
Heres why no Western conservative can replicate Donald Trump
The current US president is a unique product of Americas political disfunction, and attempts to mimic him are foolish
Australia's Labor government was returned to office at last Saturday's federal election in a landslide win.
Labor now holds 90 seats in the House of Representatives to the opposition's 40, inflicting a devastating defeat on the conservatives. The opposition leader, Peter Dutton, a keen admirer of Donald Trump, lost his seat.
The conservative opposition in Australia has now been reduced to political irrelevancy in its present form, and - consumed by bitter infighting and recriminations - is destined to disappear as a major political force in the next few years.
Earlier last week the centrist Liberal party in Canada won a federal election, defeating the Conservative party, which had been 25 points ahead in the polls earlier in the year. The Canadian Conservative party leader, Pierre Poilievre - once touted as "Canada's Donald Trump" - also lost his seat.
Last Thursday, in UK local council elections, the British Conservative party suffered a catastrophic defeat at the hands of Nigel Farage's populist Reform party - losing control of a raft of local councils and mayoralties.
Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, is an enthusiastic fan of Donald Trump. She once praised him for being "a force for good in the world" and demanded that the Labour Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary apologise to Trump for daring to have criticised him.
Badenoch is certain to face a leadership challenge in the near future and will be deposed as the conservative leader. The UK Conservative party, just like the conservative coalition in Australia, is destined for political oblivion. So dire is the party's predicament that Robert Jenrick, Badenoch's likely replacement as leader, recently called for it to form a coalition with the Reform party.
These three election results make clear that conservative parties in the West that seek to imitate Trump derive no benefit from doing so - and that mimicking Trump only hastens their imminent political demise.
It is true that Canada is a special case. Trump's absurd threat to make Canada America's "51st state" - a ham-fisted attack on Canadian sovereignty - together with his recent imposition of crippling tariffs made a Liberal election victory virtually inevitable. Canadians have always been particularly sensitive to threats of domination from America.
It is also true that Trump's misguided tariff policy - that threatened the globalist economic order, until the global financial system swiftly compelled him to reverse it - caused his popularity within almost all Western nations, such as it was, to decline overnight.
Why then have conservative leaders in the West nevertheless continued to flirt with Trumpism despite the negative electoral consequences for them?
Conservative leaders clearly believe that by imitating Trump they can duplicate his political "success."
That belief, however, is delusional in the extreme - because the circumstances that created a creature like Trump are qualitatively different from the situation in which conservative leaders in the West are constrained to function.
No mainstream politician in the West could behave as Trump does and seriously expect to be elected prime minister. Nor could a prime minister who refused to accept the result of an election, fomented a violent attack on a sitting parliament, flagrantly disregarded the rule of law, or jailed judges that handed down decisions adverse to him hope to remain in office.
Trump is not a politician at all - despite twice being elected president. Trump is a grotesque populist disrupter, a bizarre product of America's unique political system and its debauched popular celebrity culture.
Conservative leaders ignore the fact that Trump is a president - not a prime minister. Trump does not sit in Congress, and he is not accountable to parliament in the same way that a prime minister or leader of the opposition is.
Furthermore, as president, Trump has executive powers far beyond those exercised by any prime minister. Since being elected last year, Trump has governed by means of executive orders - a quasi-dictatorial political device that has no counterpart in most Western democracies.
Conservative leaders also fail to appreciate the fact that Trump has taken over the Republican party and purged it of ideological divisions.
The Republican party - like all traditional conservative parties - had, prior to Trump's capture of it, always been made up of ideologically opposed factions. When Trump took over the party in 2016 he drove out all the old Reagan and Bush conservatives and brutally imposed ideological unity on the party - hence the sad fate of Liz Cheney and other remnants of the older Republican elites.
Trump has transformed the Republican party into his own personal fiefdom - and this allows him to behave in the disruptive and crude manner in which he has during both of his crisis-ridden presidencies.
No other traditional conservative party in the West is as ideologically unified as Trump's Republican party. In fact, they are all bitterly and deeply ideologically divided. That is why no conservative leader can adopt a fully-fledged Trump agenda - because it would alienate a significant portion of their own parties.
Conservative leaders also fail to appreciate that Trump's Republican party is no longer a conservative party at all - it is a populist party committed to a populist agenda.
Conservative leaders, for all of the above reasons, are in a very different position from Trump.
Nevertheless, they seek to emulate Trump because they are desperate to differentiate themselves from their social democratic political opponents with which - as many voters well know - they are actually in basic ideological and policy agreement.
They also hope that flirting with Trump will help them to ward off the increasingly potent threat from emerging populist parties to their right and shore up their waning electoral support.
This misguided gambit, however, has recently become a losing game for conservative leaders because disaffected voters in the West understandably now seek a genuine ideological alternative to both major parties. These voters - they make up 30% of the electorate and their numbers are increasing - don't want Trump lite, they want the real thing.
Peter Dutton, like Badenoch and Poilievre, has foolishly flirted with Trumpism since becoming the conservative opposition leader three years ago - and his demise neatly illustrates the futility of a conservative leader attempting to turn himself into a Trump clone.
Dutton - urged on by right-wing commentators employed by the Murdoch press, Sky News and the Spectator, as well as his close friend and outspoken Trump enthusiast billionaire Gina Rinehart - eagerly welcomed Trump's election as president last year.
So deranged are Rinehart and segments of the Murdoch media that - even after Saturday's catastrophic election loss - they are still urging what is left of the conservative coalition to become more Trump-like.
Earlier this year, Dutton acquiesced to calls by Trump's lickspittle supporters in his own party and the Murdoch media to recall Australia's ambassador to the US, former Labor Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, because he had the audacity to criticise Trump during his first presidency.
Dutton enthusiastically mimicked Trump's "toughness" towards China and his support for the Netanyahu regime's atrocities in Gaza. When Trump announced his ludicrous and inhumane plan to turn Gaza into a Middle Eastern version of the Riviera, Dutton sycophantically hailed him as "a big thinker" and "shrewd."
Then, just as the election campaign began, Trump imposed his draconian tariffs, thereby endangering the entire globalist economic order, and the Australian stock market crashed.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese rightly protested and criticised Trump for this - but all Dutton did was to suggest that Albanese's attempt to protect Australia's economic interests and was not "tough" enough.
Interestingly, the populist Nigel Farage, who is a close personal friend of Trump and who has campaigned for him, was far more critical of Trump on the tariff issue than Dutton was. Farage even compared Trump to Liz Truss - surely the ultimate political insult. Farage, unlike Dutton, knows that the only way to deal effectively with Trump is to stand up to him. The newly elected Canadian prime minister, Mark Carney, did precisely this at his meeting with Trump this week.
Trump has never been popular with mainstream voters in Australia, and his popularity plummeted after the tariff debacle.
Dutton, however, persisted with his ill-advised Trump flirtation, foolishly following the advice of conservative commentators who urged him to become even more Trump-like. One commentator penned an article early last week stating that Trump had not caused the Conservative party to lose the Canadian election. Perhaps Dutton believed such nonsense.
Dutton staunchly defended one of his shadow cabinet - to whom he had allocated the DOGE-like task of weeding out public service inefficiency - when she was photographed wearing a MAGA cap during the final stages of the election campaign.
And early last week Dutton urged voters to pay no attention to the ABC and The Guardian - which he described, in Trumpian terms, as "the hate media."
Then - just two days before election day - it was revealed that Trump's campaign co-manager, Chris LaCivita, had made a secret trip to Australia two weeks previously to give Dutton election advice. This suggests that Dutton's infatuation with Trump may have been much more intense than previously thought - and the fact that Dutton kept the visit secret speaks for itself.
Dutton could mimic Trump all he liked, but the one thing that he could not do, as a conservative party leader, was adopt a fully-fledged Trumpian agenda that distinguished him from the Labor government. Thus he alienated mainstream voters - while at the same time being unable to attract the votes of those disaffected voters who were seeking a genuine populist alternative to both major parties.
These voters reacted by overwhelmingly voting for the safe and unthreatening Albanese government - that had never cravenly ceded Australia's autonomy to Trump as had Dutton - in unprecedented and unexpected numbers.
And, on Monday, to add insult to injury, in an interview Donald Trump said "I am very friendly with Albanese. I have no idea who the other fellow who ran against him is." In similar fashion, Trump treated Mark Carney with respect when he met with him this week at the White House. Trump may use sycophants, but he only respects winners.
Dutton did not lose last week's election just because of his imprudent mimicking of Donald Trump - but his aping of Trump was indicative of a fundamental lack of political judgment that led to his calamitous electoral defeat.
Donald Trump has exerted a toxic influence on conservative politicians in the West for almost a decade, and will no doubt continue to do so - because conservatism's pathetic and increasingly desperate embrace of Trump is a symptom of its political irrelevance and its ideological bankruptcy.
(RT.com)
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Global News
3 minutes ago
- Global News
World Bank lowers global growth forecast, citing trade war ‘turbulence'
U.S. President Donald Trump's trade wars are expected to slash economic growth this year in the United States and around the world, the World Bank forecast Tuesday. Citing 'a substantial rise in trade barriers'' but without mentioning Trump by name, the 189-country lender predicted that the U.S. economy – the world's largest – would grow half as fast (1.4 per cent) this year as it did in 2024 (2.8 per cent). That marked a downgrade from the 2.3 per cent U.S. growth it had forecast back for 2025 back in January. The bank also lopped 0.4 percentage points off its forecast for global growth this year. It now expects the world economy to expand just 2.3 per cent in 2025, down from 2.8 per cent in 2024. In a forward to the latest version of the twice-yearly Global Economic Prospects report, World Bank chief economist Indermit Gill wrote that the global economy has missed its chance for the 'soft landing'' — slowing enough to tame inflation without generating serious pain — it appeared headed for just six months ago. Story continues below advertisement 'The world economy today is once more running into turbulence,' Gill wrote. 'Without a swift course correction, the harm to living standards could be deep.'' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy America's economic prospects have been clouded by Trump's erratic and aggressive trade policies, including 10 per cent taxes — tariffs — on imports from almost every country in the world. These levies drive up costs in the U.S. and invite retaliation from other countries. 1:46 Can the Liberal government's trade bill unify Canada's economy? The Chinese economy is forecast to see growth slow from five per cent in 2024 to 4.5 per cent this year and four per cent next. The world's second-largest economy has been hobbled by the tariffs that Trump has imposed on its exports, by the collapse of its real estate market and by an aging workforce. The World Bank expects the 20 European countries that share the euro currency to collectively grow just 0.7 per cent this year, down from an already lackluster 0.9 per cent in 2024. Story continues below advertisement Trump's tariffs are expected to hurt European exports. And the unpredictable way he rolls them out — announcing them, suspending them, coming up with new ones — has created uncertainty that discourages business investment. India is once again expected to the be world's fastest-growing major economy, expanding at a 6.3 per cent clip this year. But that's down from 6.5 per cent in 2024 and from the 6.7 per cent the bank had forecast for 2025 in January. In Japan, economic growth is expected to accelerate this year – but only from 0.2 per cent in 2024 to a sluggish 0.7 per cent this year, well short of the 1.2 per cent the World Bank had forecast in January. The World Bank seeks to reduce poverty and boost living standards by providing grants and low-rate loans to poor economies. Another multinational organization that seeks to promote global prosperity — the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development — last week downgraded its forecast for the U.S. and global economies.


Global News
16 minutes ago
- Global News
‘Arrest me': California governor dares Trump as L.A. ICE protests escalate
California Gov. Gavin Newsom urged U.S. President Donald Trump to stop targeting immigrants and arrest him instead after the deployment of an additional 2,000 National Guard troops and 700 Marines to anti-ICE protests in Los Angeles on Monday. Trump had already sent 2,000 National Guard troops to the city on Sunday as violence escalated during three days of demonstrations driven by outrage over the president's ramped-up enforcement of his immigration policy that critics say is tearing migrant families apart. View image in full screen Demonstrators protest outside a downtown jail in Los Angeles following two days of clashes with police during a series of immigration raids on June 8, 2025. Spencer Platt / Getty Images Monday's protests saw fewer violent clashes between civilians and U.S. military forces, as thousands of participants marched peacefully at city hall and hundreds outside of a federal detention centre where some immigrants are being held following sweeping citywide raids. Story continues below advertisement View image in full screen Hundreds of protesters gather to demand an immediate end to Immigration and Customs Enforcement workplace raids in Los Angeles, Calif., on June 8, 2025. (PhotTayfun Coskun / Getty Images On Monday, Trump endorsed the arrest of Newsom by Tom Homan, the U.S. border czar, telling reporters, 'I would do it, I think it's great.' On Tuesday, Newsom responded to Trump in a television interview saying, 'Get it over with, arrest me.' Story continues below advertisement 'If you need some head to scalp, do it with me, but stop messing with these kids, stop messing with four-year-olds, kids in elementary school,' he continued, adding there are hundreds of students in California who are not attending their graduation ceremonies in fear of their classmates being detained by ICE. Last week, 18-year-old Marcelo Gomes Da Silva from Milford, Mass., was absent from his girlfriend's graduation, where he was supposed to play drums in the school band, because he was detained by ICE on his way to volleyball practice. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Still in their gowns, students rallied for his return after the ceremony. View image in full screen Family and classmates of Marcelo Gomes Da Silva protested outside of Milford Town Hall on June 1, 2025, a day after the teen was detained by ICE on his way to volleyball practice. Jessica Rinaldi / Getty Images Gomes Da Silva was released from custody on bond on June 6. Story continues below advertisement Despite his call to Trump, Newsom has not been charged with any crimes, and there is no evidence that he has committed an offence or broken any laws, nor has he been accused by anyone in government of conduct that could lead to criminal charges, according to NBC News. The outlet added that Trump's statement was followed by a warning from Homan, who suggested over the weekend that state and local officials could face arrest and criminal charges if they interfere with federal agents executing raids. In recent weeks, the Trump administration has arrested numerous political and judicial officials, alleging they acted in contravention of its anti-immigration mandate. Ras Baraka, the Democratic mayor of Newark, N.J., was arrested by ICE during a visit to a federal immigration detention centre that he says is violating safety protocols. Story continues below advertisement Similarly, Democratic U.S. House member LaMonica McIver was charged after visiting an ICE detention facility in New Jersey. In April, a sitting Wisconsin judge, Hannah Dugan, was also taken into custody and charged with crimes that allegedly obstructed the detention of an undocumented immigrant, according to the FBI. On Tuesday, United States Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth said before the House Committee that military personnel would remain in Los Angeles for 60 days to 'ensure that those rioters, looters and thugs on the other side assaulting our police officers know that we're not going anywhere.' Trump, who has repeatedly referred to Newsom as 'Newscum' this week, also said in a Truth Social post that the protesters in Los Angeles were 'violent insurrectionist mobs' who 'are swarming and attacking federal agents,' adding that 'order will be restored and the Illegals will be expelled.' As the protests escalated, Trump continued to comment on social media, writing Monday, 'Looking really bad in L.A. BRING IN THE TROOPS!!!' In January, on his first day of his second term in office, the president pardoned 1,500 people charged with crimes for their role in the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, including those convicted of assaulting police officers. Following Trump's claims of insurgency, Newsom responded to Deputy Chief of Staff Stephen Miller's X comments, which accused the governor of overseeing 'a criminal sanctuary for millions of illegal alien invaders, cartel killers, foreign terrorists, transnational gangs and insurrectionist mobs,' with the rebuttal: 'The only people defending insurrectionists are you and @realDonaldTrump…or, are we pretending like you didn't pardon 1500 of them?' Story continues below advertisement The only people defending insurrectionists are you and @realDonaldTrump. Or, are we pretending like you didn't pardon 1500 of them? — Gavin Newsom (@GavinNewsom) June 10, 2025 Newsom also confirmed Monday that California will sue Trump over his deployment of the National Guard to quash protests without the consent of the governor. The deployment of the National Guard without the permission of a state governor marked a significant escalation against those seeking to hamper the government's mass deportation efforts. The last time a president invoked this power was in 1965, when Lyndon B. Johnson sent troops to protect a civil rights march in Alabama, according to the Brennan Center for Justice. — With files from The Associated Press


Global News
32 minutes ago
- Global News
‘Scant progress' offloading federal office space for affordable housing: AG
The federal government has made little headway on its pledge to get rid of unused office space and transform some of it into affordable housing. A report released Tuesday by Auditor General Karen Hogan found that Public Services and Procurement Canada has made 'scant progress' on that commitment, reducing its office footprint by only two per cent between 2019 and 2024. The department planned to cut office space by 50 per cent by 2034, estimating it could save nearly $4 billion over the next decade. But Hogan says there has been little movement on the initiative, which could also alleviate the housing crisis. The auditor general blamed the inaction 'mainly on a lack of funding.' 1:36 Report gives Alberta lowest rating in the country for housing policies 'The federal government has been slow to reduce office space and cut costs to support hybrid work, and to convert surplus properties into affordable housing,' Hogan said. Story continues below advertisement 'Public Services and Procurement Canada and federal tenants need to accelerate their efforts to reduce the office space they occupy and contribute to increasing stock for housing that is sustainable, accessible, and affordable.' Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Last year, former prime minister Justin Trudeau promised to free up public land and vacant government offices to build more homes for Canadians, as part of his commitment in the Liberals' 2024 budget to restore fairness 'for every generation.' 'Governments across Canada are sitting on surplus, underused public land, like empty office towers, low rise buildings, there is great potential.' To unlock some of that potential, Trudeau announced a $500-million public lands acquisition fund. 1:43 Should home prices go down? 'No,' says Canada's new housing minister In 2017, Ottawa estimated that half of its office space was either vacant or underused. Three years later, even more buildings sat empty, as COVID-19 ushered in a new era of remote work. Story continues below advertisement Today, with public servants mandated to work a minimum of three days a week in office, most federal offices are still not at 100 per cent capacity. With bureaucrats back in the office, federal tenants are reluctant to leave. 'More public servants needing to spend more time in the building and hence are hesitant … to clear out of the building,' Hogan said. 'I know from our office I can tell you that we put up our hand and said with hybrid work, we don't need the space that we have, and we have offered to reduce our workspace,' she added. 'I would hope that other deputy heads would do the same in order to support the goal.'