Time to walk away? NHL analyst stirs controversy by claiming Sidney Crosby could be 'aged out' of Penguins rebuild
For the first time in years, the unthinkable is being discussed out loud—Sidney Crosby, the face of the Pittsburgh Penguins for nearly two decades, could potentially finish his career elsewhere.
That's the bombshell NHL analyst Justin Cuthbert dropped on The FAN Pregame podcast, citing the Penguins' recent failure to rebuild around Crosby effectively.
Sidney Crosby
's loyalty questioned amid Penguins' playoff drought and aging roster
Justin Cuthbert argued that Pittsburgh has wasted Sidney Crosby's late prime by surrounding him with veteran stopgaps instead of younger core pieces. 'They missed the opportunity to get better, and around Sidney Crosby to the point now that I think it's very possible,' he said, hinting at the once-taboo idea of a Crosby trade.
'They did it with a lot older, veteran-type players,' he added, pointing to moves like acquiring Erik Karlsson instead of building a long-term foundation.
Sidney Crosby still producing elite numbers while the franchise slips further from contention
Despite missing the playoffs three years in a row, Crosby has managed to score over 90 points in each of those seasons, shouldering the team's burden and keeping hopes alive. But even his heroics may not be enough to offset the Penguins' trajectory. 'Pittsburgh is not going to be very good for a long time,' Cuthbert said bluntly.
'He's going to age out in that roster to go win somewhere else, is what I think.'
The 2026 Winter Olympics are being floated as a possible turning point, with speculation mounting that Crosby may reassess his future based on the team's direction and whether longtime teammate Evgeni Malkin stays or goes.
Insiders suggest the final decision rests with Sidney Crosby alone
NHL insider Frank Seravalli also weighed in this week, stating, 'He (Crosby) hasn't shown any interest to the Pittsburgh Penguins in moving.
And they're sure as heck not going to go ask a franchise icon if he's interested in moving.' Seravalli emphasized that the only way a move would happen is if Crosby initiates it.
For now, fans must grapple with a sobering reality: the Crosby-Malkin era may be approaching its emotional final chapter.
Also Read:
Connor McDavid's cryptic comments spark panic as Oilers fans fear star could walk in free agency
FAQs
1. Is Sidney Crosby considering leaving the Pittsburgh Penguins?
While Sidney Crosby hasn't shown interest in leaving, NHL analysts believe he might consider it if the Penguins keep struggling.
2. Why are analysts suggesting Sidney Crosby should be traded?
Experts like Justin Cuthbert say the Penguins failed to rebuild around Sidney Crosby and that he's 'aging out' of a roster with little chance to win.
3. Would the Penguins ever trade Sidney Crosby?
According to Frank Seravalli, the team won't suggest a move—any trade would only happen if Sidney Crosby initiates the conversation himself.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
NHL Trade Rumors: Erik Karlsson sets clear condition for Pittsburgh Penguins exit amid rebuilding talks
As the Pittsburgh Penguins enter a pivotal offseason, veteran defenseman Erik Karlsson has become a central figure in trade discussions. The team, which has missed the Stanley Cup Playoffs for three consecutive years, is now shifting toward a rebuild, making big names like Karlsson, Rickard Rakell, and Bryan Rust available for potential trades. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now But one thing stands out in Karlsson's case: he's not willing to land just anywhere. Eric Karlsson wants one thing in a trade: a real shot at winning the Stanley Cup According to NHL insider Frank Seravalli, Erik Karlsson has made it clear that he only wants to be traded to a contender. 'Karlsson wants a chance to win,' Seravalli shared, emphasizing that any interested team will not only have to absorb Karlsson's sizable contract but also meet his championship expectations. With this demand, the market for Karlsson becomes both exclusive and strategic. Only teams with both the cap flexibility and playoff-ready rosters need apply, making destinations like the Dallas Stars, Detroit Red Wings, and Carolina Hurricanes the most viable suitors. Each of these franchises has reportedly been exploring ways to reinforce their defensive core and make a serious Cup run. Penguins expected to move Eric Karlsson before start of 2025–26 NHL season Karlsson's contract, coupled with his desire to win, limits trade options but also clarifies the direction of talks. The Penguins, led by GM Kyle Dubas, are looking to refresh the roster and prepare for the future, meaning offloading Karlsson before the puck drops in the 2025–26 season is a top priority. The former Norris Trophy winner still has value, especially to a playoff-bound team in need of elite offensive skill from the blue line. Despite the obstacles, insiders believe a trade could realistically happen in the coming weeks, positioning Karlsson for one last serious Stanley Cup push. Also Read: FAQs does Erik Karlsson want in a trade? He only wants to be traded to a Stanley Cup contender. 2. Which teams are most likely to trade for Eric Karlsson? Detroit, Dallas, and Carolina have been named as top possibilities. 3. Will Eric Karlsson be traded before the 2025–26 season starts? All signs point to the Penguins moving him before the 2025–26 campaign begins.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
NHL Trade Buzz: Connor McDavid's future unclear as Oilers maintain wait-and-see stance while contract runs out
Connor McDavid's future with Oilers in doubt as contract extension talks remain at a standstill (Imagn Images) With Connor McDavid entering the final year of his blockbuster eight-year deal, the Edmonton Oilers find themselves walking a tightrope. The franchise's most valuable asset— and arguably the NHL's best player— is eligible for an extension, but as of now, no formal movement has taken place. Fans, media, and league insiders are watching closely, yet Oilers management is taking a patient, calculated approach as McDavid continues to call the shots. Connor McDavid's contract future keeps Oilers Nation on edge as extension talks stay quiet Oilers general manager Stan Bowman, who stepped into the spotlight during a recent interview with CHED 880, acknowledged that contract discussions are still in the 'early stages.' And while that might sound like a cause for concern, Bowman emphasized that giving McDavid space has been part of the strategy. 'I've had really good conversations with Judd Moldaver [McDavid's agent] since the season ended,' Bowman said. 'I've tried to give Connor his space, and I think that it's important. A lot of this is respecting the athlete and their timeline.' This measured approach comes after a grueling season in which McDavid once again put up eye-popping numbers—100 points in the regular season and 33 more in the playoffs— leading Edmonton to back-to-back Stanley Cup Final appearances. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Benefits of Trading Bitcoin CFDs IC Markets Learn More Undo by Taboola by Taboola His performance only reaffirms his elite status, and it's no surprise that the Oilers are ready to make him the NHL's highest-paid player, with estimates crossing the $17 million mark once the cap rises to $104 million in 2026–27. Winning is still the priority for Connor McDavid Despite the looming pressure of free agency in 2026, McDavid's comments after Edmonton's Stanley Cup Final loss shed light on what matters most to him. 'Winning would be at the top of the list,' he said. 'Winning is the most important thing. If I feel there's a good window to win here over and over again, then signing is no problem.' That sentiment echoes Bowman's understanding of the situation. '(McDavid is) a huge part of everything we do here,' he added. 'I don't have a timeline update, but I do expect to have some conversations with them soon and hopefully get that wrapped up.' For now, the hockey world waits. McDavid holds the keys, and the Oilers seem determined to do everything they can to keep them in Edmonton— on his terms. FAQs: 1. Is Connor McDavid a free agent? Connor McDavid can become an unrestricted free agent on July 1, 2026. 2. Has Connor McDavid ever played for another NHL team? No. McDavid has spent his entire NHL career with the Edmonton Oilers, who drafted him first overall in 2015. 3. How much could McDavid earn in his next contract? Reports suggest the Oilers are prepared to make him the highest-paid player in NHL history, potentially offering over $17 million annually, especially with the league's salary cap projected to hit $104 million by 2026–27. Also Read: NHL Trade Rumors: Oilers captain Connor McDavid reportedly eyeing Maple Leafs switch to reunite with Auston Matthews For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
Dakota Joshua reflects on cancer battle and eyes redemption with Toronto Maple Leafs ahead of 2025–26 NHL season
After a challenging 2024–25 campaign marred by health issues and injury setbacks, Dakota Joshua is ready for a fresh start, this time with the Toronto Maple Leafs. Traded from the Vancouver Canucks, the 29-year-old is eager to move forward from a season he calls a "setback," and he's looking to make a meaningful impact on a team hungry to overcome its playoff struggles. Dakota Joshua opens up on cancer diagnosis, injury setbacks, and mental resilience ahead of Maple Leafs debut Joshua's 2024–25 season was derailed before it began, as a testicular cancer diagnosis forced him to miss training camp and the opening stretch of the season. After returning to action, a lower-body injury sidelined him once again, ultimately limiting him to just 14 points in 57 games. In a recent interview on Leafs Morning Take, Joshua called the experience mentally and physically draining. 'That was a tough situation to go through,' he said. 'To go through that, especially after signing a new deal, was tough… It felt like I was playing catch-up the whole season.' Despite the hardship, Joshua said he's grateful for the support he received and is focused on leaving that chapter behind. 'I'm very happy and thankful to be in good health now and once again try to build my career and keep going.' Dakota Joshua Talks Trade to Toronto, Playing for Berube, & Beating Cancer Maple Leafs reunion gives Dakota Joshua fresh opportunity, roster depth, and confidence boost for 2025–26 NHL season The move to Toronto is also something of a full-circle moment for Joshua. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo He was originally selected by the Maple Leafs in the fifth round of the 2014 NHL Entry Draft but never played a game for them. His NHL breakthrough came with Vancouver, where he posted a career-best 32 points in 2023–24, earning a four-year, $3.25 million AAV contract. Now returning to the team that once drafted him, Joshua is ready to take on a key depth role. 'Not just relying so much on the top-end guys… you need everybody,' he said of Toronto's playoff ambitions. 'I feel like for myself, adding to the depth of the team will help a lot.' Joshua credits his time in Vancouver with helping him find consistency and confidence in his game, saying he now understands what it takes to be an everyday NHL player. Dakota Joshua's journey back to Toronto is more than just a trade, it's a chance to reclaim momentum in his career. With renewed health, perspective, and purpose, he now looks to be a difference-maker for a Leafs team eager to end its postseason drought. FAQs: 1. Was Dakota Joshua originally drafted by the Maple Leafs? Yes, he was drafted by Toronto in the fifth round of the 2014 NHL Entry Draft. 2. What happened to Dakota Joshua last season? He was diagnosed with cancer and missed time due to injury. Also Read: Connor McDavid contract update: Edmonton Oilers GM Stan Bowman 'encouraged' by early NHL extension talks with superstar forward For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
