke Road Association and by R. John McBratney and others in their appeals lodged against the decision to grant by Dublin City Council to Courtney Lounge Bars Ltd.
Advertisement
Courtney Lounge Bars Ltd now has permission to demolish all existing buildings on site at 10 Haddington Rd and construct a four-storey and part five-storey mixed-use building comprising a pub at basement and ground floor and six residential units at the upper floors.
In the case, ACP has granted planning permission for the scheme due to its proximity to a wide range of community services and social facilities, the existing pattern and character of development in the vicinity, and the design, scale and layout of the proposed development.
The board stated that, subject to conditions, the proposed development 'would constitute an acceptable quantum of development in this accessible urban location, and would not seriously injure the residential or visual amenities of the area or detract from its character or built heritage'.
The board has ordered that the pub's outdoor seating area shut at 10pm each night as part of the conditions attached.
Advertisement
The planning commission has granted planning permission after its inspector in the case, Ian Boyle concluded that 'the design approach adopted by the applicant demonstrates sufficient privacy and residential amenity will continue to be afforded to adjoining and nearby properties'.
As part of his 44-page report, Mr Boyle concluded that 'the proposed higher density mixed-use development would make a positive contribution towards the evolving urban character of this urban area'.
Mr Boyle stated that 'the new customer area would be marginally smaller than the corresponding area for the existing licensed premises - 140 sqm existing vs 134 sqm proposed.
He said that the modern fit-out of the new pub would also be required to provide enhanced sound insulation consistent with present-day building regulations.
Advertisement
He said: 'This would lead to a reduction in noise levels generated during busy periods by blocking or absorbing sound waves. This would benefit existing nearby homes and residents, but also the future occupants of the above apartments.'
In response to the plans initially lodged, the Pembroke Rd Association told the council that "a local pub can be a wonderful social amenity in a mixed residential area, as Smyth's has been over the years, but a 'super' pub in the same type of area is a problem'.
In his original objection, Mr R. John McBratney contended that: 'It is a substantial intensification of the use of the site. I note the application is silent as to why the pub serving area needs to be increased further.'
A resident on Percy Place, Mr McBratney stated that: 'The proposed development would radically change what is known as Smyth's pub and create a five-storey building with protruding balconies and a roof terrace which would overbear the houses in Percy Place.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
19 minutes ago
- The Guardian
McDonald's UK arm slashed donations to Children in Need last year, accounts show
McDonald's UK arm has cut its donations to some charities despite profits soaring more than 80% last year as it shed almost 2,000 jobs, according to its latest accounts. Documents newly filed at Companies House for the fast food chain's British business in 2024 show it gave £529,000 to Children in Need – reduced from £952,000 the previous year – and handed £744,000 to Ronald McDonald House charities, down from £779,000. It reduced the headcount at its directly operated business to 24,375 from 26,384 – with all reductions from restaurants and operations rather than head office. McDonald's has more than 1,400 sites in the UK and Ireland, with a large proportion operated by franchisees who employ their own staff – more than 140,000 people. Just over half of sales reported by the UK arm came via franchisees. It was not made clear in the accounts if some workers who left McDonald's wholly owned outlets were transferred to franchise partners. The UK business said it had paid an £83m dividend to its parent group in 2024, up from zero a year before, as pre-tax profits rose to £120m despite a slight fall in sales to £1.82bn. The details of reduced staffing at McDonald's come after the group said its high street estate 'continues to be impacted by challenging retail footfall'. A statement from the board included in the accounts said an improvement in operating profits had been 'predominantly driven by savings in administrative expenses', but that improvement had been slowed 'by continued inflationary pressures impacting food, paper and utility costs on the company operated estate'. The business, which has been criticised for its heavy use of zero-hours contracts, which are to be restricted under new government measures, said it offers staff 'the choice between guaranteed hours and flexible contracts'. After reports of harassment of UK staff on zero-hours contracts, McDonald's said in its accounts it was recruiting a 'head of safeguarding' and had set up an investigations handling unit to follow up claims of abuse. In January, the chief executive of McDonald's told MPs that 29 people had been dismissed in the past year after allegations of sexual harassment. The UK boss of the fast food chain, Alistair Macrow, said the company had been alerted to 75 allegations of sexual harassment over the last 12 months, 47 of which had been upheld with disciplinary action taken and 29 of which resulted in people being dismissed. At the time a spokesperson for the group said: 'Any incident of misconduct and harassment is unacceptable and subject to rapid and thorough investigation and action.' McDonald's UK was approached for comment.
BreakingNews.ie
4 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Tusla warns it will blow its budget by nearly €68m this year
Tusla has warned it will blow its budget by nearly €68 million this year as it struggles to deal with huge demand for its services. The child and family agency warned in an update in May that it had already overspent by €8.9 million, but this figure was likely to multiply by the end of the year. Advertisement Tusla said its expected overspend for 2025 was €67.8 million, which included €7.6 million for kids in the international protection process and refugees from Ukraine. In a monthly briefing, the agency said demand for its service was growing especially for residential care, fostering, legal bills, and separated children seeking asylum. It said they were trying to cut costs by expanding residential provision to replace special emergency arrangements that were a 'significant cost driver.' Tusla said some savings had been made in this area in 2024 through a 'strict pricing arrangement' and that this would continue this year. Advertisement However, the agency warned that costs remained 'unpredictable' due to the inflated cost of placements. The briefing explained: 'As the majority of Tusla's expenditure is on demand-led arrangements, it is not possible to reduce expenditure materially to meet the budget allocated, without adversely impacting on services for vulnerable children and families.' It said there was likely to be an overspend of €38.8 million on placements for special care, fostering, and private residential arrangements. Tusla also detailed the high cost of 'out-of-state placements' which involves a small number of children brought to the U.K. when services are not available in Ireland. Advertisement The briefing said: 'If the agency cannot place children into special care in the existing facilities in 2025, this has the potential to impact on this year's overspend.' It said costs for staff travel were also likely to be up by as much as €2.2 million despite on expenses being introduced. Tusla also detailed a sharp rise in the number of placements for separated children who had applied for international protection in Ireland. The overspend here was predicted to be around €6.1 million to offer 343 residential placements for vulnerable asylum seekers without parents. Advertisement Other areas of concern for Tusla were 'Guardian ad Litem' (GAL] arrangements where a person was appointed to represent the interests of a child in court. 'There is continued increased usage of GALs by the courts,' the document said, 'and this also has an increased legal cost.' The child and family agency also predicted an overspend for child refugees fleeing the war in Ukraine, according to records released under FOI. Asked about the budget difficulties, a spokesman said: 'Throughout 2025, the agency has experienced unprecedented demand for services, which was unpredictable in nature, and we have worked to prioritise cost saving initiatives around these contributing factors. 'Tusla has strong budget controls in place, however the projected overspend for 2025 is the result of demand-led pressures in the agency for the accommodation of children in the care of the state as well as costs for accommodating unaccompanied minors and associated legal and Guardian ad Litem (GAL) costs.'
BreakingNews.ie
4 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
New Heuson Station control centre faces further delays and cost overrun
A new centre in Dublin developed by Iarnród Éireann to control all train movements on the national rail network which was completed in 2022 will not become operational until late 2028 and is projected to cost €41 million over budget. Further delays and cost overruns on the development of a National Train Control Centre (NTCC) at Heuston Station and a new train traffic management system have been confirmed by the National Transport Authority. Advertisement The NTA admitted that 'additional funding will be required to support the completion of the project." The State's public spending watchdog has also forecast that the total cost of the project, which had an original budget of €148 million, is now likely to be €189 million. In a report on the NTA's annual financial statements for 2024, the Comptroller and Auditor General observed that the estimated cost overrun is now 28% over the original budget. The C&AG, Seamus McCarthy, also noted that the proposal by Iarnród Éireann to develop the NTCC was first approved by the NTA in July 2019. Advertisement The project included the construction of a new train control centre building at Heuston Station, the refurbishment of the existing central train control centre at Connolly Station, and the development of a new electronic train traffic management system and back-up facility. In its latest annual report, the NTA said expenditure on the NTCC had increased by €9.5 million last year compared to 2023 due to 'additional expenditures incurred in 2024 on equipment, materials and project management resources.' While the NTA said it performed in the role of approving authority for public transport projects, the delivery of the NTCC is the responsibility of Iarnród Éireann as the designated sponsoring agency. The NTA said total expenditure on the project up to the end of December 2024 has been €132.5 million. Advertisement In addition to the completion of the new centre at Heuston Station in 2022, the NTA said signalling, electrical and telecommunications enabling works were progressing 'on time and budget.' However, it confirmed that the delays had been experienced over the past two years in relation to the development of the traffic management system component of the project. 'As a result, while the remaining element of the project is planned to be delivered on a phased basis, the final phase is forecasted to be delayed by two years to May 2028,' the NTA stated. Last year, the NTA had estimated that the project would be completed by May 2026. Advertisement The C&AG said final acceptance and handover of the complete system including the back-up facilities are now expected in November 2028 due to 'a significant delay' over the development of the train traffic management system. The NTA said Iarnród Éireann had agreed a revised delivery strategy and associated contractual changes to the software element of the project last year in order to address the delays. In a letter to the Dáil Public Accounts Committee last month, the NTA's interim chief executive, Hugh Creegan, said the current train control system in use on the Irish rail network was reaching end of life and had become 'challenging to maintain.' Mr Creegan stressed that the costs for the building works and other elements of the programme had been and were being delivered within their projected budgets. Advertisement He told TDs that the contractor for the train traffic management system has replaced some key personnel and brought a significant number of additional resources to the project to provide further experience and expertise to the delivery of a complex system. In addition, Mr Creegan said Iarnród Éireann has enhanced its project management resources to deliver better oversight of the contractor and for monitoring progress. Ireland Tusla warns it will blow its budget by nearly €68m... Read More The new NTCC building also houses a new control centre for An Garda Síochána in the Dublin Metropolitan Region. It will also be the location for a new control centre for regional road traffic being overseen by Dublin City Council which is expected to be operational in mid-2026 The Minister for Transport, Darragh O'Brien told the Oireachtas Transport Committee in June that the expected cost outturn for the NTCC was expected to be between €170 and €200 million. 'It is a very important piece of infrastructure. It is something we are working on with the NTA and Iarnród Éireann to get under the bonnet on that,' said Mr O'Brien.
