logo
There's a bigger story behind Colbert's cancellation

There's a bigger story behind Colbert's cancellation

Vox5 days ago
is a senior correspondent on the Culture team for Vox, where since 2016 she has covered books, publishing, gender, celebrity analysis, and theater.
On Thursday, CBS announced that it was going to cancel The Late Show With Stephen Colbert after Colbert's contract ends in May 2026. The news comes at a politically fraught moment for CBS and its parent company, Paramount Global. It's also the capper on the long arc of late-night political comedy, a genre Colbert was instrumental in building and which now, finally, appears to be on its last legs.
In a statement, CBS said its decision to end The Late Show — which began with David Letterman as host in 1993 — was 'purely financial.'
'We are proud that Stephen called CBS home,' the CBS statement said. 'This is purely a financial decision against a challenging backdrop in late night. It is not related in any way to the show's performance, content or other matters happening at Paramount.'
Vox Culture
Culture reflects society. Get our best explainers on everything from money to entertainment to what everyone is talking about online. Email (required)
Sign Up
By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Notice . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
That last line, that The Late Show's cancellation has nothing to do with 'other matters happening at Paramount,' seems directly aimed at tamping down speculation about CBS and Paramount Global's political motivations for cancelling a decades-long fixture of network television.
Paramount Global is currently attempting to merge with Skydance Media, and company leadership has been acting as though they are concerned that President Donald Trump might try to block the merger. Earlier this month, CBS and 60 minutes announced a $16 million settlement in its lawsuit with Trump over the editing of a segment about former Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris — an extraordinary concession for a media company in a case that experts agree CBS would have likely won in court. The longtime executive producer of 60 Minutes also resigned earlier this year, citing threats to his journalistic independence.
Days before the cancellation, Colbert said on his show, 'I am offended' by the settlement. 'I don't know if anything — anything — will repair my trust in this company. But, just taking a stab at it, I'd say $16 million would help,' he quipped. The payout, he added, was a 'big fat bribe.'
Colbert's ousting feels symbolic, not just of CBS's apparent decision to bow down to Trump, but of the end of late-night political comedy as a genre.
Two days later, reports say, CBS told Colbert they were canceling his show.
The network's stated reason for canceling the show has the sheen of believability. It's true that the late-night ecosystem is struggling. Still, Colbert's show has consistently led the ratings for its time slot. CBS and Paramount Global, The Atlantic contended on Thursday, no longer deserve the benefit of the doubt.
On Truth Social, Trump — a frequent target of Colbert's jokes — is celebrating.
'I absolutely love that Colbert got fired,' Trump posted Friday morning. 'His talent was even less than his ratings.'
Colbert's ousting feels symbolic, not just of CBS's apparent decision to bow down to Trump, but of the end of late-night political comedy as a genre. Sure, John Oliver's Last Week Tonight continues gamely on HBO, but the kind of late-night show that felt urgent and necessary 20 years ago — the stalwart outraged host cracking wise about the foibles of the corrupt federal government and the credulous media ecosystem that enabled it — has been fading for a long time. Now, its moment is coming to a close.
Jon Stewart and the rise of political comedy
The late-night political comedy show as we know it was developed and perfected by The Daily Show under Jon Stewart over the course of the 2000 presidential election. As the question of whether Al Gore or George W. Bush had won the electoral college wended its way through the Supreme Court, The Daily Show took on a central role: Stewart and his colleagues, including Colbert, were the TV personalities best equipped to talk about how fundamentally weird and confusing the whole thing was.
After Bush emerged victorious, The Daily Show became even more crucial. Their skill set was uniquely suited to the Bush years. While the administration took on a pious pose of compassionate conservatism, it was lying to the American people and embroiling the country in an endless foreign war. Stewart and his cohorts knew how to call Bush out on their hypocrisy and be funny about it, too. They were young and edgy, making one of the most exciting shows on television. It felt as if they were telling the truth in a time when no one else was.
Stewart always insisted that he wasn't a real journalist and The Daily Show wasn't a real news show. Nonetheless, a 2007 poll from the Pew Research Center found Stewart tied for fourth place in a list of America's most trusted journalists, along with Brian Williams, Tom Brokaw, Dan Rather, and Anderson Cooper. For lots of liberals, especially young ones, Stewart absolutely was a journalist, and so were the comedians he elevated.
In 2005, Colbert developed his own Daily Show spin-off, The Colbert Report. Even more biting than The Daily Show, The Colbert Report saw the host playing a parodic version of Bill O'Reilly, then the biggest star on Fox News. Like O'Reilly, Colbert's character was pompous and swaggering, lapping up his audience's applause and pontificating on 'truthiness' and the American dream. In 2006, he headlined the White House Correspondent's Dinner in character and ripped into Bush directly to his face, in a moment that Vanity Fair would say turned Colbert into a 'folk hero for the left.'
With The Colbert Report an accepted institution, Colbert and Stewart developed a double act. They held a 2010 Rally to Restore Fear and/or Sanity, with Stewart pleading for sanity and Colbert for fear. In retrospect, those years would represent the zenith of their popularity.
Colbert was the first Stewart acolyte to get a Daily Show spin-off, but his wouldn't be the last. John Oliver got his own show in 2014. Samantha Bee got hers in 2015. Hasan Minhaj got his in 2018. The 2010s saw The Daily Show model of news-focused political comedy spread across the landscape of television, no longer a scrappy upstart, but an institution, what we understood as what late-night television was supposed to look like.
They couldn't critique hidebound media institutions for failing to do their jobs anymore, because now they were media institutions.
There were two big problems with all that success. The first was that the Bush years were over. In 2008, Barack Obama became president, and while his administration had plenty of foibles for liberal comics to skewer, the central joke of the hypocrisy of neoconservatism was no longer available to them. The urgency of their comedy, the sense that they were meeting a moment as no one else could, began to fade away.
The second problem was that success meant that The Daily Show brand of comedy was no longer punching exclusively up. They couldn't critique hidebound media institutions for failing to do their jobs anymore, because now they were media institutions. What else could it mean when, in 2015, Colbert took over The Late Show and became the face of CBS's late-night lineup?
How late-night television lost its bite
When Trump won the presidential election in 2016, part of the received wisdom was that this would be great for comedy. Trump, after all, was a joke. He would offer all those Daily Show graduates plenty of fodder for their routines.
Instead, liberal comedy faltered. The skill set they had developed for the Bush years, the ripping away of pious lies to reveal the violent truth below, had no particular effect on a figure as shameless and straightforward as Trump.
One by one, the shows of the Daily Show alums began to topple. Patriot Act With Hasan Minhaj went in 2020. Full Frontal With Samantha Bee left in 2022. On The Daily Show itself, hosted from 2015 to 2022 by Trevor Noah, ratings toppled.
Colbert dropped his character to host The Late Show, but he criticized Trump often and vociferously as himself. All the same, his work didn't feel particularly biting or urgent anymore. Young people, particularly young men, were more likely to find right-wing comedy to be edgy and transgressive.
Yet somehow, with a president this thin-skinned, and a corporate leadership this obsequious, Stephen Colbert has been rendered threatening once again.
'If something was the height of fashion 20 years ago, that almost inversely makes it less likely to seem hip and cool at the moment,' the media critic Matt Sienkiewicz told me in 2022. 'There's a rebelliousness in the way people think of this right-wing comedy, right? Even if it really is regressive and pointing back to old dominant ideas. But it can be branded as being the opposite of Stephen Colbert crying about January 6 during his monologue, which is very much not cool to the teens.'
That's part of what's so striking about Paramount's decision to cancel Colbert's show in an apparent attempt to curry favor with Trump: Colbert's work hasn't felt dangerous in a long time. We're a long way from that 2006 White House Correspondent's Dinner, when Colbert delivered his jokes to a tense and scandalized crowd and Bush walked away furious. Colbert is the definition of a mainstream comedian now, and it doesn't seem as though anyone has any illusions that the jokes he cracks in between celebrity glad-handing and crowd work are culturally fundamental.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Dallas-area ICE arrests of noncriminals skyrocketed
Dallas-area ICE arrests of noncriminals skyrocketed

Axios

time4 minutes ago

  • Axios

Dallas-area ICE arrests of noncriminals skyrocketed

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrests of people without criminal charges or convictions in the Dallas area soared in June, per data compiled by the Deportation Data Project. Why it matters: The surge follows a national trend that coincides with the Trump administration's decision on May 21 to triple ICE's arrest quota. By the numbers: In January, ICE agents arrested 1,085 total people in the Dallas Field Office region, which includes North Texas, the Texas Panhandle and Oklahoma. As of June 26 — the most recent data available — the monthly arrest figure increased 59% to 1,726. Zoom in: The monthly share of Dallas-area ICE detainees without criminal charges or convictions more than doubled, from 197 in January (18% of all arrests) to 524 (30%) in June. The big picture: Nationwide, people without criminal charges or convictions made up an average of 47% of daily ICE arrests in early June, up from about 21% in early May, before the quota increase. The other side: "The media continues to peddle this FALSE narrative that ICE is not targeting criminal illegal aliens," Department of Homeland Security assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement to Axios. McLaughlin added that 70% of ICE arrests were for immigrants with criminal convictions or pending charges, but did not elaborate on that figure. Between the lines: " ICE has the authority to arrest immigrants who are suspected of violating immigration laws, regardless of criminal history," writes Austin Kocher, research assistant professor at Syracuse University's S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications and immigration expert, in an analysis of the new data. "Nevertheless, the administration has gone to great lengths in the press and on social media to emphasize the criminality of people they are arresting. Both things can be true, of course."

NJ Democrats rip DOJ over removal of Habba successor
NJ Democrats rip DOJ over removal of Habba successor

The Hill

time4 minutes ago

  • The Hill

NJ Democrats rip DOJ over removal of Habba successor

New Jersey Democratic Sens. Cory Booker and Andy Kim slammed the Trump administration on Tuesday for failing to uphold the court ordered appointment of Alina Haba's successor to serve as the state's interim U.S. attorney. Desiree Leigh Grace, Habba's first assistant, was tapped by the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey to lead the office upon the expiration of her 120-day temporary term. But, on Tuesday, Grace was 'removed' from the post by the Justice Department (DOJ). 'Trump's Department of Justice is once again criticizing a court that acted within its authority, continuing a pattern of publicly undermining judicial decisions and showing disregard for the rule of law and the separation of powers,' Booker and Kim said in a statement. 'The firing of a career public servant, lawfully appointed by the court, is another blatant attempt to intimidate anyone that doesn't agree with them and undermine judicial independence,' the duo continued. 'This Administration may not like the law, but they are not above it.' DOJ officials have accused the Democratic senators of plotting to oust Habba, who failed to be confirmed by judges for a long-term position. 'They forced out President Trump's pick, @USAttyHabba, then installed her deputy, colluding with the NJ Senators along the way. It won't work,' Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche wrote on social platform X, referring to Booker and Kim. 'Pursuant to the President's authority, we have removed that deputy, effective immediately,' he added. 'This backroom vote will not override the authority of the Chief Executive.' Attorney General Pam Bondi said, 'politically minded judges refused to allow her to continue in her position.' Habba received a considerable amount of backlash after initiating charges against Newark Mayor Ras Baraka (D) and Rep. LaMonica McIver (D-N.J.) stemming from an incident at a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in the Garden State. Both Baraka and McIver denied the accusations resulting in charges dropped against the Newark mayor. Baraka has sued Habba for damages over his arrest. A federal judge said the New Jersey mayor's arrest suggested a 'worrisome misstep' by Habba's office, noting the 'apparent rush' in bringing the case that culminated in the government's 'embarrassing' retraction of the charge. 'The people of New Jersey deserve a U.S. Attorney who will enforce the law and pursue justice for the people of our state without partisanship or politics,' Booker and Kim said on Tuesday, following Habba's failure to be retained as the state's top federal prosecutor.

Jim Beam column:Texas GOP wants more seats
Jim Beam column:Texas GOP wants more seats

American Press

time4 minutes ago

  • American Press

Jim Beam column:Texas GOP wants more seats

Texas Republicans are trying to increase their congressional seats during a current special session.(Image courtesy of Wikipedia). Republican President Donald Trump and many GOP members are obviously concerned about the party's possible loss of congressional seats at the 2026 midterm elections. Texas began a special session this week that is aimed at increasing its GOP seats in Congress and addressing the state flooding that killed at least 135 people. Louisiana won't be changing its congressional elections. It did that during the first special session of 2024 when it redrew its election lines after a federal court order. It created a second majority-Black 6th Congressional District and U.S. Rep. Cleo Fields of Baton Rouge was elected with 51% of the vote on Nov. 5, 2024. The Associated Press said Trump is pushing Texas to take a 'high-risk, high reward push to get Texas Republicans to redraw their political map. Trump is seeking to avoid the traditional midterm letdown that most incumbent presidents endure and hold onto the House, which the GOP narrowly controls.' Trump supporters won't agree, but The AP said, 'Trump's push comes as there are numerous danger signs for his presidency …' One is the Jeffrey Epstein case that has some MAGA supporters upset with Trump and new polling that shows U.S. adults think his policies haven't helped them. Six recent national polls, according to one report, give Trump an average approval rating of 46%. Some voters said they think his tax cut and spending bill will only help the wealthy. Like the other 49 states, Texas redrew its election lines after the 2020 Census. The AP said there are two terms that explain what might happen when election lines are redrawn. Gerrymandering is when one party rigs the map against the other party. 'Dummymander' is when aggressively redrawing a map, which Texas wants to do, puts the redrawing party's own seats at risk. The AP said Texas drew its election lines cautiously in 2021 after the 2020 Census because in the 2010s it padded its majority and lost two seats to Democrats. In 2021, Republicans decided to mainly shore up their incumbents rather than target Democrats. Doing what Trump wants, Texas Republicans have decided to go after Democratic seats during the current special session. Democratic U.S. Rep. Vicente Gonzalez of the Rio Grande Valley area is being targeted. However, Gonzelez said he isn't worried. He said the Democratic voters they want to take out of his district will end up in districts that flank his and those districts will be more competitive for Democrats. A national GOP official doesn't agree. He said, 'Smart map-drawing can yield pickup opportunities while not putting our incumbents in jeopardy.' Texas has 38 seats in the House — Republicans in 25 and Democrats in 12. One Democrat, a former Houston mayor, died in March. The AP said Texas isn't the only Republican state engaged in mid-decade redistricting. Ohio Republicans hope to go from a 10-5 party advantage in the House to a lopsided 13-2 advantage. We won't know which party gained the most advantage in Texas until its session is over. And we may not know until after the Texas midterm elections next year. Louisiana will be holding its political party closed primaries on April 18, 2026, and May 30, 2026. U.S. Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-Baton Rouge, is seeking a third six-year term and already has three Republican challengers. Political analysts don't expect any changes in Louisiana's 6 congressional districts. Republicans hold four seats and Democrats have two. Louisiana legislators were involved in gerrymandering when they eliminated former Republican U.S. Rep. Garret Graves of Baton Rouge from the 6th Congressional District. Graves was targeted by GOP Gov. Jeff Landry because he endorsed someone else in the 2023 gubernatorial election. The redrawn 6th District map runs from Shreveport to Baton Rouge and some non-Black voters filed suit, saying it was based on race. Landry and GOP legislators argued it was based on politics to protect two north Louisiana Republican congressional districts. Although an appellate federal panel said the new lines were illegal, the U.S. Supreme Court said the new map could be used for the 2024 congressional elections. The nation's highest court has again delayed a hearing, which means the existing map will be used again for congressional elections in 2026. Rep. Fields will be happy about that, but most voters are tired of waiting for court decisions that take much too long. Jim Beam, the retired editor of the American Press, has covered people and politics for more than six decades. Contact him at 337-515-8871 or

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store