Lions' series win will leave Schmidt and Wallabies to ruminate over 'what ifs'
'Who will this delay suit more?'
'How will the players deal with an interruption like this?
'Does it mean anything that Australia are back on the field ahead of the resumption while the Lions are still in the changing room?'
While these questions are virtually impossible to answer, it would be a fair read of the third Test that it meant more to the Wallabies than it did to the Lions, totally understandably.
In retrospect, Andy Farrell may question his selection: a handful of players with a greater point to prove than the series winners might have stirred something other than a lame Lions performance.
From Joe Schmidt's perspective, though, the questions will lead with 'what if'.
Advertisement
What if Rob Valetini had been available for the the full series? What if Will Skelton was up to full speed? What if Harry Potter had lasted for all of the second Test? What if I hadn't so readily discarded Taniela Tupou? What if we got a fair crack of the whip from the officials?
The former Ireland head coach won't be happy that Dan Sheehan's clear-out on Tom Lynagh, for example, which led to the Aussie out-half's withdrawal following a HIA, went unpunished. But to zoom out from the third Test specifically and unpack the series as a whole, Schmidt has reason to be seriously proud of his players.
In the sands of time, only the Lions' 2-1 win will really matter, but from the 43rd minute of the first Test onwards, Schmidt's Wallabies were arguably the better side.
Indeed, their trajectory might one day soon see to it that the Lions' 2025 series victory is painted in a different complexion.
Before this tour, the consensus would have been that Ireland, England, or perhaps even Scotland, could have won a summer series in Australia, not to mind a collection of the best players from those countries and Wales. Such bullishness would be rarer now.
Ahead of this third Test, the Lions laid it plain that they were chasing history, a first 3-0 series sweep since a tour of Argentina 98 years ago. Easily forgotten is the motivation to avoid becoming a part of history, and the Wallabies' cause — as well as their players — simply proved stronger than those of the Lions in Sydney.
Farrell will be disappointed but hardly dismayed. That his side fell short of their 3-0 target will rankle but one day in the distant future, beyond the documentaries and podcasts and after-dinner speaking, rugby fans will see that he was a series-winning head coach. More intriguing may be the 'New Zealand tour of 2029′ category on his Wikipedia page.
And while the Lions' overall achievement in Australia may have been unremarkable (the tourists have won eight out of 10 total series Down Under), the feeling of futility that pervaded rugby discourse on either side of the first Test was obliterated by the spectacle that was the second meeting in Melbourne.
If it gave us nothing else, the 2025 tour gave us that epic at the MSG, perhaps the greatest Test match since the World Cup quarter-finals weekend of 2023, and certainly the best Lions Test since the second game in South Africa in 2009. And surely a game like Melbourne is the point of these things, or at least it's the trade-off for the naked commercialism that fuels the Lions as a concept in the modern era. Most rugby fans still consider it a fair deal.
That second Test and the summer as a whole have highlighted an undeniable truth, which is that rugby union needs a strong Australia. The sport is just more fun for the rest of us when the Wallabies are good, and when the Australian public is engaged with its national team.
Should the series catapult Schmidt's side back to the top table in time for the 2027 World Cup — and that idea will be tested away to South Africa in the Rugby Championship in two weeks' time — then it was worthwhile for that alone.
This series was less the Lions' Everest, more a hike up the Sugar Loaf. The view is still pretty nice from the top.
And yet the Wallabies were only a stroke of fortune or two short of scaling a far mightier height.
As this year's tour begins to fade out of view, another difficult question can be put to rest: yes, the Lions should absolutely tour Australia again in 2037.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Jim Williams recalls Munster move: 'It was one of the best decisions I ever made'
A visit to Australia by the British & Irish Lions always offers former Wallaby Jim Williams an opportunity to reflect, both on his experience of playing against the tourists and the doors it opened for a career-defining move to Munster. It is 24 years ago that Williams captained a Brumbies side including Stephen Larkham against a Lions team featuring Munster icons and soon-to-be clubmates Ronan O'Gara and David Wallace and then tasted victory over Graham Henry's 2001 tourists in an Australia A jersey. Two months later, having been overlooked for the Test series after 14 caps and a place in the 1999 World Cup-winning squad, the No.8 was making his debut in red in a pre-season friendly for Declan Kidney's side at Musgrave Park against London Irish. Williams played 74 times for Munster, became the province's captain before transitioning to an assistant coach under Kidney in the historic 2005-06 season at the end of which the Heineken Cup was lifted for the first time. By the time he left for home to take up the same role with the Wallabies at the end of the 2007-08, 'Seamus' was a Munster icon in his own right and now 56 he has not forgotten the impact his seven years in Ireland has made on him. Williams is no longer involved in rugby, choosing lifestyle over coaching professionally with a career change to a government job and moving south of Sydney to Woolongong. Yet the 2025 Lions tour drew him back in once more, if only from his sofa. "It's been excellent," he told the Irish Examiner before settling down for the final Test last Saturday. "I mean I love the Lions tours, doesn't matter where they are and where they're playing, it's always something that I try not to miss." Shane Horgan, Leinster, in action against Munster's Jim Williams, 6, and Ronan O'Gara in the Celtic League Final 2001. Pic: Matt Browne, Sportsfile Playing against the 2001 Lions was a significant moment for Williams. "It was my first introduction to Ronan O'Gara and guys like that. It certainly holds special memories, and the game down in Canberra (with the Brumbies) was excellent. "We got really close to beating them that night, great atmosphere, and all those special memories certainly of that Lions tour when they came out in 2001. "And I joined Munster straight after that Lions tour.' Williams credits a young adult life as an amateur player for helping him to settle so successfully at Munster. He joined the Australian Army at 17, also worked as a plumber and had a season in English club rugby at West Hartlepool in the mid-nineties. "I didn't play professional rugby until I was 30, with the Brumbies. I suppose that might have helped a little bit, being a little bit more mature, and moving with my partner at the time wasn't a big deal because it was the two of us. "So it wasn't a massive move, but I certainly did take the time, and I had a lot of advice from John Langford at the time about Munster. "I did have a few other offers in France and I just thought basically going to an English-speaking place over in Europe was probably on my mind. "And the fact that it was Munster and John Langford had been there and had raved about it an had been so well accepted and had been successful himself, it really wasn't an issue about where I was going to go after that. "It was always going to be Munster from there on in, and certainly it worked out that way. It was just a wonderful time of my life." For Munster supporters, memories of Williams the powerful ball carrier and tackler with excellent leadership qualities tend to stand out, yet the man himself equally cherishes the dressing room camaraderie he felt as a player and his time as a coach under Kidney, when the province finally lifted the Heineken Cup. "Winning those from a coaching perspective, my first year of coaching and having the likes of Declan Kidney back and that kind of thing, that was wonderful from that perspective. And to be able to do it in 2008 as well, that was very special. 'Obviously as a player, you always want to win those titles, but I think from a coaching perspective, it was extremely rewarding. "It's not easy to go from a playing environment to a coaching environment, especially with guys that you've just done so much with. "As a player, I just had the right environment around me, I had the right coaching, I had the right players, and the right support outside of rugby as well to be able to succeed while I was there. "I can't pick out one game. I mean, people pick out the Gloucester game, the Miracle game and all that kind of thing but I think every time I got on the pitch with those boys, the likes of Ronan O'Gara, Paul O'Connell, Donncha O'Callaghan, Anthony Horgan, those type of guys, it was always something that I was going to try my best at. "I didn't need to think about it. I didn't need to do anything different from what I normally do. I did the work during the week and I knew all these boys would. "You didn't always win games, things didn't always work out, but I knew the effort was always there and I think that was probably the most enjoyable thing from a playing perspective. "I always knew these guys were always going to put it in every time they went out and from a coaching perspective, I think to coach that and see that from outside was just as rewarding. "I suppose just the experience that I had playing with the guys and being able to coach them, I think it's probably the most special thing that I can take away from my time at Munster. "I had success playing with them. I probably had more success being part of the coaching staff and being able to be a part of those two titles that we got, I think it was just wonderful. It's just something that I'll never forget." Williams thinks Australia should send more of their players overseas to experience different environments, conditions and team cultures and cites Will Skelton's current spell under O'Gara at La Rochelle as a prime example of the benefits to Wallaby rugby. And he cited his only visit to the redeveloped Thomond Park with the Australians on the November tour of 2016 as the perfect example of a collective lack of experience as Munster defeated the touring Wallabies 15-6 on a typically wild cold and stormy winter's night in Limerick. 'I've been back to the stadium once with Australia which wasn't a happy hunting ground That was a wild night. I've seen conditions like that before and I wasn't surprised. "The team that went out that night, the coaches that went out that night, the looks on their faces, they hadn't been a part of conditions like that. 'I had no illusions about the conditions that were going to happen and full credit to Munster that game, they just played the conditions perfectly and that's more or less what won them the game and they thoroughly deserved it. "That's the beauty about playing overseas and going overseas and playing. Obviously playing in different countries but playing in different environments and playing in different conditions. "You've got the likes of Nic White who have come back and guys like Will Skelton who I think is a better player for the fact of playing overseas and understanding what it's like to play in different conditions and different arenas and different styles of football. "It should be a wonderful learning experience to go overseas with the Wallabies on the Spring tours. Yes, they want to play and they want to play well and they want to win but they want to learn from those aspects about playing overseas and playing in different conditions and weather that's not conducive to running rugby and adjusting your game and adjusting the mentality about what you do and how you do things to win games. 'It's certainly an honour playing over in Europe and playing in different conditions and it's just something that I'm so glad I did, when I had the opportunity to do it. It was one of the best decisions I ever made."
Irish Daily Mirror
13 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Ireland star has Lions teammates in stitches after brutal putdown
The British and Lions tours are famous for behind the scenes access to players and coaches. Quite often, some of the most memorable moments of Lions tours comes from the documentary episodes as players from four different nations come together as one squad. The 2025 Lions tour, under the leadership of Irish boss Andy Farrell, featured 11 Irish players including Leinster's Josh van der Flier. The 2022 world player of the year failed to make a test appearance but he has absolutely nailed Welsh captain Jac Morgan in the final part of the Ultimate Test' docu-series. That YouTube series has taken fans behind the curtain on the 2025 tour. As part of the final episode, viewers were able to see what was happening on the team coach to the stadium ahead of the last game. Reading out suggestions for the 'Barry Crocker' (shocker) award, Van der Flier read out Morgan's message. The Wales captain and Lions teammate's text read: "Alright Josh, boy? You should do yourself for Barry Crocker for being the only Leinster player in the original squad not to get named in the Test team!" As Van der Flier mouthed "Ooo", the players laughed in response, with Jamie George and James Lowe lapping up the sledging. However, the Irish flanker had a very sharp and witty retort. "That's very rich from a man who's won more games for the Lions than he has for club and country this year!" he hit back. There was a massive roar from the players, with Ellis Genge's fist flying in the air, exchanging a smile with buddy Morgan, who was sat right next to Van der Flier. However, this wasn't the only bit of banter dished out by Morgan, who quipped via text: "Alright Josh, boy? Any ideas for the Barry Crocker? I was thinking we do Bundee Aki for being 37 years old and his highest academic achievement is the World Rugby Anti-Doping module." The Lions wrapped up the series against Australia after the second Test, winning with a game to spare for the first time since 1997 against South Africa. The docu-series has given fans a number of other highlights and insights. Ireland's Dan Sheehan revealed that he has struck up a surprising bromance with England's Ellis Genge, with the Leinster man admitting he was surprised to learn that the prop was 'not a d******d'.
The Irish Sun
15 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Rassie Erasmus aims brutal comeback at Virgin Media pundit after his South Africa Lions Tour jibe
Erasmus referred back to when Williams presided over a Six Nations rival of Ireland's between 2003-2005 TAKE MATT Rassie Erasmus aims brutal comeback at Virgin Media pundit after his South Africa Lions Tour jibe THE dust has begun to settle on the 2025 Lions Tour of Australia with opinions split on whether it was good, bad or indifferent. A 2-1 series win for the British and Irish all-star squad epitomises the middling sense most rugby fans have come away from it with. Advertisement 4 Matt Williams is on the more positive side of the debate Credit: @offtheball 4 Rassie Erasmus has cultivated an image of himself as a serial winner Credit: AP 4 Which the South African boss used to his advantage while responding to Williams 4 These days the 65-year-old is primarily known on these shores as a Virgin Media analyst Credit: @VMSportIE A 3-0 series sweep would've at least ensured there was a more historic component to beating one of the weaker Australian teams in living memory. This is because was the last time a Lions selection went unbeaten while on Tour. The Aviva Stadium opener on June 20 where they lost to Argentina technically didn't count since they hadn't touched down on Australian soil yet. But in any case, Sunday's lightning-interrupted letdown allowed the Wallabies to salvage some pride with a 22-12 victory. Advertisement The visitors' presence Down Under reportedly hasn't gripped the nation given rugby union is far behind the likes of Aussie Rules and rugby league in the pecking order. But it has at least erased the Australian rugby union's sizeable debts to the tune of an approximate $100m. Aussie Matt Williams has also made the case that it was a better spectacle than its predecessor - a trudge of kick-tennis between the Lions and South Africa in front of no crowds due to the pandemic. He told Off the Ball: "The 2021 South Africa Tour were the worst games of international rugby I think I've ever seen. Advertisement "The way both management teams, the off field teams, conducted themselves was disgraceful. "Rassie was running on the field as a water carrier and leaking videos criticising referees, ringing people up. Ireland rugby ace dressed as 'Fred Flintstone' stuns pub crowd in Mayo with stunning accordion performance on stag night "The style of rugby was an abomination, all they did was kick across the field and chase. It was not played in a good spirit. 'It was aggressive, I have no problem with it being aggressive but it wasn't played in the spirit of rugby. Advertisement 'The Lions are the keepers of the law. They are so special, and they got to keep going, but to suggest that this Lions Tour didn't restore that absolutely tarnished image of what it meant to play Lions rugby is just a fallacy. 'They came to Australia, and from the first second, Andy Farrell and his coaching staff made the Lions play a running game. "They put the ball in hand, they took chances and made errors, because it's high-risk rugby but jeez, it was entertaining. It was fabulous to watch. 'The Lions can be very proud that they took that and restored their image on the field.' Advertisement Williams has been an ardent critic in the past when it comes to Erasmus' effective if blunt playing style with the former arguing World Rugby ought to try out new rules to negate the ever-growing importance of scrums. So it wasn't altogether surprising to see his latest criticism had drawn a reaction from Springboks supporters - and Erasmus himself. The former Munster chief took aim at Williams' paltry winning percentage when in charge of the Scotland national team while sarcastically adding: "Hello Sir Matt."
