FAI admit defeat on 'summer soccer' plan
Recently departed chief football officer Marc Canham produced a Football Pathway Plan 18 months ago which claimed 65% of surveyed participants preferred an alignment of the seasons from underage to senior.
Yet that position was soon challenged, with the two largest affiliates in the country, Schoolboys/girls FAI and Leinster FA pleading with the parent body to consider allowing leagues freedom to choose their format.
The board backing of Canham's 11-point blueprint was passed at General Assembly level by a narrow 57% majority but the LFA branded the latter outcome as 'flawed'.
Whereas the LOI voted among their clubs for the switch in 2002, this ballot was taken across all strands.
Opposition soon spiked.
On top of established affiliates, which included the majority of Ulster and Connacht, the Grassroots Amateur Football Clubs of Ireland was founded from the coalface.
It was a fusion of 600 clubs across 22 leagues in 17 counties seeking autonomy, raising their concerns in political circles.
Rather than helping the game grow, this move was perceived as hindering it, as the overlap with the core GAA games programme was cited.
Other factors such as summer holidays, referee shortages and drop offs after breaks were raised, as well as the absence of impact study on clubs fearful of losing volunteers.
Belatedly, the FAI bowed to pressure by undertaking a 'Listening and Learning exercise' in May – with the inevitable outcome of plans for roll-out from January 2026 being culled.
Their ploy of linking grants for the Gaynor and Kennedy Cup tournaments to compliance with the move spectacularly backfired.
A proposal to postpone implementation by three years was rejected by the SFAI, who highlighted the point that even the minority of leagues moving to summer supported the right to choose for others.
It was noteworthy that FAI executives were not invited to these sessions, only elected officials.
They relayed feedback to board level that the concept was a non-starter.
An email from President Paul Cooke to the 145-strong General Assembly on Friday afternoon confirmed the climbdown.
'The FAI board of the Football Association of Ireland has decided to implement an exemption process by application for leagues with regard to our Aligned Football Calendar.
'The terms of reference of the exemption process will be agreed by the board and communicated with members of the General Assembly in due course.
'The FPP continues to be implemented as part of the on-going development and future of Irish football whilst also respecting the implementation challenges that leagues may encounter in relation to the Aligned Football Calendar.'
The initial feeling is that leagues are reluctant to engage in this committee having already informed their clubs at recent AGMs of continuity. The traditional September-June format will be maintained by the majority, as it is for 80% of national associations across Uefa's 55 members.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Why Everton FC's new home means a lost legacy for Liverpool city
Analysis: One of the major impacts of Everton's new Hill Dickinson Stadium is the loss of Liverpool city's UNESCO World Heritage listing Soccer never sleeps. Since Liverpool FC lifted their record-equalling title in May, there has been a Club World Cup, UEFA Nations League Finals, a Women's European Championship, not to mention the League of Ireland and the relentless hum of transfer speculation. However, the impending return of the Premier League with a major new addition. At an estimated cost of over €925 million, Everton's new Hill Dickinson Stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock is set to become a major icon of the game and the city of Liverpool. From RTÉ Radio 1's Liveline, Everton superfan Andy Ring and former Everton player Mark Ward discuss being fans of the Toffees While fans will, of course, be sorry to leave the historic Goodison Park after 133 years, the move has been broadly met with popular support. The positive sentiment has been supported by the confirmation that Goodison Park will now be the permanent home for Everton Wome n, becoming the largest dedicated women's football stadium in England. Despite the first goal scored in the new stadium was by a Liverpool FC fan, ongoing concerns about parking and dire warnings of flooding due to rising sea levels, the successful test events, replete with obligatory blue toffee topped doughnuts have contributed to general optimism about the new stadium. This is an opportune moment to rewind four years to one of the major impacts to the development. Since 1978 the World Heritage Committee has met annually to add new sites to its UNESCO World Heritage list. This year's meeting in Paris brought the current total to 1,248 and new sites include the Palaces of King Ludwig II of Bavaria, the Bijagós Archipelago in Guinea-Bissau and Mount Kumgang in North Korea. As one of the world's major trading centres in the 18th and 19th centuries, the city centre and docklands of Liverpool have been on the list since 2004 for its maritime and mercantile history and its central role in the mass movement of slaves and emigrants during the British Empire. However, Liverpool was struck from the list in 2021, becoming only the third site, following the Arabian Oryx Sanctuary in Oman (2007) and the Elbe Valley in Dresden in Germany (2009), to be delisted. Despite the Liverpool mayor's response at the time that the decision was "incomprehensible", there had been many warnings. In 2006, commenting on the new Liverpool Museum to be built on the docks (a design it commended), UNESCO urged the UK "to put in place strategic plans for future development that set out clear strategies for the overall townscape and for the skyline and river front". From Everton FC, a historic day at Hill Dickinson Stadium Following concerns in 2012 about the proposed multi-billion residential, commercial and office Peel Group development of Liverpool Waters, Liverpool was then placed on the List of World Heritage in Danger. This was a call to urgent action about the development the city and how its heritage would be preserved. The 2021 approval of the new Everton FC stadium was the final straw for UNESCO and the city's certificate was rescinded. The new stadium, which filled in the dock, is the very antithesis of heritage led regeneration. Despite appearances, UNESCO aren't necessarily against redevelopment of sites per se. In 2021, they decided that the docklands are no longer the site of outstanding universal heritage value it was in 2004. A building of this scale and type within the core site is particularly egregious and detrimental to the named heritage qualities for which Liverpool was first inscribed on the list. After all, sports stadiums are a dubious source of urban regeneration. Delisting is rare and the Committee normally does not seek to anger countries (Oman, for example, requested delisting). UNESCO's reluctance to take this decision was evident in the fact that it eventually was decided by a secret ballot, requiring a two-thirds majority. That Liverpool was not able to secure forbearance from UNESCO was mistakenly viewed at the time as a diplomatic and lobbying failure of the Brexit era. Most committee members were non-European and both the city of Bath and the Slate Landscape of Northwest Wales were added in 2021. It is worth remembering that UNESCO cannot reverse local planning decisions. Listing, like other cultural awards, is about recognition. It doesn't bring immediate change, rather how recognition is leveraged is what matters. Cities, however, should not be caught between a false dilemma of heritage and regeneration and no parties in this episode, including UNESCO, are blameless. A more flexible approach and greater dialogue could perhaps have seen the decision deferred or site boundaries amended. UNESCO's decision ought to serve as a warning to other sites such as Vienna, already on the 'in danger' list for similar reasons, and counties like Ireland who have recently declared a goal to increase their number of World Heritage Sites. It also is a lesson that this process is insufficient and too rigid for balancing heritage preservation and urban regeneration. From RTÉ News, Ireland's only Moravian village receives UNESCO World Heritage status As Everton fans saying goodbye to Goodison at that emotional final home game in May know, letting go is difficult. The unsatisfactory loss of status for Liverpool should be taken as an opportunity for the UK and UNESCO to develop a new chapter. Encouragingly, in 2024 the UK belatedly adopted the 2003 convention on intangible culture and added two more sites: Flow Country in Scotland and the Gracehill Moravian Settlement in Co Antrim in 2024. As Everton look forward to a new future with increased capacity, greater revenue and possibly some trophies to match their rivals, it is worth reflecting on what Liverpool has lost and the challenge to cities when it comes to preserving their heritage and building for the future. Until that happens, all that remains is the dubious record that their new stadium has already given the city. In football, it is well known that Juventus were stripped of the 2004-2005 Italian League title and had their records scrubbed. In contrast, Liverpool's name will remain on UNESCO's list, but with a line struck through it as a reminder of what the French philosopher Jacques Derrida called sous rature (under erasure). In other words, Liverpool's place on the heritage list remains necessary but inadequate.
Irish Daily Mirror
19 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Shelbourne's hearts broken at the death as Europa League dream ends
Two outrageous goals on Tuesday night extinguished Shelbourne's second effort at securing group stage football - but the Reds will fight another day in the Conference League play-offs next week. Coming into tonight's Europa League second-leg 2-1 up, they looked set for a grandstand finish when Mipo Odubeko scored from the spot to level the tie with five minutes remaining. There was time for a heartbreaking twist as HNK Rijeka snatched an 88th minute winner through Ante Orec, who minutes earlier had conceded the penalty with a tug of John Martin's jersey. Shelbourne battled bravely, but conceded two screamers, with Toni Fruk living up to his billing as a potential heir to Luka Modric's spot in the Croatia team by scoring a spectacular opener. Even that, however, was topped by Tiago Dantes' strike 18 minutes from time. There were more twists to come as the game hurtled towards a dramatic finish, but one twist too many as far as the League of Ireland champions were concerned. Shelbourne will now play the winners of Linfield's tie with Vikingur of the Faroe Islands for a spot in the league phase of the Conference League - and they will do so buoyed by tonight's performance. There were times when it was backs-to-the-wall, but they showed their attacking pedigree too, particularly in the second-half when Martin replaced Ali Coote and set-up a two-pronged front-line with Odubeko. Healy was one of several big names in the directors' box. Bertie Ahern, based just around the corner from Tolka Park, was Taoiseach the last time Shelbourne welcomed a Croatian side to the Drumcondra venue. Reds fan Stephen Cluxton was three years into his glittering career as Dublin goalkeeper when they famously saw off Hajduk Split. A year earlier, he had reportedly been chased by Shels' League of Ireland rivals St Patrick's Athletic. Ireland boss Heimir Hallgrímsson was another famous face in the crowd, but his only link to that era was that he was playing at the time in the same league as KR Reykjavik, the team Shelbourne beat prior to facing Split. On the pitch Fruk, returning from suspension, was quick to showcase his skills. The attacking midfielder was constantly on the move in the narrow corridor between the Shelbourne defence and the midfield pair of Kerr McInroy and JJ Lunney. As early as the second minute, the 24-year-old former Fiorentina prospect spun in a blur past Kameron Ledwidge and accelerated towards the area, looking for a return pass that never arrived. By the eighth minute, he had the ball at his feet on the edge of the Shels penalty area, where he baited a foul that led to a free-kick dangerously close to goal. A few yards in front of the Shelbourne wall, the Croatians formed a three-man wall of their own, which split as Fruk let fly. Although blinded by Rijeka's antics, the Reds barrier did its job and the ball ricocheted out to Tiago Dantas. His half-volley fizzed wide of the left-hand post. Another Fruk chance on 19 minutes, a first-time effort from a half-cleared free-kick, drew a brave block from the impressive McInroy. Even more eye-catching, however, was Paddy Barrett's block at full-stretch, which kept Ante Juric's on-target shot from troubling goalkeeper Wessel Speel. Shels' Kerr McInroy dejected after conceding the first goal of the game (Image: Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Ryan Byrne) By that stage, just past the halfway mark in the first-half, on-loan netminder Speel had just one save to make, and it was an easy one as Juric's low shot was straight at the Dutchman. At the other end, there was a nervy early moment for Rijeka keeper Martin Zlomislic, who must have feared a VAR check on the coming together between him and Ali Coote. Coote, racing onto a long Harry Wood ball, just couldn't get a decisive touch on the ball, but it still bounced past Zlomislic, and the Shels attacker fell over the goalie's clumsy challenge. No penalty, according to Romanian referee Marian Barbu, and there was no encouragement from the video assistant to send him over to the monitor on the touchline. There was no need either for a VAR review on Fruk's 33rd minute opener, although the ref might have wished for a chance to watch a replay of the young attacker's brilliant strike. It was as sweet a strike as Fruk could have struck, a curling 20-yard volley from the right of the D inside the left-hand upright, after good work by Ante Oric, Juric and Dantas. He could hardly have placed it any better to evade the despairing dive of Speel. Rijeka had been knocking on the door, and minutes before the opener Ante Majstorovic prodded a corner just wide of the near post, but immediately after the goal Shels produced their best attacking move. Recent signing Milan Mbeng was busy and on top of his game defensively, but he showed his class at the other end by making room for, and delivering, a cross towards the back post. Shels' JJ Lunney dejected after conceding the second goal of the game (Image: Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Ryan Byrne) James Norris cushioned a header into the path of McInroy, his effort was packed with power but was straight at Zlomislic, who parried, and Coote sent the rebound wide. As half-time approached, Rijeka attempted to turn the screw, and Shels survived a couple of scares, most notably when Dejan Petrovic sent a free header wide of goal. A half-time change saw John Martin come in for Coote, and he was quick into the action, racing onto a McInroy ball down the left and crossing low towards Odubeko. The former Manchester United and West Ham striker was under pressure as he attempted to convert, but should have done better than steer the ball wide of the near post. So too should McInroy, when a heavy touch in midfield sent the visitors sprinting forward; the attack ending with a Niko Jankovic shot that Speel saved well to his right. But there was nothing the Shelbourne keeper could do about the goal that, with 18 minutes remaining, finally separated the two sides. Tiago Dantas received the ball from the left, moved onto his right foot and put his laces through the ball, sending it from all of 30 yards into the top right hand corner. Shels' John Martin dejected after conceding the second goal of the game (Image: Mandatory Credit ©INPHO/Ryan Byrne) But there was another twist. With eight minutes left, a tug of Martin's jersey by Orec wasn't spotted by the referee, but it was picked up by VAR, and after a long check Barbu pointed to the spot. Odubeko struck the ball low to his right, and got a bit of luck as the ball slipped under the dive of Zlomislic. However, Shelbourne's luck ran out over the next few minutes, as Mbeng drilled a shot straight at the keeper, before Rijeka scored a crucial third. The hosts couldn't clear a cross and Orec, the villain minutes earlier, turned hero with a shot on the spin from 16 yards that arrowed low inside the left-hand upright.
Irish Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
‘Shelbourne defender teases huge prize on offer in crunch Euro clash
Paddy Barrett says Shelbourne's players are just 90 minutes away from a 'life changing' experience. The League of Ireland champions can guarantee league phase football by finishing the job they started last week against Croatian giants HNK Rijeka, when they secured a shock 2-1 win in the away leg. The winners of the tie will progress to the Europa League play-offs against either PAOK of Greece or Austrian side Wolfberg, with the latter holding a 2-0 lead from last week. And the losers of that play-off tie would be parachuted straight into the Conference League proper. Barrett was a member of the Dundalk side that made it to the Europa League group stages in 2016. He is eager for a return to elite European competition. 'Obviously back then I was a lot younger,' said the 32-year-old, who went on to have spells in the USA (FC Cincinnati and Indy Eleven), and Cambodia (PKR Savy Rieng) before returning to Ireland with St Patrick's Athletic and then Shels. 'But it was an amazing experience that time, and it would be more amazing now that I'm more of a leader, older, a more mature player than I was back then. 'I had an amazing time back then but I want to recreate those memories again this time with Shelbourne. It's something that I'm driven to do at this club. Click this link or scan the QR code to receive the latest League of Ireland news and top stories from the Irish Mirror. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice . 'Obviously the plan is to get to the group stages in European competition and I think it would be amazing to do so.' Dundalk became the second Irish club to compete in the group or league stages, after Shamrock Rovers five years earlier. They became the first Irish club to earn a point (away to AZ Alkmaar) and then a win (at home to Maccabi Tel Aviv) in the group stages, but lost out narrowly on progression to the knockouts. Paddy Barrett celebrates Dundalk's win over BATE Borisov (Image: INPHO/Ciaran Culligan) The Lilywhites returned to the Europa League in 2020 when they faced Arsenal, Molde and Rapid Vienna. Since then, Shamrock Rovers have appeared in the Conference League proper in 2022 and again last season, when they made history by progressing to the last-32. So, progress for Shels would be another huge step for Irish football, and a sign that clubs here could hope to compete on a regular basis at that level. 'We know the task ahead,' Barrett said. 'It's obviously not something that clubs from Ireland do year in, year out. 'But when it comes along, when the opportunity does come along, it's amazing and we know what's at stake, and you have to appreciate what's at stake, because these are life changing experiences, that you can travel and you can play against top quality opposition, and it's great to be a part of. 'It's life-changing experiences as in you are playing against top quality players, top quality teams, and you're playing against unbelievable fan bases like our own here. 'These are the experiences that you want as a player. So it's great to be a part of that.' Not that Barrett has been consumed by memories of the 2016 run in the build-up to tonight's game. 'To be honest I don't think back about any games. If that was the case I'd be sitting here all day thinking about all the mistakes I've made throughout my career,' he said. 'But look, it's all about (tonight) and it's one that we're looking forward to.' There are elements of his previous experiences that he can share with teammates ahead of the visit of Rijeka. Nine years ago it was BATE Borisov that stood between Stephen Kenny's Dundalk and the group stages - and on that occasion Barrett and Co were a goal down coming into the second-leg in Tallaght Stadium. He recalled the tension inside the ground ahead of that game - but tension is something that could work in Shelbourne's favour tonight. The longer they hold onto their first-leg lead, the more anxious their opponents will be. However, Rijeka welcome Toni Fruk back from suspension. The 24-year-old has recently been called into the Croatia squad, and is tipped to be the long-term replacement for Luka Modric in the international side. 'There was tension but it was also confidence as well,' said Barrett of the BATE game, which Dundalk won 3-0. 'We knew the quality of team that we had at the time, we were unbelievable, we had an unbelievable squad and we felt the tension from the ground as well. 'But once that first goal went in I think we knew ourselves as a full team, as a squad, even the staff, we knew we were going to go on and push on and win that game, and we did.' Acknowledging that tonight would have a different dynamic, with Shels defending, rather than chasing, he said: 'There's still a big game, there's a lot at stake. 'We know the quality of opposition, we know what they're like. We obviously got a feel of them last week, but again we just need to take our own game to them. 'We've worked on things this week that we want to put to them and put our best foot forward, as the gaffer said, and have a right crack off them.' Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email .
