Alleged text after wife drowns revealed
The text allegedly sent by Graeme Davidson in 2023 - three years after his wife Jacqueline drowned while the couple were kayaking north of Brisbane - was aired during a bail application at Brisbane Supreme Court on Wednesday.
A judge is yet to rule on whether Mr Davidson, who held ranks in the British and Australian Armies, will be granted bail despite submissions continuing over a week.
Mr Davidson is facing a single charge of murder in relation to Jacqueline's death. No plea has been entered.
The couple were kayaking on Lake Samsonvale in Petrie on November 27, 2020 when Jacqueline drowned and could not be revived. Graeme Davidson is charged with the murder of his wife Jacqueline, after she drowned while the couple were kayaking in Petrie in 2020. Supplied Credit: Supplied
Police allege Mr Davidson was involved in his wife's death.
He is also charged with fraud and attempted fraud, relating to allegations he tried to claim almost $1m in life insurance payouts following his wife's death. No pleas have been entered.
Mr Davidson's barrister Craig Eberhardt KC has made lengthy submissions over the course of the bail application, attesting to the weakness of the Crown's case and the strength of the evidence against his client.
On Wednesday, crown prosecutor Caroline Marco argued it only needed to be determined whether Mr Davidson had shown cause as to why his detention in custody was unjustified, not to rule on the strength of the case. Ms Davidson could not be revived after she was pulled from the waters of Lake Samsonvale. Supplied / Channel 9 Credit: Supplied
She told the court the case against Mr Davidson was circumstantial – noting inconsistencies in statements he allegedly gave about his wife's death.
They allegedly include telling witnesses that she 'jumped, or dove' into the water from the kayak and that she was still 'alive', 'conscious' when she was pulled to shore.
Ms Marco said Mr Davidson's phone allegedly 'ceased to exist on the network' at 11.14am - three-and-a-half hours before the triple-0 call and an hour after the couple set off on their kayaks.
'Some... explanations may be that the phone was switched off, it was otherwise inoperable, on flight mode or not connecting with the tower,' Ms Marco said. Crown Prosecutor Caroline Marco said Mr Davidson posed an 'unacceptable risk' if released on bail. NewsWire / John Gass Credit: News Corp Australia Craig Eberhardt KC, who is representing Mr Davidson. NewsWire / John Gass Credit: News Corp Australia
The court was told Mr Davidson had given no explanation for why it was not on the network.
Ms Marco said the device had never been recovered and there was 'inexplicable evidence' of its disconnection from the network.
She said Mr Davidson posed an 'unacceptable risk' of 'interfering with witnesses or obstructing the course of justice'.
'There's inexplicable evidence of its disconnection to the network,' she said.
'There had to be a reason why it could not be used to render assistance to Jacqueline, and therefore to justify the course that was taken of walking her two kilometres back to the boat ramp.'
Ms Marco said the risk of Mr Davidson failing to appear was due to the mandatory penalty of life imprisonment he faced if convicted, in addition to his lack of ties to Australia, as he had only returned from Thailand twice since his wife's death.
The court was told Mr Davidson allegedly texted a friend three years after Jacqueline's death, describing himself as a 'cliche' because he was an 'older man married to a younger woman'. The court was told Mr Davidson's phone had not been recovered and allegedly 'ceased to exist on the network' an hour before the kayaking trip. Supplied / Channel 9 Credit: Supplied
It was allegedly followed by the comment: 'There are lots of western divorcees out here because are no de facto rules and you can't lose 50 per cent of your s--t'.
Ms Marco said this exchange went to allegations that Mr Davidson expressed concerns about 'dividing assets' in the event of a failed relationship.
The court has previously been told Ms Davidson discovered her husband was having an affair with a woman in Papua New Guinea in 2019, leading to a strain in their marriage.
She referenced an exchange Mr Davidson had with his friend Chesty in the years prior to Jacqueline's death, where he had allegedly said he would kill his wife and move to Thailand if she ever 'sought a divorce and made a claim to his military pension'.
Mr Eberhardt described it as a 'quip' as the pair were discussing how, on the day of Chesty's retirement, his wife announced she was leaving him, taking half his assets and moving to Thailand.
'My learned friend described this as a 'quip', but Your Honour can see it's not supported by (Chesty's) evidence... it shocked him,' Ms Marco said.
Mr Eberhardt said there was no suggestion his client had fled Australia's jurisdiction by moving to Thailand as he had maintained contact with police and the Coroner's Court in the years since Jacqueline's death. Mr Davidson is alleged to have texted a friend about divorce in Thailand in 2023. Queensland Police Service Credit: News Corp Australia
The court was told Mr Davidson was still receiving military pensions from both the Australian and British governments.
'It's not as if he's a Tony Mokbel, who had the criminal contacts and resources to escape... this fellow is an otherwise law-abiding citizen who has been a commissioned officer in both the British and the Australian Army for many, many years,' Mr Eberhardt said.
Mr Davidson was prepared to report daily, offer a substantial $250,000 surety offered by his family members, not go near international departure points, abide to a curfew and wear an ankle bracelet as part of his bail conditions.
He also indicated he would surrender both his Australian and British passports.
Justice Sullivan will deliver his decision on Mr Davidson's bail application on Friday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
4 hours ago
- Perth Now
Netflix star bugged after fatal crash: court
An Aussie reality television star was allegedly heard on covert recordings complaining his mates would 'start squealing' and suggested to 'torch' critical documents after the death of his co-star. Outback Wrangler Matt Wright has pleaded not guilty to three allegations of attempting to pervert the course of justice following the fatal helicopter crash death of his mate, Chris 'Willow' Wilson. The 34-year-old father was last seen alive dangling in the air from a sling attached to a Robinson R-44 helicopter during a crocodile egg collecting mission on February 28, 2022. During this dangerous mission, the helicopter crashed into a paperbark swamp along the King River in Arnhem Land, killing Mr Wilson and critically injuring his 28-year-old pilot Seb Robinson. Outback Wrangler Matt Wright has been supported by wife Kaia Wright at court. Zizi Averill Credit: News Corp Australia The 45-year-old Netflix and Apple TV star was accused of trying to cover up the crashed chopper's flight logs and a 'pattern' of failing to properly record flight times. The jury has repeatedly heard the cause of the crash was not the subject of the trial, rather Mr Wright's alleged actions in its wake. On Thursday the jury was brought back to the scene of the traumatic chopper crash, with Wild Harvest NT director and The Crocodile King of the NT Mick Burns the first to give evidence. Wild Harvest NT director and 'The Crocodile King of the NT' Mick Burns gave evidence at the trial. Zizi Averill Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Burns, who held the permit for the crocodile egg collection, said that day's mission was subcontracted to Mr Wright's Helibrook, Michael Burbidge's Remote Helicopters Australia and North Australia Helicopters with pilot Ty 'Mudcrab' Richardson. The jury heard Mr Robinson and Mr Wilson were flying for Helibrook, while the other helicopters were manned by Jock Purcell and Tim Luck. Mr Burns said the 'collectors' — who dangled through the sky to drop into deadly crocodile nests — were paid $1000 a day, while the pilots were paid by their respective chopper companies. He said he paid for all fuel, repeating they only used high-lead content 'Green' fuel as 'we thought it was safer as if allows the engine to run cooler'. The jury has heard the petrol, and a refuelling stop at Mt Borradaile, would be a source of contention through the trial, with Crown prosecutor Jason Gullaci SC stating a witness maintained it was 'filled to the brim'. At some point after leaving an agreed staging area near the King River crocodile nests, the Robinson R-44 with Mr Robinson and Mr Wilson crashed to the ground. Mr Burns told the jury that after hearing the news, he, Mr Wright, and senior off-duty NT Police officer Neil Mellon immediately flew to the crash site. Using the same model of Robinson R-44 used in the crash, Mr Burns said they flew non-stop for up to 90 minutes to the crash site, with no refuelling breaks — arriving just as Careflight crews left with the injured Mr Robinson. Mr Burns started to tear up as he remembered arriving at the horrific scene, where his mate's body lay in the swamp. Former NT Police Northern Watch Commander Neil Mellon got emotional at court. Zizi Averill Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Mellon was also emotional as he told the jury how he put his friend in a body bag, the experienced cop saying 'I've done it so many times, I didn't think these guys needed to do that'. Mr Mellon said he disconnected Mr Wilson's harness, removed a handgun from his hip, and removed his mobile phone — handing it to Mr Burbidge. He said Mr Burbidge told him Mr Wilson's wife Dani 'doesn't need to see what's on that' and later admitted the phone was 'gone' and was 'in the ocean'. Croc egg collector Chris Wilson was killed, while his pilot Sebastian Robinson was critically injured in a helicopter crash on the King River, West Arnhem on February 28, 2022. Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Gullaci also alleged Mr Wright, Mr Burbidge, and Mr Purcell approached the crashed helicopter and removed some items and 'play(ed) around with the dash'. Mr Mellon agreed Mr Wright and Mr Burbidge were 'in and around' the crashed chopper's cockpit, but Mr Burns did not remember seeing this. 'I can't remember seeing anyone inside the helicopter. It was pretty low to the ground,' Mr Burns said. He said Mr Burbidge reported the chopper still had fuel inside. Mr Gullaci said initially Mr Wright told investigators he saw there was half a tank of fuel still in the crash chopper, however later said 'I didn't see f--king any fuel in the tank, zero'. In a bugged conversation months later, Mr Wright allegedly said: 'I just looked in it then. F--k that, nah, it just had no fuel'. 'He had run out of fuel. I'll just say he was a sh-t pilot,' he allegedly said. Mr Gullaci said at the time of the crash the Robinson R-44 had recorded 2070 hours on the Hobbs metre — just 130 hours shy of a costly maintenance overhaul requirement. However, Mr Wright was allegedly recorded telling his wife, Kaia Wright, he knew the helicopter had overrun its maintenance threshold. Outback Wrangler Matt Wright and his wife Kaia Wright approaching the Supreme Court in Darwin on Thursday August 7. Zizi Averill Credit: News Corp Australia Mr Gullaci alleged Mr Wright repeatedly tried to manipulate the Robinson R-44's documents, including pressuring Mr Robinson — the now paraplegic pilot — to forge the records and suggested to others the original maintenance release should be 'destroyed'. Mr Gullaci alleged Mr Wright was recorded saying: 'Just torch it, I don't know where it is'. 'Now everyone is f--king, now they are starting to put the pressure on everyone, you know, they will start squealing,' he allegedly said in September. Defence senior counsel David Edwardson said while Mr Wright did have a practice of disconnecting the Hobbs metre and under-reporting flight hours, this was 'commonplace' among Territory pilots and not a 'motive' for the serious allegations against him. Mr Edwardson said the charges against his client relied on statements made by Mr Robinson and his family whose 'credibility and reliability' was in question, and inaudible and unclear recordings. The jury heard the lengthy trial would likely focus on the trace levels of cocaine found in Mr Robinson's blood after the crash. Mr Gullaci said expert evidence would be presented saying this indicated recreational use in the days before the crash — rather than while he was piloting the chopper. The trial continues on Friday.
7NEWS
7 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Death row lawyer Maria DeLiberato explains why she defends killers: ‘We don't put down our animals that way'
Maria DeLiberato, an American death row lawyer, has spent nearly two decades fighting for inmates facing execution, including those convicted of the most heinous crimes. Currently representing six clients awaiting their fate, Ms DeLiberato told Lad Bible she is driven by cases like that of Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin, a Honduran immigrant who spent 14 years in prison and 10 years on death row before being acquitted through new DNA evidence. 'Clemente's case probably solidified it for me the most, in terms of how shockingly wrong we get it,' she said. Ms DeLiberato also highlights the disproportionate application of the death penalty to people of colour. Making her move from Miami to Tampa in 2006, she has lost clients along the way, including paedophile Larry Eugene Mann, who abducted and killed 10-year-old Elisa Nelson. She also defended Jerry Correll who murdered four family members. Both were executed by lethal injection. Despite this, Ms DeLiberato remains committed to defending her clients, acknowledging, 'Even if you felt like the death penalty was somehow appropriate from a pure vengeance standpoint, and I certainly get the desire for revenge, but that's all it is.' Initially opposed to the death penalty on moral and religious grounds, Ms DeLiberato's research revealed the criminal justice system's many failures. She spoke out amid a rise in US executions in 2025, with 26 so far, surpassing totals from 2024 and 2023, according to the British anti-death penalty group Reprieve. Concerning reports of botched executions, she explained that Florida's use of midazolam feels like 'they were torturing people' and raised similar concerns for drugs like etomidate. On other methods such as lethal gas and firing squads, she stated, 'we're just talking about premeditated murder and brutality.' Calling the fight for abolition 'terrifying and frustrating,' Ms DeLiberato noted that many people are reluctant to oppose the death penalty because 'it's human nature to be like 'well, the victim got worse than whatever they got'.' She also addressed difficulties, claiming lethal injection drugs are sourced via black markets, highlighting pharmaceutical companies' refusal to supply states for executions. 'Everything is so secret, so it's really difficult to know,' she said. Sharing a personal perspective, she added, 'I've been under anaesthesia and I always ask them, what are you giving me and why?' She emphasised that people don't euthanise animals using these drugs. Ms DeLiberato criticised lethal injection as the most 'dishonest' execution method—deceptively humane but often painful. Comparing it to a firing squad, she acknowledged its brutal terror despite a quicker death. Reflecting on losing a client, she recalled murderous inmate Larry Eugene Mann writing a letter to be opened after his death, in which he thanked her for her tireless defence. 'Losing him was incredibly challenging and changing, it was so sad and senseless,' she said. 'He basically wrote it saying if I'm alive, great, if I'm not, thank you for the work that you did, telling us to hang in there and stay strong for everyone on death row.' Although she works alongside other lawyers across the US, DeLiberato said there is 'a different sense of pressure and grief' when losing a client. Her ongoing commitment reflects a belief in fighting 'to the wire' against a flawed death penalty system. It comes as a Tennessee death row inmate, Byron Black, 69, cried out in pain during his execution on August 5 after the state declined to deactivate his implanted heart defibrillator, despite concerns raised about possible suffering. Black was executed by lethal injection at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution for the 1988 murders of his girlfriend, Angela Clay, and her two daughters, Latoya, 9, and Lakeisha, 6. As the lethal drugs began flowing, Black appeared visibly distressed, multiple witnesses reported, according to the Daily Mail. He was heard sighing heavily and breathing heavily, he then repeatedly lifted his head and told his spiritual advisor, 'It's hurting so bad,' before passing away about ten minutes after the process began. She then responded: 'I'm so sorry. Just listen to my voice,' before comforting him by singing. Legal experts say this is the first documented case where an inmate was put to death with an active defibrillator still in place, raising questions about the risk of repeated electrical shocks as his heart failed.
Perth Now
7 hours ago
- Perth Now
How ACA nearly derailed Netflix star's trial
A Territory judge has savaged a national television program for airing 'unfair' coverage on the eve of the trial of reality star Outback Wrangler Matt Wright. The Aussie reality television star has pleaded not guilty to three allegations of attempting to pervert the course of justice, following the chopper crash death of his mate and co-star Chris 'Willow' Wilson three years ago. It took two hours for a jury pool of 107 Territorians to be whittled down into the final team of 12 jurors and two reservists on Tuesday. However overnight that careful selection process was put in jeopardy following the episode by A Current Affair. The segment was broadcast on A Current Affair. Credit: Supplied On Wednesday Justice Alan Blow ripped into the Channel Nine segment which he said threatened to 'abort' the high-profile celebrity trial. 'It was a piece of journalism that was aimed to suggest that Mr Wright is guilty of something — and that's not what TV journalists should be doing,' Justice Blow said. 'It's very important that Mr Wright gets a fair trial and watching that program could interfere with his right to a fair trial.' Justice Blow told the 12-person jury and two reservists that the program published a 'stale' witness list and a photo from the fatal helicopter crash site. 'This isn't a case about why the helicopter crashed,' he told the jury. 'It's not suggested that Mr Wright was responsible, in any way, for the crashing of the helicopter. 'If you watched the program, you might get the impression that he was responsible, and that he was guilty of something and that he's headed to jail for it. 'It was quite unfair and it created a danger of this trial having to be aborted.' Outback Wrangler Matt Wright and his wife Kaia Wright approaching the Supreme Court in Darwin. NewsWire/Pema Tamang Pakhrin Credit: News Corp Australia Only one juror out of the 14 members said he had watched the segment. Under questioning from Justice Blow, the juror said he would be able to remain impartial, and had not discussed the ACA show with any of his fellow jurors. Justice Blow then warned the remaining 13 Territorians to not try and access the program played on Tuesday night. 'It's an excellent example of what I told you not to do yesterday,' he said. 'Please don't try to find out about that program.' Both prosecutor Jason Gullaci and Defence senior counsel David Edwardson said they were comfortable with the current jury continuing. The trial continues.
