South Africa presents its arguments against Israel at the ICJ over human rights violations
South Africa's legal battle against Israel at the ICJ: A call for accountability and justice
Image: UN Photo/ICJ-CIJ/Frank van Beek
South Africa is taking to the international stage on Tuesday, presenting its case before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) at The Hague, challenging Israel's aggression and genocide in the Palestinian territories.
South Africa's government has accused Israel of violating international law through its ongoing occupation of Palestinian territories, including East Jerusalem and Gaza, where the Israeli forces have allegedly killed more than 52,000 people.
The country alleged that Israel's settlement expansion, restrictions on movement, and military operations amount to violations of human rights and international humanitarian law.
Central to South Africa's argument is the claim that Israel's actions amount to a form of apartheid—systematic segregation and discrimination—reminiscent of South Africa's history of institutionalised racial segregation.
South Africa is calling for the ICJ to hold Israel accountable, demanding an end to what it describes as illegal occupation and urging the international community to enforce measures that uphold Palestinian sovereignty and human rights.
South Africa's Arguments and Diplomatic Stance
In its presentation earlier on Tuesday, the South African delegation emphasised the importance of international law in safeguarding human dignity.
They cited numerous UN resolutions condemning settlement activities and military actions deemed disproportionate or punitive.
South Africa also highlighted the suffering of Palestinian civilians—including children, women, and the elderly—caught in the crossfire, with reports of destruction of homes, restricted access to essentials, and ongoing violence.
South Africa's government has continuously reiterated its stance that the Israeli government must be held accountable for actions that violate international norms.
They called for an immediate halt to settlement expansion, unrestricted humanitarian access to Gaza, and renewed efforts for a peaceful resolution based on a two-state solution.
International Condemnation and the Global Response
Numerous international organisations have strongly condemned South Africa's legal challenge.
The United Nations has issued multiple statements condemning Israeli policies.
The UN Human Rights Council's recent March report described Israeli settlement expansion as 'a violation of international law and an obstacle to peace,' calling on Israel to cease such activities immediately.
'The ongoing destruction of Palestinian homes and the displacement of families constitute serious violations of international humanitarian law,' UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk stated.
The Arab League and several African nations have vocally supported South Africa's stance, with the Arab League fully rallying behind the country's efforts to restore peace in Gaza.
'Israel's actions in Palestinian territories constitute a blatant violation of international norms and human rights. We stand with South Africa in seeking justice.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
3 hours ago
- The Citizen
Naledi Pandor contniues to receive threats, 'they never stopped'
In February 2024, in the midst of South Africa's case against Israel at ICJ, Pandor's security was beefed up amid threats. As Israel and Iran continue to trade blows, South Africa's former International Relations Minister Naledi Pandor and her family continue to receive threats. An insider close to the family told The Citizen that the threats against Pandor and her family have not ceased since South Africa brought Israel before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) for genocide committed against Palestinians in Gaza. 'Threats' 'No, they never stopped. The threats are ongoing and you shouldn't get to close [to us] because you become a target,' the insider told The Citizen at a function in Gauteng. The insider did not want to disclose more information, fearing that the threats would escalate. 'We don't want our security compromised.' Friends of Naledi Pandor were all eliminated by Israel last night. June 13, 2025 ICJ case In February 2024, in the midst of South Africa's case against Israel at the ICJ, Pandor's security was beefed up amid threats against her and her family. South Africa approached the World Court seeking several orders, including for Israel to immediately suspend its Gaza offensive; to stop forced displacement; to enable humanitarian access to thousands of displaced Palestinians; and to preserve evidence. In its judgment, the ICJ ordered Israel to take 'all measures within its power' to prevent acts of genocide in Gaza. ALSO READ: Israeli forces seize Gaza-bound Madleen with aid and Greta Thunberg [VIDEO] Security beefed up Following President Cyril Ramaphosa's State of the Nation Address (Sona) on 8 February 2024, Pandor told journalists that she believed the threats were related to the ICJ case. The minister did not disclose who the threats were from, but confirmed that then-Police Minister Bheki Cele had to strengthen her security detail. 'I spoke to Minister Cele because of the various messages I was getting, and I felt it would be better if we had extra security. What I am more concerned about is my family because in some of the social media messages, my children are mentioned and so on.' Gaza Pandor said, despite the personal cost of taking on Israel, South Africa will see the ICJ matter through. 'This is part of the course, the Israeli agents' intelligence services are how they behave, and they seek to intimidate you. So, we must not be intimidated; there is a course that is underway. The people of the world and of Palestine didn't draw back when the apartheid state was at its worst. 'They stood with the liberation movement, so we can't stand back now, we must be with them, and I think one of the things we must not allow is a failure of courage. It's extremely important we continue with this, we talk to the South African people and they understand why it is that we have taken up this moral course,' Pandor said. ALSO READ: SA calls for urgent probe after 32 Palestinians killed while waiting for food Israel and Iran Meanwhile, Pretoria has expressed profound concern regarding the attacks conducted by Israel on targets within Iran on Friday, including reported impacts on military areas, nuclear facilities, and civilian infrastructure. 'Reports of civilian casualties, alongside military personnel, are deeply troubling,' the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (Dirco) spokesperson Chrispin Phiri said. 'These actions raise serious concerns under international law, including the principles of sovereignty, territorial integrity, and the protection of civilians enshrined in the UN Charter and international humanitarian law'. Nuclear safety Phiri added that South Africa has taken note with particular concern of the implications for nuclear safety and security arising from attacks in the vicinity of nuclear facilities. 'We recall the firm stance of the IAEA General Conference, reflected in resolutions such as GC(XXIX)/RES/444 and GC(XXXIV)/RES/533, against armed attacks on peaceful nuclear installations as violations of the UN Charter and international law. 'South Africa extends its sincere condolences to the Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the families of all victims,' Phiri said. 'Peaceful resolutions' Phiri reiterated Pretoria's 'unwavering commitment' to the peaceful resolution of disputes. 'South Africa urges maximum restraint by all parties and calls for the urgent intensification of diplomatic efforts to de-escalate tensions and promote stability in the Middle East. 'We support ongoing bilateral discussions, such as those between the USA and Iran, and reaffirm the critical importance of establishing a Nuclear-Weapon-Free Zone in the Middle East,' Phiri said. In February this year, South Africa's Head of Public Diplomacy Clayson Monyela dismissed claims of any cooperation with Iran on nuclear energy. The claims of nuclear cooperation between South Africa and Iran were levelled by US President Donald Trump's administration in an executive order on 7 February 2025. ALSO READ: Israel accused of starving Gaza 'by design' — South Africa addresses ICJ
TimesLIVE
4 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Yemen's Houthis target Israel with ballistic missiles in co-ordination with Iran
Yemen's Iran-aligned Houthis said on Sunday they targeted Israel in co-ordination with Iran, the first time an Iran-aligned group has publicly announced joint co-operation on attacks with Tehran. The Yemeni group targeted central Israel's Jaffa with several ballistic missiles in the past 24 hours, military spokesperson Yehya Sarea said in a televised address. 'Triumphing for the oppressed Palestinian and Iranian peoples ... This operation was co-ordinated with the operations carried out by the Iranian army against the criminal Israeli enemy,' he added. The Israeli military earlier said sirens were activated in several areas in the country after missile launches from Iran and Yemen. Israel and Iran continued to exchange missile attacks since Israel launched its biggest-ever military strike against its long-standing enemy on Friday. On the same day Israel launched its attack on Iran, Israel said a missile that was launched from Yemen towards Israel fell in Hebron in the occupied West Bank. The Yemeni group however did not claim responsibility for the missile launch. The Houthis have been launching attacks against Israel, most of which have been intercepted, in what they say is support for Palestinians in Gaza during the Israel-Hamas war there since Hamas' October 7 2023 attack on Israel. Israel has carried out a series of retaliatory strikes. The US also launched intensified strikes against the Houthis this year, before President Donald Trump halted the offensive after the Houthis agreed to stop attacks on American ships.
IOL News
4 hours ago
- IOL News
Trump issues chilling threat as Israel and Iran exchange fire overnight
A fire blazes in the oil depots of Shahran, northwest of Tehran, on June 15 after further attacks from Israel. Image: Atta Kenare / AFP Iranians and Israelis woke to smoke and rubble on Sunday after the arch-rivals expanded their attacks overnight, with Israel striking Tehran's defence ministry, and Iran unleashing a deadly barrage of missiles. Air raid sirens and explosions were heard by AFP journalists in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv early on Sunday, as Israel's military said millions of Israelis were "running for shelter" around the country. Israel's emergency services said at least eight people, including children, were killed in the overnight strikes, and around 200 were wounded. In Iran's capital, AFP journalists heard a series of blasts at around 2:30am. The third day of tit-for-tat attacks comes despite global calls for de-escalation, with Iran scrapping its latest nuclear talks with the United States, saying it could not negotiate while under fire from Israel. US President Donald Trump warned Iran on Sunday that it would experience "the full strength" of the US military if it attacks the United States, reiterating that Washington "had nothing to do" with Israel's strikes on Tehran's nuclear and intelligence facilities. 'Nuclear project' sites struck After decades of enmity and conflict by proxy, it is the first time the arch-enemies have traded fire with such intensity, triggering fears of a prolonged conflict that could engulf the Middle East. Israel's operation, which began early on Friday, has targeted Iranian nuclear and military sites, killing dozens of people including top army commanders and atomic scientists, according to Tehran. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vowed to hit "every target of the ayatollah regime", while Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian warned further strikes would draw "a more severe and powerful response". Iran's UN ambassador said 78 people were killed and 320 wounded in Friday's first wave of Israeli strikes. Iranian authorities have not provided an updated toll as of early Sunday. Israel's military said it had struck Iran's defence ministry headquarters, "nuclear weapons project" infrastructure sites and other targets, including fuel tankers, just before 2:40am on Sunday. The targeted sites, including the "headquarters of the SPND (Organisation of Defensive Innovation and Research) nuclear project", advanced Iran's efforts to obtain a nuclear weapon, according to Israel. Iranian news agency Tasnim earlier reported that an Israeli strike had targeted the defence ministry headquarters in Tehran and damaged one of its buildings. The ministry did not comment. Iran's Revolutionary Guards said on Sunday that the country had struck sites used by Israeli warplanes for refuelling, in retaliation for the strikes carried out by Israel. "The Iranian armed forces' offensive operations will continue more fiercely and more broadly if the depravity and attacks (against Iran) continue," the Guards said in a statement. Overnight, Israel stuck two fuel depots in Tehran, the Iranian oil ministry said on Sunday. According to the ministry, the oil depots at Shahran, northwest of Tehran and another reservoir south of the city were hit. Washington's 'dishonesty' Netanyahu maintained Israel's operation had the "clear support" of US President Donald Trump. Trump said he and Russian President Vladimir Putin had agreed in a phone call on Saturday that the conflict between Iran and Israel "should end". According to a statement from his office, Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian condemned Washington's "dishonesty" for supporting Israel while engaged in nuclear talks with Iran - which mediator Oman said would no longer take place on Sunday. Western governments have repeatedly accused Iran of seeking a nuclear weapon, which it denies. Iran's top nuclear negotiator, Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi, said the Israeli attacks undermined negotiations and were pushing the region into a "dangerous cycle of violence". Israeli strikes have hit Iran's Natanz uranium enrichment plant and killed its highest-ranking military officer, Mohammad Bagheri, as well as the head of the powerful Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, Hossein Salami. The Israeli military said its strikes had killed more than 20 Iranian commanders. Iranian media reported five Guards killed Saturday in Israeli strikes, while authorities in one northwestern province said 30 military personnel had been killed there since Friday. Iran's Red Crescent said an ambulance was hit Saturday in Urmia city, killing two. Iran called on its citizens to unite in the country's defence, while Netanyahu urged them to rise up against the government. Highlighting the global unease, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan warned against a "devastating war" with regional consequences, in a call with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Ankara said. UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer said Saturday that his country was deploying fighter jets and other "assets" to the Middle East "for contingency support", while he also urged de-escalation. AFP
